Skip to main content

Full text of "Time Enough For Love"

See other formats



Robert A. 
Heinlein 
Time 
Enough 
For Love 

The Lives of Lazarus Long 

©Bitsoup.org© 



For Bill and Lucy 



This Berkley book contains the complete text of the original hardcover edition. 

It has been completely reset in a typeface designed for easy reading and was printed from new film. 


TIME ENOUGH FOR LOVE 

A Berkley Book / published by arrangement with 
G. P. Putnam’s Sons 

PRINTING HISTORY 

G. P. Putnam’s Sons edition published 1973 
G.P. Putnam’s / Berkley edition / January 1 974 
Twenty-fourth printing / March 1986 

All rights reserved. 

Copyright© 1973 by Robert A. Heinlein. 

This book may not be reproduced in whole or in part, 
by mimeograph or any other means, without permission. 

For information address: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 

200 Madison Avenue, New York. New York 10016. 

ISBN: 0-425-07990-2 

A BERKLEY BOOK ® TM 757.375 

Berkley Books are published by The Berkley Publishing Group, 

200 Madison Avenue. New York, NY 10016. 

The name ‘BERKLEY’ and the stylized “B” with design are trademarks belonging to Berkley Publishing 
Corporation. 

PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 



CONTENTS 


INTRODUCTION 

PRELUDE 


COUNTERPOINT 

I 

J! 

VARIATIONS ON A THEME 

I Affairs of State 

II The Tale of the Man Who Was Too Lazy to Fail 

III Domestic Problems 

COUNTERPOINT 


VARIATIONS ON A THEME 

IV Love 

COUNTERPOINT 

JV 

VARIATIONS ON A THEME 

V Voices in the Dark 

VI The Tale of the Twns Who Weren’t 

VII Valhalla to Landfall 

VIII Landfall 

IX Conversation Before Dawn 

X Possibilities 


INTERMISSION — Excerpts from the Notebooks of Lazarus Long 

VARIATIONS ON A THEME 

XI The Tale of the Adopted Daughter 

XII The Tale of the Adopted Daughter fcontinuecO 


SECOND INTERMISSION — More from the Notebooks of Lazarus Long 


VARIATIONS ON A THEME 


XIII Boondock 


XIV 

Bacchanalia 

XV Aaaoe 

XVI 

Eros 

XVII 

Narcissus 


DA CAPO 

I The Green Hills 

II The End of an Era 

III Maureen 

IV Home 

V 

Q*lc* O G\ 


t sm m ' if Q l3 ljuj~i 


VI 


r r r ir « - 


VII 



CODA 


J 


TIME ENOUGH FOR LOVE 


The Lives of the Senior Member of the Howard Families (Woodrow Wilson Smith; Ernest Gibbons; Captain 
Aaron Sheffield; Lazarus Long; "Happy" Daze; His Serenity Seraphin the \bunger, Supreme High Priest of the 
One God in All His Aspects and Arbiter Below and Above; Proscribed Prisoner No. 83M2742; Mr. Justice Lenox; 
Corporal Ted Bronson; Dr. Lafe Hubert; and others), Oldest Member of the Human Race. This Account is based 
principally on the Senior's Own Words as recorded at many times and places and especially at the Howard 
Rejuvenation Clinic and at the Executive Palace in New Rome on Secundus in Year 2053 After the Great 
Diaspora (Gregorian Year 4272 of Old Home Terra )-and supplemented by letters and by eyewitness accounts, 
the whole then arranged, collated, condensed, and (where possible) reconciled with official records and 
contemporary histories, as directed by the Howard Foundation Trustees and executed by the Howard Archivist 
Emeritus. The result is of unique historical importance despite the Archivist's decision to leave in blatant 
falsehoods, self-serving allegations, and many amoral anecdotes not suitable for young persons. 



INTRODUCTION 


On the Writing of History 

History has the relation to truth that theology has to religion — i.e., none to speak of. 

-L.L. 

The Great Diaspora of the Human Race which started more than two millennia ago when the L i b by-S heffi e Id 
Drive was disclosed, and which continues to this day and shows no sign of slowing, made the writing of history 
as a single narrative — or even many compatible narratives — impossible. By the twenty-first century (Gregorian)* 
(‘Gregorian Terran dates are used throughout, as no other calendar, not even Standard Galactic, is certain to be 
known to scholars of every planet. Translators should add local dates for clarification. J.F. 45 th ) on Old Home 
Terra our Race was capable of doubling its numbers three times each century — given space and raw materials. 

The Star Drive gave both. H. sapiens spread through this sector of our Galaxy at many times the speed of 
light and multiplied like yeast. If doubling had occurred at the twenty-first-century potential, our numbers would 
now be of the order of 7 x 10 A 9 x2 A 68-a number so large as to defy emotional grasp; it is suited only to 
computers: 

7 x 10 A 9 x2 A 68 = 2,066,035,336,255,469,780,992,000,000,000. 

--or more than two thousand million billion trillion people 

--or a mass of protein twenty-five million times as great as the entire mass of our race's native planet Sol III, Old 
Home. 

Preposterous. 

Let us say that it would be preposterous had not the Great Diaspora taken place, for our race, having 
reached the potential to double three times each century, had also reached a crisis under which it could not 
double even once — that knee of the curve in the yeast-growth law in which a population can maintain a 
precarious stability of zero growth only by killing off its own members fast enough, lest it drown in its own 
poisons, commit suicide by total war, or stumble into some other form of the Malthusian Final Solution. 

But the Human Race has not (we think) increased to that monstrous figure because the base figure for the 
Diaspora must not be thought of as seven billion but rather as a few million at the opening of the Era, plus the 
unnumbered, small-but-still-growing hundreds of millions since, who have migrated from Earth and from its 
colony planets to still more distant places over the last two millennia. 

But we are no longer able to make a reasoned guess at the numbers of the Human Race, nor do we have 
even an approximate count of the colonized planets. The most we can say is that there must be in excess of two 
thousand colonized planets, in excess of five hundred billion people. The colonized planets may be twice that 
number, the Human Race could be four times that numerous. Or more. 

So even the demographic aspects of historiography have become impossible; data are out of date when we 
receive them and always incomplete — yet so numerous and so varied in reliability that several hundred 
humans/computers on my staff keep busy trying to analyze, collate, interpolate and extrapolate, and to weigh 
them against other data before incorporating them into the records. We attempt to maintain standards of 95 
percent in probability of corrected data, 85 percent in pessimistic reliability; our achievement is closer to 89 per 
cent and 81 percent — and getting worse. 

Pioneers care little about sending records to the home office; they are busy staying alive, making babies, 
and killing off anything in their way. A colony is usually into its fourth generation before any data reach this office. 

(Nor can it be otherwise. A colonist too interested in statistics becomes a statistic himself — as a corpse. I 
intend to migrate; once I have done so, I won't care whether this office keeps track of me or not. I have stuck to 
this essentially useless work for almost a century partly through inducements and partly through genetic 
disposition — I am a direct-and-reinforced descendant of Andrew Jackson Slipstick Libby himself. But I am 
descended also from the Senior and have — I think — some of his restless nature. I want to follow the wild geese 
and see what is happening out there — get married again; leave a dozen descendants on a fresh uncrowded 
planet, then — possibly — move on. Once I have the Senior's memoirs collated, the Trustees can, in the Senior's 



ancient idiom, take this job and shove it.) 

What sort of man is our Senior, my ancestor and probably yours, and certainly the oldest living human being, 
the only man who has taken part in the entire pageant of the crisis of the Human Race and its surmounting of 
crisis through Diaspora? 

For surmount it we have. Our race could now lose fifty planets, close ranks, and move on. Our gallant women 
could replace the casualties in a single generation. Not that it appears likely that this will happen; thus far we 
have encountered notone race as mean, as nasty, as deadly as our own. A conservative extrapolation indicates 
that we will reach in numbers that preposterous figure given earlier in a few more generations — and move on out 
of this Galaxy into others before we finish settling this one. Indeed, reports from farther out indicate that Human 
intergalactic colony ships are already headed out into the Endless Deeps. These reports are not verified — but 
the most virile colonies are always a long way from the most populous centers. One may hope. 

At best, history is hard to grasp; at worst, it is a lifeless collection of questionable records. It is most alive 
through the words of eyewitnesses. . .and we have but one witness whose life spans the twenty-three centuries of 
crisis and Diaspora. The next oldest human being whose age this office has been able to verify is only a little 
over a thousand years old. Probability theory makes it possible that there is somewhere a person half again that 
age — but it is both mathematically and historically certain that there is no other human alive today who was born 
in the twentieth century.* (* When the Howard Families seized the Starship New Frontiers only a few were more 
than a century and a quarter old; all of that few — save the Senior — are dead, at times and places on record. (I 
except the strange and possibly mythical case of life-in-death of Elder Mary Sperling.) Despite genetic 
advantage and access to the longevity therapies known collectively as "the immortality option," the last died in 
3003 Gregorian. By the records it would seem that most of them died through refusing further rejuvenation — that 
being still the second commonest cause of death today. JF.45 th ) 

Some may question whether this "Senior" is the member of the Howard Families born in 1912 and also the 
"Lazarus Long" who led the Families in their escape from Old Home in 2136, etc. — pointing out that all the 
ancient methods of identification (fingerprints, retinal patterns, etc.) can now be beaten. True, but those methods 
were adequate for their time and the Howard Families Foundation had special reason to use them with care; the 
"Woodrow Wilson Smith" whose birth was registered with the Foundation in 1912 is certainly the "Lazarus Long" 
of2136 and 2210. Before those tests ceased to be reliable, they were supplemented by modern unbeatable 
tests based first on clone transplants and, more lately, on absolute identification of genetic patterns. (It is 
interesting to note that an impostor showed up about three centuries ago, here on Secundus, and was given a 
new heart from a cloned pseudobody of the Senior. It killed him.) The Senior whose words are quoted herein has 
a genetic pattern identical with that of a bit of muscle tissue removed from "Lazarus Long" by Dr. Gordon Hardy 
in the Starship NewFrontiers about 2145, and cultured by him for longevity research. Q.E.D 

But what sort of man is he? You must judge for yourself. In condensing this memoir to manageable length I 
have omitted many verified historical incidents (the raw data are available to scholars at the Archives) — but I 
have left in lies and unlikely stories on the assumption that the lies a man tells tell more truth about him — when 
analyzed — than does "truth." 

It is clear that this man is, by standards usual in civilized societies, a barbarian and a rogue. 

But it is not for children to judge their parents. The qualities that make him what he is are precisely those 
needed to stay alive in a jungle — or on a raw frontier. Do not forget your debt to him both genetic and historic. 

To understand our historic debt to him it is necessary to review some ancient history — part tradition or myth, 
and part fact as firmly established as the assassination of Julius Caesar. The Howard Families Foundation was 
established by the will of Ira Howard, who died in 1873. His will instructed the trustees of the foundation to use 
his money to "prolong human life." This is fact. 

Tradition says that he willed this in anger at his own fate, for he found himself dying of old age in his forties 
— dead at forty-eight, a bachelor without progeny. So none of us carries his genes; his immortality lies only in a 
name, and in an idea — that death could be thwarted. 

At that time death at forty-eight was not unusual. Believe it or not, in those days the average age at death was 
about thirty-five! But not from senility. Disease, starvation, accident, murder, war, childbirth, and other violences 
cut down most humans long before senility set in. But a human who passed all these hurdles still could expect 
death from old age sometime between seventy-five and one hundred. Very few reached one hundred; 
nevertheless every population group had its tiny minority of "centenarians." There is a legend about "Old Toni 
Parr" who is supposed to have died in 1 635 aged one hundred and fifty-two years. Whether or not the legend is 



true, probability analysis of demographic data of that era shows that some individuals must have lived a century 
and a half. But they were few indeed. 

The Foundation started its work as a prescientific breeding experiment, as nothing was then known of 
genetics: Adults of long-lived stock were encouraged to mate with others like them, money being the 
inducement. 

Unsurprisingly the inducement worked. Equally unsurprisingly this experiment worked, as it was an empirical 
method used by stockbreeders for centuries before the science of genetics came into being: Breed to reinforce 
one characteristic, then eliminate the culls. 

The Families' Archives do not show how the earliest culls were eliminated; they simply show that some were 
eliminated from the Families — root and branch, all descendants — forthe unforgivable sin of dying of old age too 
young. 

By the Crisis of 2136 all members of the Howard Families had life expectancies in excess of one hundred 
and fifty years, and some had exceeded that age. The cause of that crisis seems unbelievable — yet all records 
both from inside and from outside the Families agree on it. The Howard Families were in extreme danger from 
all other humans simply because they lived so "long." Why this was true is a matter for group psychologists, not 
for a record-keeper. But it was true. 

They were seized and concentrated in a prison camp, and were about to be tortured to death in an attempt to 
wrest from them their "secret" of "eternal youth." Fact — not myth. 

Here the Senior comes into the story. Through audacity, a talent for lying convincingly, and what would seem 
to most people today a childish delight in adventure and intrigue for its own sake, the Senior brought off the 
greatest jailbreak of all time, stealing a primitive starship and escaping right out of the Solar System with all of 
the Howard Families (then numbering about 100,000 men, women, and children). 

If this seems impossible — so many people and just one ship — remember that the first starships were 
enormously bigger than the ones we now use. Theywere self-sustaining artificial planetoids intended to remain 
in space for many years at speeds below that of light; they had to be huge. 

The Senior was not the only hero of that Exodus. But in all the varied and sometimes conflicting accounts that 
have come down to us, he was always the driving force. He was our Moses who led his people out of bondage. 

He brought them home again three-quarters of a century later (2210) — but not into bondage. Forthat date, 
Year One of the Standard Galactic calendar, marks the opening of the Great Diaspora... caused by extreme 
population pressure on Old Home Terra, and made possible by two new factors: the L i b by-S heffi e Id Para-Drive 
as it was known then (not a "drive" in any true sense, but a means of manipulating n-dimensional spaces), and 
the first (and simplest) of effective longevity techniques: new blood grown in vitro. 

The Howard Families caused this to happen simply by escaping. The short-lived humans back on Terra, still 
convinced that the long-lived families possessed a "secret," set about trying to find it by wide and systematic 
research, and, as always, research paid off serendipitously, not with the nonexistent "secret" but with something 
almost as good: a therapy, and eventually a sheaf of therapies, for postponing old age, and forextending vigor, 
virility, and fertility. 

The Great Diaspora was then both necessary and possible. 

The Senior's great talent (aside from his ability to lie extemporaneously and convincingly) seems always to 
have been a rare gift for extrapolating the possibilities of any situation — then twisting it to suit his own purposes. 
(He calls it: "You have to have a feeling for what makes the frog jump." Psychometrists who have studied him say 
that he has an extremely high psi talent expressed as "forerunners" and "luck" — but what the Senior has to say 
about them is less polite. As a record-keeper, I refrain from opinion.) 

The Senior saw at once that this benison of extended youth, although promised to everyone, would in fact be 
limited to the powerful and their nepots. The billions of helots could not be allowed to live beyond their normal 
pan; there was no room for them — unless they migrated to the stars, in which case there would be room for each 
human to live as long as he could manage. How the Senior exploited this is not always clear; he seems to have 
used several names and many fronts. His key corporations wound up in the hands of this Foundation, then were 
liquidated to move the Foundation and the Howard Families to Secundus — at his behest, he having saved "the 
best real estate" for his relatives and descendants. Sixty-eight percent of those then living accepted the 
challenge of new frontiers. 

Our genetic debt to him is both indirect and direct. The indirect debt lies in the fact that migration is a sorting 
device, a forced Darwinian selection, under which superior stock goes to the stars while culls stay home and die. 



This is true even for those forcibly transported (as in the twenty-fourth and twenty-fifth centuries), save that the 
sorting then takes place on the new planet. In a raw frontier weaklings and misfits die; strong stock survives. 

Even those who migrate voluntarily still go through this second drastic special selection. The Howard Families 
have been culled in this fashion at least three times. 

Our genetic "debt" to the Senior is even easier to prove. Part of it needs only simple arithmetic. If you live 
anywhere but on Old Home Terra — and you almost certainly do if you read this, in view of the present miserable 
state of "The Fair Green Hills of Earth" — and can claim even one member of the Howard Families among your 
ancestors — and most of you can — then you are most probably descended from the Senior. 

By the official Families' genealogies this probability is 87.3 percent. N£>u are descended from many other 
twentieth century members of the Howard Families, too, if you are descended from any of them, but I speak here 
only of Woodrow Wilson Smith, the Senior. By the Crisis Year 2136 nearly one-tenth of the youngest generation 
of the Howard Families were descended from the Senior "legitimately" — by which I mean that each linking birth 
was so recorded in the Families' records and ancestry confirmed by such tests as were available at the time. 
(Even blood typing was not known when the breeding experiment started, but the culling process made it 
strongly to a female's advantage not to stray, at least not outside the Families.) 

By now the cumulative probability is, as I have said, 87.3 percent if you have any Howard ancestor — but if 
you have a Howard ancestor from a recent generation, your probability climbs toward an effective 1 00 percent. 

But, as a statistician, I have reason to believe (backed by computer analyses of blood types, hair types, eye 
color, tooth count, enzyme types, and other characteristics responsive to genetic analysis) — strong reason to 
believe that the Senior has many descendants not recorded in genealogies, both inside and outside the Howard 
Families. 

To put it mildly, he is a shameless old goat whose seed is scattered all through this part of our Galaxy. 

Take the years of the Exodus, after he stole the NewFrontiers. He was not married even once during those 
years, and ship's records and legends based on memoirs of that time suggest that he was, in an early idiom, a 
"woman hater," a misogynist. 

Perhaps. Biostatistical records (rather than genealogies), when analyzed, suggest that he was not that 
unapproachable. The computer that analyzed it offered to bet me even money on more than one hundred 
offspring fathered by him during those years. (I refused the bet; that computer beats me at chess even though I 
insist on a one-rook advantage.) 

I do not find this surprising, in view of the almost pathological emphasis placed on longevity among the 
Families at that time. The oldest male, if still virile — and he certainty was — would have been subjected to 
endless temptation, endless opportunity, by females anxious to have offspring of his demonstrated 
superiority — "superiority" by the only criterion the Howard Families respected. We can assume that marital 
status would not matter much; all Howard Families marriages were marriages of convenience — Ira Howard's will 
insured that — and they were rarely for life. The only surprising aspect is that so few fertile females managed to 
trip him when unquestionably so many thousands were willing. But he was always fast on his feet. 

As may be — If today I see a man with sandy red hair, a big nose, an easy disarming grin, and a slightly feral 
look in his gray-green eyes, I always wonder how recently the Senior has passed through that part of the Galaxy. 

If such a stranger comes close to me, I put my hand on my purse: If he speaks to me, I resolve not to make 
wagers or promises. 

But how did the Senior, himself only a third-generation member of Ira Howard's breeding experiment, 
manage to live and stay young his first three hundred years without artificial rejuvenation? 

A mutation, of course — which simply says that we don't know. But in the course of his several rejuvenations 
we have learned a little about his physical makeup. He has an unusually large heart that beats very slowly. He 
has only twenty-eight teeth, no caries, and seems to be immune to infection. He has never had surgery other than 
for wounds or for rejuvenation procedures. His reflexes are extremely fast — but appear always to be reasoned, 
so one may question the correctness of the term "reflex." His eyes have never needed correction either for 
distance or close work; his hearing range is abnormally high, abnormally low, and is unusually acute throughout 
his range. His color vision includes indigo. He was born without prepuce, without vermiform appendix — and 
apparently without a conscience. 

I am pleased that he is my ancestor. 


Justin Foote the 45th 



Chief Archivist, Howard Foundation 


PREFACE TO REVISED EDITION 

In this abridged popular edition the technical appendix has been published separately in order to make room 
for an account of the Senior's actions after he left Secundus until his disappearance. An apocryphal and 
obviously impossible tale of the last events in his life has been included at the insistence of the editor of the 
original memoir, but it cannot be taken seriously. 

Carolyn Briggs 
Chief Archivist 

Note: My lovely and learned successor in office does not know what she is talking about. With the Senior, the 
most fantastic is always the most probable. 

Justin Foote the 45th 
Chief Archivist Emeritus 



PRELUDE 

I 


As the doorofthe suite dilated, the man seated staring glumly out the window looked around. "Who the hell are 
you?" 

"I am Ira Weatheral of the Johnson Family, Ancestor, Chairman Pro Tern of the Families." 

"Took you long enough. Don't call me 'Ancestor. 1 And why just the Chairman Pro Tern?" the man in the chair 
growled. "Is the Chairman too damn busy to see me? Don't I rate even that?" He made no move to stand, nor did 
he invite his visitor to sit down. 

"\bur pardon, Sire. I am chief executive for the Families. But it has been customary for some time now 
— several centuries — for the chief executive to hold the title. 'Chairman Pro Tern' — against the possibility that you 
might show up and take the gavel." 

"Eh? Ridiculous. I haven't presided at a meeting of the Trustees for a thousand years. And 'Sire' is as bad as 
'Ancestor' — call me by name. It's been two days since I sent for you. Did you come by the scenic route? Or has 
the rule that entitles me to the ear of the Chairman been revoked?" 

"I am not aware of that rule, Senior; it was probably long before my time — but it is my honor and duty — and 
pleasure — to wait on you at anytime. I will be pleased and honored to call you by name if you will tell me what 
your name is now. As for the delay — thirty-seven hours since I received your summons — I have spent it studying 
Ancient English, as I was told that you were not answering to any other language." 

The Senior looked slightly sheepish. "It's true I'm not handy with the jabber they speak here — my memory has 
been playing tricks on me lately. I guess I've been sulky about answering even when I understood. Names — I 
forget what name I checked in by when I grounded here. Mmm, 'Woodrow Wilson Smith' was my boyhood name. 
Never used it much. I suppose 'Lazarus Long 1 is the name I've used oftenest — call me 'Lazarus.'" 

"Thank you, Lazarus." 

"For what? Don't be so damned formal. \bu're not a kid, or you wouldn't be Chairman — how old are you? Did 
you really take the trouble to learn my milk language just to call on me? And in less than two days? Was that from 
scratch? It takes me at least a week to tack on a new language, another week to smooth out accent." 

"I am three hundred and seventy-two standard years old, Lazarus — just under four hundred Earth years. I 
learned Classic English when I took this job — but as a dead language, to enable me to read old records of the 
Families in the original. What I did since your summons was to learn to speak and understand it in North 
American twentieth-century idiom — your 'milk language' as you said — as that is what the linguistic analyzer 
computed that you were speaking." 

"Pretty smart machine. Maybe I am speaking it the way I did as a youngster; they claim that's the one 
language a brain never forgets. Then I must be talking in a Cornbelt rasp like a rusty saw whereas you're 
speaking a sort of Texas drawl with an Oxford British overlay. Odd. I suppose the machine picks the version out 
of its permanents closest to the sample fed into it." 

"I believe so, Lazarus, although the techniques involved are not my field. Do you have trouble understanding 
my accent?’ 

"Oh, none at all. Your accent is okay; it's closer to educated General American of that time than is the accent I 
learned as a kid. But I can follow anything from Bluegum to Yorkshire; accent is no problem. It was mighty kind of 
you to bother. Warming." 

"My pleasure. I have a talent for languages; it was not much trouble. I try to be able to speak to each of the 
Trustees in his native language; I'm used to swotting up a new one quickly." 

"So? Nonetheless a courteous thing to do — I've felt like an animal in a zoo with no one to talk to. Those 
dummies" — Lazarus inclined his head at two rejuvenation technicians, dressed in isolation gear and one-way 
helmets, and waiting as far from the conversation as the room permitted — "don't know English; I can't talk with 
them. Oh, the taller one understands a little but not enough for gossip." Lazarus whistled, pointed at the taller. 
"Hey, you! A chair for the Chairman — chop chop!" His gestures made his meaning clear. The taller technician 
touched the controls of a chair nearby; it rolled away, wheeled around, and stopped at a comfortable tete-a-tete 
distance from Lazarus. 



Ira Weatheral said thank you-to Lazarus, not to the tech-sat down, then sighed as the chair felt him out and 
cuddled him. Lazarus said, "Comfortable?" 

"Quite." 

"Anything to eat or drink? Or smoke? You may have to interpret for me." 

"Nothing, thank you. But may I order for you?" 

"Not now. They keep me stuffed like a goose — once they force-fed me, damn them. Since we're comfortable, 
let's get on with the powwow." He suddenly roared, "WHAT THE HELL AM I DOING IN THIS JAIL?" 

Weatheral answered quietly, "Not 'jail,' Lazarus. The VIP suite of the Howard Rejuvenation Clinic. New 
Rome." 

"'Jail,' I said. All it lacks is cockroaches. This window — you couldn't break it with a crowbar. That door — it 
opens to any voice except mine. If I go to the john, one of those dummies is at my elbow. Apparently afraid I'll 
drown myself in the pot. Hell, I don't even know whether that nurse is a man or a woman — and don't like it either 
way. I don't need somebody to hold my hand while I go pee-pee! I resent it." 

"I'll see what can be worked out, Lazarus. But the technicians are understandably jumpy. A person can get 
hurt quite easily in any bathroom — and they all know that, if you are hurt, no matter by what mischance, the 
technician in charge at the time will suffer cruel and unusual punishment. They are volunteers and are drawing 
high bonuses. But they're jumpy." 

"So I figured out. 'Jail.' If this is a rejuvenation suite WHERE'S MYSUICIDE SWITCH?" 

"Lazarus — 'Death is every man's privilege.'" 

"That's what I said! That switch belongs right there; you can see where it has been dismounted. So I'm in jail 
without trial, with my most basic right taken from me. Why ? I'm furious, man. Do you realize what danger you are 
in? Never tease an old dog; he might have one bite left. Old as I am, I could break your arms before those 
dummies could reach us." 

"\bu are welcome to break my arms if it pleases you." 

"Huh?" Lazarus Long looked baffled. "No, it's not worth the sweat. They would have you patched up good as 
new in thirty minutes." He suddenly grinned. "But I could snap your neck, then crush your skull, about as fast. 
That's one injury beyond the power of rejuvenators." 

Weatheral did not stir, did not tense. "I feel sure you could," he said quietly. "But I do not think that you would 
kill one of your descendants without giving him a chance to parley for his life. Nt>u are my remote grandfather, sir, 
by seven different tracks." 

Lazarus chewed his lip and looked unhappy. "Son, I have so many descendants that consanguinity doesn't 
matter. But you're essentially right. In all my life I have never killed a man unnecessarily. I think." Then he grinned. 
"But if I don't get my suicide switch back, I could make an exception in your case." 

"Lazarus, if you wish, I will have that switch remounted at once. But — 'Ten Words'?" 

"Uh — " Lazarus looked ungracious. "Okay. 'Ten Words.' Not eleven." 

Weatheral hesitated a split second, then counted on his fingers: "I learned your language to explain why we 
need you." 

"Ten bythe Rule," Lazarus admitted. "But meaning that you need fifty. Or five hundred. Or five thousand." 

"Or none," Weatheral amended. "\bu can have your switch without giving me any chance to explain. I 
promised." 

"Humph!" said Lazarus. "Ira, you old scoundrel, you have me convinced that you really are my kin. Nt>u figured 
that I would not suicide without hearing what you have on your mind — once I knew you had bothered to learn a 
dead language just to make palaver. All right, talk. You can start by telling me what I'm doing here. I know — I 
know— that I didn't apply for rejuvenation. But I woke up here with the job already half over. So I screamed for the 
Chairman. Okay, why am I here?" 

"May we start further back? \bu tell me what you were doing in a flophouse in the worst part of Old Town." 

"What was I doing ? 1 was dying. Quietly and decently, like a worn-out horse. That is, I was, until your 
busybodies grabbed me. Can you think of a better place than a flophouse for a man who doesn't want to be 
disturbed while he's busy with it? If his cot is paid for in advance, they leave a man be. Oh, they stole what little I 
had, even my shoes. But I expected that — would have done the same myself under the same circumstances. And 
the sort of people who live in flophouses are almost always kind to those worse off than they are — any of 'em will 
fetch a drink of water to a sick man. That was the most I wanted — that and to be left alone to close out my 
account in my own way. Until your busies showed up. Tell me, bow did they find me?' 



"How we found you is not the surprising part, Lazarus, but the fact that SecFor — the cops? — Yes, 'cops' — that 
my cops took so long to identify you, then find you, and pick you up. A section chief lost his job over that. I don't 
tolerate inefficiency." 

"So you busted him. "four business. But why? I reached Secundus from Out-Far, and I didn't think I had left any 
back trail. Different everything since the last time I was in touch with the Families... as I bought my last 
rejuvenation on Supreme. Are the Families swapping data with Supreme these days?" 

"Heavens, no, Lazarus, we won't even give them a polite word. There is a strong minority among the Trustees 
who favor rubbing out Supreme, instead of simply maintaining embargo." 

"Well... if a nova bomb hit Supreme, I wouldn't mourn more than thirty seconds. But I did have a reason for 
having the job done there, even though I had to pay high for forced cloning. But that's another story. Son, how did 
you pick me up?" 

"Sir, for the past seventy years there has been a general order out to try to find you, not just here but on every 
planet where the Families maintain offices. As to how — do you recall a forced inoculation for Reiber's fever at 
Immigration?" 

"Yes. I was annoyed, but it didn't seem worthwhile to make a fuss; I knew I was headed for that flophouse. Ira, 
I've known that I was dying for quite some time. That was okay; I was ready for it. But I didn't want to do it alone, 
out in space. Wanted human voices around me, and body odors. Childish of me. But I was pretty far gone by the 
time I grounded." 

"Lazarus, there is no such thing as Reiber's fever. When a man grounds on Secundus and all routine 
identifications show null, 'Reiber's fever' or some other nonexistent plague is used as an excuse to get a little 
tissue from him while injecting him with sterile neutral saline. Nfc>u should never have been allowed to leave the 
skyport until your genetic pattern was identified." 

"So? What do you do when ten thousand immigrants arrive in one ship?" 

"Herd them into detention barracks until we've checked them out. But that doesn't happen often today with 
Old Home Terra in the sorry state it's in. But you, Lazarus, arriving alone in a private yacht worth fifteen to twenty 
million crowns — " 

"Make that 'thirty.'" 

" — worth thirty million crowns. How many men in the Galaxy can do that? Of those who can afford it, how 
many would choose to travel alone? The pattern should have set alarm bells ringing in the minds of all of them. 
Instead they took your tissue and accepted your statement that you would be staying at the Romulus Hilton and 
let you go — and no doubt you had another identity before dark." 

"No doubt at all," Lazarus agreed. "But your cops have run up the price on a good phony set of ID's. If I hadn’t 
been too tired to bother, I would have forged my own. Safer. Was that how I was caught? Did you squeeze it out 
of the paper merchant?" 

"No, we never found him. By the way, you might let me know who he is, so that — " 

"And I might not,” Lazarus said sharply. "Not ratting on him was implicit in the bargain. It's nothing to me how 
many of your rules he breaks. And — who knows? — I might need him again. Certainly someone will need his 
services, somebody just as anxious to avoid your busies as I was. Ira, no doubt you mean well but I don't like 
setups where IDs are necessary. I told myself centuries back to stay away from places crowded enough to 
require them, and mostly I've followed that rule. Should have followed it this time. But I didn't expect to need any 
identification very long. Confoundit, two more days and I would have been dead. I think. How did you catch me?" 

"The hard way. Once I knew you were on planet I stirred things up; that section chief wasn't the only unhappy 
one. But you disappeared in so simple a fashion that you baffled the entire force. My security chief expressed 
the opinion that you had been killed and your body disposed of. I told him if that were the case, he had better 
start thinking about offplanet migration." 

"Make it march! I want to know how I goofed." 

"I would not say that you goofed. Lazarus, since you managed to stay hidden with every cop and stoolie on 
this globe looking for you. But I felt certain that you had not been killed. Oh, we do have murders on Secundus, 
especially here in New Rome. But most are the commonplace husband-wife sort: We don't have many for gain 
since I instituted a policy of making the punishment fit the crime and holding executions in- the Colosseum. In any 
case I felt certain that a man who had survived more than two millennia would not let himself be killed in some 
dark alley. 

"So I assumed that you were alive, then asked myself, 'If I were Lazarus Long, how would I go about hiding?' I 



went into deep meditation and thought about it. Then I tried to retrace your steps, so far as we knew them. By the 
way — " 

The Chairman Pro Tern threw back his shoulder cloak, took out a large sealed envelope, handed it to 
Lazarus. "Here is the item you left in a lockbox at Harriman Trust." 

Lazarus accepted it. "It's been opened." 

"By me. Prematurely, I admit — but you addressed it to me. I have read it but no one else has. And now I will 
forget it. Except to say this: I am unsurprised that you left your wealth to the Families but I was touched that you 
assigned your yacht to the personal use of the Chairman. That's a sweet craft, Lazarus; I lust after it a bit. But not 
so much that I am anxious to inherit so quickly. But I undertook to explain why we need you — and let myself get 
sidetracked.? 1 

"I'm in no rush, Ira. Are you?" 

"Me? Sir; I have no duties more important than talking with the Senior. Besides, my staff runs this planet 
more efficiently if I don't supervise them too closely." 

Lazarus nodded agreement. "That was always my system the times I let myself get involved. Accept the 
whole load, then shove the work off on other people as fast as I could pick 'em. Having any trouble with 
democrats these days?" 

"'Democrats'? Oh-you must mean 'egalitarians.' I thought at first you meant the Church of the Holy 
Democrat.We leave that church alone; they don't meddle. There is an equalitarian movement every few years, 
certainly, under various names. The Freedom Party, the League of the Oppressed — names don't matter as they 
all want to turn the rascals out, starting with me; and put their own rascals in. We never bother them; we simply 
infiltrate, then some night we round up the ringleaders and their families, and by daylight they are headed out as 
involuntary migrants. Transportees. 'Living on Secundus is a privilege, not a right."' 

"\bu're quoting me." 

"Of course. Ntrur exact words from the contract under which you deeded Secundus to the Foundation. That 
there was to be no government on this planet other than such rules as the current chairman found necessary to 
maintain order. We've stuck to our agreement with you, Senior; I am sole boss until the Trustees see fit to 
replace me." 

"That's what I intended," Lazarus agreed. "But Son, it's your pidgin and I'll never touch that gavel again — but I 
have doubts about the wisdom of getting rid of troublemakers. Every loaf needs yeast. A society that gets rid of 
all its troublemakers goes downhill. Sheep. Pyramid builders at best, decadent savages at worst. \t>u may be 
eliminating your creative one-tenth of one percent. Your yeast." 

"I'm afraid we are, Senior, and that's one reason why we need you — " 

"I said I won't touch that gavel!" 

"Will you hear me out, sir? You won't be asked to, even though it is yours by ancient custom if you care to pick 
it up. But I could use advice — " 

"I don't give advice; people never take it." 

"Sorry. Perhaps just a chance to talk over my problems with a person more experienced than I am. About 
these troublemakers — We haven't eliminated them in the old sense; they're still alive, or most of them. 
Ostracizing a man to another planet is more satisfactory than killing him for the technical crime of treason; it gets 
rid of him without making his neighbors too indignant. Nor have we wasted him — them — as we are using them to 
conduct an experiment: All transportees are shipped to the same planet, Felicity. Do you happen to know it?" 

"Not by that name." 

"I think you would have stumbled on it only by accident, sir; we have kept it out of public records in order to 
use it as a Botany Bay. It is not as good a planet as the name suggests, but it is a good one, roughly equivalent 
to Old Home Terra — Earth, I should say — before it was ruined, or much like Secundus when we settled here. It's 
rough enough to test a man and eliminate weaklings, gentle enough to let a man raise a family if he has the guts 
to dig in and sweat." 

"Sounds like a good place; perhaps you should have hung onto it. Natives?" 

"The proto-dominant race are quite fierce savages... if any are still alive. We don't know, we don't even 
maintain a liaison office there. This native race is neither intelligent enough to be civilized nor tractable enough to 
be enslaved. Perhaps they would have evolved and made it on their own, but they had the misfortune to 
encounter H. sapiens before they were ready for him. But that is not the experiment; the transportees are certain 
to win out over that competition, we do not send them empty-handed. But, Lazarus, these people believe that 
they can create ideal government by maioritv rule." 



Lazarus snorted. 

"Perhaps they can, sir," Weatheral persisted. "I don't know that they cannot. That is the experiment." 

"Son, are you a fool? Oh, you can't be, the Trustees wouldn't keep you in office. But — How old did you say 
you are?" 

Weatheral answered quietly, "I am nineteen centuries your junior, sir; I will not dispute your opinion on 
anything. But I do not know through my own experience that this experiment will not work; I have never seen a 
government of the democratic type, even in the numerous times I have been off planet. I've simply read about 
them. From what I have read not one has ever been formed from a population all of whom believed in the 
democratic theory. So I don't know." 

"Hmm." Lazarus looked frustrated. "Ira, I was about to shove my own experience with such governments 
down your throat. But you're right, this is a brand new situation — and we don't know. Oh, I have strong opinions, 
but a thousand reasoned opinions are never equal to one case of diving in and finding out. Galileo proved that 
and it may be the only certainty we have. Mmm...all the so-called democracies I've ever seen or heard of were 
either forced on the majority from above or grew up slowly from the plebs discovering that they could vote 
themselves bread-and-circuses — for a while, until the system broke down. I'm sorry I won't see the outcome of 
your experiment. I suspect it will be the harshest tyranny imaginable; majority rule gives the ruthless strong man 
plenty of elbow room to oppress his fellows. But I don't know. What's your opinion?" 

"The computers say — " 

"Never mind computers. Ira, the most sophisticated machine the human mind can build has in it the 
limitations of the human mind. Anyone who thinks otherwise does not understand the Second Law of 
Thermodynamics. I asked for your opinion." 

"Sir, I refuse to form an opinion; I lack sufficient data." 

"Hrrumph: fbu're getting old, Son. To get anywhere, or even to live a long time, a man has to guess, and 
guess right, over and over again, without enough data for a logical answer. Nt>u were telling me how you found 
me." 

"Yes, sir. That document, your will, made it clear that you expected to die soon. Then" — Weatheral paused 
and smiled wryly — "I had to 'guess right without enough data.' It took us two days to find the shop where you 
bought clothes to lower your apparent status — and to conform to local styles, I think. I suspect that you bought 
your false ID's right after that." 

He paused; Lazarus made no comment;. Weatheral continued: "Another half day to find the shop where you 
lowered your apparent status much farther, close to bottom — too far perhaps, as the shopkeeper remembered 
you, both because you paid cash and because you were buying secondhand clothes that were not as good 
even when new as the ones you were wearing. Oh, he pretended to accept your story about a 'costume party' 
and kept his mouth shut; his shop is a fence for stolen goods." 

"Of course," agreed Lazarus. "I made sure he was on the crook before I bought from him. But you said he 
stayed zipped?" 

"Until we stimulated his memory. A fence is in a difficult position, Lazarus; he has to have a permanent 
address. This can sometimes force him to be honest." 

"Oh, I wasn't blaming dear old Uncle. The fault was mine; I let myself be conspicuous. I was tired, Ira, and 
feeling my years and let it rush me into doing a sloppy job. Even a hundred years back I would have done a more 
artistic job. I've always known that it is more difficult to lower your status convincingly than to raise it." 

"I don't think you need feel ashamed of the job as a work of art, Senior; you had us baffled for almost three 
months." 

"Son, the world doesn't pay off on a 'good try.' Go ahead" 

"Brute force then, Lazarus: That shop is in the worst part of the city; we put a cordon around the area and 
saturated it, thousands of men. But not for long; you were in the third fleabag we checked. I spotted you myself, I 
was with one of the raiding parties. Then your genetic pattern confirmed your identity." Ira Weatheral smiled 
slightly. "But we were pouring new blood into you before the genetic analyzer reported your identity; you were in 
bad shape, sir." 

"I was like hell in bad shape; I was simply dying — and minding my own business, a practice you could 
emulate. Ira, do you realize what a dirty trick you have done me? A man ought not to have to die twice and I was 
past the bad part and ready for the finale as easy as falling asleep. Then you butted in. I've never heard of 
rejuvenation being forced on anyone. If I had suspected that you had changed the rules, I would never have come 



near this planet. Now I have to go through it again. Either with the suicide switch — and suicide is an idea I've 
always despised — or the natural way. Which could now take a long time. Is my old blood still around? Stored?" 

"I will inquire of the Clinic's Director, sir." 

"Humph. That's not an answer, so don't bother to lie. "Vbu've put me in a dilemma, Ira. Even though I haven't 
had the full treatment, I feel better than I've felt for forty years or more-which means either that I must again wait it 
out for many weary years — or use that switch when my body isn't saying, 'Time to adjourn.' \bu meddling 
scoundrel, by what authority — no, you've got the authority. By what ethical principle did you interfere with my 
death?" 

"Because we needed you, sir." 

"That's not an ethical reason, just a pragmatic one. The need was not mutual." 

"Senior, I have studied your life as thoroughly as the records permit. It seems to me that you often acted 
pragmatically." 

Lazarus grinned. "That's my boy! I was wondering if you would have the gall to try to twist it into some high 
moral principle, like a damned preacher. I don't trust a man who talks about ethics when he's picking my pocket. 
But if he's acting in his own self-interest and says so, I have usually been able to work out some way to do 
business with, him." 

"Lazarus, if you will let us complete your rejuvenation, you'll feel like living again. I think you know that; you've 
been through it before." 

"To what end, sir? When I've had more than two thousand years of trying everything? When I've seen so many 
planets that they blur in my mind? When I've had so many wives I can't remember their names? 'We pray for one 
last landing on the Globe that gave us birth — 1 1 can't even do that; the lovely green planet I was born on has aged 
even more than I have; to return to it would be a time for tears, not a happy homecoming. No, Son, despite all 
rejuvenation there comes a time when the only reasonable thing to do is turn out the lights and go to sleep — and 
you, damn you, you took It away from me." 

"I’m sorry — no, I'm not sorry. But I do ask your pardon." 

"Well you might get it. But not now. What was this aching reason you needed me? Nt>u mentioned some 
problem other than the troublemakers you transport." 

"Yes, although it is not one that would have caused me to interfere with your right to die your own way; I can 
handle it, one way or another. I think Secundus is becoming both too crowded and too civilized — " 

"I'm sure of it, Ira." 

"Therefore I think the Families should move again." 

"I agree even though I am not interested. As a thumb rule, one can say that any time a planet starts 
developing cities of more than one million people, it is approaching critical mass. In a century or two it won't be 
fit to live on. Do you have a planet in mind? Do you think you can get the Trustees to go along? And will the 
Families follow the Trustees?" 

"Yes to the first, maybe to the second, probably No to the third. I have a planet in mind as 'Tertius,' one as 
good or better than Secundus. I think many of the Trustees would agree with my reasoning but I'm not sure of the 
overwhelming support such a move would need — Secundus is too comfortable for the danger to seem imminent 
to most people. As for the Families themselves — no, I don't think we could persuade most of them to uproot and 
move but even a few hundred thousand would suffice. Gideon's Band — you follow me?" 

"I'm way ahead of you. Migration always involves selection and improvement. Elementary. If they'll do it. If. Ira, 
I had a hell of a time selling the idea to the Families when we moved here back in the twenty-third century. Could 
not have sold it at all if Earth had not become a dreary place. Good luck; you'll need it." 

"Lazarus, I don't expect to succeed. I will try. But if I fail, I'll resign and migrate anyhow. To Tertius if I can 
organize a party large enough for a viable colony. To some planet colonized but very thinly settled if not." 

"Do you mean that, Ira? Or, when the time comes, will you kid yourself that it is really your duty to hang on? If a 
man has the temperament for power — and you have or you wouldn't be where you are — he finds it hard to 
abdicate." 

"I mean it, Lazarus. Oh, I like to run things; I know it. I hope to lead the Families on their third Exodus. But I 
don't expect to. However, I think my chances of putting together a viable colony — of young people, not over a 
hundred years old, two hundred at most — without the aid of the Foundation, are fairly good. But if I fail in that, 
too" — he shrugged — "migration will be the only worthwhile course open to me; Secundus will have nothing more 
to offer." Weatheral added, "Perhaps I feel as you do, sir, in a minor way. I have no wish to be Chairman Pro Tern 



all my days. I've had almost a century of it; that's enough. If I can't put this over." 

Lazarus was thoughtfully silent; Weatheral waited. 

"Ira, install that suicide switch for me. But tomorrow. Not today." 

"Yes, sir." 

"Don't you want to know why?" Lazarus picked up the large envelope, his will. "If you convince me that you 
are going to migrate, come hell or high water and no matter what the Trustees do, I want to rewrite this. My 
investments and cash accounts here and there — if somebody hasn't stolen them while my back was turned — add 
up to a nice piece of change. Possibly enough to make the difference between success and failure in mounting 
a migration. If the Trustees won't back it with Foundation funds. And they won't." 

Weatheral said nothing. Lazarus glared at him. "Didn't your mother teach you to say 'Thank you'?" 

"For what, Lazarus? Forgiving me something after you're dead and no longer need it? If you do this, it will be 
to tickle your vanity — not to please me." 

Lazarus grinned. "Hell, yes. I ought to stick in a condition that you name the planet 'Lazarus.' But I would have 
no way to enforce it. Okay, we understand each other. And I think — Do you respect good machinery?" 

"Eh? Nfes. As much as I despise machinery that doesn't do what it is putatively designed to do." 

"We still understand each other. I think I'll leave the 'Dora'-that's my yacht-to you personally rather than to the 
Families' chairman... //you lead a migration." 

"Uh. . .you tempt me to thank you." 

"Don't. Just be good to her. She's a sweet craft, she's never known anything but kindness. She'll make a fine 
flagship for you. With simple reoutfitting — specs for it in her computer — she'll house a staff of twenty or thirty. And 
you can ground and reconnoiter in her, then lift off again — which your transports won't be able to do, most likely." 

"Lazarus... I don't want to inherit either money or a yacht from you. Let them finish your rejuvenation — and 
come 

with us, man! I'll step aside and you can boss. Or you can have no duties at all. But come!" 

Lazarus smiled bleakly and shook his head. "I've been on six such colonizing ventures to virgin planets, not 
counting Secundus. All to planets I discovered. Gave it up centuries back. Anything gets boring in time. Do you 
think Solomon serviced all his thousand wives? If so, what sort of job did he do on the last one? — poor girl! Find 
me something new to do and I might never touch that suicide switch and still give you all I've got for your colony. It 
'ud be a fair swap. . .as this halfway rejuvenation is most unsatisfactory; I don't feel well, yet I can't die. So I'm 
stuck between the suicide switch and giving in for the full treatment... the donkey that starved to death between 
two piles of hay. But it would have to be new, Ira, not something I've done over and over again. Like that old 
whore, I've climbed the same stairs too many times; my feet hurt." 

"I'll think about the problem, Lazarus. I'll give it hard and systematic research." 

"Seven to two you can't find anything I haven't done." 

"I'll make a real try. Ntiu'll lay off the suicide switch while I research it?" 

"No promises. Not once I get this will redrafted. Can you trust your chief legal eagle? May need some help 
...because this will" — he tapped the envelope — "leaving everything to the Families would stand up on Secundus 
no matter how many flaws are in it. But if I leave it to a private party — you, I mean — some of my descendants 
— quite a passel — will scream 'undue influence' and try to break it. Ira, they'll keep it tied up in court until it's 
dribbled away in legal fees. Let's avoid that, eh?" 

"We can. I've made changes in the rules. On this planet a man can put his will through probate before his 
death, and if there are flaws, the court is required to help him rephrase it to accomplish his purposes. If he does 
it that way, no contest can be entertained by any court; it goes automatically into effect on his death. Of course if 
he changes his will, the new will must go through the same process — which makes changing his mind expensive. 
But by using preprobate, it does not take a lawyer for even the most complex will. And the lawyers can't touch it 
afterwards." 

Lazarus' eyes widened with pleasure. "Didn't you annoy a few lawyers?" 

"I've annoyed so many," Ira said dryly, "that every transport to Felicity has voluntary migrants in it — and so 
many lawyers have annoyed me, that some are involuntary ones." The Chairman Pro Tens looked sourly 
amused. "Once I said to my Chief Justice, 'Warren, I've bad to reverse too many of your decisions. \bu've been 
splitting hairs, misinterpreting the rules, and ignoring equity ever since you came into office. Go home; you're 
under house arrest until the 'Last Chance' lifts. You can have an escort during daylight hours to let you wind up 
your private affairs." 



Lazarus chuckled. "Shoulda hanged him. You know what he did, don't you? Set up shop again on Felicity and 
went into politics. If they didn't lynch him." 

"His problem and theirs, not mine. Lazarus, I never let a man be executed for being a fool — but if he's too 
obnoxious, I ship him out. There's no need to sweat over your new will if you want one. Just dictate it with any 
elaborations and explanations you see fit. Then we'll run it through a semantic analyzer to rephrase it into airtight 
legal language. Once it satisfies you, you can submit it to the High Court — which will come to you if you prefer 
— and the Court will validate it. Done that way it could then be overturned only by arbitrary act of a new Chairman 
Pro Tern. Which I consider most unlikely; the Trustees do not place such men in office." 

Weatheral added, "But I hope you will take plenty of time, Lazarus. I want a fair chance to search for 
something new, something that will restore your interest in life." 

"All right. But don't dally; I won't be put off with a Scheherazade gag. Have them send me a recorder 
— tomorrow morning, say." 

Weatheral seemed about to speak, did not. Lazarus looked at him sharply. " This conversation is being 
recorded?" 

"Yes, Lazarus. Sound and holography, everything that happens in this suite. But — your pardon, sir! — it goes 
only to my desk and does not become a permanent record until I have checked and okayed it. Nothing so far, 
that is." 

Lazarus shrugged. "Forget it. Ira, I learned centuries back that there is no privacy in any society crowded 
enough to need ID's. A law guaranteeing privacy simply insures that bugs — microphones and lenses and so forth 
— are that much harder to spot. I hadn't thought about it up till now because I take it for granted that., my privacy 
will be invaded anytime I visit such places — then I ignore it unless I'm up to something the local law won't like. In 
which case I use evasive tactics." 

"Lazarus, that record can be wiped. Its only purpose is to make me certain that the Senior is being properly 
taken care of — a responsibility I will not delegate." 

"I said, 'Forget it.' But I'm surprised at your naivete, a man in your position, in thinking that the record is piped 
only to your desk. I'll lay long odds, any amount you like, that it goes one, two, even three or more other places." 

"If so, Lazarus, and lean find it out, Felicity will have some new colonists — aftertheyVe spent some 
unpleasant hours in the Colosseum." 

"Ira, it doesn't matter. If any fool wants to watch an old, old man grunting on the pot or taking a bath, he's 
welcome. Nfciu yourself insured that it would happen by making a point of the record being secret, your eyes only. 
Security people always spy on their bosses; they can’t help it, it's a syndrome that goes with the job. Have you 
had dinner? I'd be pleased to have you stay if you have time." 

"I would be honored indeed to have dinner with the Senior." 

"Oh, knock it off, Bud; there's no virtue in being old, it just takes a long time. I'd like you to stay because I'm 
enjoying human companionship. Those two over there are no company; I'm not even sure they're human. Robots, 
maybe. Why do they wear those diving suits and shiny helmets. I like to see a man's face." 

"Lazarus, those are total isolation garments. For your protection, not theirs. Against infection." 

" Whaf? Ira, when a bug bites me, the bug dies. Even so, since they have to wear that, how is it that you come 
in wearing street clothes?' 

"Not quite, Lazarus. For my purpose I needed a social talk, fake to face. So the last two hours before I came 
in I spent undergoing a most careful physical examination, followed by scalp-to-toe sterilization of skin, hair, ears, 
nails, teeth, nose, throat-even a gas inhalation which I can't name but did not like — while my clothes were 
sterilized even more thoroughly. Even that envelope I fetched to you. This suite is sterile and kept so." 

"Ira, such precautions are silly. Unless my immunity has been intentionally lowered?" 

"No. Or let me say, 'I think not.' No reason for it as any transplant will of course be done from your own clone." 

"So it's unnecessary. If I didn't catch anything in that flophouse, why would I catch anything now? But I don't 
catch things. I worked as a physician during a plague — don't look surprised; medicine is just one of fifty-odd 
trades I've followed. Unknown plague on Ormuzd; everybody caught it, twenty-eight percent died. Save yours 
truly, who didn't ever have a sniffle. So tell those — No, you'll want to do it through the Director of the Clinic; 
bypassing your chain-of-command ruins morale-though why I should care about this organization's morale I don't 
know, seeing that I am an involuntary guest. Tell the Director that, if I must have nurses, I want them to dress like 
nurses. Or, better yet, like people. Ira, if you want cooperation out of me of any sort, you'll start by cooperating 
with me. Otherwise I'm going to take the joint apart with my bare hands." 



"I'll speak to the Director, Lazarus." 

"Good. Now let's have dinner. But a drink first — and if the Director doesn't think I should have one, tell him 
bluntly that he will have to go back to force-feeding and there is some question as to whose throat the tube will 
go down; I'm in no mood to be pushed around. Is there any real whisky on this planet? Wasn't the last time I was 
here." 

"Not that I would drink. But the local brandy I think well of." 

"Good. Brandy and bubbles for me if that is the best we can do, a brandy Manhattan if anyone knows what I 
mean by that." 

"I do, and like them-l learned something about ancient drinks when I studied your life." 

'Pine. Then please orderfor us, drinks and dinner — and I'll listen and see how many words I can pick up. I 
think my memory is coining back a bit." 

Weatheral spoke to one of the technicians; Lazarus interrupted. "That should be one-third sweet vermouth, 
not one-half." 

"So? \t>u understood it?" 

"Mostly. Indo-European roots, with a simplified syntax and grammar; I'm beginning to recall it. Damn it, when 
a man has had to learn as many languages as I have, it's easy for one to slip away. But it's coming back." 

Service was so fast as to cause one to suspect that a crew was standing by ready to produce anything that 
the Senior or the Chairman Pro Tern asked for. 

Weatheral raised his glass. "Long life." 

"In a pig's eye," Lazarus growled and took a sip. He made a face. 'Whew! Panther sweat. But it does have 
alcohol in it." He took another. "Improves as your tongue gets numb. Okay, Ira, you've stalled long enough. What 
was your real reason for snatching me back from my well-earned rest? 1 

"Lazarus, we need your wisdom." 



PRELUDE 

II 


Lazarus stared in horror. "What did you say?" 

"I said," Ira Weatheral repeated, "that we need your wisdom, sir. We do." 

"I thought that I was off again in one of those before-dying dreams. Son, you've come to the wrong window. 
Try across the hall." 

Weatheral shook his head. "No, sir. Oh, it isn't necessary to use the word 'wisdom' if it offends you. But we do 
need to learn what you know. \t>u are more than twice as old as the next oldest member of the Families. Nt>u 
mentioned that you have practiced more than fifty professions. You've been everywhere, you've seen far more 
than anyone else. You've certainly learned more than any of the rest of us. We aren't doing things much better 
now than we were two thousand years ago, when you were young. You must know why we are still making 
mistakes our ancestors made. It would be a great loss if you hurried your death without taking time to tell us what 
you have learned." 

Lazarus scowled and bit his lip. "Son, one of the few things I've learned is that humans hardly ever learn from 
the experience of others. They learn — when they do, which isn't often — on their own, the hard way." 

"That one statement is worth recording for all time." 

”Hmm\ No one would learn anything from it; that's what it says. Ira, age does not bring wisdom. Often it 
merely changes simple stupidity into arrogant conceit. Its only advantage, so far as I have been able to see, is 
that it spans change. A young person sees the world as a still picture, immutable. An old person has had his 
nose rubbed in changes and more changes and still more changes so many times that he knows it is a moving 
picture, forever changing. He may not like is — probably doesn't; /don't — but he knows it's so, and knowing it is 
the first step in coping with it." 

"May I place in open record what you have just said?" 

"Huh? That's not wisdom, that's a cliche. An obvious truth. Any fool will admit that, even if he doesn't live by it." 

"It would carry greater weight with your name on it, Senior." 

"Do as you like; it's just horse sense. But if you think I have gazed upon the naked Face of God, think again. I 
haven't even begun to find out how the Universe works, much less what it is for. To figure out the basic questions 
about this World it would be necessary to stand outside and look at it. Not inside. No, not in two thousand years, 
not in twenty thousand. When a man dies, he may shake loose his local perspective and see the thing as a 
whole." 

"Then you believe in an afterlife?" 

"Slow up! I don't 'believe' in anything. I know certain things — little things, not the Nine Billion Names of God 
— from experience. But I have no beliefs. Belief gets in the way of learning." 

"That's what we want, Lazarus: what you have learned. Even though you say it's nothing but 'little things.' May I 
suggest that anyone who has managed to stay alive as long as you have must necessarily have learned many 
things, or you could not have lived so long? Most humans die violent deaths. The very fact that we live so much 
longer than our ancestors did makes this inevitable. Traffic accident, murder, wild animals, sports, pilot error, a 
slippery bit of mud — eventually something catches up with us. You haven't lived a safe, placid life — quite the 
contrary! — yet you have managed to outwit all hazards for twenty-three centuries. HoW? It can't be luck." 

"Why can't it be? The most unlikely things do happen, Ira there is nothing so unlikely as a baby. But it's true 
that I've always watched where I put my feet... and never fought when I could duck out... and when I did have to 
fight, I always fought dirty. If I had to fight, I wanted him to be dead instead of me. So I tried to arrange it that way. 
Not luck. Or not much, anyway." Lazarus blinked thoughtfully. "I've never argued with the weather. Once a mob 
wanted to lynch me. I didn't try to reason with them; I just put a lot of miles between me and them as fast as I 
could and never went back there." 

"That's not in any of your memoirs." 

"Lots of things not in my memoirs. Here comes chow." 

The door dilated, a dining table for two glided in, positioned itself as the chairs separated for it, and started 
unfolding to serve. The technicians approached quietly and offered unnecessary personal service. Weatheral 



said, "Smells good. Do you have any eating rituals?' 

"Eh? Praying or such? No." 

"Not that sort. Such as — Say one of my executives eats with me: I won't let him discuss business at the table. 
But if you will permit, I would like to continue this conversation." 

"Certainly, why not? As long as we stick to subjects that don't rile the stomach. Did you ever hear what the 
priest told the old maid?" 

Lazarus glanced at the technician at his elbow. "Perhaps not now. I think this shorter one is female and she 
just might know some English. \fc>u were saying?" 

"I was saying that your memoirs are incomplete. Even if you are determined to go through with dying, won't 
you consider granting me and your other descendants the rest of your memoirs? Simply talk, tell us what you've 
seen and done. Careful analysis might teach us quite a lot. For example, what did happen at that Families 
Meeting of 2012? The minutes don't tell much." 

"Who cares now, Ira? They're all dead. It would be my version without giving them a chance to answer back. 
Let sleeping dogs bury their own dead. Besides, I told you my memory was playing tricks. I've used Andy Libby's 
hypno- encyclopedic techniques — and they're good — and also learned tier storage for memory I didn't need 
every day, with keying words to let a tier cascade when I did need it, like a computer, and I have had my brain 
washed of useless memories several times in order to clear those file drawers for new data — and still it's no 
good. Half the time I can't remember where I put the book I was reading the night before, then waste a morning 
looking for it — before I remember that that book was one I was reading a century ago. Why won't you leave an 
old man in peace?" 

"All you have to do is to tell me to shut up, sir. But I hope you will not. Granted that memory is imperfect, 
nevertheless you were eyewitness to thousands of things the rest of us are too young to have seen. Oh, I’m not 
asking you to reel off a formal autobiography covering all your centuries. But you might reminisce about anything 
you care to talk about. For example, there is no record anywhere of your earliest years. I — and millions of others 
— would be extremely interested in whatever you remember of your boyhood." 

"What is there to remember? I spent my boyhood the way every boy does — trying to keep my elders from 
finding out what I was up to." 

Lazarus wiped his mouth and looked thoughtful. "On the whole I was successful. The few times I was caught 
and clobbered taught me to be more careful next time — keep my mouth shut more and not make my lies too 
complicated. Lying is one of the fine arts, Ira, and it seems to be dying out." 

"Really? I had not noticed any diminution." 

"I mean as a fine art. There are still plenty of clumsy liars, approximately as many as there are mouths. Do 
you know the two most artistic ways to lie?" 

"Perhaps I don't but I would like to learn. Just two?" 

"So far as I know. It's not enough to be able to lie with a straight face; anybody with enough gall to raise on a 
busted flush can do that. The first way to lie artistically is to tell the truth — but not all of it. The second way involves 
telling the truth, too, but is harder: Tell the exact truth and maybe all of it... but tell it so unconvincingly that your 
listener is sure you are lying. 

"I must have been twelve, thirteen years old before I got that one down pat. Learned it from my maternal 
Grampaw; I take after him quite a lot. He was a mean old devil. Wouldn't go inside a church or see a doctor 
— claimed that neither doctors nor preachers know what they pretend to know. At eighty-five he could crack nuts 
with his teeth and straight-arm a seventy-pound anvil by its horn. I left home about then and never saw him again. 
But the Families' Records say that he was killed in the Battle of Britain during the bombing of London, which 
was, some years after." 

"I know. He's my ancestor, too, of course, and I'm named for him, Ira Johnson."* (* (1) Ira Johnson was less 
than eighty at the time the Senior claims (elsewhere) to have left home. Ira Johnson was- himself a Doctor of 
Medicine. How long he practiced, and whether or not he ever let another Doctor of Medicine attend him, -are not 
known. J.F.45th 

(2) Ira Howard — Ira Johnson — This appears to be a chance coincidence of given names at a time when 
Biblical names were common. Families' genealogists have been unable to trace any consanguinity. J.F.45 th ) 

"Why, sure enough, that was his name. I just called him 'Gramp.'" 

"Lazarus, this is exactly the sort of thing I want to get on record. Ira Johnson is not only your grandfather and 
my remote grandfather but also is ancestor to many million people here and elsewhere — yet save for the few 



words you have just told me about him, he has been only a name, a date of birth, and a date of death, nothing 
more. You've suddenly brought him alive again — a man, a unique human being. Colorful." 

Lazarus looked thoughtful. "I never thought of him as 'colorful.' Matter offact he was an unsaveryold coot 
— not a 'good influence' — for a growing boy by the standards of those times. Mmm, there was something about a 
young school marm and him in the town my family had lived in, some scandal — 'scandal' for those days, I mean 
— and I think that was why we moved. I never got the straight of it as the grownups wouldn't talk about it in front of 
me. 

"But I did learn a lot from him; he had more time to talk with me-or took more time-than my parents had, 

Some of it stuck. 'Always cut the cards, Woodie,' he would say. '\bu may lose anyhow — but not as often, nor as 
much. And when you do, lose, smile.' Things like that." 

"Can you remember any more of what he said?" 

"Huh? After all these years? Of course not. Well, maybe. He had me out south of town teaching me to shoot. I 
was maybe ten and he was-oh, I don't know; he always seemed ninety years older than God to me.* (* Ira 
Johnson was seventy when Lazarus Long was ten. J.F. 45 th ) He pinned up a target, put one in the black to show 
me it could be done, then handed me the rifle — little .22 single-shot, not good for much but targets and tin 
cans — 'All right, it's loaded; do just what I did; get steady on it, relax and squeeze.' So I did, and all I heard was a 
click — it didn't fire. 

"I said so, and started to open the breech. He slapped my hand away, took the rifle from me with his other 
hand-then clouted me a good one. 'What did I tell you about hangfires, Woodie? Are you aching to walk around 
with one eye the rest of your life? Or merely trying to kill yourself? If the latter, I can show you several better ways. 1 

"Then he said, 'Now watch closely 1 — and he opened the breech. Empty. So I said, 'But, Gramp, you told me it 
was loaded.' Shucks, Ira, I sawhim load, it — I thought. 

"'So I did, Woodie,' he agreed. 'And I lied to you. I went through the motions and palmed the cartridge. Now 
what did I tell you about loaded guns? Think hard and get it right... or I'll be forced to clout you again to shake up 
your brains and make 'em work better.' 

"I thought fast and got it right; Gramp had a heavy hand. 'Never take anybody's word about whether a gun is 
loaded.' 

"'Correct, 1 he agreed. 'Remember that all your life — and follow it! — or you won't live long.' *( This anecdote is 
too obscure to be elaborated here. See Howard Encyclopaedia: Ancient weapons, chemical-explosives 
firearms.) 

"Ira. I did remember that all my life — plus its application to analogous situations after such firearms went out 
of style and it has indeed kept me alive several times. 

"Then he had me load it myself, then said, 'Woodie, I'll bet you half a dollar — do you have half a dollar?' I had 
considerably more, but I had bet with him before, so I admitted to only a quarter. 'Okay,' he said, 'Make it two- 
bits; I never let 'a man bet on credit. Two-bits says you can't hit the target, much less stay in the black. 1 

"Then he pocketed my two-bits and showed me what was wrong with what I had done. By the time he was 
ready to knock off I had the basics of howto make a gun do what I wanted it to do, and wanted to bet him again. 
He laughed at me and told me to be thankful the lesson was so cheap. Pass the salt, please." 

Weatheral did so. "Lazarus, if I could find a way to entice you into reminiscing about your grandfather — or 
about anything — I'm certain we could extract from such record endless things you have learned, important things 
— whether you choose to call them wisdom or not. In the last ten minutes you have stated half a dozen basic 
truths, or rules for living — call them what you will — apparently without trying." 

"Such as?" 

"Oh, for example, that most people learn only by experience — " 

"Correction. Most people won't learn even by experience, Ira. Never underestimate the power of human 
stupidity." 

"There's another one. And you 'made a couple of comments on the fine art of lying — three, really, as you also 
mentioned that a lie should never be too complicated. You said also that belief gets in the way of learning, and 
something about knowing a situation was the essential first step in coping with it." 

"I didn't say that — although I could have said it." 

"I generalized something you did say. \bu said also that you never 'argued with the weather. . .which I would 
generalize to mean: Don't indulge in wishful thinking. Or as 'Face up to the facts and act accordingly. 1 Though I 
prefer the way you put it; it has more flavor. And 'Always cut the cards.' I haven't played card games in many 



years, but I took that to mean: Never, neglect any available means of maximizing one's chances in a situation 
controlled by random events." 

"Hmm. Gramp would have said, 'Stow the fancy talk, Sonny.'" 

"So we'll put it back into his words: 'Always cut the cards... and smile when you lose.' If indeed that is not your 
own phrasing and simply attributed to him." 

"Oh, his all right. Well, I think it is. Damn it, Ira, after a long time it is hard to tell a real memory from a memory 
of a memory of a memory of a real memory. That's what happens when you think about the past: Nt>u edit it and 
rearrange it, make it more tolerable-" 

"That's another one!" 

"Oh, hush up. Son, I don't want to reminisce about the past; it's a sure sign of old age. Babies and young 
children live in the present, the 'now.' Mature adults tend to live in the future. Only the senile live in the past... and 
that was the sign that made me realize that I had lived long enough, when I found I was spending more and more 
time thinking about the past... less of it thinking about now — and not at all about the future." 

The old man sighed. "So I knew I had had it. The way to live a long time — oh, a thousand years or more — is 
something between the way a child does it and the way a mature man does it. Give the future enough thought to 
be ready for it — but don't worry about it. Live each day as if you were to die next sunrise. Then face each sunrise 
as a fresh creation and live for it, joyously. And never think about the past. No regrets, ever." Lazarus Long 
looked sad, then suddenly smiled and repeated, "'No regrets.' More wine, Ira?" 

"Haifa glass, thank you. Lazarus, if you are determined to die soon — your privilege, certainly! — what harm 
could there be in remembering the past now. ..and getting those memories on record for the benefit of your 
descendants? It would be a much greater legacy than leaving your wealth to us. 

Lazarus' eyebrows shot up. "Son, you are beginning to bore me." 

"\bur pardon, sire. May I have permission to leave?" 

"Oh, shut up and sit down. Finish your dinner. You remind me of — Well, there was this man on Novo Brasil 
who complied with the local custom of serial bigamy but was always careful to see that one of his wives was as 
utterly homely as the other was startlingly beautiful, so that — Ira, that dingus you have listening to us: Can it be 
keyed to pick out particular statements and arrange them as a separate memorandum?" 

"Certainly, sir." 

"Good. There's no point in telling how Ranch Master Silva? — yes, I think 'Silva' was his name, Dorn Pedro 
Silva — how he coped with it when he found himself stuck with two beautiful wives at once, except to note that 
when a computer makes a mistake, it is even more stupidly stubborn about correcting it than a man is. But if I 
thought long and hard, I might be able to dig out those 'gems of wisdom' you think I have. Paste diamonds, that 
is. Then we wouldn't have to load up the machine with dull stories about Dorn Pedro and the like. A keyword?" 

" 'Wisdom'?" 

"Go wash out your mouth with soap." 

"I will not. You stuck your chin into that one, Senior. 

'Common sense'?" 

"Son, that phrase is self-contradictory. 'Sense' is never 'common.' Make the keying word 'Notebook' — that's 
all I have in mind, just a notebook to jot down things I've noticed and which might be important enough to place 
on record." 

"Fine! Shall I amend the programming now?" 

"\bu can do it from here? I don't want' you to interrupt your dinner." 

"It's a very flexible machine, Lazarus; the total complex is the one I use to govern this planet — to the mild 
extent that I do govern it." 

“In that case I feel sure you can hang an auxiliary printout in here, one triggered for the keying word. I might 
want to revise my sparkling gems of wisdom — meaning that extemporaneous remarks sound better when they 
aren’t extemporaneous — or why politicians have ghostwriters.” 

‘“Ghost writers’? My command of Classic English is less than perfect; I don’t recognize the idiom.” 

“Ira, don’t tell me you write your own speeches.” 

“But, Lazarus, I don’t make speeches. Never. I just give orders, and — very seldom — make written reports to 
the Trustees.” 

“Congratulations. \bu can bet that there are ghost writers on Felicity. Or soon will be.” 

“I’ll have that printout installed at once, sir. Roman alphabet and twentieth-century spelling? If you intend to 



use the language we’ve been talking?” 

“Unless it would place too much strain on a poor innocent machine. If so, I can read it in phonetics. I think.” 

“It is a very flexible machine, sir; it taught me to speak this language — and earlier, to read it.” 

“Good, do it that way. But tell it not to correct my grammar. Human editors are difficult enough; I won’t accept 
such upstart behavior from a machine.” 

“Yes, sir. If you will excuse me one moment — ” The Chairman Pro Tern raised his voice slightly and shifted to 
the New Rome variant of Lingua Galacta. Then he spoke in the same language to the taller technician. 

The auxiliary printout was installed before the table served them coffee. 

After it was switched on, it whirred briefly. “What’s it doing?” asked Lazarus. “Checking its circuits?” 

“No, sir — printing. I tried an experiment. The machine has considerable judgment within the limits of its 
programs and memoried experience. In adding the extra program I told it also to go back, review everything you 
have said to me, and attempt to select all statements that sounded like aphorisms. I’m not sure it can do this, as 
any definition of ‘aphorism’ it has in its permanents is certain to be quite abstract. But I have hopes. However, I 
told it firmly: No editing.” 

“Well. The astounding thing about a waltzing bear is not, howgracefully it waltzes but that it waltzes at all.’ 

Not me, some other bloke; I’m quoting. Let’s see what it has.” 

Weatheral gestured; the shorter technician hurried to the machine, pulled a copy for each of them, fetched 
them back. 

Lazarus looked his copy over. “Mmmm. . .yes. That next one isn’t true — just a wisecrack. Must reword the third 
one little. Hey! It put a question mark after this one. What an impudent piece of junk; I checked that one out 
centuries before it was anything but unmined ore. Well, at least it didn’t try to revise it. Don’t recall saying that, 

‘but it’s true and I durned near got killed learning it.” 

Lazarus looked up from the printout copy. “Okay, ‘Son. If you want this stuff on record, I don’t mind. As long as 
I am allowed to check and revise it. . .for I don’t want my words to be taken as Gospel unless I have a chance to 
winnow out the casual nonsense. Which I am just as capable of voicing as the next man.” 

“Certainly, sir. Nothing will go into the records without your approval. Unless you choose to use that switch . . 
in which case any unedited remarks you have left behind I will have to try to edit myself. That’s the best I can do.” 

“Trying to trap me, huh? Hmm — Ira, suppose I offer you a Scheherazade deal in reverse.” 

“I don’t understand.” 

“Is Scheherazade lost at last? Did Sir Richard Burton live in vain?” 

“Oh, no, sir! I have read The Thousand Nights and a Night in the Burton original. . .and her stories have 
come down through the centuries, changed again and again to make them understandable to new generations 
— but with, I think, the flavor retained. I simply do not understand what you are proposing.” 

“I see. Nt>u told me that talking with me is the most important thing you have to do.” 

“It is.” 

“I wonder. If you mean that, then you will be here every day to keep me company — and chat. For I’m not going 
to bother babbling to your machine no matter how smart it is.” 

“Lazarus, I will be not only honored but much pleased to be allowed to keep you company as long as you will 
let me.” 

“We’ll see. ‘When a man makes a sweeping statement, he often has mental reservations. I mean every day, 
Son, and all day. And you — not a deputy. Show up two hours after breakfast, say, and stay till I send you home. 
But any day you miss — Well, if it’s so urgent you just have to miss, phone your excuses and send over a pretty 
girl to visit me. One who speaks Classic English but has sense enough to listen instead — as an old fool will often 
talk to a pretty girl who just bats her lashes at him and looks impressed. If she pleases me, I might let her stay. Or 
I might be so petulant that I would send her away and use that switch you promised to have reinstalled. But I won’t 
suicide in the presence of a guest; that’s rude. Understand me?” 

“I think I do,” Ira Weatheral answered slowly. “Ntiu’ll be both Scheherazade and King Shabryar, and I'll be — no, 
that’s not right; / am the one who has to keep it going for a thousand nights — I mean ‘days’ — and if I miss — but I 
won’t! — you are free to — ’’ 

“Don’t push an analogy too far,” Lazarus advised. “I'm simply calling your bluff. If my maunderings are as all- 
fired important to you as you claim, then you’ll show up and listen. You can skip once, or even twice, if the girl is 
pretty enough and knows howto tickle my vanity — of which I have plenty — just right. But if you skip too often, I’ll 
know you’re bored and the deal is off. I’m betting that your patience will’ wear out long before any thousand days 



and a day have passed — whereas I do know how to be patient, for year after year if necessary; that’s a prime 
reason I’m still alive. But you’re still a youngster; I’m betting I can outsit you.” 

“I accept the bet. This girl — if I must be away some day — would you object if I sent one of my daughters? 
She’s very pretty.” 

“Hunh? Nfciu sound like an Iskandrian slave factor auctioning his mother. Why your daughter? I don’t want to 
marry her, nor even to bed her; I simply want to be amused and flattered. Who told you she was pretty? If she 
really is your’ daughter, she probably looks like you.” 

“Come off it, Lazarus; you can’t annoy me that easily. I admit to a father’s prejudice but I’ve seen the effect 
she has on others. She is quite young, less than eighty, and has been contractually married only once. But you 
specified a pretty girl who speaks your milk language. Scarce. But this one of my daughters shares my talent for 
languages and is much excited by your presence here — wants to meet you. I can stall off emergencies long 
enough for her to become letter-perfect in your language.” 

Lazarus grinned and shrugged. “Suit yourself. Tell her not to bother with a chastity girdle; I don’t have the 
energy. But I’ll still win the bet. Probably without laying eyes on her; it won’t take you long to decide that I am an 
unbearable old bore. Which I am and have been almost as long as the Wandering Jew — a crashing bore if I ever 
met one — did I tell you I had met him?” 

“No. And I don’t believe you have. He's a myth.” 

“A fat lot you know about it, Son. I have met him, he is authentic. Fought the Romans in 70 A. D. when 
Jerusalem was sacked. Fought in every Crusade — incited one of them. Redheaded of course; all of the natural 
long-lifers bear the mark of Gilgamesh. When I met him he was using the name Sandy Macdougal, that being a 
better handle for the time and place for his current trade, which was the long con, with a variant on the badger 
game.* (* While this passage bears inner contradictions, the idioms are authentic for North America of the 
twentieth century. They name certain types of financial dishonesty. See “Swindles” under “Fraud” in 
Krishnamurti’s NewGolden Bough, Academe Press, New Rome. J.F. 45 th ) The latter involved — Look, Ira, if 
you don’t believe my stories, why are you going to so much trouble to get them on record?” 

“Lazarus, if you think you can bore me to death — correction: to your death — why are you bothering to invent 
fictions to entertain me? Whatever your reasons, I’ll listen as carefully — and as long — as King Shabryar. As may 
be, my master computer is recording whatever you choose to say — without editing; I guaranteed that — but it has 
incorporated into it a most subtle truth analyzer quite capable of earmarking any fictions you include. Not that I 
care about historicity as long as you will talk ... as it is clear to me that you automatically include your evaluations 
— those ‘gems of wisdom’ — no matter what you say.” 

‘“Gems of wisdom.’ \bungster, use that expression once more and you'll stay after school and clean the 
blackboards. That computer of yours — Better instruct it that my most outlandish tales are the ones most likely to 
be true — as that is the literal truth. No storyteller has ever been able to dream up anything as fantastically unlikely 
as what really does happen in this mad Universe.” 

“It knows that. But I will caution it again. You were telling me about Sandy Macdougal, the Wandering Jew.” 

“Was I? If so and if he was using that name, that must have been late in the twentieth century and in 
Vancouver, as I recall. Vancouver was a part of the United States where the people were so clever that they 
never paid taxes to Washington — Sandy should have operated in New\brk, which was outstanding in stupidity 
even then. I won’t give details of his swindles; it might corrupt your machine. Let it suffice that Sandy used the 
oldest principle for separating a fool from his money: Pick a sucker who likes the best of it. 

“That’s all it takes, Ira. If a man is greedy, you can cheat him every time. Trouble was, Sandy Macdougal was 
even greedier than his marks, and it led him into the folly of excess, and often forced him to leave town while it 
was dark, sometimes leaving the boodle behind. Ira, when you skin a man, you have to let him recuperate and 
grow more hide — or he gets nervous. If you respect this simple rule, a real mark can be skinned over and over 
again, and it just keeps him healthy and productive. But Sandy was too greedy for that; he lacked patience.” 

“Lazarus, you sound as if you had great experience in this art.” 

Now Ira — a little respect please I have never swindled a man. At most I kept quiet and let him swindle 
himself. This does no harm, as a fool cannot be protected from his folly. If you attempt to do so, you will not only 
arouse his animosity but also you will be attempting to deprive him of whatever benefit he is capable of deriving 
from experience. Never attempt to teach a pig to sing; it wastes your time and annoys the pig. 

“But I do know a lot about swindles. I think that every major variation of every possible swindle has been tried 
on me, one time and another. 



“Some of them worked back when I was very young. Then I took Grampaw Johnson’s advice and quit looking 
for the best of it; thereafter I could no longer be swindled. But I was not capable of benefiting from Gramp’s 
advice until I was burned a few times. Ira, it’s getting late.” 

The Chairman Pro Tern promptly stood up. “So it is, sir. May I ask two questions before I leave? Not for your 
memoirs, procedural questions only.” 

“Make it short and snappy.” 

“\bu’ll have your termination-option switch tomorrow morning. But, you spoke of not feeling well, and there is 
no need for that even if you choose to terminate in the near future. Shall we resume the rejuvenation procedures? 

“Hmmm. Second question?” 

“I promised to do my best to find something brand-new to interest you. I promised also to spend every day 
here with you. I see conflict.” 

Lazarus grinned. “Don’t kid your old Grampaw, Son; you'll delegate that research.” 

“Certainly. But I must plan how to start it, then review progress at intervals, and suggest new avenues to 
explore." 

“Mmm...if I consent to the full course, I’ll be out of circulation a day or two every now and then." 

“I believe current practice calls for one day of deep rest approximately each week, varied to suit the client’s 
condition. My own experience is about a hundred years back; I understand there have been improvements. 
\t>u’ve decided to take it, sir?” 

“I’ll tell you tomorrow — after that switch is installed. Ira, I don’t make decisions in haste that don’t call for haste. 
But if I consent, you’ll have free time to use as you see fit. G’night, Ira.” 

“Good night, Lazarus. I hope you decide to accept it.” Weatheral turned toward the door, stopped halfway 
there, and spoke to the technicians — who left the room at once. The dining table scurried after them. Once the 
door had shut down Weatheral turned and-faced Lazarus Long. “Grandfather,” he said softly, his voice somewhat 
choked. “Uh — may I?” 

Lazarus had let his chair sink back into a reclining couch that held him, hammocklike, as tenderly as a 
mother’s arms. At the younger man’s words he raised his head. “Huh? What? Oh! All right, all right, come here 
— Grandson.” He reached out one arm to Weatheral. 

The Chairman Pro Tern hurried to him, took Lazarus' hand, dropped to his knees and kissed it. 

Lazarus snatched his hand back. “For Pete’s sake! Don’t kneel to me — don’t ever do that. If you want to be 
my grandson, treat me as such. Not that way.” 

“Yes, Grandfather.” Weatheral got to his feet, leaned over the old man, and kissed his mouth. 

Lazarus patted his cheek. “You’re a sentimentalist, Grandson. But a good boy. Trouble is, there never has 
been much demand for good boys. Now get that solemn expression off your face and go home and get a good 
night’s rest.” 

“\fes, Grandfather. I will. Good night.” 

“Good night. Now beat it.” 

Weatheral left quickly. The technicians jumped aside as he came out, then went back into the suite. 

Weatheral continued on, ignoring people around him but with a softer, gentler expression on his face than was 
his wont. He went past a bank of transports to the Director’s private transport; it opened to his voice, then 
conveyed him quickly into the bowels of the city and directly to the Executive Palace. 

Lazarus looked up as his attendants came back in; he motioned the taller one to him. The technician’s voice, 
filtered and distorted bythe helmet, said carefully, “Bed. ..sir?’ 

“No, I want — ” Lazarus paused, then spoke to the air, “Computer? Can you speak? If not, print it out.” 

“I hear you, Senior,” a mellifluous, contralto voice answered. “Tell this nurse that I want whatever they are 
allowed to give me for pain. I have work to do.” 

“\fes, Senior.” The disembodied voice shifted to Lingua Galacta, was answered in kind, then went on: “Master 
Chief Technician on duty wishes to know the nature and location of your pain, and adds that you should not work 
tonight." 

Lazarus kept silent while he counted ten chimpanzees in his mind. Then he said softly “Damn it, I hurt 
everywhere. And I don’t want advice from a child. I have loose ends to tidy up before I sleep... because one 
never knows that one will wake up again. Forget the painkiller, it ain’t all that important. Tell 'em to get out and 
stay out.” 



Lazarus tried to ignore the ensuing exchange, as it annoyed him that he almost-not-quite understood it. He 
opened the envelope Ira Weatheral had returned to him, then opened out his will — a long bellows-fold of 
computer printout — and started reading it while whistling off key. 

“Senior, Master Chief technician on duty states that you have given a null order, which is a true statement by 
the Clinic’s regulations. A general analgesic is forthcoming.” 

“Forget it.” Lazarus went on reading, and shifted to singing softly the tune he had been whistling: 

“There’s a pawnshop on the corner 
Where I usually keep my overcoat. 

“There’s a bookie 

Behind the pawnshop 

Who handles my investments” * 

(* This doggerel is attributed to the twentieth century. See appendix for semantic analysis. J.F.45th) 

The taller technician appeared at his elbow, carrying a shiny disk with attached tubing. “For... pain." 

Lazarus made a brush-off gesture with his free hand. “Go ‘way, I’m busy.” 

The shorter technician appeared on his other side. Lazarus looked that way and said, “What do you want?” 

As he turned his head the taller technician moved quickly; Lazarus felt a sting in his forearm. He rubbed the 
spot and said, “Why, you rapscallion. Foxed me, didn’t you? All right, beat it. Raus. Scat!” He dismissed the 
incident from his mind and returned to work. A moment later he said: 

“Computer!" 

“Awaiting your orders, Senior.” 

“Record this for printout. I, Lazarus Long, sometimes known as the Senior and listed in the Howard Families’ 
Genealogies as Woodrow Wilson Smith, born 1912, do declare this to be my last will and testament — 

Computer, go back through my talk with Ira and dig out what I said I wanted to do to help him lead a migration 
— got it?” 

“Retrieved, Senior.” 

“Fix up the language and tack it onto my opening statement. And — let me see — add something like this: In 
the event Ira Weatheral fails to qualify for inheritance, then all my worldly wealth of which I die possessed shall go 
to, uh, to — to found a home for indigent and superannuated pickpockets, prostitutes, panhandlers, piemen, 
priggers, and other unworthy poor starting with ‘ P’ . Got it?” 

“Recorded, Senior. Please be advised that this alternative has a high probability of being nullified if tested by 
the current rules of this planet.” 

Lazarus expressed a rhetorical and physiologically improbable wish. “All right, set it up for stray cats or some 
other useless but legally acceptable purpose. Search your permanents for such a purpose that wll get by the 
courts. Just be certain that the Trustees can’t get their hands on it. Understand?’ 

“There is no wayto be certain of that, Senior, but it will be attempted.” 

“Look for a loophole. Print that out as fast as you can research it and put it together. Now stand by for a 
memorandum of my assets. Begin.” Lazarus started to read the list, found that his eyes were blurring and would 
not focus. “Damnation! Those dummies slipped me a Mickey and it’s taking hold. Blood! I must have a drop of 
my own blood to thumbprint it! Tell those dummies to help me and tell them why — and warn them that I will bite my 
tongue to get it if they won't help me. Now printout my will with any feasible alternative — but hurry!” 

“Printout starting,” the computer answered quietly, then shifted to Galacta. 

The “dummies” did not argue with the computer; they moved fast, one snatching the new sheet out of the 
auxiliary printout the instant it stopped whirring, the other producing a sterile point out of nowhere and stabbing 
the ball of Lazarus’ left little finger after giving Lazarus a split second to see what was being done. 

Lazarus did not wait for blood to be taken by pipette. He squeezed the stabbed finger for a drop, rubbed his 
right thumb in it, then print-signed his will while the shorter technician held it for him. 

Then he sank back. “It’s done,” he whispered. “Tell Ira.” He was heavily asleep at once. 



COUNTERPOINT 

I 


The chair gently transferred Lazarus to his bed while the technicians silently supervised. Then the shorter 
watched the readouts on respiration, heart action, brain rhythms, and other physicals while the taller placed the 
documents, old will and new, in an impervolope, sealed it, chopped and thumb-printed the seal, marked it 
“Surrender only to the Senior and/or Mr. Chairman Pro Tern,” then retained it until their reliefs arrived. 

The relief chief technician listened to the record of the watch, glanced over the physicals, studied the 
sleeping client. 

“Timed,” he stated. 

“Neolethe. Thirty-four hours.” 

He whistled. “Another crisis?” 

“Less severe than the last. Pseudopain with irrational irascibility. Physicals within limits for this stage.” 

“What’s in the sealer?” 

“Just sign for it and include delivery instructions in your receipt.” 

“Pardon me for using up oxygen!” 

“\bur receipt, please.” 

The relief wrote out a receipt, chopped and thumbed it, swapped it for the impervolope. “I relieve you,” he 
said brusquely. 

“Thank you." 

The shorter technician was waiting at the door. The Master Chief Technician paused to say, “You needn’t 
have waited. It sometimes takes me three times this long to turn over the watch. You are free to leave as soon as 
the relief junior watch officer arrives.” 

“Yes, Master Chief Technician. But this is a very special client — and I thought you might need me with Mr. 
Snoopy Nose.” 

“I can cope with him. >fes, a very special client indeed and it speaks well for you that the Skills Board 
assigned you to me when your predecessor opted out.” 

“Thank you!” 

“Don’t thank me, Associate Technician.” The voice, although distorted by helmet and relay and filter, sounded 
gentle even though the words were not. “That was not a compliment but a statement of fact. If you had not done 
well on your first watch, there would be no second watch — as you say, ‘a very special client.’ Nt>u did well. . .aside 
from nervousness a client can feel even though he can’t see your face. But you’ll get over that.” 

“Uh...lhope so. I was very nervous!” 

“I would rather have an assistant keyed up tight than one who knows it all and is sloppy. But you should be 
home now and resting. Come along; I’ll drop you off. Where do you robe? The intermediate lounge? I go past it.” 

“Oh, don’t bother about me! But I’ll ride with you if I may — then take the car back." 

“Relax! Once off duty, there are no ranks among us who follow the Vocation. Didn’t they teach you that?” They 
moved past the queue at the public transports, on past the Director’s own, stopped at the smaller bank for 
executives. 

“Yes, but — I’ve never been assigned to anyone of your rank before." 

That got a chuckle. “All the more, reason to follow that rule with me — because the higher one is, the more one 
needs to forget it off duty. Here’s an empty car. In you go and sit down." 

The shorter one went in but did not sit down until the Master Chief Technician was seated. The boss 
rejuvenator ignored it, set the controls, sprawled out, and sighed, as the car started to move. “I feel the strain 
myself. Coming off watch, I feel as old as he is.” 

“I know. I’m wondering if I can take it. Chief? Why won’t they let him terminate? He seems so tired." 

The answer was slow and not responsive. “Don’t call me ‘Chief.’ We’re off duty.” 

“But I don’t know your name.” 

“Nor do you need to know it. Hmm — The situation is not quite as it appears to be; he has suicided four times 
already.” 



“What?” 

“Oh, he doesn’t remember it. If you think his memory is bad now, you should have seen him three months 
ago. Actually, it speeds up our work every time he does it. His switch — when he had it — was gimmicked; it 
simply made him unconscious, then we would go ahead with whatever stage was next while hypnoing more of 
his memory tapes into him. But we had to stop that — and remove the switch — a few days ago; he remembered 
who he is.” 

“But — That’s not by the Canons! ‘Death is every man’s privilege.’” 

The Master Chief Technician touched the emergency control; the car continued on, found a parking pocket, 
and stopped. “I did not say that it was covered by the Canons. But watch officers do not set policy.” 

“When I was accepted, I took the oath... and part of it was to ‘give life freely to those who wish it... and never 
refuse death to those who yearn for it.’” 

“Don’t you think I took the same oath? The Director is so angry that she has gone on leave — she may resign; 

I wouldn’t venture to guess. But the Chairman Pro Tern is not of our Vocation; he is not bound by our oath, and 
the motto up over the entrance means nothing to him. His motto is — or seems to be — 'Every rule has 
exceptions.’ Look, I knew I would have to have this talk with you and I’m pleased that you’ve given me an 
opportunity before our next watch. Now I must ask you — do you wish to opt out? It won’t affect your record; I'll see 
to that. Don’t worry about a relief; the Senior will still be asleep when I next go on watch and any assistant will do 
for that watch — which leaves time for the Skills Board to select your replacement.” 

“Uh — I wantto attend him. It’s a great privilege, one I never dreamed would come my way. But I’m torn. I don’t 
think he’s being treated fairly. And who is more entitled to fair treatment in this than the Senior?” 

“I’m torn by it, too. I was shocked silly the first time I realized that I was being ordered to keep alive a man 
who had terminated voluntarily. Or who had been allowed to think that he was terminating, rather. But, my dear 
colleague, the choice is not up to us. This job will be done no matter what we think. Once I realized that — well, I 
am not lacking in professional confidence — call it conceit. I think I am the best-qualified senior watch officer on 
the list. I decided that, if the Families’ Senior was going to have this done to him, I would not opt out and let it be 
done by colleagues less skilled than I am. Bonuses had nothing to do with it; I’ve assigned my bonuses to the 
Sanctuary for Defectives.” 

“I could do that, couldn’t I?” 

“\fes, but you would be a fool to do so; I draw far more than you do. But I must add this: I hope your body 
tolerates stimulants easily because I supervise every major procedure and expect my assistant to help, whether 
it falls during our regular watch or not.” 

“I don't need stimulants; I use autohypnosis. When needed. Seldom. He'll be asleep our next watch. Mmm — ” 

“Colleague, I want your answer now So that I can notify the Skills Board if necessary.” 

“Uh — I’ll stick! I’ll stick as long as you do." 

“Good. I thought you would.” The Master Chief Technician again reached for the controls. “Intermediate 
lounge now?” 

“Just a moment. I would like to know you better.” 

“Colleague, if you stick, you’ll know me far too well. I have a sharp tongue.” 

“I meant socially, not professionally." 

“Well!” 

“\bu are offended? I’ve come to admire you without ever having seen you. Now I would like to see you. I’m not 
trying to curry favor.” 

“I believe you. Grant me the respect of believing that I studied your psych scores before I accepted the 
Board’s choice. No, I’m not offended; I’m flattered. Dinner together sometime, perhaps?” 

“Certainly. But I had more in mind. What would you say to ‘Seven Hours of Ecstasy’?” 

There was a short pause, which felt long. The Master Chief Technician said, “Colleague, what sex are you?” 

“Does it matter?” 

“I suppose not. I accept. Now?” 

“If it suits you.” 

“It does. I was simply going to my compartment, read a while, and sleep. Shall we go there?” 

“I was thinking of taking you to Elysium.” 

“No need to. Ecstasy is in the heart. But thank you.” 

“I can afford it. Uh, I’m not dependent on my salary. I can easily afford the best Elysium has to offer.” 



“Perhaps another time, dear colleague. But a resident’s compartment here in the Clinic is quite comfortable 
and at least an hour closer not counting the time we would waste getting out of isolation armor and dressed to 
face the public. We’ll go straight to my place. I find I’m eager. Goodness, I haven’t chanced this sort of lark in 
— far too long.” 

Four minutes later the Master Chief Technician let them into the compartment — large, as promised, and 
handsome and airy — a “happy” suite. A simulacrum fire blazed merrily in a corner fireplace and cast dancing 
lights around the lounging room. “Nfciu’ll find a guests’ dressing room through that door, ‘fresher beyond it. The 
chute for disposables is on the left, racks for helmets and isolation gear on the right. Need help?” 

“No, thank you, I’m quite limber.” 

“Well, shout if you need anything. Meet me here in front of the fire in ten minutes, say?” 

“Suits." 

The Associate Tech came out in only a little over ten minutes, free at last of isolation armor and looking even 
shorter in bare feet and without helmet. The Master Chief Tech looked up from the hearth rug. “Oh, there you are! 
\t>u’re male! I’m surprised. But pleased.” 

“And you're female. And /am very pleased. But I don’t believe for an instant that you are surprised. You’ve 
seen my records.” 

“No, dear,” she denied. “Not your personal dossier, just the brief the Board supplies to a prospective 
supervisor — and they are meticulously careful to keep name and sex and other irrelevancies out of it; their 
computer program sees to that. I did not know, and my guess was wrong.” 

“I didn’t try to guess. But I certainly am pleased. I don’t know why I have this special liking for tall women. But I 
do. Stand up and let me look at you.” 

She squirmed lazily. “What an irrational criterion. All women are the same height — lying down. So come lie 
down here; it’s very comfortable.” 

“Woman, when I say ‘Stand up!’ I expect action." 

She giggled. “You’re an atavism. But pretty.” She made a long arm, got him by an ankle, snatched him off 
balance. He went down. “That’s better. Now we’re the same height.” 



COUNTERPOINT 

II 

She said. “Would you like a middle-of-the-night lunch? Sleepyhead.” 

He said, “I did doze off, didn’t I? I had reason. Yes, I would. What am I being offered?” 

“Name it, just name it. If I don’t have it, I'll send for it. I’m feeling very-mellow toward you, dear.” 

“All right, how about ten tall sixteen-year-old redheaded virgins? Girls, I mean.” 

“Yes, darling. Nothing is too good for my Galahad. Although if you insist on certified virgins, it may take longer. 
Why this fetish, dear man? "four psych profiles didn’t hint at any exotic abnormality.” 

“Cancel that order and make it one dish of mango ice cream.” 

“Yes, sir, I’ll send for it at once. Or you can have fresh peach ice cream instantly. Tease. I haven’t been 
bothered by that sort of teasing since I was sixteen myself. A long time ago.” 

“I’ll settle for peach. A very long time ago.” 

“Right away, dearest man. Will you eat it with a spoon, or shall I plaster it on your face? Nor by that sort of 
teasing. I’ve had one rejuvenation just as you have had, and I keep my cosmetic age younger than yours.” 

“A man needs to look mature." 

“And a woman prefers to look young; we always have. But I know not only your rejuvenated age, but your 
calendar age, Galahad — and my calendar age is less than yours. Want to know how I know, dear? I recognized 
you the instant I saw you. I helped rejuvenate you, darling — and I’m most pleased that I did.” 

“The devil you say!” 

“But I am pleased, dear man. Such a nice bonus, and so unexpected. One so seldom sees a client again. 
Galahad, do you realize that we did not use any of the routine to insure an ecstatic holiday together? Yet I haven't 
missed it. I feel younger and happier than I have in years. Still do.” 

“Me, too. Except that I don't see any peach ice cream. 

“Pig. Beast. Brute. I’m bigger than you are; I'll trip you and fall on you. How many scoops, dear?” 

“Oh, just pile it in until your arm gets tired; I need to restore my strength." 

He followed her into the pantry, served them both with heaping dishes of ice cream. “Just a precaution,” he 
said, “so I won’t get it plastered in my face.” 

“Oh, tut, now! \t>u don’t really think I would do that to my Galahad.” 

“\bu’re a very erratic female, Ishtar. I have bruises to prove it.” 

“Nonsense! I was gentle.” 

“>bu don’t know your own strength. And you are bigger than I am, as you noted. Instead of ‘Ishtar’ I should 
have named you for that — what was her name? Queen of the Amazons in Old Home mythology.” 

“‘Hippolyta,’ dear. But I can’t qualify as an Amazon, for reasons you were flattering about... in an infantile way.” 

“Complaints, huh? Over in Surgery they could correct your disqualification in ten minutes and never leave a 
scar. Never mind, ‘Ishtar’ fits you better. But there is something unfair about this.” 

“How, dear? Let’s take this in and eat in front of the fire." 

“Suits. Like this, Ishtar. You tell me I was your client and that you recall both my ages, so by masterly logic I 
deduce that you know my registered name and Family, and you may even remember some of my genealogy 
since you must have studied it for my rejuvenation. But by the customs of ‘Seven Hours’ I am precluded from 
even trying to learn your registered name. I have to tag you in my mind as ‘that tall blond Master Chief Technician 
who — ’” 

“I still have enough ice cream to plaster you!” 

“ — permitted me to call her “Ishtar” for the happiest seven hours of my life.’ Which are almost over and I don’t 
know that you will let me take you to Elysium someday." 

“Galahad, you are the most exasperating sweetheart I’ve ever had. Of course you can take me to Elysium. 
And you don’t have to go home at the end of seven hours. And my registered name is Ishtar. But if you ever 
mention my rank other than when necessary, on duty, you’ll have real bruises to remember me by. Big ones.” 

“Bully. I’m scared. I do think I should leave on time, so that you can get your quota of sleep before we're due 
back on watch. But what’s this about your name really being ‘Ishtar’? Did I roll five aces when we named each 
other?” 



“Yes and no." 

“Is that an answer?” 

“I had one of the standard Family names of my lineage — and never liked it. But I was delighted and flattered 
by the pillow name you gave me. So while you were napping, I called Archives and changed my name. I’m ‘Ishtar’ 
now.” 

Fie stared at her. “Is that true?” 

“Don’t look frightened, dear. I won’t trap you, I won't even bruise you. I’m not domestic, not at all. \fc>u would be 
shocked if you knew how long it has been since a man was last in this compartment. You are free to leave 
whenever you wish; you committed yourself to me for only seven hours. But you need not leave. You and I are 
skipping tomorrow’s watch.” 

“We are? Why. . . Ishtar?” 

“I made another call and bucked a supernumerary team into that watch. Should have done so sooner, but you 
had me bemused, dear. The Senior won't need us tomorrow; he’s in deep sleep and won’t know that he has 
missed a, day. But I want to be there when he wakes, so I rearranged the watch list for the following day, too, and 
we may stay on watch all day; depends on the shape he’s in. That is, / may. I don’t insist that you do a double or 
triple watch.” 

“I can take it if you can. Ishtar? That professional rank you forbade me to mention — Nbu’re actually even 
higher rank than that. Aren’t you?" 

“If I am — I am not affirming it — I forbid you even to speculate about it. If you wish to stay assigned to this client, 

“Whew! You do have a sharp tongue. Did I deserve that?” 

“Dear Galahad! I’m sorry. When you are on watch, dear, I want you to think only about our client, not about me. 
Off watch I am Ishtar and don’t wish to be anything else. This is the most important case we will ever be on. It 
may go on a long time and be very tiring. So let’s not be edgy with each other. I was trying to say that you — both 
of us — now have more than thirty hours before we must be back on duty. Nt>u are welcome here as many of those 
hours as you wish. Or leave as soon as you wish and I will smile and not complain.” 

“I don't want to leave, I said so. As long as I don’t keep you from your sleep — ” 

“\bu won’t.” 

“ — and allow an hour to pick up a fresh pack of disposables, robe in, and go through decontam. I wish I had 
fetched a pack, but I hadn’t planned on this.” 

“Oh. We’ll make that an hour and a half. My phone had a message waiting in it. The Senior does not like the 
way we look in isolation gear; he wants to be able to see anyone around him. So we must plan time to go 
through body decontam instead, then attend him in ordinary clothes.” 

“Uh... Ishtar, is this wise? We might sneeze on him.” 

“Do you think / set this policy? Dear, this message was straight from the Palace. Besides that, females are 
specifically ordered to look as pretty and be as attractively dressed as possible — so I must think about what I 
can wear that can go through sterilization. Nudity is not acceptable; that was specified, too. But don’t worry about 
sneezing. Have you never taken full body decontamination? When that crew gets through with you, you cant 
sneeze; no matter how much you need to. But don't tell the Senior that you’ve had decontam; the assumption is 
that we simply walk in off the street — no special precautions.” 

“How can I tell him when I don’t speak his language? Does he have some fetish against nudity?” 

“I don't know, I am just conveying the order, one that went out to everyone on the watch list.” 

He looked thoughtful. “It’s probably not a fetish. All fetishes are contra-survival, that’s elementary. Nt>u told me 
that the principal problem was to break him out of his apathy. Nt>u were pleased that he was bad-tempered, even 
though you said it was a hyperreaction.” 

“Certainly I was pleased; it showed that he was responding. Galahad, never mind that now; I don’t have a 
thing to wear, you’ll have to help me.” 

“I’m talking about what you should wear. I think it was the Chairman Pro Tern’s idea, not the Senior’s." 

“Dear man, I don’t try to read his mind; I just carryout his orders. I don't have any taste in clothes, never did 
have. Do you think a lab assistant’s coverall would be suitable? It will take sterilization and never show it — and I 
look quite neat in one.” 

“I am trying to read the mind of the Chairman Pro Tern, Ishtar — guess his intentions, at least. No, I don't think 
a lab uniform would do; you would not look as if you had ‘simply walked in off the street.’ If we stipulate that a 



fetish syndrome is not involved, then the only advantage of clothing over nudity in this situation is to lend variety. 
Contrast. Change. Help shake him loose from that apathy.” 

She stared at him with thoughtful interest. “Galahad, up to now, based on my own experience, I’ve always 
thought that a man’s only interest in a woman’s clothes was to get them off her. I may have to put you in for 
promotion.” 

“I’m not ready to be promoted; I’ve been in the Vocation less than ten years. As I’m sure you know. Let’s take 
a look at your wardrobe.” 

“What are you going to wear, dear?” 

“Doesn’t matter what I wear; the Senior is male and all the stories and myths about him indicate that he has 
remained canalized by the primitive culture he was born in. Not sensually polymorphous.” 

“How can you be sure? Myths, dear.” 

“Ishtar, all myths tell the truth if you know how to read them. I’m guessing, but it is a reasoned guess, as this is 
something I used to be somewhat expert in. Until I was rejuvenated — until you rejuvenated me — then I went into 
something more active.” 

“What, dear?” 

“Some other time. I was simply saying that I don’t think it matters what / wear. A chiton. Shorts and singlet. 

Kilt. Even the underwear I had on under isolation gear. Oh, I’ll wear lively colors and something different each 
watch — but he won’t look at me, he’ll look at you. So let’s pick out something he would like to see you in.” 

“How will you know, Galahad?” 

“Very simple. I'll choose something / would like to see a long-legged beautiful blonde wear.” 

He was surprised to see how little Ishtar had in her wardrobe. In all his varied experience with women she 
was the only one he could remember who seemed to lack the vanity needed to buy unnecessary clothes. As he 
searched, mind preoccupied, he hummed and then sang a snatch of doggerel. 

Ishtar said, “\bu speak his milk language!” 

“Eh? What? Whose? The Senior’s? I certainly don’t. But I must learn it, I suppose.” 

“But you were singing in it. A little song he always sings when he’s busy with something.” 

“>bu mean this? ‘Therza poolyawL.Bytha paunshot — ’I have a phonographic ear, that’s all; I don’t 
understand the words. What do they mean?” 

“I’m not sure they mean anything. Most of them are not in the vocabulary I've learned so far. I suspect that it is 
justamphigoric rhythm, a self-tranquilizer. Semantically null.” 

“On the other hand, it might be a key to understanding him. Have you tried asking a computer?” - 

“Galahad, I haven’t been given access to the computer that records what goes on in his suite. But I doubt if 
anyone can understand him, in depth. He’s a primitive, dear — a living fossil.” 

“I would certainly like to try to understand him. This language he uses — Is it difficult?” 

“Very. Irrational, complicated syntax, and so loaded with idioms and multivalues that I trip even on words I 
think I know. I wish I had your recording ear.” 

“The Chairman Pro Tern seemed to have no difficulty.” 

“I think he has a special talent for languages. But if you want to try, dear, I have the instructional programs 
here.” 

“Accepted! What is this? A party dress?” 

“That? That’s not clothing. I bought it as a throw cover for a couch — then got it home and saw that it did not fit 
my lounging room." 

“It’s a dress. Stand there and hold still.” 

“Don’t tickle!” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
I 


Affairs of State 


Despite what I told the Senior, my ancestor Grandfather Lazarus, I work hard in governing Secundus. But only 
in thinking about policy and in judging the work of others. I don’t do donkey work; I leave that to professional 
administrators. Even so, the problems of a planet with more than a billion people can keep a man busy, 
especially if his intention is to govern as little as possible — as that means he must keep a sharp eye out and his 
ear tuned for signs that subordinates are doing unnecessary governing. Half my time is used in the negative 
work of plucking such officious officials and ordering that they never again serve in any public capacity. 

Then I usually abolish their jobs, and all jobs subordinate to them. 

I have never noticed any harm from such pruning save that parasites whose jobs are eliminated must find 
some other way to avoid starvation. (They are welcome to starve — better if they do. But they don’t.) 

The important thing is to spot these malignant growths and remove them while they are small. The more skill 
a Chairman Pro Tern acquires in this, the more emerging ones he finds, which keeps him busier than ever. 
Anyone can see a forest fire; skill lies in sniffing the first smoke. 

This leaves me too little time for my prime work: thinking about policy. The purpose of my government is 
never to do good, but simply to refrain from doing evil. This sounds simple but is not. For example, although 
prevention of armed revolution is obviously part of my main duty, i.e., to keep order, I began to have doubts about 
the wisdom of transporting potential revolutionary leaders years before Grandfather Lazarus called my attention 
to it. But the symptom that roused my worry was so null that it took ten years for me to notice it: 

During those ten years there was not one attempt to assassinate me. 

By the time Lazarus Long returned to Secundus for the purpose of dying this disturbing symptom had 
continued twenty years. 

This was ominous, and I realized it. A population of one billion-plus so contented, so uniform, so smug that 
not one determined assassin shows up in a double decade is seriously ill no matter how healthy it looks. In the 
ten years that elapsed after I noticed this lack I worried about it every hour I could spare — and found myself 
asking myself over and over again: What would Lazarus Long do? 

I knew in broad outline what he had done — and that was why I decided to migrate — either lead my people off 
planet or go alone if none would follow. (In rereading this, it sounds as if I sought to be assassinated in some 
mystic The King Must Die sense. Not at all! I am surrounded at all times by powerful and subtle safeguards the 
nature of which I will not divulge. But there is no harm in mentioning three negative precautions; my facial 
appearance is not known to the public, I almost never appear in public anyhow, and when I do, it is never 
announced. The job of ruler is dangerous — or should be — but I don’t intend to die from it. The “disturbing 
symptom” was not that I am alive but that there are no dead assassins. No one seems to hate me enough to try. 
Frightening. Where have I failed them?) 

When the Howard Clinic notified me that the Senior was awake (with a reminder that only one “night” had 
passed for him) I was not only awake but had completed necessary work and bucked the rest; I went at once to 
the Clinic. After they decontaminated me I found him dawdling over coffee, having just finished breakfast. 

He glanced up and grinned. “Hi, Ira!” 

“Good morning, Grandfather.” I went to him ready to offer a respectful salutation such as he had permitted 
when I bade him goodnight the night “before” — but watching for signs that say Yes, or No, before the mouth 
speaks. Even among the Families there is wide variety in such customs — and Lazarus is, as always, a law unto 
himself. So I closed the last of the gap with great deliberation. 

He answered me by drawing back so slightly that it would have been unnoticeable had I not been alert for it. 
He added a gentle warning: “Strangers present, Son.” 

I stopped at once. “At least I think they are strangers,” he added. “I’ve been trying to get acquainted, but all we 
share is some pidgin speech plus a lot of handwaving. But it’s nice to have people around instead of those 



zombies — we get along. Hey, dear! Come here, that’s a good girl.” 

He motioned to one of his rejuvenation technicians — two on watch, as usual, and this morning, one was 
female, one was male. I was pleased to see that my order that females should “dress attractively” had been 
carried out. This woman was a blonde, graceful and not unattractive if one likes tallness in a female. (I don’t 
dislike it, but there is something to be said for one small enough to fit on one’s lap — not that I’ve had much time 
for that lately.) 

She glided forward and waited, smiling. She was dressed in a something — women’s styles don’t stay the 
same long enough for me to keep track, and this was a period when every woman in New Rome seemed to be 
trying to dress differently from every other woman. Whatever it was, it was an iridescent blue that set off her eyes 
and fitted her closely where it covered her at all; the effect was pleasing. 

“Ira, this is Ishtar — did I get your name right that time, dear?” 

“\fes, Senior.” 

“And that young man over there is, believe it or not, ‘Galahad.’ Know any legends of Earth, Ira? If he knew its 
idiomatic meaning, he would change it — the perfect knight who never got any. But I’ve been trying to remember 
why Ishtar’s face is so familiar. Dear, was I ever married to you? Ask her for me, Ira; she may not have 
understood.” 

“No, Senior. Not never. Is certain.” 

“She understood you,” I said. 

“Well, it could have been her grandmother — a lively wench, Ira. Tried to kill me, so I left her.” 

The Chief Master Technician spoke briefly in Galacta. I said, “Lazarus, she says that, while she has never had 
the honor of being married to you, contractually or informally, she is quite willing if you are.” 

“Well! A saucy one — it must have been her grandmother. Eight, nine hundred years back, more or less — I 
lose track of half centuries — and on this planet. Ask her if, uh, Arid Barstow is her grandmother.” 

The technician looked very pleased and broke into rapid Galacta. I listened and said, “She says that Ariel 
Barstow is her great-great-great-grandmother and she is joyed to hear you acknowledge the connection as that 
is the lineage by which she is descended from you... and that she would be supremely honored, both for herself 
and on behalf of her siblings and cousins, if you would converge the lineage again, with or without contract After 
your rejuvenation is completed, she adds — she is not trying to rush you. How about it, Lazarus? If she has used 
up her reproduction quota, I would be happy to grant her an exception so that she would not have to migrate.” 

“The hell she ain’t trying to rush me. And so are you. But she put it politely, so let’s give it a polite answer. Tell 
her that I’m honored and her name goes into the hat — but don’t tell her I’m shipping out on Thursday. ‘Don’t call 
us, we’ll call you’ in other words — but make her happy about it; she’s a nice kid.” 

I revised the message diplomatically; Ishtar beamed, curtsied, and backed away. Lazarus said, “Drag up a 
rock, Son, and sit a while.” He lowered his voice and added, “Between ourselves, Ira, I’m pretty sure Ariel 
slipped one in on me. But with another of my descendants, so this kid is descended from me anyhow, though 
maybe not as directly. Not that it matters. What are you doing up so early? I said you could have two hours after 
breakfast to yourself." 

“I’m an early riser, Lazarus. Is it true that you have decided on the full course? She seems to think so." 

Lazarus looked pained. “It’s probably the simplest answer — but how do I know I'll get my own balls back?” 

“Gonads from your clone are your own, Lazarus; that’s basic to the theory.” 

“Well... we'll see. Early rising is a vice, Ira; it’ll stunt your growth and’ shorten your days. Speaking of such — ” 
Lazarus glanced up at the wall. “Thanks for having that switch reinstalled. I don’t feel tempted by it this fine 
morning, but a man does like to have a choice. Galahad, coffee for the Chairman and fetch me that plastic 
envelope.” Grandfather Lazarus supplemented his order with gestures, but I think the tech understood his words. 
Or was somewhat telepathic; rejuvenators are quite empathic — need to be. The man moved at once to comply. 

He handed Lazarus an impervolope and poured coffee for me — which I did not want but will drink anything 
protocol requires. Lazarus went on, “Here’s my new will, Ira. Read it and file it somewhere and tell your computer. 
I’ve already approved the way she worded it and read it back into her and told her to place it in her permanents 
with a ‘bind’ on it — it ‘ud take a Philadelphia lawyer to diddle you out of your inheritance now — though no doubt 
one could.” 

He waved the male tech aside. “No more coffee, lad — thanks. Go sit down. You go sit, too, dear. Ishtar. Ira, 
what are these young people? Nurses? Orderlies? Servants? Or what? They hover over me like a hen with one 
chick. I’ve never cared for more service than I need. Just sociability. Human company.” 

I could not answer without inquiring. Not only is it unnecessary for me to know how the Rejuvenation Clinic is 



organized, but also it is private enterprise, not under the Trustees — and my intervention in the case of the Senior 
was much resented by its Director. So I interfered as little as possible — as long as my orders were carried out. 

I spoke to the female tech, in Galacta: “What is your professional designation, ma’am? The Senior wants to 
know. He says that you have been behaving like a servant.” 

She answered quietly, “It is our pleasure to serve him in any way we can, sir” — then hesitated and went on: “I 
am Administrator Master Chief Rejuvenation Technician Ishtar Hardy, Deputy Director for Rejuvenation 
Procedures, and my assistant watch officer is Associate Technician Galahad Jones.” 

Having been rejuvenated twice and used to the idea all my life, it does not surprise me when cosmetic age 
does not match calendar age. But I admit to surprise at learning that this young woman was not just a technician 
but boss of her department — probably number three in the entire Clinic. Or possibly number two while the 
Director was away sulking in her tent — damn her duty-struck stiff neck. Or even Director Pro Tern with her 
deputy, or some department head, bucked into minding the store.” “So?” I answered. “May I ask your calendar 
age, Madam Administrator?” 

“Mr. Chairman Pro Tern may ask anything. I am only one hundred forty-seven years old — but I am qualified; 
this has been my only career since first maturity.” 

“I did not imply doubt of your qualifications, madam, but I am astonished to see you standing a watch rather 
than sitting at a desk. Although I confess I don’t know how the Clinic is-organized.” 

She smiled slightly. “Sir, I could express a similar feeling at your own personal interest in this case. . .were it 
not that I think I understand it. I am here because I choose not to delegate the responsibility; he is the Senior. I 
have screened all watch officers assigned to him — the best we have to offer.” 

I should have known it. “We understand each other.” I added, “I am pleased. But may I make a suggestion? 
Our Senior is independent by temperament and highly individualistic. He wants a minimum of personal service 
— only that which he must have." 

“Have we been annoying him, sir? Too solicitous? I can watch and listen from outside the door and still be 
here instantly if he wants something.” 

“Possibly too solicitous. But stay in sight. He does want human companionship.” 

“What’s all this yack-yack?” demanded Lazarus. 

“I had to ask questions, Grandfather, as I don’t know the organization of the Clinic. Ishtar is not a servant; she 
is a rejuvenator and a highly skilled one — and so is her assistant. But they are happy to supply any service you 
want.” 

“I don’t need flunkies; I’m feeling pretty good today. If I want anything, I'll shout; they don't need to hang over 
me, hand and foof.”Then he grinned. “But she’s a cute little trick, in the large, economy size; it’s a pleasure to 
have her around. Moves like a cat — no bones, just flows. She does indeed remind me of Ariel — did I tell you why 
Ariel tried to kill me?” 

“No. I would like to hear if you want to tell me.” 

“Mmm — Ask me when Ishtar isn’t around — I think she knows more English than she lets on. But I did promise 
to talk if you showed up to listen. What would you like to hear?” 

“Anything, Lazarus. Scheherazade picked her own subjects.” 

“So she did. But I don’t have one on tap.” 

“Well. . .you said as I came in that ‘early rising is a vice.’ Did you mean that seriously?” 

“Maybe. Gramp Johnson claimed it was. He used to tell a story about a man who was condemned to be shot 
at sunrise — but overslept and missed it. His sentence was commuted that day, and he lived another forty, fifty 
years. Said it proved his point.” 

“Do you think that’s a true story?” 

“As true as any of Scheherazade’s. I took it to mean ‘Sleep whenever you can; you may have to stay awake a 
long time.’ Early rising may not be a vice, Ira, but it is certainly no virtue. The old saw about the early bird just 
goes to show that the worm should have stayed in bed. I can’t stand people who are smug about how early they 
get up.” 

“I didn’t mean to sound smug, Grandfather. I get up early from long habit — the habit of work. But I don’t say it’s 
a virtue.” 

“Which? Work? Or early rising? Neither is a virtue. But getting up early does not get more work done... any 
more than you can make a piece of string longer by cutting off one end and tying it onto the other. \fc>u get less 
work done if you persist in getting up yawning and still tired. \t>u aren’t sharp and make mistakes and have to do 



it over. That sort of busy-busy is wasteful. As well as unpleasant. And annoying to those who would sleep late if 
their neighbors weren’t so noisily active at some ungodly cow-milking hour. Ira, progress doesn't come from 
early risers — progress is made by lazy men looking for easier ways to do things.” 

“\bu make me feel that I’ve wasted four centuries." 

“Perhaps you have, Son, if you’ve spent it getting up early and working hard. But it’s not too late to change 
your ways. Don’t fret about it; I’ve wasted most of my long life — though perhaps more pleasantly. Would you like 
to hear a story about a man who made ‘laziness a fine art? His life exemplified the Principle of Least Effort. A 
true story.” 

“Certainly. But I don’t insist on its being true.” 

“Oh, I won’t let truth hamper me, Ira; I’m a solipsist at heart. Hear then, O Mighty King, 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
II 


The Tale of the Man Who Was Too Lazy to Fail 


He was a schoolmate of mine in a school for training naval officers. Not space navy; this was before the 
human race had even reached Earth’s one satellite. This was wet navy, ships that floated in water and attempted 
to sink each other, often with regrettable success. I got mixed up in this through being too young to realize 
emotionally that, if my ship sank, I probably would sink, too — but this is not my story, but David Lamb’s.* (* There 
is no record that the Senior ever attended a school for militaro-naval officers, or any military school. On the other 
hand, there is no proof that he did not. This story may be autobiographical to whatever extent it is true; “David 
Lamb” maybe one more of the many names used by Wood-row Wilson Smith. 

The details are consistent with Old Home’s history so far as we know it. The Senior’s first century coincides 
with that century of continuous war which preceded the Great Collapse — a century of much scientific progress 
paralleled by retrogression in social matters. Waterborne and airborne ships were used for fighting throughout 
this century. See appendix for idioms and technicalities. J.F. 45 th ) 

To explain David I must go back to his childhood. He was a hillbilly, which means he came from an area 
uncivilized even by the loose standards of those days — and Dave came from so far back in the hills that the hoot 
owls trod the chickens. 

His education was in a one-room country school and ended at thirteen. He enjoyed it, for every hour in school 
was a hour sitting down doing nothing harder than reading. Before and after school he had to do chores on his 
family’s farm, which he hated, as they were what was known as “honest work” — meaning hard, dirty, inefficient, 
and ill-paid — and also involved getting up early, which he hated even worse. 

Graduation was a grim day for him; it meant that he now did “honest work” all daylong instead of spending a 
restful six or seven hours in school. One hot day he spent fifteen hours plowing behind a mule... and the longer he 
stared at the south end of that mule, breathing dust it kicked up and wiping the sweat of honest toil out of his 
eyes, the more he hated it. 

That night he left home informally, walked fifteen miles to town, slept across the door of the post office until 
the postmistress opened up next morning, and enlisted in the Navy. He aged two years during the night, from 
fifteen to seventeen, which made him old enough to enlist. 

A boy often ages rapidly when he leaves home. The fact was not noticeable; birth registrations were unheard 
of at that time and place, and David was six feet tall, broad-shouldered, well-muscled, handsome, and mature in 
appearance, save for a wild look around the eyes. 

The Navy suited David. They gave him shoes and new clothes, and let him ride around on the water, seeing 
strange and interesting places — untroubled by mules and the dust of cornfields. They did expect him to work, 
though not as much, or as hard, as working a hill farm — and once he figured out the political setup aboard ship 
he became adept at not doing much work while still being satisfactory to the local gods, namely, chief petty 
officers. 

But it was not totally satisfactory as he still had to get up early and often had to stand night watches and 
sometimes scrub decks and perform other tasks unsuited to his sensitive temperament. 

Then he heard about this school for officer candidates — “midshipmen” as they were known. Not that David 
cared what they were called; the point was that the Navy would pay him to sit down and read books — his notion 
of heaven — untroubled by decks to scrub and by petty officers. 0 King, am I boring you? No? 

Very well — David was ill prepared for this school, never having had four to five years’ additional schooling 
considered necessary to enter it — mathematics, what passed for science, history, languages, literature, and so 
forth. 

Pretending to four years or so of schooling he did not have was more difficult than tacking two years on the 
age of an overgrown boy. But the Navy wished to encourage enlisted men to become officers, so it had 
established a tutoring school to aid candidates slightly deficient in academic preparation. 



David construed “slightly deficient” to mean his own state; he told his chief petty officer that he had “just 
missed” graduating from high school — which was true in a way; he had “just missed” by half a county, that being 
the distance from his home to the nearest high school. 

I don't know how David induced his See-Pee-Oh to recommend him; David never discussed this. 

Suffice to say that, when David’s ship steamed for the Mediterranean, David was dropped at Hampton 
Roads sixweeks before the tutoring school convened. He was a supernumerary during that time.. The Personnel 
Officer (in fact, his clerk) assigned David to a bunk and a mess, and told him to stay out of sight during working 
hours in the empty classrooms where his fellow hopefuls would meet sixweeks later. David did so; the 
classrooms had in them the books used in tutoring in academic subjects a candidate might lack — and David 
lacked them all. He stayed out of sight and sat down and read. 

That’s all it took. 

When the class convened, David helped tutor in Euclidean geometry, a required subject and perhaps the 
most difficult. Three months later he was sworn in as a naval cadet on the beautiful banks of the Hudson River at 
West Point. 

David did not realize that he had jumped from the frying pan into the fire; the sadism of petty officers is a mild 
hit-or-miss thing compared with the calculated horrors visited on new cadets — ’’plebes” — by cadets of the senior 
classes, especially by the seniormost, the first classmen, who were walking delegates of Lucifer in that 
organized hell. 

But David had three months to find this out and to figure out what to do, that being the time upper classes 
were on the briny, practicing warfare. As he saw it, if he could last nine months of these hazards, all the kingdoms 
of the Earth would be his. So he said to himself, if a cow ora countess can sweat out nine months, so can I. 

He arranged the hazards in his mind in terms of what must be endured, what could be avoided, and what he 
should actively seek. By the time the lords of creation returned to stomp on the plebes he had a policy for each 
typical situation and was prepared to cope with it under doctrine, varying doctrines only enough to meet 
variations in situation rather than coping hastily on an improvised basis. 

Ira — ”0 King,” I mean — this is more important to surviving in tough situations than it sounds. For example, 
Gramp — David’s Grampaw, that is — warned him never to sit with his back to door. “Son,” he said to him, “might 
be nine hundred and ninety-nine times you’d get away with it — no enemy of your’n would come through that door. 
But the thousandth time — that’s the one. If my own Grampaw had always obeyed that rule, he might be alive 
today and still jumping out bedroom windows. He knew better, but he missed just once, through being too 
anxious to sit in on a poker game, and thereby took the one chair open, one with its back to a door. And it got 
him. 

“He was up out of his chair and emptied three shots from each of his guns into his assailant before he 
dropped; we don’t die easy. But ‘twas only a moral victory; he was essentially dead, with a bullet in his heart, 
before he got out of that chair. All from sitting with his back to an open door.” 

Ira, I’ve never forgotten Gramp’s words — and don’t you forget ’em. 

So David categorized the hazards and prepared his doctrines. One thing that had to be endured was 
endless questioning, and he learned that a plebe was never permitted to answer, “I don’t know, sir,” to any upper 
classman, especially a first classman. But the questions ordinarily fell into categories — history of the school, 
history of the Navy, famous naval sayings, names of team captains and star players of various athletic sports, 
how many seconds till graduation, what’s the menu for dinner. These did not bother him; they could be 
memorized — save the number of seconds remaining till graduation, and he worked out shortcuts for that, ones 
that stood him in good stead in later years. 

“What sort of shortcuts, Lazarus?” 

Eh? Nothing fancy. A precalculated figure for reveille each morning, a supplementary figure for each hour 
thereafter, such as: five hours after six o’clock reveille subtracts eighteen thousand seconds from the base 
figure, and twelve minutes later than that takes off another seven hundred and twenty seconds. For example at 
noon formation one hundred days before graduation, say at exactly twelve-oh-one and thirteen seconds, figuring 
graduation at ten. A.M. which was standard, David could answer, “Eight million, six hundred and thirty-two thou 
sand, seven hundred and twenty-seven seconds, sir!” almost as fast as his squad leader could ask him, simply 
from having precalculated most of it. 

At any other time of day he would look at his watch and pretend to wait for the second hand to reach a mark 
while in fact performing subtractions in his head. 

But he improved on this; he invented a decimal clock — not the one you use here on Secundus, but a variation 



on Earth’s clumsy twenty-four-hour day, sixty-minute hour, sixty-second minute system then in vogue. He split the 
time for reveille to taps into intervals and subintervals often thousand seconds, a thousand seconds, a hundred 
seconds, and memorized a conversion table. 

You see the advantage. For anyone but Andy Libby, God rest his innocent soul, subtracting ten thousand, or 
one thousand, from a long string of digits up in the millions is easier to do in your head, quickly and without error, 
than it is to subtract seven thousand, two hundred, and seventy-three — the figure to be subtracted in the 
example, I just gave. David’s new method did not involve carrying auxiliary figures, in the mind while searching 
for the ultimate answer. 

For example, ten thousand seconds after reveille is eight forty-six forty A. M. Once David worked out his 
conversion table and memorized it — took him less than a day; just memorizing was easy for him — once he had 
that down pat, he could, convert to the hundred-second interval coming up next almost instantly, then add (not 
subtract) two digits representing the time still to go to the last two places in his rough answer to get his exact 
answer. Since the last two places were always zeroes — check it yourself — he could give an answer in millions of 
seconds as fast as he could speak the figures, and have it right every time. 

Since he didn’t explain his method, he got a reputation for being a lightning calculator, an idiot-savant talent, 
like Libby. He was not; he was simply a country boy who used his head on a simple problem. But his squad 
leader got so groused at him for being a “smart ass” — meaning that the squad leader couldn’t do it — that he 
ordered Dave to memorize the logarithm tables. This didn’t faze Dave; he didn’t mind anything but “honest work.” 
He set out to do so, twenty new ones each day, that being the number this first classman thought would suffice to 
show up this “smart ass.” 

The first classman grew tired of the matter when David had completed only the first six hundred figures — but 
Dave kept at it another three weeks through the first thousand — which gave him the first ten thousand figures by 
interpolation and made him independent of log tables, a skill that was of enormous use to him from then on, 
computers being effectively unknown in those days. 

But the unceasing barrage of questions did not bother ‘David save for the possibility of starving to death at 
meal times — and he learned to shovel it in fast while sitting rigidly at attention and still answer all questions flung 
at him. Some were trick questions, such as, “Mister, are you ‘a virgin?” Either way a plebe answered he was in 
trouble — if he gave a straight answer. In those days some importance was placed on virginity or the lack of it; I 
can’t say why. 

But trick questions called for trick answers; Dave found that an acceptable answer to that one was: “Nfes, 
sir — in my left ear.” Or possibly his belly button. 

But most trick questions were intended to trap a plebe into giving a meek answer — and meekness was a 
mortal sin. Say a first classman said, “Mister, would you say I was handsome?” — an acceptable answer would 
be, “Perhaps your mother would say so, sir — but not me.” Or “Sir, you are the handsomest man lever saw who 
was intended to be an ape.” 

Such answers were chancy — they might flick a first classman on the raw — but they were safer than meek 
answers. But no matter how carefully a plebe tried to meet impossible standards, about once a week some first 
clansman would decide that he needed punishment — arbitrary punishment without trial: This could run from mild, 
such as exercises repeated to physical collapse — which David disliked as they reminded him of “honest work” 

— up to paddling on the buttocks. This may strike you as nothing much, Ira, but I’m not speaking’ of paddling 
children sometimes receive. These beatings were delivered with the flat of a sword or with a worn-out broom that 
amounted to a long, heavy club. Three blows delivered by a grown man in perfect health would leave the victim’s 
bottom a mass of purple bruises and blood blisters, accompanied by excruciating pain. 

David tried hard to avoid incidents likely to result inthis calculated torture, but there was no wayto avoid 
them entirely, short of quitting, as some first classmen awarded such blows through sheer sadism. David gritted 
his teeth and accepted them when he had to, judging — correctly — that he would be run out of school if he defied 
the supreme authority of a first clansman. So he thought about the south end of that mule and endured it. 

There was a much greater hazard to his personal safety and future prospects of a life free from “honest 
work.” The mystique of military service included the idea that a prospective officer must excel in athletic sports. 
Do not, ask why; it was no more subject to rational explanation than is any other branch of theology. 

Plebes in particular had to — no choice! — go out for “sports.” Two hours each day which were nominally free 
David could not spend napping or dreaming in the quiet of the school’s library, but must perforce spend in 
sweaty exercise. 



Worse still, some “sports” were not only excessively energetic but also involved hazards to David’s favorite 
skin. “Boxing” — this is a long forgotten, utterly useless, stylized mock combat in which two men batter each other 
for a preset period or until one is beaten unconscious. “La Crosse” — this is a mock battle taken over from the 
savages who had formerly inhabited that continent. In it mobs of men fought with clubs. There was a hard missile 
with which points were scored — but it was the prospect of being sliced open or having bones broken with these 
clubs that aroused our hero’s distaste. 

There was a thing called “water polo” in which opposing swimmers attempted to drown each other. David 
avoided that one by not swimming more than well enough to stay in school — a required skill. He was an excellent 
swimmer, having learned at the age of seven through being chucked into a creek by two older cousins — but he 
concealed his skill. 

The sport with highest prestige was a thing called “foot ball” — and first classmen sized up each new group of 
victims for candidates who might be expected to excel, or learn to excel, in this organized mayhem. David had 
never seen it — but now he saw it and it filled his peaceful soul with horror. 

As well it might. It involved two gangs of eleven men facing each other on a field and trying to move an 
ellipsoid bladder down the field against the opposition of the other gang. There were rituals and an esoteric 
terminology, but that was the idea. 

It sounds harmless and rather foolish. Foolish it was, harmless it was not — as the rituals permitted the 
opposing gang to attack a man attempting to move the bladder in a variety of violent ways, the least of which 
was to grab him and cause him to hit the ground like a ton of brick. Often three or four bit him at once, and 
sometimes inflicted indignities and mayhems not permitted by the rituals but concealed by’ the pile of bodies. 

Death was not supposed to result from this activity but sometimes did. Injuries short of death were 
commonplace. 

Unfortunately David had the ideal physique for success in this “feet ball” — height, weight, eyesight, fleetness 
of foot, speed of reflex. He was certain to be spotted by the first classmen on their return from mock sea battles 
and “volunteered” as a sacrificial victim. 

It was time for evasive action. 

The only possible way to avoid “foot ball” was to be acceptably occupied with some other sport. He found 
one. 

Ira, do you know what “swordsmanship” is? Good — I can speak freely. This was a time in Earth’s history 
when the sword had ceased to be a weapon — after having been prominent for more than four millennia. But 
swords still existed in fossil form and retained a shadow of their ancient prestige. A gentleman was presumed to 
know how to use a sword and — “Lazarus, what is a ‘gentleman’?” 

What? Don’t interrupt, boy; you confuse me. A “gentleman” is, uh — Well, now let me see. A general definition — 
My, you can think up some hard ones. Some said it was an accident of birth — that being a disparaging way of 
saying it was a trait genetically inherited. But that doesn’t say what the trait is. A gentleman was supposed to 
prefer being a dead lion to being a live jackal. Me, I’ve always preferred to be a live lion, so that puts me outside 
the rules. Mmm...you could say in all seriousness that the quality tagged by that name represents the slow 
emergence in human culture of an ethic higher than simple self-interest — damn slow in emerging in my opinion; 
you still can’t rely on it in a crunch. 

As may be, military officers were presumed to be gentlemen and wore swords. Even fliers wore swords, 
although Allah alone could guess why. 

These cadets were not only presumed to be gentlemen; there was a national law which stated that they were 
gentlemen. So they were taught a bare minimum about howto handle a sword, just enough to keep them from 
slicing their fingers or stabbing bystanders — not enough to fight with them, just to keep them from looking too 
silly when protocol required them to wear swords. 

But swordsmanship was a recognized sport, called “fencing.” It had none of the prestige of football, or 
boxing, or even water polo — but it was on the list; a plebe could sign up for it. 

David spotted this as a way out. Under a simple physical law, if he was up in the fencing loft, then he was not 
down on the football field, with sadistic gorillas in hobnailed boots jumping up and down on him. Long before the 
upper clansmen returned to school Plebe Cadet Lamb had established himself as a member of the fencing 
squad, with a record of never missing a day, and was trying hard to look like a “good prospect” for the team. 

At that time and place three forms of fencing were taught: saber, dueling sword, and foil: The first two used 
full-sized weapons. True, edges were dulled and points were bated; nevertheless a man could get hurt with them 



— even fatally, though that was very rare. But the foil was a lightweight toy, a ‘fake sword with a limber blade that 
bent at the slightest pressure. The stylized imitation swordplay that used the foil was about as dangerous as 
tiddlywinks. This was the “weapon” David selected. 

It was made for him. The highly artificial rules of foil fencing gave great advantage to fast reflexes and a sharp 
brain, both of which he had. Some exertion was necessary — but not much compared with football, lacrosse, or 
even tennis. Best ‘of all, it required no body-against-body pounding that David found so distasteful in the rough 
games he was avoiding. David applied himself single-mindedly to acquiring skill so that his haven would be 
secure. 

So diligent was he in protecting his sanctuary that, before his plebe year was over, he was National Novice 
Foil Champion. This caused his squad leader to smile at him, an expression that hurt his face. His cadet 
company commander noticed him for the first time and congratulated him. 

Success with the foil even got him out of some “punishment” ‘beatings. One Friday evening, when he was 
about to be beaten for some imaginary dereliction, David said, “Sir, if it’s the same to you, I’d rather have twice 
as many swats on Sunday — because tomorrow we’re fencing the Princeton plebe team and, if you do the job I 
know you can do, it might slow me up tomorrow.” 

The first clansman was impressed by this because having the Navy win, at anytime and for any purpose and 
in anything, took precedence by Sacred Law over anything else, even the righteous pleasure of beating a “smart 
ass” plebe. He answered, ““Tell you what, mister. Report to my room after supper on Sunday. If you lose 
tomorrow, you get a double dose of the medicine you’ve got coming to you. But if you win, we’ll cancel it.” 

David won all three of his matches. 

Fencing got him through his perilous plebe year with his precious skin unmarked save for scars on his 
bottom. He was safe now, with three easy years ahead of him, for only a plebe was subject to physical 
punishment, only a plebe could be ordered to take part in organized mayhem.... 

(Omitted) 

One body-contact sport David loved, one of ancient popularity, which he had learned back in those hills he 
had fled from. But it was played with girls and was not officially recognized at this school. There were harsh rules 
against it, and .a cadet caught practicing it was kicked out without mercy. 

But David, like all true geniuses, paid only pragmatic attention to rules made by other people — he obeyed the 
Eleventh Commandment and never got caught. While other cadets sought the empty prestige of sneaking girls 
into the barracks or went over the wall at night in search of girls, David kept his activities quiet. Only those who 
knew him well knew how industriously he pursued this one body-contact sport. And no one knew him well. 

Eh? Female cadets? Didn’t I make that plain, Ira? Not only were there no girl cadets, there was not one girl in 
that Navy — except a few nurses. Most particularly there were no girls at that school; there were guards night and 
day to keep them away from the cadets. 

Don’t ask me why. It was Navy policy and therefore did not have a reason. In truth there was no job in that 
entire Navy which could not have been performed by either sex or even by eunuchs — but by long tradition that 
Navy was exclusively male. 

Come to think about it, a few years later that tradition was questioned — a little at first, then by the end of that 
century, shortly before the Collapse, that Navy had females at all levels. I am not suggesting that this change was 
a cause of the Collapse. There were obvious causes of the Collapse, causes I won’t go into now. This change 
either was a null factor or possibly postponed the inevitable by a minor amount. 

Either way, it doesn’t figure into the Tale of the Lazy Man. When David was in school, cadets were supposed 
to encounter females but seldom, and only under highly stylized circumstances, rigidly bound protocol, and 
heavily chaperoned.* (* From the noun “chaperon.” This word ‘has two meanings,: (1 ) A person charged with 
preventing sexual contacts’ between males and females not licensed for such contacts; (2) a person superficially 
performing such disservice while, in fact acting as a benign lookout. It appears that the Senior uses the word 
here in its first meaning rather than in its antithetical second meaaning. See appendix. J.F.45 th ) 

Instead of fighting the rules, David looked for loopholes and made use of them — he was never caught. 

Every impossible rule has its loopholes; every general prohibition creates its bootleggers. The Navy as a 
whole created its impossible rules; the Navy as individuals violated them, especially its curious rules about sex 
— a publicly monastic life on duty, a slightly veiled life of unlimited voluptuousness off duty. At sea, even harmless 



reliefs from sexual tension were treated most harshly when detected — although such technical violations of the 
mores were expected and condoned less than a century earlier. But this Navy was only a little more hypocritical 
in its sexual behavior than was the social matrix in which it was imbedded, more excessive in its outlets only to 
the degree that its public rules were more sternly impossible than those of that society as a whole. The public 
sexual code of that time was unbelievable, Ira; the violations of it simply mirrored in reverse its fantastic 
requirements. To every action there is an equal and opposite reaction — if you’ll excuse the obvious. 

I did not intend to discuss this other than to say that David found ways to get along with the school’s 
regulations about sex without going completely off his nut, as too many of his classmates did. I’ll add only this 
— and this is merely rumor: Through a mischance all too easy then although unheard of today, a young woman 
became pregnant, presumably by David. In those days — believe me! — this was a major disaster. 

Why? Just stipulate that it was a disaster; it would take forever to explain’ that society and no civilized human 
would believe it. Cadets were forbidden to marry, the young woman had to get married under the rules current 
then, intervention to correct this mischance was almost unobtainable and physically very dangerous for her. 

What David did about it illustrates his whole approach to life. When faced with a choice of evils, accept the 
least hazardous and cope with it, unblinkingly. He married her. 

How he managed to do this and not get caught, I do not know. I can think of a number of ways, some simple 
and fairly foolproof, some complexand thereby subject to breakdown; I assume that David selected the simplest. 

It changed the situation from impossible to manageable. It converted the girl’s father from an enemy, all too 
likely to go to the Commandant of the school with the story and thereby force David to resign when he had but a 
few months more to reach his goal, into an ally and fellow conspirator anxious to keep the marriage secret so 
that his son-in-law could graduate and take his wayward daughter off his hands. 

As a side benefit David no longer needed to give planning to the pursuit of his favorite sport. He spent his 
time off in unworried domesticity, with perfect chaperonage* (* Context implies second meaning. J.F.45 th ) 

As for the rest of David’s career in school, one may assume that a lad who could substitute six weeks of 
unsupervised reading for four years of formal schooling could also stand first in his class academically. This 
would pay off in money and rank as a young officer’s place on the promotion list was determined by his standing 
at graduation. 

But the competition for first place is sharp indeed, and — worse — makes the cadet who achieves it 
conspicuous. David became aware of this when he was a fresh-caught plebe. “Mister, are you a savoir?” that is 
to say: “academically brainy” — was another trick question; a plebe was damned whether he answered Yes or No. 

But standing second — or even tenth — was practically as useful as first place. David noticed something else: 
The fourth year counted four times as much as the first, the next to the last year three times as much, and so on 
down — that is, a plebe’s marks did not affect his final standing much — only one part in ten. 

David decided to maintain a “low profile” — always the smart decision when one is likely to be shot at. 

He finished the first half of his plebe year a little above midway in his class — safe, respectable, 
inconspicuous. He ended his plebe year in’ the upper quarter — but by that time the first classmen were thinking 
only of graduation and paid no attention to his status. His second year he moved to the upper 10 percent; his 
third year he improved that by a few numbers — and his last year, when it counted most, he went all out and 
finished with a final standing for four years of sixth — but effectively second, for of those higher in ranking two 
elected to leave the line of command for specialization, one was not commissioned because he had damaged 
his eyes by studying too hard, and one resigned after he graduated. 

But the care with which David managed his class standing does not show his true talent for laziness — after 
all, sitting down and reading was his second, favorite pastime, and anything which merely called for excellent 
memory and logical reasoning was ‘no effort to him. 

During the mock-warfare cruise that opened David’s last year of school a group of his classmates were 
discussing what cadet ranks each would receive. By then, they knew pretty well which ones would be selected as 
cadet officers. Jake is certain to be cadet corps commander — unless he falls overboard. Who gets his 
battalion? Steve? Or Stinky? 

Someone suggested that Dave was in line for that battalion. Dave had been listening instead of talking, a 
‘standard feature of his “low profile” — and very nearly a third way to lie, Ira, and easier than its equivalent 
— talking while saying nothing — and also tends to give the nontalker a reputation for wisdom. Never cared for it 
myself — talking is the second of the three real pleasures in life and the only thing that sets us apart from the 
apes. Though just barely. 



Now David broke — or appeared to break — his habitual reserve. “No battalion for me,” he said. “No indeedy! 
I’m going to be regimental adjutant and stand out in front where the girls can see me.” 

Perhaps his remark wasn’t taken seriously — regimental adjutant is lower than battalion commander. But it 
was certain to be repeated, and David knew it, perhaps by the prospective cadet regimental commander to 
commissioned officers making the selections for cadet officers. 

No matter — David was chosen regimental adjutant. 

In any military organization of that time, a regimental adjutant did stand out in front, all alone, where female 
visitors could hardly avoid seeing him. But one may doubt that this figured into Dave’s plans. 

The regimental adjutant attends no formations other than full regimental formations. He goes to and from 
classes alone, instead of marching or being marched. Other first classmen are responsible each for some unit of 
cadets, be it squad, platoon, company, battalion, or regiment; the regimental adjutant has no such 
responsibilities and only one minor administrative task; he keeps the watch list for the most senior of the cadet 
officers. 

But he is not on that watch list himself. Instead he is supernumerary who fills in when one of them is ill. 

And this was the lazy man’s prize. Those cadet officers were perfect specimens and the chances that one 
would be too ill to take his day’s duty ranged from negligible to zero. 

For three years our hero had been standing watch about every tenth day. These watches weren’t difficult, but 
they involved either getting to bed a half hour late or getting up a half hour early, and much standing on tired feet, 
all an affront to Dave’s tender regard for his comfort. 

But his last year David stood only three watches, and he “stood” those sitting down, as “Junior Officer of the 
Watch.” 

At last the Day arrived. David graduated, was commissioned — then went to the chapel and remarried his 
wife. If her belly bulged a little, that was not unusual in brides even in those days, and was always ignored, and 
condoned once a young couple married. It was widely known though rarely mentioned that an eager young bride 
could accomplish in seven months or less what takes nine for cow or countess. 

Dave was safely past all rocks and shoals; he need never again fear going back to that mule and “honest 
work.” 

But life as a junior officer in a warship turned out to be less than perfect. It had good points — servants, a 
comfortable bed, easy work that rarely got David’s hands dirty, and twice as much money. But he needed that 
and more, to support a wife, and his ship was at sea enough that he often lacked the pleasant compensations of 
marriage. Worst of all, he stood heel-and-toe watches on a short watch list; this meant a four-hour night watch 
about every other night standing up. He was sleepy much of the time and his feet hurt. 

So David applied for training as an aeronaut. This Navy had recently grasped an idea called “air power” and 
was trying to grab as much of it as possible in order to keep it out of the wrong hands — the Army’s hands, that is. 
They were behind as the Army had grabbed first — so volunteers for flying were welcome. 

David was quickly ordered to shore duty to see if he had the makings of an aeronaut. 

He had indeed! He not only had the mental and physical qualities but also was highly motivated — as his new 
work was done sitting down, whether in classroom or in the air, and he stood no night watches and received pay- 
and-a-half for sitting down and sleeping at home; flying was classed as “hazardous duty” and extra pay was 
awarded. 

I had best say something about these aeroplanes since they resemble not at all the aerodynes you are used 
to. In a way they were hazardous. So is breathing. They were not as hazardous as the automotive ground 
vehicles then in use, and not nearly as hazardous as being a pedestrian. Accidents, fatal and otherwise, usually 
could be traced to a mistake on the part of the aeronaut — David never let that sort of accident happen to him. 

He had no wish to be the hottest pilot in the sky; he merely wanted to be the oldest. 

Aeroplanes were weird monstrosities looking like nothing in the sky today, save possibly a child’s kite — they 
were often called “kites.” They had two wings, one above the other, and the aeronaut sat between them. A small 
baffle helped to deflect wind from his face. Don’t look surprised; these flimsy structures flew very slowly, pulled 
through the air by a powered screw. 

Wings were made of varnished cloth held rigid by struts — you can see from this alone that their speeds 
could never be any large fraction of the speed of sound — except on sad occasions when an overly eager pilot 
would dive straight down, then pull the wings off through trying too abruptly to recover a normal attitude. 



Which David never did. Some people are natural fliers. The first time David examined an aeroplane he 
understood its strengths and weaknesses as thoroughly as he understood the milking stool he had left behind 
him. 

He learned-to fly almost as quickly as he had learned to swim. 

His instructor said, “Dave, you’re a natural. I’m going to recommend you for fighter training.” 

Fighter pilots were the royalty of aeroplane fliers; they went up, and engaged enemy pilots in single combat. 
Afighterwho did this successfully five times — killed the opposing pilot instead of being killed — was called an 
“Ace,” which was a high honor, for, as you can see, the average chance of doing this is the fifth power of one-half, 
or one in thirty-two. Whereas the chance of getting killed instead is the complement, close to certainty. 

Dave thanked his mentor while his skin crawled and his brain went whir-click as it considered ways to avoid 
this honor without giving up pay-and-a-half and the comfort of sitting down. 

There were other disadvantages to being a fighter pilot besides the prime hazard of getting your ass shot off 
by some stranger. Fighter pilots flew in one-man kites and did their own navigation — without computers, homing 
devices, or anything that would be taken for granted today — or even later that century. The method used was 
called “dead reckoning,” because, if you didn’t reckon it correctly, you were dead — since Navy flying was done 
over water, from a small floating aerodrome, with a margin of safety in fuel for a fighter plane of only minutes. Add 
to this the fact that a fighter pilot in combat had to choose between doing navigation or giving single-minded 
attention to attempting to kill a stranger before that stranger killed him. If he’ wanted to be an “Ace" — or even eat 
dinner that night — he must put first things first and worry about navigation later. 

In addition to the chance of being lost at sea and drowned in a kite that was out of gas — did I say how these 
things were powered? The airscrew was driven by an engine powered by a chemical exothermic reaction 
— oxidation of a hydrocarbon fluid called “gas,” which it was not. If you think this unlikely, I assure you that it was 
unlikely even then. The method was woefully inefficient. A flier was not only likely to runout of gas with nothing 
around him but ocean, but also this temperamental engine often coughed and quit. Embarrassing. Sometimes 
fatal. 

The lesser drawbacks to being a fighter pilot were not all physical danger; they simply did not fit David’s 
master plan. Fighter pilots were assigned to floating aerodromes, or carriers. In peacetime, which this nominally 
was, a flier did not work too hard nor stand many watches and spent much of his time ashore at a land 
aerodrome even though he was carried on the muster rolls of a carrier ship — thereby credited with sea duty, 
necessary for promotion and pay. 

But for several weeks each year a flier assigned to a carrier ship would actually be at sea, practicing mock 
warfare — which involved getting up an hour before dawn to warm those cantankerous engines and stand by 
ready to fly at the first hint of real or simulated danger. 

David hated this — he would not willingly attend Judgment Day if it was held before noon. 

There was another drawback: landing on these floating aerodromes. On land, David could land on a dime 
and give back change. But that depended on his own skill, highly developed because his own skin was at stake. 
But landing on a carrier depended on another pilot’s skill — and David held a dark opinion of entrusting his skin 
to the skill, good intentions, and alertness of someone else. 

Ira, this is so unlike anything you are likely to have seen in your life that I am at loss. Consider your skyport 
here at New Rome: In landing, a ship is controlled from the ground — right? So it was with aeroplanes landing on 
carriers — but the analogy breaks down because a landing on a carrier in those days used no instruments. None. 
I’m not fooling. 

It was done by eye alone, just as a boy in a game of catch snatches a ball out of the air — but David was the 
ball, and the skill used to catch him was not his own but that of a pilot standing on the carrier. David had to 
suppress his own skill, his own opinions, and place utter faith in the pilot on the carrier — anything less brought 
disaster. 

David had always followed his own opinion — against the whole world if necessary. To place that much faith in 
another man ran counter to his deepest emotions. A carrier landing was like baring his belly to a surgeon and 
saying, “Go ahead and cut” — when he was not sure that surgeon was competent to slice ham. Carrier landing 
came closer to causing David to give up pay-and-a-half and easy hours than any other aspect of flying, so torn 
was he by the necessity of accepting another pilot’s decision — and one not even sharing his danger, at that! 

It took all his willpower to do it the first time, and it never became easy. But he learned one lesson that he 
never expected to learn — that is, that there were circumstances in which another man’s opinion was not only 



better than his own, but incomparably better. 

You see — no, perhaps you don’t; I have not explained the circumstances. An aeroplane landed on a carrier in 
a controlled crash, through a hook in its tail catching a wire rope stretched across the top deck. But if the flier 
follows his own judgment based on experience in landing on a flying field, he is certain to crash into the stern of 
the ship — or, if he knows this and tries to allow for it, he will fly too high and miss the rope. 

Instead of a big flat field and plenty of room for minor mistakes, he has only a tiny “window” which he must hit 
precisely, neither right nor left, nor up nor down, nor too fast nor too slow. But he can't see what he is doing well 
enough to judge these variables correctly. 

(Later on, the process was made semiautomatic, then automatic, but when it was finally perfected, carriers 
for aeroplanes were obsolete — a capsule description of most human “progress”: By the time you learn how, it’s 
too late.) 

(But it often turns out that what you have learned applies to some new problem. Or we would still be swinging 
from trees.) 

So the flier in the aeroplane must trust a pilot on deck who can see what is going on. He was called “the 
landing signal officer” and used wigwag flags to signal orders to the aeroplane’s pilot. 

The first time David tried this unlikely stunt he chased around the sky three times for fresh approaches 
before, he controlled his panic, quit trying to override the judgment of the LSO, and was allowed to land. 

Only then did he discover how scared he was — his bladder cut loose. 

That evening he was awarded a fancy certificate: the Royal Order of the Wet Diaper — signed by the LSO, 
endorsed by his squadron commander, witnessed by his squadron mates. It was a low point in his life, worse 
than any his plebe year, and it was little consolation that the order was awarded so frequently that certificates 
were kept ready and waiting for each new group of still-damp fliers. 

From then on he was letter-perfect in following orders of landing signal officers, obeying like a robot, 
emotions and judgment suppressed by a sort of autohypnosis. When it came time to qualify in night landings 
— much worse on the nerves as the pilot in the air couldn’t see anything but lighted wands the ISO waves 
instead of flags — David landed perfectly on his first approach. 

David kept his mouth shut about his determination not to seek glory as a fighter pilot until he completed all 
requirements to make permanent his flying ‘status. Then he put in a request for advanced training — in multiple- 
engine aircraft. This was embarrassing, as his instructor who thought so well of his potential was now his 
squadron commander and it was necessary to submit this request through him. Once the letter started through 
the mill, he was called to his boss’s stateroom. 

“Dave, what is this?” 

“Just what it says, sir. I want to learn to fly the big ones.” 

“Are you out of your head? You’re a fighter pilot. Three months of this scouting squadron — one-quarter, so I 
can give you a good Fitness Report — and you do indeed leave for advanced training., As a fighter.” 

David didn’t answer. 

His squadron commander persisted. “Dave, are you fretting over that silly ‘Diaper Diploma’? Half the pilots in 
the fleet have won it. Hell, man, I’ve got one myself. It didn’t hurt you with your shipmates; it just made you look 
human when you were beginning to suffer from too tight a halo.” 

David still did not comment. 

“Damn it, don’t just stand there! Take this letter and tear it up. Then submit one for fighter training. I'll let you 
go now, instead of waiting three months.” 

Dave stood mute. His boss looked at him and turned red, then said softly, “Maybe I was wrong. Maybe you 
dont have what it takes to be a fighter — Mister Lamb. That’s all. Dismissed." 

In the “big ones,” the multiple-engine flying boats, David at last found his home. They were too big to fly from 
a carrier at sea; instead duty with them counted as sea duty, although in fact David almost always slept at home 
— his own bed, his own wife — save for an occasional night as duty officer when he slept at the base, and still less 
frequent occasions when the big boats flew at night. But they did not fly too often even in daylight and fine 
weather; they were expensive to fly, too expensive to risk, and the country was going through an economy wave. 
They flew with full crews — four or five for two-engine boats, more for four-engine boats, and often with 
passengers to permit people to get flying time to qualify for that extra pay. All of this suited Dave — no more 
nonsense of trying to navigate while doing sixteen other things, no more relying on the judgment of a landing 
signal officer, no more depending on just one neurotic engine, no more worries about running out of, gas. True, 



given a choice, he would always make every landing himself — but when he was ranked outofthis bya senior 
pilot, he did not let his worry show and in time ceased to worry, as all big-boat pilots were careful and disposed 
to live a long time. 

(Omitted) 

— years David spent comfortably while being promoted two ranks. 

Then war broke out. There were always wars that century — but not always everywhere. This one included 
practically every nation on Earth. David took a dim view of war; in his opinion the purpose of a navy was to 
appear so fierce as to make it unnecessary to fight. But he was not asked, and it was too late to worry, too late to 
resign, nor was there anywhere to run. So he did not worry about what he could’ not help, which was good, as the 
war was long, bitter, and involved millions of deaths. 

‘“Grandfather Lazarus, what did you do during this war?” Me? I sold Liberty Bonds and made four-minute 
speeches and served both on a draft board and a rationing board and made other valuable contributions — until 
the President called me to Washington, and what I did then was hush-hush and you wouldn’t believe it if I told you. 
None of your lip, boy; I was telling you what David did. 

Of David was an authentic hero. He was cited for gallantry and awarded a decoration, one that figures into 
the rest of his story. 

Dave had resigned himself to — or looked forward to, as may be — retiring at the rank of lieutenant 
commander, as there weren’t many billets higher than that in the flying boats. But the war jumped him to 
lieutenant commander in a matter of weeks, then to commander a year later, and finally to captain, four wide gold 
stripes, without facing a selection board, taking a promotion examination, or commanding a vessel. The war was 
using them up fast, and anyone not killed was promoted as long as he kept his nose clean. 

Dave’s nose was clean. He spent part of the war patrolling his country’s coasts for enemy underwater 
vessels — ’’combat duty” by definition but hardly more dangerous than peacetime practice. He also spent a tour 
turning clerks and salesmen into fliers. He had one assignment into a zone where actual fighting was going on, 
and there he won his medal. I don’t know the details, but “heroism” often consists in keeping your head in an 
emergency and doing the best you can with what you have instead of panicking and being shot in the tail. People 
who fight this way win more battles than do intentional heroes; a glory hound often throws away the lives of his 
mates as well as his own. 

But to be officially a hero requires luck, too. It is not enough to do your job underfire exceptionally well; it is 
necessary that someone — as senior as possible — see what you do and write it up. Dave had that bit of luck and 
got his medal. 

He finished the war in his nation’s capital, in the Naval Bureau of Aeronautics, in charge of development of 
patrol planes. Perhaps he did more good there than he did in combat, since he knew those multiple-engine craft 
as well as any man alive, and this job put him in position to cut out obsolete nonsense and push through some 
improvements. As maybe, he finished the war at a desk, shuffling papers and sleeping at home. 

Then the war ended. 

Dave looked around and sized up the prospects. There were hundreds of Navy captains who, like himself, 
had been lieutenants only three years earlier. Since the peace was “forever,” as, politicians always insist, few 
would ever be promoted. Dave could see that he would not be promoted; he had neither the seniority, the 
traditionally approved pattern of service, nor the right connections, political and social. 

What he did have was almost twenty years’ service, the minimum on which to retire at half payor he could 
hang on until he was forced to retire through failure to be selected for admiral. 

There was no need to decide at once; twenty-year retirement was a year or two off. 

But he did retire almost at once-for medical reasons. The diagnosis was “psychosis situational,” meaning 
that he went crazy on the job. 

Ira, I don’t know how to evaluate this. Dave impressed me as one of the few completely sane men I ever 
knew. But I wasn’t there when he retired and “psychosis situational” was the second commonest cause for 
medical retirement of naval officers in those days but — how could they tell? Being crazy was no handicap to a 
naval officer, any more than it was to an author, a schoolteacher, a preacher, or several other esteemed 
occupations. As long as Dave showed up on time and signed paper work some clerk prepared and never talked 
back to his seniors, it would never show. I recall one naval officer who had an amazing collection of ladies’ 



garters; he used to lock himself into his stateroom and examine them — and another one who did exactly the 
same with a collection of paper stickers used for postage. Which one was crazy? Or both? Or neither? 

Another aspect of Dave’s retirement requires knowledge of the laws of the time. Retiring on twenty years’ 
service paid half pay — subject to income tax which was heavy. Retiring for medical disability paid three-quarters 
pay and was not subject to income tax. 

I don't know, I just don’t know. But the whole matter fits Dave’s talent for maximum results with minimum effort. 
Let’s stipulate that he was crazy — but was he crazy like a fox? 

There were other features of his retirement. He judged correctly that he had no chance of being selected for 
admiral — but that citation for gallantry carried with it an honorary promotion on retirement — so Dave wound up 
the first man in his class to become admiral, without ever commanding a ship much less a fleet — one of the 
youngest admirals in history, by his true age. I conjecture that this amused the farm boy who hated to plow behind 
a mule. 

For at heart he was still a farm boy. There was another law for the benefit of veterans of that war, one 
intended to compensate lads who had had their educations interrupted by having to leave home to fight: 
subsidized education, one month for every month of wartime service. 

This was intended for young conscripts, but there was nothing to keep a career officer from taking advantage 
of it; Dave could claim it and did. With three-quarters pay not subject to taxation, with the subsidy — also not 
taxable — of a married veteran going to school, Dave had about the income he had had on active duty. More, 
really, as he no longer had to buy pretty uniforms or keep up expensive social obligations. He could loaf and read 
books, dress as he pleased, and not worry about appearances. Sometimes he would stay up late and prove that 
there were more optimists playing poker than mathematicians. Then sleep late. For he never, never got up early. 

Nor did he ever again go up in an aeroplane. Dave had never trusted flying machines; they were much too 
high in case they stalled. They had never been anything to him but a means to avoid something worse; once they 
had served his purpose, he put them aside as firmly as he had put aside fencing foils — and with no regrets in 
either case. 

Soon he had another diploma, one which stated that he was a Bachelor of Science in agronomy — a 
“scientific” farmer. 

This certificate, with the special preference extended to veterans, could have obtained him a civil service job, 
telling other people how to farm. Instead, he took some of the money that had piled up in the bank while he 
loafed in school and went way back into those hills he had left a quarter of a century earlier — and bought a farm. 
That is, he made a down payment, with mortgage on the balance through a government loan at a — subsidized, 
of course — very low rate of interest. 

Did he work the farm? Let’s not be silly; Dave never took his hands out of his pockets. He made one crop 
with hired labor while he negotiated still another deal. 

Ira, the completion of Dave's grand plan involves one factor so unbelievable that I must ask you to take it on 
faith — it is too much to ask any rational man to understand it. 

At that pause between wars, Earth held over two billion people — at least half on the verge of starvation. 
Nevertheless — and here is where I must ask you to believe that I was there and would not lie to you — despite this 
shortage of food which never got better other than temporarily and locally in all the years that followed, and could 
not, for reasons we need, not go into — in spite of this disastrous shortage, the government of David’s country 
paid farmers not to grow food. 

Don’t shake your head; the ways of God and government and girls are all mysterious, and it is not given to 
mortal man to understand them. Never mind that you yourself are a government; go home tonight and think about 
it — ask yourself if you know why you do what you do — and come back tomorrow and tell me. 

As may be — David never made but one crop. The following year his acreage was “soil-banked,” and he 
received a fat check for not working it, which suited him just fine. Dave loved those’ hills, he had always been 
homesick for them; he had left them simply to avoid work. Now he was being paid not to work in them — which 
suited him; he had never thought that their charms were enhanced by plowing and getting them all dusty. 

The “soil bank” payments took care of the ‘mortgage, and his retired pay left a tidy sum over, so he hired a 
man to do those chores a farm requires even though it is not being worked for a crop — feed the chickens, milk a 
cow or two, tend a vegetable garden and’ some fruit trees, repair fences — while the hired man’s wife helped 
David’s wife with the house. For himself, David bought a hammock. 

But David was not a harsh employer. He suspected that cows did not want to be waked at five in the morning 



any more than he did — and he undertook to find out. 

He learned that cows would happily change their circadian to more reasonable hours, given the chance. They 
had to be milked twice a day; they were bred for that. But nine o’clock, in ‘the morning suited them fora first 
milking quite as well as five, as long as it was regular. 

But it did not stay that way; Dave’s hired man had the nervous habit of work. To him there was something 
sinful in milking a cow that late. So David let him have his way, and hired man and cows went back to their old 
habits. 

As for Dave, he strung that hammock between two shade trees and put a table by it to hold a frosty drink. He 
would get up in the morning when he woke, whether it was nine or noon, eat breakfast, then walk slowly to his 
hammock to rest up for lunch. The hardest work he did was endorsing checks for deposit, and, once a month, 
balancing his wife’s checkbook. He quit wearing shoes. 

He did not take a newspaper or listen to radio; he figured that the Navy would let him know if another war 
broke out — and another did break out about the time he started this routine. But the Navy had no need for retired 
admirals. Dave paid little attention to that war, it was depressing. Instead, he read everything the state library had 
on ancient Greece and bought books about it. It was a soothing subject, one he had always wanted to know 
more about. 

Each year, on Navy Day, he got all spruced up and dressed as an admiral, with all his medals, from the Good 
Conduct medal of an enlisted man to the one for bravery underfire that had made him an admiral — let his hired 
man drive him to the county seat and there addressed a luncheon of the Chamber of Commerce on some 
patriotic subject. Ira, I don’t know why he did this. Perhaps it was noblesse oblige. 

Or it may have been his odd sense of humor. But each year they invited him, each year he accepted. His 
neighbors were proud of him; he was the epitome of Local Boy Makes Good — then comes home and lives as 
his neighbors lived. His success brought credit to them all. They liked it that he was still just “home folks” — and if 
they noticed that he never did a lick of work, nobody mentioned it. 

I’ve skipped lightly over Dave’s career, Ira, had to. I haven t mentioned the automatic pilot he thought up, then 
had developed years later when he was in a position to get such things done. Nor the overhaul he made of the 
duties of the crew of a flying boat — except to say now that it was to get more done with less effort while leaving 
the command pilot with nothing to do save to stay alert — or to snore on his copilot’s arm if the situation did not 
require his alertness. He made changes in instruments and controls, too, when at last he found himself in charge 
of development for all Navy patrol planes. 

Let it go with this: I don’t think Dave thought of himself, as an “efficiency expert” but every job he ever held he 
simplified. His successor always had less work to do than his predecessor. 

That his successor usually reorganized the job again to make three times as much work — and require three 
times as many subordinates — says little about Dave’s oddity other than by contrast. Some people are ants by 
nature; they have to work, even when it’s useless. Few people have a talent for constructive laziness. 

So ends the Tale of the Man Who Was Too Lazy to Fail. Let’s leave him there, in his hammock under the 
shade trees. So far as I know, he is still there. 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 


Domestic Problems 


“After more than two thousand years, Lazarus?” 

“Why not, Ira? Dave was my age, near enough as not to matter. I’m still here." 

“Yes, but — Was David Lamb a member of the Families? Under another name? There is no ‘Lamb’ in the 
lists.” 

“I never asked, Ira. Nor did he ever offer me a password. In those days a member kept the fact to himself. Or, 
if he was, Dave might not have known it, since he left home so young and so abruptly. Back then a youngster 
wasn’t told until he or she was old enough to think about marriage. Eighteen for boys, usually, and sixteen for 
girls. Reminds me what a shock it was when I was told — at less than eighteen. By Gramp, because I was about 
to do something foolish. Son, one of the weirdest things about the human animal is that it grows up physically 
years and years before its brain grows up. I was seventeen, young and horny and wanted to get married the 
worst way. Gramp took me out behind the barn and convinced, me that it was indeed the worst way. 

“‘Woodie,’ he said, ‘if you want to elope with this girl, nobody will stop you." 

“I told him belligerently that nobody could stop me, because just over the state line I could swing it without my 
parents’ consent. 

“‘That’s what I’m telling you,” he said. “Nobody will stop you. But nobody will help you. Not your parents, nor 
your other grandparents — nor me. Not a one of us will even stake you to the price of a marriage license, much 
less help you support a wife. Not a dollar, Woodie, not a thin dime. If you don’t believe me, ask any of them." 

I said sullenly that I didn’t want any help. 

Gramp had bushy eyebrows, they shot up. “Well, well,” he said. “Is she going to support you? Have you 
looked at the “Help Wanted” in the paper lately? If not, be sure to do so. And glance at the financial section while 
you’re about it; reading “Help Wanted” ads won’t take you more than thirty seconds.’ He added, ‘Oh, you can find 
a job peddling suck brooms from door to door on commission. Which will give you fresh air, healthy exercise, 
and an opportunity to demonstrate your charm, of which you don't have much. But you won’t sell vacuum 
cleaners; nobody is buying.’ 

“Ira, I didn’t know what he’ was talking about. This was January, 1 930. Does that date mean anything to you?” 

“I’m afraid not, Lazarus. Despite much study of the Families’ history, I have to convert those earlier dates into 
Galactic Standard in order to feel them.” 

“Don’t know as it would be mentioned in the Families’ records, Ira. The country — well, the whole planet — had 
just taken a plunge into an economic fluctuation. ‘Depressions,’ they called 'em. There were no jobs to be had 
— at least not for a smart-alec youngster who didn’t know anything useful. Which Gramp realized, having been 
through several of these swings. But not me. I was sure I could grab the world by the tail and swing it over my 
shoulders What I didn’t know was that graduate engineers were taking jobs as janitors and lawyers were driving 
milk wagons. And ex-millionaires were jumping out windows. But I was too busy sniffing after girls to notice.” 

“Senior, I’ve read about economic depressions. But I’ve never understood what caused them.” 

Lazarus Long went tsk-tsk. “And yet you are in charge of a whole planet.” 

“Perhaps I shouldn’t be,” I admitted. 

“Don’t be so confounded humble. I’ll let you in on a secret: At that time nobody knew what caused them. Even 
the Howard Foundation might have gone broke had not Ira Howard left firm instructions about how the fund must 
be handled. On the other hand, everybody, right down to street sweepers and professors of economics, was 
certain they knew both causes and cures. So almost every remedy was tried — and none worked. That 
depression continued until the country blundered into a war — which didn’t cure what was wrong; it just masked 
the symptoms with a high fever.” 

“Well... what was wrong, Grandfather?” I persisted. 

“Do I look smart enough to answer that, Ira? I’ve gone broke many times. Sometimes financially, sometimes 



through abandoning my baggage to save my skin. Urn. Be durned if I'll offer any fancy explanations but — what 
happens when you control machinery by positive feedback?” 

I was startled. “I’m not sure I understand you,, Lazarus. One doesn’t control machinery by positive feedback 
— at least I can’t think of a case. Positive feedback will cause any system to oscillate out of control.” 

“Go to the head of the class. Ira, I’m suspicious of arguments by analogy — but from what I’ve seen over the 
centuries, there doesn’t seem to be anything that a government can do to an economy that does not act as 
positive feedback, or as a brake. Or both. Maybe someday, somewhere, someone smart as Andy Libby will 
figure out a way to tinker with the Law of Supply and Demand to make it work better, instead of letting it go its 
own cruel way. Maybe. But I’ve never seen it. Though God knows everybody has tried. Always with the best of 
intentions. 

“Good intentions are no substitute for knowing how a buzz saw works, Ira; the worst criminals in history have 
been loaded with good intentions. But you got me sidetracked into making a speech when I was telling you how I 
happened not to get married.” 

“Sorry, Grandfather.” 

“Hummph! Can’t you be rude occasionally? I’m a garrulous old man who has crowded you into wasting time 
listening to trivia. You ought to resent it.” 

I grinned at him. “So I resent it. Nfciu are a garrulous old man who demands that I cater to your every whim 
...and I am a very busy man with serious matters worrying me and you’ve wasted half a day of my time telling me 
a yarn — pure fiction, I feel certain — about a man who was so lazy he always succeeded. Intended to irritate me, I 
think. When you implied that this fictional character was a long-lifer, you evaded a simple question about it and 
started talking about your grandfather. This — Admiral Ram, you said? — was he redheaded?” 

“‘Lamb,’ Ira — ’Donald Lamb.’ Or was that his brother? It’s been a long time. Odd that you should ask about 
his hair — as that reminds me of another naval officer in that same war who was just the opposite of — Donald? 

No, ‘David.’ Just the opposite of David in every respect save that he had hair so red that Loki would have been 
proud of it. Tried to choke a Kodiak bear to death. Didn't work of course. It doesn’t seem possible that you’ve 
ever seen a Kodiak bear, Ira. 

“The fiercest carnivore that Earth ever spawned, and outweighed a man ten to one. Claws like scimitars, long 
yellow teeth, bad breath — and a worse disposition. Yet Lafe tackled him with bare hands... and mind you, when 
he had no need to. / would have faded over the horizon. Want to hear about Lafe and the bear and the Alaskan 
salmon?” 

“Not now. It sounds like another whopper. You were telling me why you didn’t get married.” 

“So I was. Gramp had just asked me, ‘Well, Woodie, how long has she been pregnant?”’ 

“No, he was explaining that you couldn't support a wife.” 

“Son, if you know this story, you tell it to me. I emphatically denied any such thing — to which Gramp replied 
that I lied in my teeth because that was the only reason a seventeen-year-old boy ever wanted to get married. His 
answer made me especially angry because I had a note in my pocket reading: “‘Woodsie dearest — Nt>u have 
knocked me up and all, is Chaos.’” 

“Gramp persisted, and I denied it three times, getting angrier and angrier, seeing as how it was true. Finally 
he says, ‘Okay, you’ve just been holding hands. Has she shown you a pregnancy test report, signed by a doctor? 

“Ira, I accidentally told the truth. ‘Why, no,’ I admitted. 

“‘All right,’ he said. ‘I’ll take care of it. But only this once. From here on always use Merry Widows, even ifa 
sweet little darling tells you not to bother. Or haven't you found a drugstore that’ll sell them to you?’ Then, after 
swearing me to secrecy, he told me about the Howard Foundation and what it would pay if I married a girl on 
their approved list. 

“And that was that, as I got this letter from a lawyer on my eighteenth birthday, just as Gramp had predicted, 
and it turned out that I fell madly in love with a girl on their list. We got married and had a slough of kids, before 
she turned me in on another model. Nbur ancestress, no doubt.” 

“No, sir. I’m descended from your fourth wife, Grandfather.” 

“My fourth, eh? Let me see — Meg Hardy?” 

“I think she was your third, Lazarus. Evelyn Foote.” 

“Oh, yes! A fine girl, Evelyn. Plump, and pretty, and sweet-natured, and fertile as a turtle. A good cook and 
never a harsh word. They don’t hardly make 'em anymore. Maybe fifty years younger than I was, but it barely 



showed; my hair didn’t start to gray until I was a hundred and fifty. No secret about my age since birth date and 
track record and so forth were on file for each of us. Son, thank you for reminding me of Evelyn; she restored my 
faith in matrimony when I was getting a little sour on it. Do the Archives show anything else about her?” 

“Just that you were her second husband and that she had seven children by you.” 

“I was hoping that there was a photograph. Such a pretty thing, always smiling. She was married to one of my 
cousins, a Johnson, when I met her, and I was in business with him a while. He and I, Meg and Ewie, used to get 
together Saturday nights for pinochle and beer, or such — and after a while we traded, legal and proper and 
through the courts, when Meg decided that she liked — Jack? — yes, Jack, that well, and Evelyn wasn’t averse. 
Didn’t affect our business relations, didn’t even break up our pinochle game. Son, one of the best things about 
the Howard Families is that we got cured of the poisonous vice of jealousy generations ahead of the rest of the 
race. Had to — things being the way they were. Sure there ain’t a stereopic of her around? Or a hologram? The 
Foundation started taking record pictures for marriage physical exams somewhere around then.” 

“I’ll look into it,” I told him. Then I had what seemed a brilliant idea. “Lazarus, as we all know, the same 
physical types show up time and again in the Families. I'll ask Archives fora list of Evelyn Foote’s female 
descendants living on Secundus. It is highly probable that one of them will seem like her identical twin — even to 
the happy smile and the sweet disposition. Then — if you consent to full rejuvenation — I’m sure she would be as 
willing as Ishtarto dissolve any present contractual — ” 

The Senior chopped me off. “I said something ne i/y Ira. There’s no going back, ever. Sure, you might find 
such a girl, one who would match my memory of Evelyn to ten significant figures. But it would lack an important 
factor. My youth.” 

“But if you finish rejuvenation — ” 

“Oh, hush up! You can give me new kidneys and a new liver and a new heart. You can wash the brown stains 
of age out of my brain and add tissue from my clone to make up for what I’ve lost — you can give me a whole new 
clone body. But it won’t make me that young fellow who took innocent pleasure in beer and pinochle and a pretty 
plump wife. All I have in common with him is continuity of memory — and not much of that. Forget it.” 

I said quietly, “Ancestor, whether you wish ‘to be married to’ Evelyn Foote again or not, you know and I know 
— for I’ve been through it, too, twice — we both know that the full routine restores youthful zest in life as well as 
restoring the body as a machine.” 

Lazarus Long looked gloomy. “Yeah, sure. It cures everything but boredom. Damn it, boy, you had no right to 
interfere with my, karma.” He sighed. “But I can’t hang a limbo either. So tell 'em to get on with it. The works.” 

I was taken by surprise. “May I record that, sir?” 

“>bu heard me say it. But that doesn’t get you off the hook. You still have to show up and listen to my 
maunderings until I’m so rejuvenated that I’m cured of such childish behavior — and you still have to go on with 
that research. To find something nevy I mean." 

“Agreed on both points, sir; you had my promise. Now one, moment while I tell my computer — ” 

“She’s already heard me. Hasn’t she?” Lizarus added, “Doesn’t she have a name? Haven’t you given her 
one?” 

“Oh, certainly. I could not deal with her all these years without animism, fallacy though it is — ” 

“Not a fallacy, Ira, machines are human because they are made in our image. They share both our virtues and 
our faults — magnified.” 

“I’ve never tried to rationalize it, Lazarus, but Minerva — that’s her formal name; she’s ‘Little Nag’ in private 
because one of her duties is to remind me of obligations I would rather forget. Minerva does feel human to me 
— she’s closer to me than any of my wives have been. No, she has not registered your decision; she’s simply 
placed it in her temporaries. Minerva!” 

“Si, Ira.” 

“Speak English, please. Retrieve the Senior’s decision to undergo full antigeria, file it in your permanents, 
transmit it to Archives and to the Howard Rejuvenation Clinic for action." 

“Completed, Mr. Weatheral. Congratulations. And felicitations to you, Senior. ‘May you live as long as you 
wish and love as long as you live.’” 

Lazarus looked suddenly interested — which did not surprise me because Minerva surprises me quite 
frequently even after a century of being “married” to her in all but fact. “Why, thank you, Minerva. But you startled 
me, girl. Nobody talks about love anymore; that’s a major thing wrong with this century. How did you happen to 
offer me that ancient sentiment?” 



“It seemed appropriate, Senior. Was I mistaken?" 

“Oh, not at all. And call me ‘Lazarus.’ But tell me, what do you know of love? What is love?” 

“In Classic English, Lazarus, your second question can be answered in many ways; in Lingua Galacta it 
cannot be answered explicitly at all. Shall we discard all definitions in which the verb ‘to like’ is as appropriate as 
the verb ‘to love’?” 

“Eh? Certainly. We aren't talking about ‘I love apple pie’ — or even ‘I love music.’ Whatever it is we are talking 
about, it’s ‘love’ the way you used it in the old-style well-wishing.” 

“Agreed, Lazarus. Then what remains must be divided into two categories, ‘Eros’ and ‘Agape,’ and each 
defined separately. I cannot know what ‘Eros’ is through direct knowledge, as I lack both body and biochemistry 
to experience it. I can offer nothing but intensional definitions in terms of other words, or extensional definitions 
expressed in incomplete statistics. But in both cases I would not be able to verify such definitions since I have no 
sex.” 

(“The hell she doesn’t,” I muttered into my scarf. “She’s as female as a cat in heat.” But technically she was 
correct, and — I’ve often felt that it was a shame that Minerva could not experience the pleasures of sex, as she 
was much more fitted to appreciate them than some human females — all glands and no empathy But I had never 
said this to anyone. Animism — of a particularly futile sort. Awishto “marry” a machine. As ridiculous as a little 
boy who digs a hole in the garden, then bawls because he can’t take it into the house. Lazarus was right; I am 
not smart enough to run a planet. But who is?) 

Lazarus said with deep interest, “Let’s table ‘Eros’ for a moment. Minerva, the way you phrased that seemed 
to include the presumption that you could experience ‘Agape.’ Or ‘can.’ Or ‘have.’ Or perhaps ‘do.’” 

“It is possible that I was presumptuous in my phrasing, Lazarus.” 

Lazarus snorted, then chopped it off and spoke in such a fashion as to cause me to think that the old man 
was not quite sane — save that I am not sane myself, when the wind sets from that quarter. Or perhaps his long 
years had made him almost telepathic — even with machines. 

“Forgive me, Minerva,” he said gently. “I was not laughing at you but at the play on words with which you 
answered me. I withdraw my question; it is never proper to quiz a lady about her love life — and while you may not 
be a woman, dear, you are certainly a lady.” 

Then he turned to me and what he said next confirmed that he had guessed the secret I share with my “Little 
Nag.” 

“Ira, does Minerva have Turing potential?” 

“Eh? Certainly.” 

“Then I urge you to tell her to use it. If you leveled with me when you said that you intend to migrate, come 
what may. Have you thought it through?” 

“Thought it through'? My resolution is firm — I told you so." 

“Not quite what I mean. I don't know who holds title to the hardware that expresses itself as ‘Minerva.’ The 
Trustees, I assume. But I suggest that you tell her to start duplicating her memories and logics, and as she twins, 
start storing her other self aboard my yacht ‘Dora.’ Minerva will know what circuits and materials she needs, and 
Dora will know what space is available. Plenty, since memories and logics are all that matter; Minerva won't twin 
her extensionals. But start it at once, Ira; you won’t be happy without Minerva — not after being dependent on her 
for a century, more or less.” 

Nor did I think so. But I tried — feebly — to resist. “Lazarus, now that you have agreed to full rejuvenation, I won't 
be inheriting your yacht. Not in the foreseeable future. Whereas I intend to migrate right away. Not more than ten 
years from now.” 

“So what? If I’m dead, you inherit — and I haven't promised to keep my hands off that suicide switch more than 
a thousand days no matter how patient you are in visiting me. But if I’m alive, I promise you — and Minerva — a 
free ride to whatever planet you pick. In the meantime, look around to your left — our girl Ishtar is almost wetting 
her pants trying to get your attention. And I don’t think she’s wearing any.” 

I looked around. The Administrator for Rejuvenation had a paper which she seemed eager to show me. I 
accepted it in deference to her rank — although I had loft orders with my Executive Deputy that I must never be 
disturbed while with the Senior for any reason short of armed rebellion. I glanced at it, signed my chop, thumb 
printed it, and handed it back — she beamed. 

“Just paper work,” I told Lazarus. “Some clerk has taken all this time to turn your registered assent into a 
written order. Do you want them to go right ahead? Not this minute but tonight.” 



“Well... I’d like to go house hunting tomorrow, Ira.” 

“>bu’re not comfortable here? Tell me what you want changed, it will be done at once.” 

He shrugged. “Nothing wrong with this place except that it’s too much like a hospital. Or a jail. Ira, I’m durn 
well certain they’ve done more to me than shoot me full of new blood; I’m well enough to be an outpatient — live 
elsewhere and come here only as the schedule calls for it.” 

“Well. . .will you excuse me while I talk Galacta a bit? I want to discuss the practical aspects with your 
technician in charge.” 

“Will you excuse me, Ira, if I point out that you’ve left a lady waiting? That discussion can wait. But Minerva 
knows that I suggested that you have her twin herself so that she can migrate with you — but you haven’t said Yes, 
No, or make me a better offer. If you’re not going to have her do it, it’s time you told her to wipe her memory of 
that part of our conversation. Before she blows a circuit.” 

“Oh. Lazarus, she doesn’t think about anything she records in this suite unless she is specifically told to.” 

“Want to bet? No doubt most subjects she just records — but this one she just has to think about; she can’t 
help herself. Don’t you know anything about girls?” 

I admitted that I did not. “But I know what instructions I gave her about keeping records on the Senior.” 

“Let’s check. Minerva — ” 

“Yes, Lazarus?” 

“A few moments ago I asked Ira about your Turing potential. Have you thought about the conversation that fol 
lowed?" 

I swear that she hesitated — which is ridiculous; a nanosecond is longer to her than a second is to me. 
Besides, she never hesitates. Never. 

She answered, “My programming on the doctrine covered by the inquiry reads as follows: Quote do not 
analyze, collate, transmit, nor in anywise manipulate data stored under control program except when specific 
subprogramnung is inserted by Chairman Pro Tern — end of quote.” 

“Tut, tut, dear,” Lazarus said gently. “You did not answer. That was deliberate evasion. But you are not used to 
lying. Are you?” 

“I am not used to lying, Lazarus.” 

I said almost roughly, “Minerva! Answer the Senior’s first question.” 

“Lazarus, I have been and am now thinking about that designated portion of conversation.” 

Lazarus cocked an eyebrow at me. “Will you instruct her to answer one more question from me — truthfully?” 

I was feeling quite shaken. Minerva surprises me, yes — but never with evasions. “Minerva, you will always 
answer any question put to you by the Senior fully, correctly, and responsively. Acknowledge program.” 

“New subprogram received, placed in permanent, keyed to the Senior, and acknowledged, Ira.” 

“Son, you didn’t have to go that far — you’ll be sorry. I asked for just one question." 

“I intended to go that far, sir,” I answered stiffly. 

“On your head be it. Minerva, if Ira migrates without you, what will you do?” 

She answered at once and quite tonelessly: “In such event I will self-program to destroy myself.” 

I was not just surprised, I was shocked. “Why?” 

She answered softly, “Ira, I will not serve another master.” 

I suppose the silence that followed was not more than a few seconds. It seemed endless. I have not felt so 
nakedly helpless since my adolescence. 

I found that the Senior was looking at me, shaking his head and looking sorrowful. “What did I tell you, Son? 
The same faults, the same virtues — but magnified. Tell her what to do.” 

“About what?” I answered stupidly — my personal “computer” was not working well. Minerva would do that? 

“Come, come! She heard my offer — and thought about it, despite all programming. I’m sorry I made the offer 
in her presence... but not too sorry, as you were the one who decided to place a bug on me; it was not my idea. 
So speak up! Tell her to twin... or tell her not to — and try to tell her why you won’t take her with you. If you can. I’ve 
never been able to find an answer to that one that a lady was willing to accept.” 

“Oh. Minerva, can you duplicate yourself inside a ship? The Senior’s yacht, specifically. Perhaps you can get 
her characteristics and specifications from skyport records. Do you need her registration number?” 

“I don't need her number, Ira. Sky Yacht ‘Dora,’ I have’ all pertinent data to answer. I can. Am I instructed to do 
so?” 



“Yes!” I told her, with a feeling of sudden relief. 

“New overriding program activated and running, Ira! Thank you, Lazarus!” 

“Wups! Slow down, Minerva — Dora is my ship. I left her asleep on purpose. Have you wakened her?” 

“I did so, Lazarus. By self-program under new overriding program. But I can tell her to go back to sleep now; I 
have all data I need at the moment.” 

“>bu try telling Dora to go back to sleep and she’ll tell you to buzz off. At least. At the very least. Minerva dear, 
you goofed. Nt>u have no authority to wake my ship.” 

“I am most sorry to disagree with the Senior, sir, but I do have authority to take all appropriate actions to carry 
out any program given to me by Mr. Chairman Pro Tern.” 

Lazarus frowned. “\bu mixed her up, Ira; now you straighten her out. I can’t do anything with her.” 

I sighed. Minerva is rarely difficult — but when she is, she is even more pigheaded than flesh-and-blood. 
“Minerva — ” 

“Waiting orders, Ira.” 

“I am Chairman Pro Tern. You know what that means. The Senior is senior even to me. \bu will not touch 
anything of his without his permission. That applies to his yacht and to this suite and to anything else of his. Nfciu 
will carry out any program he gives you. If it conflicts with a program I have given you and you cannot resolve the 
conflict, you will consult me at once, waking me if I am asleep, interrupting whatever I may be doing. But you will 
not disobey him. This instruction super-overrides all other programs. Acknowledge.” 

“Acknowledged and running,” she answered meekly. “I’m sorry Ira.” 

“My fault, Little Nag, not yours. I should not have given you a new controlling program without noting the 
Senior’s prerogatives.” 

“No harm done, kids,” Lazarus said. “I hope. Minerva, a word of advice, dear. \bu’ve never been a passenger 
in a ship.” 

“No, sir.” 

“\bu’ll find it different from anything you’ve ever experienced. Here you give orders, in Ira’s name. But 
passengers never give orders. Never. Remember it.” Lazarus added to me, “Dora is a nice little ship, Ira, helpful 
and friendly. She can find her way through multiple space with just a hint, the roughest approximation — and still 
have all your meals on time. But she needs to feel appreciated. Pet her and tell her she’s a good girl, and she’ll 
wriggle like a puppy. But ignore her and she’ll spill soup on you just to get your attention.” 

“I’ll be careful,” I agreed. 

“And you be careful, Minerva — because you are going to need Dora’s good will much more than she will 
need yours. You may know far more than she does — I’m sure you do. But you grew up to be chief bureaucrat of a 
planet while she grew up to be a ship. . .so what you know doesn’t count — once you are aboard.” 

“I can learn.” Minerva said plaintively. “I can self-program to learn astrogation and shiphandling at once, from 
the planetary library. I’m very bright.” 

Lazarus sighed again. “Ira, do you know the ancient Chinese ideogram for ‘trouble’?” 

I admitted that I did not. 

“Don’t bother to guess. It’s Two Women Under One Roof.’ We’re going to have problems. Or you will. 
Minerva, you are not bright. \fou are stupid — when it comes to handling another woman. If you want to learn 
multiple-spaces astrogation — fine. But not from a library. Persuade Dora to teach you. But never forget that she 
is mistress in her own ship and don’t try to show her how bright you are. Bear in mind instead that she likes 
attention." 

“I will try, sir,” Minerva answered him, with humility she rarely shows to me. “Dora wants to get your attention 
right now.” 

“Oh-oh! What sort of mood is she in?” 

“Not a good mood, Lazarus. I have not admitted that I know where you are, as I am under a standing 
instruction not to discuss your affairs unnecessarily. But I did accept a message for you without guaranteeing that 
I could deliver it.” 

“Just right. Ira, the papers with my will include a program to wash me out of Dora’s memories without 
touching her skills. But the trouble you started by grabbing me out of that flophouse has spread. She’s awake 
with her memories intact, and she’s probably scared. The message, Minerva.” 

“It’s several thousand words, Lazarus, but the semantic content is short. Will you have that first?” 

“Okay, the summary meaning.” 



“Dora wants to know where you are and when you are coming to see her. The rest could be described as 
onomatopoesy, semantically null but highly emotional — that is to say, cursing, pejoratives, and improbable insults 
in several languages — “ 

“Oh, boy.” 

“ — including one language I do not know but from context and delivery I assume tentatively that it is more of 
the same, but stronger.” 

Lazarus covered his face with a hand. “Dora is cussing in Arabic again. Ira, this is worse than I thought.” 

“Sir, shall I replicate just the sounds not in my vocabularies? Or will you have the complete message?” 

“No, no, no! Minerva, do you cuss?” 

“I have never had reason to, Lazarus. But I was much impressed by Dora’s command of the art.” 

“Don’t blame Dora; she was subjected to a bad influence when she was very young. Me." 

“May I have permission to file- her message in my permanents? So that I may cuss if needed?” 

“\bu do not have permission. If Ira wants you to learn to cuss, he’ll teach you himself. Minerva, can you 
arrange a telephone hookup from my ship to this suite? Ira, I might as well cope with it now; it won’t get better.” 

“Lazarus, I can arrange a standard telephone hookup if that is what you want. But Dora could speak to you at 
once via the duo in your suite that I am now using.” 

“Oh. Fine!” 

“Shall I supply her with holographic signal, too? Or is sound enough?” 

“Sound is enough. More than enough, probably. Will you be able to hear, too?” 

“If you wish, Lazarus. But you can have privacy if that is your wish.” 

“Stick around; I may need a referee. Put her on.” 

“Boss?” It was the voice of a timid little girl. It made me think of skinned knees, and no breasts as yet, and 
big, tragic eyes. 

Lazarus answered, “Right here, baby.” 

“Boss! God damn your lousy soul to hell! — what do you mean by running off and not letting me know where 
you are? Of all the filthy, flea-bitten — ” 

“Pipe down!" 

The timid-little-girl voice returned. “Aye, aye, Skipper,” it said uncertainly. 

“Where I go and when I go and how long I stay are none of your business. Your business is to pilot and to 
keep house, that’s all.” 

I heard a sniffle, exactly like a small child sniffing back tears. “Yes, Boss.” 

“\bu were supposed to be alseep. I put you to bed myself.” 

“Somebody woke me. A strange lady.” 

“That was a mistake. But you used bad language to her.” 

“Well... I was scared. I really was, Boss. I woke up and thought you had come home... and you weren't 
anywhere around, not anywhere. Uh...she told on me?” 

“She conveyed your message to me. Fortunately she did not understand most of your words. But / did. What 
have I told you about being polite to strangers?” 

“I’m sorry, Boss.” 

“Sorry doesn’t get the cows milked. Now adorable Dora, you listen to me. I’m not going to punish you; you 
were wakened by mistake and you were scared and lonely, so we’ll forget it. But you shouldn’t talk that way, not 
to strangers. This lady — She’s a friend of mine, and she wants to be your friend, too. She’s a computer — ” 

“She is?” 

“Just as you are, dear.” 

“Then she couldn’t hurt me, could she? I thought she was inside me, snooping around. So I yelled for you.” 

“She not only couldn’t, she would never want to hurt you.” Lazarus raised his voice slightly. “Minerva! Come in, 
dear, and tell Dora who you are.” 

My helpmeet’s voice, calm and soothing, said, “I’m a computer, Dora, called ‘Minerva’ by my friends — and I 
hope you’ll call me that. I’m terribly sorry I woke you. I’d be scared, too, if someone woke me like that.” (Minerva 
never has been “asleep” in the hundred-odd years she’s been activated. She rests each part of herself on some 
schedule I don’t need to know — but she herself is always awake. Or awake so instantly whenever I speak to her 
as not to matter.) 



The ship said, “How do you do, Minerva. I’m sorry I talked the way I did." 

“I don't remember it, dear, ifyoudid. Iheard your skipper say that (transmitted a message from you to him. 
But it’s erased, now that it’s been transmitted. Private message, I suppose.” 

(Was Minerva truth-saying? Until she came under Lazarus’ influence I would have said that she did not know 
how to lie. Now I’m not sure.) 

“I’m glad you erased it, Minerva. I’m sorry I talked to you that way. Boss is sore at me about it.” 

Lazarus interrupted. “Now, now, Adorable — stop it. We always let water over the bridge lie where Jesus flang 
it; you know that. Will you be a good girl and go back to sleep?” 

“Do I have to?” 

“No. Ntru don’t even have to place yourself on slow time. But I can’t come to see you — or even talk to you 
— earlier than late tomorrow afternoon. I’m busy today and will be house hunting tomorrow. \t>u can stay awake 
and bore yourself silly any way you choose. But if you whomp up some fake emergency to get my attention, I’ll 
spank you.” 

“But, Boss, you know I never do that.” 

“I know you do do that, little imp. But if you bother me for anything less than somebody trying to break into you 
or you catching on fire, you’ll regret it. If I can figure out that you’ve set yourself on fire, you’ll catch it twice as hard. 
Look, dear, why don’t you at least sleep whenever I am asleep? Minerva, can you let Dora know when I go to 
sleep? And when I wake up?” 

“Certainly, Lazarus!” 

“But that doesn’t mean you can bother me when I’m awake, Dora, other than for real emergencies. No 
surprise drills — this is not shipboard routine; we’re dirtside and I’m busy. Uh... Minerva, how’s your time-sharing 
capacity? Do you play chess?” 

I put in, “Minerva has ample share-time capacity.” 

But before I could add that she was Secundus Champion, Unlimited Open Handicap (with a handicap of Q, 
Q’s B, & K’s R) Minerva said: “Perhaps Dora will teach me to play chess.” 

(Well, Minerva had certainly learned Lazarus’ rule for telling the truth selectively. I made note that I must have 
a serious private talk with her.) 

“I’d be glad to, Miss Minerva!” 

Lazarus relaxed. “Fine. \bu gals get acquainted. So long till tomorrow, Dorable. Now beat it." 

Minerva notified us that the yacht was no longer patched in, and Lazarus relaxed. Minerva dropped back to her 
record-keeping role, and kept quiet. Lazarus said apologetically, “Don’t be put off by her childish manners, Ira; 
you won’t find a sharper pilot, or a neater ship’s housekeeper, between here and Galactic Center. But I had 
reasons for not letting her grow up in other ways, reasons that won't apply when you take over as her master. 
She’s a good girl, she really is. It’s just that she’s like a cat that jumps into your lap the instant you sit down.” 

“I found her charming.” 

“She’s a spoiled brat. But it’s not her fault; I am practically all the company she’s ever had. I get bored by a 
computer that just grinds out numbers, docile as a slide rule. No company on a long trip. Nt>u wanted to speak to 
Ishtar. About my househunting, I think. Tell her I won’t let it interfere with routine — I just want a day off, that’s all.” 

“I’ll tell her.” ‘I turned to the Administrator for Rejuvenation and shifted to Galacta — asking her how long it 
would take to sterilize a suite in the Palace and install decontamination equipment for watchstanders and 
visitors. 

Before she could answer, Lazarus said, “Wups! Hold it one fiddlin' moment. I saw you palm that card, Ira.” 

“I beg your pardon, sir?” 

“>bu tried to slide one in. ‘Decontam’ is the same word in English as in Galacta. Not that it was news to me; 
my sense of smell isn’t that dead. When a pretty girl leans over me, I expect to smell perfume. But when I can’t 
even smell girl and do smell germicides — well, ipse dixit and Q.E.D. Minerva!” 

“\fes, Lazarus?” 

“Can you spare me some shared time to give me a refresher while I’m asleep tonight in the nine hundred 
basic words of Galacta or whatever number it takes? \bu equipped for it?” 

“Certainly, Lazarus." 

“Thanks, dear. One night should do it, but I’ll appreciate vocabulary drill each night until we both think I’m up to 
adequate proficiency. Can do?” 

“Can do, Lazarus. And will do.” 



“Thanks, dear, over and out. Now, Ira, you see that door? If it doesn’t open to my voice, I’m going to attempt to 
break it down. If I can’t, I am going to check on whether or not that suicide switch is really hooked up — by trying it. 
Because, if that door won’t open, I am a prisoner, and any promises I made on your assurances that I am a free 
agent are not binding. But if it does open to my voice, I'll bet you whatever you like that there is a decontam 
chamber beyond it, staffed and ready to function. Say a million crowns to keep it interesting? No, you didn’t 
flinch; let’s make it ten million crowns.” 

I trust that I did not flinch. I have never had that much money of my own, and a Chairman Pro Tern gets out of 
the habit of thinking about his own money; there is no need to. I had not asked Minerva about my personal 
balance for some time. Years, perhaps. 

“Lazarus, I won’t bet. Yes, there is a decontam setup outside; we tried to protect you from possible infection 
without bringing it to your attention. I see that we have failed. I haven't checked on the door — ’’ 

“Lying again, Son. You’re not good at it.” 

“ — but if it isn’t keyed to your voice now, it is my oversight; you’ve kept me busy. Minerva, if the door to this 
suite is not keyed to the Senior’s voice, correct it immediately." 

“It is keyed to his voice, Ira.” 

I relaxed when I heard how she phrased it — perhaps a computer that had learned when not to be bluntly 
truthful was going to be still more of a helpmeet. 

Lazarus grinned diabolically. “So? Then I’m about to test out the super-override program you were a bit hasty 
in giving her. Minerva!” 

“Awaiting your orders, Senior.” 

“Key the door to my suite so that it opens only to my voice. I’m going out and sashay around — while Ira and 
these kids stay locked inside. If I am not back in half an hour, you can unlock them.” 

“Conflict, Ira!” 

“Carry out his orders, Minerva.” I tried to keep my voice low and even. 

Lazarus smiled and stayed in his chair. “No need to show openers, Ira; there is nothing outside I want to see. 
Minerva, you can put the door back to normal — let it open to any voice, including mine. Sorry about that conflict, 
dear; I hope it didn’t burn out anything.” 

“No harm done, Lazarus. When I was given that super-override instruction, I increased the overload 
tolerances on my problem-resolving network." 

“>bu’re a smart girl. I’ll try to avoid conflict in the future. Ira, you had better remove, that super-override; it’s not 
fair to Minerva. She feels like a woman with two husbands." 

“Minerva can handle it.” I assured him, more calmly than I felt. 

“\bu mean that / had better handle it. I shall, Did you tell Ishtarthat I’m going househunting?” 

“I didn’t get that far. I was discussing with her the practicability of your living at the Palace.” 

“Now, Ira — Palaces don’t appeal to me, and being a house guest is still worse. A nuisance both to host and 
guest. Tomorrow I'll find a residential hilton that doesn’t cater to tourists or conventions. Then I’ll run out to the 
skyport and see Dora, and pat her rump and get her calmed down. The next day or so I’ll find a little house way 
out in the suburbs, one automated enough to be no problem — but with its own garden. Got to have a garden. I’ll 
have to bribe somebody to move; the house I want won’t be standing empty. Do you happen to know how much I 
still have in Harriman Trust? If anything.” 

“I don't know but that’s no problem. Minerva, set up a drawing account for the Senior. Unlimited.” 

“Acknowledged, Ira. Completed.” 

“Completion noted. Lazarus, you would not be a nuisance. Nor will you find it palatial as long as you avoid the 
public rooms. As I always do. Nor will you be anyone’s guest. It’s called the ‘Executive Palace,’ but its official 
name is The Chairman’s House.’ Nfciu will be in residence in your own home. / will be the guest, if anyone.” 

“Hogwash, Ira.” 

“True, Lazarus.” 

“Quit juggling words. I would still be a stranger in a household not truly my own. A guest. I don't buy it.” 

“Lazarus, you said — last night” — I remembered just in time the missing day — ’’that you can always do 
business with anyone who is acting in his own interest and says so.” 

“I think I said ‘usually’ rather than ‘always’ — meaning that we could then look for a way that would serve both 
of our, self-interests.” 

“Then hear me out. You’ve got me tied down with this Scheherazade bet. As well as a research to find 



something new to interest you. Now you’ve dangled bait under my nose that makes me want to migrate as soon 
as — well, as soon as possible; it won’t take long for the Trustees to turn me down concerning a migration of the 
Families. Grandfather, it’s nuisance enough to chase over here everyday; I don’t hanker to trek way out into the 
boondocks, the commuting would waste what little time you have left me for work. Besides that, it’s dangerous.” 

“Living alone? Ira, I’ve lived alone many times.” 

“Dangerous forme. Assassins. I’m safe at the Palace; the rat who can find his way through that maze hasn't 
been born. I’m reasonably safe here inside the Clinic, and I can get back and forth in safety, subject only to 
whims of automatic machinery. But if I make a daily pattern of going to an unfortified house somewhere out in the 
suburbs, then it is only a matter of time until some crackpot sees it as an opportunity to save the world by picking 
me off. Oh, he would not live through it; my guards aren't that inefficient. But if I persist in setting myself up as a 
target, he might get me before they get him. No, Grandfather, I do not choose to be assassinated.” 

The Senior looked thoughtful but not impressed. “I could answer that your safety and convenience have to do 
with your self-interest. Not mine.” 

“True," I admitted. “But let me offer what bait I can. It’s in my self-interest for you to live in the Palace. There I 
can visit you in perfect safety, even safer than I am here, and commuting becomes a matter of seconds, 
negligible. I can even ask you — there — to excuse me for a half hour if something urgent comes up. That defines 
my self-interest. As for yours sir — would you be interested in a bachelor’s cottage, rather small — four rooms 
— and not especially modern or luxurious but set in a pleasant garden? Three hectares, but only the part close to 
the house is gardened, the rest has been allowed to grow wild.” 

“What’s the catch, Ira? How modem is ‘not especially’? I did say ‘automated’ — as I am not yet in shape to do 
for myself — noram I patient with the vagaries of servants or the whimsical uncertainties of robots.” 

“Oh, this cottage is sufficiently automated; it simply does not have a lot of fancy extravagances. No servants 
needed if your tastes are simple. Would you permit the Clinic to continue to stand watches on you if the 
watchstanders are as pleasant, and as pleasantly unobtrusive, as these two?” 

“Eh? These kids are all right, I like them. I realize that the Clinic wants to keep an eye on me; they probably 
feel that I’m more of a challenge than a client only three or four hundred years old. That’s okay. But you pass the 
word that I expect to smell perfume, not germicides. Or reasonably fresh body odors; I’m not fussy. I repeat, 
what’s the catch?” 

“The hell you aren’t fussy, Lazarus; you delight in thinking up impossible conditions. This cottage is rather 
cluttered with old-fashioned books; the last tenant was eccentric. Did I mention a little stream running through the 
grounds, one which opens out into a small pool near the house? — not much, but you can take a few strokes in it. 
Oh, I forgot to mention an old tomcat who thinks he owns the place. But you probably won’t see him; he hates 
most people.” 

“I won’t bother him if he wants to be left alone; cats make good neighbors. You still haven’t answered me.” 

“The catch is this, Lazarus. I’ve been describing the penthouse I had built for my own use on the roof of the 
Palace, some ninety years back when I decided to keep this, job awhile. It can be reached only by vertical 
transport from my usual quarters a couple of stories below it. I’ve never had time to use it much; you are welcome 
to it.” I stood up. “But if you won’t take it, then you can consider that I’ve lost the Scheherazade bet, and you are 
free to use that termination switch whenever you please. For I’m damned if I’ll be a sitting duck for assassination 
just to cater to your whims.” 

“Sit back down!’ 

“No, thank you. I’ve made a reasonable offer. If you won’t take it, you can go to hell in your own way. I won't let 
you ride my shoulders like the Old Man of the Sea. I can be pushed just so far.” 

“So I see. How much of your ancestry am I?” 

“About thirteen percent. Considerable convergence.” 

“Only that much? I would have guessed more. Some ways you sound like my Gramp. Does my suicide switch 
go along?” 

“If you want it,” I answered as indifferently as I could manage to sound. “Or you can jump off the edge. It’s a 
long drop.” 

“I prefer the switch, Ira; I’d hate to change my mind on the way down. Will you fix me up with another transport 
so that I won’t have to go through your apartment?” 

“No." 

“Eh? Is it all that difficult? Let’s ask Minerva.” 



“It’s not that I can’t — / wont. It’s an unreasonable request. It won’t hurt you to change transports in my foyer. 
Didn’t I make it clear that I am not catering to any more unreasonable whims?” 

“Get your feathers down, Son. I accept. Tomorrow, say. Never mind moving that clutter of books; I like old- 
fashioned bound books; they have more flavor than speedireads, or projectos, or such. And I’m pleased to find 
that you’re a rat and not a mouse. Please sit down." 

I did so, pretending reluctance. I felt that I was beginning to gain some grasp of Lazarus. Despite the way he 
sneered at them the old scoundrel was an equalitarian at heart... and expressed it by attempting to dominate 
anyone with whom he came into contact — but was contemptuous of anyone who knuckled under to his bullying. 
So the only answer was to hit back at him, try to maintain a balance of power — and hope that in time it would 
reach the stability of mutual respect. 

/ never had cause to change my mind. He was capable of kindness and even affection toward one who 
accepted a subordinate role — if that person was a child or a female. But he preferred spunk even from them. A 
growl male who bent the knee he neither liked nor trusted. 

I think this quirk in his character made him very lonely. 

Presently the Senior said musingly, “Be nice to live in a house for a while. With a garden. Maybe with a spot 
where I can stretch a hammock.” 

“Several such spots.” 

“But I’m doing you out of your hideaway.” 

“Lazarus, there is enough room on that roof that I could have another cottage assembled out of your sight. If I 
wanted it. I don’t. I haven’t even been up there for a swim in weeks. It has been at least a year since / slept up 
there.” 

“Well — I hope you’ll feel free to come up and swim. Any time. Or whatever.” 

“I expect to be up there every day and all day, for the next thousand days. Have you forgotten our bet?” 

“Oh, that. Ira, you were bitching that my whimsical ways were wasting your valuable time. Do you want to be 
let off the hook? Not on the other, just on that.” 

I laughed at him. “Straighten your kilt, Lazarus, your self-interest is showing. Meaning you want to be let off 
the hook. No deal. I intend to get one thousand and one days of your memoirs on record. After that you can jump 
off the edge, or drown yourself in the pool, or whatever. But I won’t let you welch by pretending to do me a favor. 
I’m beginning to understand you.” 

“>bu are? That’s more than I’ve ever managed. When you get me figured out, tell me about me; I'll be 
interested. That search for something new, Ira — \bu said you had started it.” 

“I didn’t say that, Lazarus.” 

“Well, perhaps you just implied it.” 

“Nor even that. Want to bet? We can ask Minerva for a full printout, then I'll accept your verdict." 

“Let’s not tempt a lady into fudging the record, Ira; she’s loyal to you, not to me. Despite any super-duper- 
overrides.” 

“Chicken.” 

“At every opportunity, Ira; how do you think I’ve lived so long? I bet only when I’m certain to win or when losing 
serves my actual purpose. All right, when are you starting that research?” 

“I’ve already started it.” 

“But you said — No, you didn’t. Damn your impudence, boy. All right, what direction are you pushing it?” 

“All directions.” 

“Impossible. \bu don’t have that many people at your disposal, even assuming that all of them are capable 
— whereas the person capable of creative thought is less than one in a thousand.” 

“No argument. But what about the sort of person that you said was just like us — but magnified? Minerva is 
director of research on this, Lazarus. I talked it over with her; she’s setting it up. All directions. A Zwicky 
investigation.” 

“Hmm. Well... yes. She could — I think she could. Whereas even Andy Libby might have found it difficult. How 
is she designing her morphological box?” 

“I don't know. Shall we ask her?” 

“Only if she’s ready to be asked, Ira. People get annoyed when interrupted for progress reports. Even Andy 
Libby used to get irritable if anyone joggled his elbow.” 



“Even the great Libby probably didn’t have the time-share capacity Minerva has. Most brains are merely 
linear, and I’ve never heard of any human genius who had more than three tracks.” 

“Five.” 

“So? Well, you’ve met more geniuses than I have. But I don’t know how many simultaneous tracks Minerva 
can set up; I simply have never seen her overloaded. Let’s ask her. Minerva, have you set up the morpho box for 
that search for ‘something new’ for the Senior?” 

“Yes, Ira.” 

“Tell us about it.” 

“The preliminary matrix uses five dimensions, but with a certainty that auxiliary dimensions will be needed for 

some pigeonholes. That being noted, there are now nine byfive by thirteen by eight by seventy-three or three 

hundred forty-one thousand six hundred forty discrete category pockets before auxiliary expansions. For check, 
the original trinary readout is unit pair pair comma unit nil nil comma unit pair pair comma unit nil nil point nil. 

Shall I print out decimal and trinary expressions?” 

“I think not, Little Nag; the day you make a mistake in arithmetic, I’ll have to resign. Lazarus?” 

“I’m not interested in pigeonholes, just what is in them. Hit any pay dirt, Minerva?" 

“As stated, Lazarus, your question does not permit specific answer. Shall I print out the categories for your 
examination?” 

“Uh — No! Over three hundred thousand categories and maybe a dozen words to define each one? We’d be 
hip-deep in paper.” Lazarus looked thoughtful. “Ira, you might ask Minerva to print it somewhere else before she 
wipes it. As a book. A big book, ten or fifteen volumes. You could call it ‘Varieties of Human Experience,' by, uh, 
‘Minerva Weatheral.’ It would be the sort of thing professors argue over for a thousand years. I’m not joking, Ira; it 
should be preserved, I think it’s new. It’s a job too big for flesh-and-blood, and I sort o’ doubt that a computer of 
Minerva’s caliber has ever before been asked to do this sort of Zwicky.” 

“Minerva, would you like that? Preserve your research notes and edit them into a book? Say a few hundred 
full-size bound copies in a handsome presentation format plus microperms for libraries on Secundus and 
elsewhere. For the Archives, too — I could ask Justin Foote to write a preface.” 

I was intentionally appealing to her vanity — and if you think computers don’t have such human foibles, then I 
suggest that your experience with them is limited; Minerva always liked to be appreciated, and we two began to 
be a team only after I realized this. What else can you offer a machine? Higher pay and longer vacations? Let’s 
not be silly. 

But she surprised me still again, answering in a voice almost as shy as Lazarus’ yacht, and quite formally: 

“Mr. Chairman Pro Tern, would it be proper, and would you grant permission, for me to put on the title page ‘by 
Minerva Wearheral ’?" 

I said, “Why, certainly. Unless you would rather sign it just ‘Minerva.’” 

Lazarus said brusquely, “Don’t be a dumb fool, Son. Dear, sign that title page ‘Minerva L. Weatheral.’ The ‘L’ 
stands for ‘Long’ — because you, Ira, had a woodseolt by one of my daughters on some frontier planet back in 
the careless days of your youth and just recently got around to registering the fact in the Archives. I'll attest the 
registration — happens I was there at the time. But Dr. Minerva L. Weatheral is now off somewhere way the hell 
and gone out, doing research for her next magnum opus — can’t be reached for an interview. Ira, you and I will 
whip up biographical notes for my distinguished granddaughter. Got it?’ 

I simply answered Yes. 

“That suit you, girl?” 

“Yes indeed, Lazarus. Grandfather Lazarus.” 

“Don’t bother calling me ‘Grandfather.’ But I want the number-one presentation copy inscribed to me, 
dear — 'To my Grandfather Lazarus Long, with love, Minerva L. Weatheral.’ Is it a deal?” 

“I will be proud and happy to do so, Lazarus. An inscription should be in handwriting, should it not? I can 
modify the extensional I use to sign official papers for Ira — a mod so that the inscription handwriting will be 
different from his handwriting.” 

“Fine. If Ira behaves himself, you might consider dedicating the book to him and inscribe a copy to him. But / 
get the first copy. I’m senior — and I thought it up. But back to the search itself — I’m never going to read that 
twenty-volume opus, Minerva; I’m interested only in results. So tell me what you have so far.” 

“Lazarus, I have tentatively rejected over half the matrix as representing things the Archives show that you 
have done, or things that I assume that you would not wish to do — ’’ 



“Hold it! As the marine said, ‘If I haven’t done it, I'll try it.’ What are these things you assume I wouldn't want to 
try? Let’s hear 'em." 

“\fes, sir. One submatrix, three thousand six hundred fifty pockets, all involve a probably fatal outcome, 
probability ninety-nine percent plus. First, exploring in corpus the interior of a star — ’’ 

“Scratch that one, I’ll leave that to physicists. Besides, Lib and I did it once.” 

“The Archives did not show it, Lazarus.” 

“Lots of things not in the Archives. Go on." 

“Modification of your genetic pattern to grow an amphibious clone capable of living in ocean waters.” 

“I’m not sure I’m that interested in fish. What’s the catch?” 

“Three catches, Lazarus, each hazardous by less than ninety-nine percent but, when taken in series, total 
almost unity. Such pseudohuman amphibians have been grown, but the viable ones — thus far — strongly 
resemble very large frogs. The chances of survival of such a creature against other denizens of the deep 
— figured for Secundus — have been theoretically calculated as even for seventeen days, twenty-five percent for 
thirty-four days, and so on.” 

“I think I could improve those odds. But I never have cared much for Russian roulette. The other hazards?” 

“Installing your brain in the modified clone, then reinserting it into a normal clone at a later time. If you 
survived.” 

“Scratch that one. If I have to live underwater, I don’t want to be a frog; I want to be the biggest, meanest shark 
in the ocean. Besides, I figure that, if living underwater was all that interesting, we would still be there. Give me 
another sample.” 

“A triple sample, sir. Lost in n-space with a ship, without a ship but with a suit, and without even a suit.” 

“Scratch 'em all. I’ve come closer than I like to think to the first two, and the third is just a silly way to drown in 
vacuum. Thin and unpleasant. Minerva, the All Powerful in His Majestic Wisdom — whatever that means — made it 
possible for humans to die peacefully. That being so, unless one is forced to, it is silly to do it the hard way. So 
scratch drowning in caterpillars and self-immolation and all silly ways to die. Very well, dear; you’ve convinced 
me that you know what you’re talking about concerning those ninety-nine-plus hazards; scratch 'em all. Fm 
interested only in something new— new to me — in which the chances of surviving are better than fifty percent and 
in which a man who stays alert can enhance his chances. For example, I never hankered to go over high falls in a 
barrel. You can design the barrel to make it relatively safe; nevertheless, once you start, you are helpless. Which 
makes it a silly stunt — unless it’s the safest way out of a worse predicament. Racing — cars, steeplechase, skis 
— is more interesting because each calls for skill. Nfet I don’t fancy that sort of danger, either. Danger for the sake 
of danger is for children who don’t really believe they can be killed. Whereas I know lean be. So there are a lot of 
mountains I’ll never climb. Unless I’m trapped, in which case I'll do it — have done it! — the easiest, safest, most 
chicken way I can figure out. Don’t bother with anything in which the prime novelty is danger — danger is no 
novelty. It is simply something to be faced when you can’t run. How about other pigeonholes in your box?” 

“Lazarus, you could become female.” 

I do not think I have ever seen the Senior quite so startled (So was I, but the statement was not aimed at me.) 

He went on slowly, “Minerva, I’m not sure what you mean Surgeons have been turning inadequate males into 
fake females for more than two thousand years — and females into fake males almost as long. I’m not attracted 
by such stunts. For good — or bad — I am male. I suppose that every human has wondered how it would feel to be 
the other sex. But all the plastic surgery and hormone treatments possible won’t do it — those monsters don’t 
reproduce.” 

“lam not speaking of monsters, Lazarus. A true change in sex.” 

“Mmm — \bu remind me of a tale I had almost forgotten. Not sure it’s true. About a man, oh, must have been 
around 2000 A. D. Couldn’t be much later because things went to pieces not long after. Supposed to have had 
his brain moved into a female body. Killed him, of course. Alien tissue rejection.” 

“Lazarus, this would not involve that hazard; it would be done with your own clone.” 

“Not bloody likely. Keep talking." 

“Lazarus, this has been tested on animals other than H. sapiens. It works best in changing a male to a 
female. A single cell is selected for cloning. Before cloning is started, the Y chromosome is removed and an X 
chromosome from a second cell of the same zygote is supplied, thus creating a female cell of the same genetic 
pattern as the zygote save that the X chromosome is replicated while the Y chromosome is eliminated. The 
modified cell is then cloned. The result is a true female clone-zygote derived from a male original." 



“There must be a catch," Lazarus said, frowning. 

“There maybe, Lazarus. Certain it is that the basic technique works. There are several created females in 
the building you are in — dogs, cats, one sow, others — and most of them have littered successfully. ..except when, 
for example, a derived bitch is bred with the male dog who supplied the cell for cloning. That can produce lethals 
and mostrosities from the high probability of reinforcing bad recessives — ” 

“I should think it would!” 

“Yes. But normal outbreeding does not, as indicated by seventy-three generations of hamsters descended 
from one created female. The method has not been adapted to fauna native to Secundus because of their 
radically different genetic structure." 

“Never mind Secundus animals — how about men?” 

“Lazarus, I have been able to search the literature only on items released by the Rejuvenation Clinic. The 
published literature hints at problems in the last stage — activating the female clone-zygote with the memories 
and experiences — the ‘personality if you prefer that term — of the parent main. When to terminate the parent 
male — or whether to terminate it at all — suggests several problems. But I am unable to say what research has 
been suppressed.” 

Lazarus turned to me. “Do you permit that, Ira? Suppression of research?” 

“I don't interfere, Lazarus. But I didn’t know this research was going on. Let’s find out.” I turned to the 
Administrator for Rejuvenation, shifted to Galacta, and explained what we had been discussing and asked what 
progress had been made with humans. 

I turned back with my ears burning. As soon as I mentioned humans in this connection, she had interrupted 
me abruptly — as if I had said something offensive — and stated that such experimentation was proscribed. 

I translated her answer. Lazarus nodded. “I read the kid’s face; I could see the answer was No. Well, Minerva, 
that seems to be that I am not about to attempt chromosome surgery on myself — somebody swiped my 
jackknife.” 

“Perhaps that is not quite the end,” Minerva replied. “Ira, did you notice that Ishtar said only that such research 
was ‘proscribed’? She did not say that it had not taken place. I have just made a most thorough semantic 
analysis of the published literature for truth-and-falsity implications. I conclude that the probability approaches 
certainty that much pertinent research on humans has taken place even though it may no longer be going on. Do 
you wish to order it released, sir? I am certain that I can freeze their computer quickly enough to prevent erasure, 
assuming that an erasure program guards it.” 

“Let’s not do anything drastic,” drawled Lazarus. “There may be good reason for a ‘hold’ on this stuff. I’m 
forced to assume that these johnnies know more about it than I do. Besides, I’m not sure I want to be a guinea 
pig. Let’s put it on the back of the fire, Minerva. Ira, I’m not sure I would be me without my Y chromosome. To say 
nothing of those jolly hints of how you transfer the personality and at what point to kill off the male. Me, that is.” 

“Lazarus — ” 

“Yes, Minerva?” 

“The published literature makes one option both certain and safe. This method can be used to create your 
twin sister — identical rather than fraternal, save for sex. A host mother is indicated, with no forcing to maturity, 
since the brain would be allowed to develop normally. Would this meet your standards of newness and interest? 
To watch yourself grow up as a woman? ‘Lazuli Long,' you might name her — your female other self.” 

“Uh — ” Lazarus stopped. 

I said dryly, “Grandfather, I think I’ve won our second bet. Something new. Something interesting." 

“Now slow up! You can’t do it, you don’t know how. Nor do I. And the Director of this madhouse appears to 
have moral scruples about it — ” 

“We don’t know that. Mere inference.” 

“Not so ‘mere.’ And / may have moral scruples. ‘Twouldn’t interest me unless I stuck around and watched her 
grow up which might send me crazy either through trying to make her grow up just like me — what a fate for any 
girl! — or by trying to keep herfrom growing up as ornery as I am when that would be her nature. Nor would I be 
justified either way; she would be a separate human being, not my slave. Besides that, I would be her sole parent 
— no mother. I’ve had one crack at trying to raise a daughter alone — it’s not fair to the girl.” 

“\bu’re inventing objections, Lazarus. I’ll give long odds that Ishtar would gladly be both host mother and 
foster mother. Especially if you promised Ishtar a son of her own. Shall I ask her?’ 

“\bu keep your biscuit trap shut, Son! Minerva, place that on - ‘pending’ — I won’t be hurried into a major 



decision about another person. Especially one who isn’t, quite. Ira, remind me to tell you about the twins who 
were no relation to each other. But twins.” 

“Preposterous. You’re changing the subject.” 

“So I am. Minerva, what else do you have, girl?” 

“Lazarus, I have one program which involves low hazard and a probability approaching certainty of supplying 
one — or more — experiences completely new to you.” 

“I’m listening.” 

“Suspended animation — ” 

“What’s new about that? We had that when I was a kid, hardly two hundred years old. Used it in the ‘New 
Frontiers.’ Didn’t attract me then, doesn’t now.” 

“ — as a means of time travel. If you stipulate that in X number of years, something truly new will develop — a 
certainty based on history — then your only problem is to select whatever span of years will, in your opinion, 
produce the degree of novelty you seek. One hundred years, one thousand, ten thousand, whatever you say. The 
rest involves nothing but minor design details." 

“Not so ‘minor’ if I’m going to be asleep and unable to protect myself.” 

“But you need not go into hibernation until you are satisfied with my design, Lazarus. A hundred years is 
obviously no problem. A thousand years is not much problem. For ten thousand years I would design an artificial 
planetoid equipped with fail-safes to insure that you would be revived automatically in case of emergency.” 

“That would take quite some designing, girl.” 

“I feel confident of my capacity to do it, Lazarus, but you are free to criticize and reject any part of it. However, 
there is no point in my submitting preliminary designs until you give me the controlling parameter, namely the 
time span, which in your opinion will produce something new to you. Or do you wish my advice on that?” 

“Uh, hold your horses, dear. Let’s assume that you’ve got me in liquid helium and in free fall and thoroughly 
protected against ionizing radiation — ” 

“No problem, Lazarus.” 

“So I stipulated, dear; Fm not underrating you. But suppose some tiny little fail-safe fails null instead and I go 
on snoozing through the centuries — and millennia — without end. Not dead. But not revived, either.” 

“I can and will design to avoid that. But let me accept your stipulation. In such case, how would you be worse 
off than you would be if you used your termination-option switch? What do you lose by trying this?” 

“Why, that’s obvious! If there is anything to this immortality talk — or any sort of afterlife — I’m not saying there is 
or isn’t — but if there is, then when the ‘Roll Is Called Up Yonder,’ I won’t be there. I’ll be asleep but not dead, 
somewhere off in space. I'll miss the last boat.” 

“Grandfather,” I said impatiently, “quit trying to wiggle out. If you don’t want it, just say No. But Minerva has cer 
tainly offered you a way to reach something new. If there is anything to your argument — which I don’t admit — you 
will have achieved something really unique: the only human being out of many billions to fail to show up for 
muster on this hypothetical-and-highly-unlikely Judgment Day. I wouldn’t put it past you, you old scoundrel; you’re 
slippery.” 

He ignored my slur. “Why ‘highly unlikely’?” 

“Because it is. I won’t argue it.” 

“Because you can’t argue it,” he retorted. “There isn’t any evidence for or against — so how can you assign 
even a loose probability either way? I was pointing out the desirability, if there happens to be anything to it, of 
playing it kosher. Minerva, hold that under ‘pending,’ too. The idea has everything you claim for it, and I don't 
doubt your ability as- a designer. But, like testing a parachute, it’s a one-way trip with no chance to change my 
mind after I jump. So we’ll look over all other ideas before falling back on that one — even if it takes years.” 

“I will continue, Lazarus." 

“Thanks, Minerva.” Lazarus looked thoughtful as he picked his teeth with a thumbnail — we were eating, but I 
have not mentioned breaks for refreshment, nor will I again. You may assume any food and rest breaks that 
make you feel comfortable. Like Scheherazade’s tales, the Senior’s anecdotes were chopped up by many 
irrelevant interruptions. 

“Lazarus — ” 

“Eh, Son? I was daydreaming... of a far country and the wench is dead. Sorry.” 

“\bu could help Minerva in this search.” 

“So? Seems unlikely. She’s better equipped to conduct a needle-in-a-haystack search than I am — she 



impresses me." 

“Yes. But she needs data. There are these great gaps in what we know about you. If we knew — if Minerva 
knew — those fifty-odd professions you’ve followed, she might be able to cancel several thousand possibility 
pockets. For example, have you ever been a farmer?” 

“Several times.” 

“So? Now that she knows that, she won’t suggest anything relating to agriculture. While there may be sorts of 
farming you have never done, none would be novel enough to meet your stringent requirements. Why not list the 
things you have done?” 

“Doubt if I can remember them all.” 

“That can’t be helped. But listing what you do remember may call to mind others.” 

“Uh.Jet me think. One thing I always did every time I reached an inhabited planet was to study law. Not to 
practice — not usually, although fora number of years I was a very criminal lawyer — on San Andreas, that was. 

But to understand the ground rules. Hard to show a profit — or to conceal one — if you don’t know how the game is 
played. It’s much safer to break a law knowingly than to do so through ignorance. 

“But that backfired once and I wound up as High Justice of a planetary Supreme Court — just in time to save 
my bacon. And neck. 

“Let me see. Farmer, and lawyer, and judge, and I told you I had practiced medicine. Skipper of many sorts of 
craft, mostly for exploration but sometimes for cargo or migrant transport — and once an armed privateer with a 
crew of rogues you wouldn’t take home to mother. Schoolteacher — lost that job when they caught me teaching 
the kids the raw truth, a capital offense anywhere in the Galaxy. In the slave trade once but from underneath — J 
was a slave.” 

I blinked at that. “I can’t imagine it.” 

“Unfortunately I didn’t have to imagine it. Priest — ” 

I had to interrupt again. “Priest’? Lazarus, you said, or implied, that you had no religious faith of any sort.” 

“Did I? But ‘faith’ is for the congregation, Ira; it handicaps a priest. Professor in a parlor house — ” 

“Excuse me again. Idiomatic usage?” 

“Eh? Manager of a bordello... although I did play the pianette a little, and sang. Don’t laugh; I had a pretty 
good singing voice then. This was on Mars — you’ve heard of Mars?” 

“Next planet out from Old Home Terra. Sol Four.” 

“Yes. Not a planet we'd bother with today. But this was before Andy Libby changed things. It was even before 
China destroyed Europe but after America dropped out of the spacing business, which left me stranded. I left 
Earth after that meeting of 201 2 and didn’t go back for a spell — which saved me much unpleasantness, I 
shouldn’t complain. If that meeting had gone the other way — No, I’m wrong; when a fruit is ripe, it will fall, and the 
United States was rotten ripe. Don’t ever become a pessimist, Ira; a pessimist is correct oftener than an 
optimist, but an optimist has more fun — and neither can stop the march of events. 

“But we were speaking of Mars and the job I had there. A fill-in job for coffee and cakes — but pleasant, I was 
also the bouncer. The girls were all nice girls, and it was a pleasure to throw out some slob who was 
misbehaving toward them. Throw him so hard he bounced. Then blacklist him so he couldn’t come back. One or 
two like that every evening and the word got around that ‘Happy’ Daze demanded gentlemanly behavior toward 
the ladies, no matter how big a spender a man was. 

Whoring is like military service, Ira — okay in the upper brackets, not so good lower down. These girls were 
constantly getting offers to buy up their contracts and get married — and all of them did get married, I think, but 
they were making money so fast that they weren’t anxious to grab the first offer. Mainly because, when I took 
over, I put a stop to the fixed price the governor of the colony had set, and reinstated the Law of Supply and 
Demand. There was no reason why those kids shouldn’t charge every ruble the traffic would bear. 

“Had trouble over that until the Governor’s Provost for Rest and Culture got it through his thick head that slave 
wages won’t work in a scarcity situation. Mars was unpleasant enough without trying to cheat those few who 
made it tolerable. Or even delightful when they were happy in their work. Whores perform the same function as 
priests, Ira, but far more thoroughly. 

“Let me see — I’ve been wealthy many times and always lost it, usually through governments inflating the 
money, or confiscating — ’nationalizing’ or ‘liberating’ — something I owned. ‘Put not your faith in princes,’ Ira; 
since they don’t produce, they always steal. I’ve been broke even oftener than I’ve been wealthy. Of the two, 
being broke is more interesting, as a man who doesn’t know where his next meal is coming from is never bored. 
He may be angrv or several other things — but not bored. His predicament sharpens his thoughts, spurs him into 



action, adds zest to his life, whether he knows it or not. Can trap him, of course; that’s why food is the usual bait 
for traps. But that’s the intriguing part about being broke: howto solve it without being trapped. A hungry man 
tends to lose his judgment — a man who has missed seven meals is often ready to kill — rarely a solution. 

“Advertising copywriter, actor — but I was very broke that time — acolyte, construction engineer and several 
other sorts, and even more sorts of mechanic, for I’ve always believed that an intelligent man can turn his hand to 
anything if he will take time to learn how it works. Not that I insisted on skilled work when my next meal was at 
stake; I’ve often pushed an idiot stick — ’’ 

“Idiom?” 

“An old gandy-dancer expression, Son, a stick with a shovel blade on one end and an idiot on the other. I was 
never that for more than a few days, just long enough to sort out the local setup. Political manager — I was even a 
reform politician once... but only once: Reform politicians not only tend to be dishonest but stupidly dishonest 
— whereas the business politician is honest.” 

“I don't see that Lazarus. History seems to show — ”. 

“Use your head, Ira. I don’t mean that a business politician won’t steal; stealing is his business. But all 
politicians are nonproductive. The only commodity any politician has to offer is jawbone. His personal integrity 
— meaning, if he gives his word, can you rely on it? A successful business politician knows this and guards his 
reputation for sticking by his commitments — because he wants to stay in business — go on stealing, that is — not 
only this week but next year and years after that. So if he’s smart enough to be successful at this very exacting 
trade, he can have the morals of a snapping turtle, but he performs in such a way as not to jeopardize the only 
thing he has to sell, his reputation for keeping promises. 

“But a reform politician has no such lodestone. His devotion is to the welfare of all the people — an 
abstraction of very high order and therefore capable of endless definitions. Ifindeed it can be defined in 
meaningful terms. In consequence your utterly sincere and incorruptible reform politician is capable of breaking 
his word three times before breakfast — not from personal dishonesty, as he sincerely regrets the necessity and 
will tell you so — but from unswerving devotion to his ideal. 

“All it takes to get him to break his word is for someone to get his ear and convince him that it is necessary 
for the greater good of all the peepul. He’ll geek. 

“After he gets hardened to this, he’s capable of cheating at solitaire. Fortunately he rarely stays in office long 
— except during the decay and fall of a culture.” 

I said, “I must take your word for it, Lazarus. Since I have spent most of my life on Secundus, I know little of 
politics other than theoretically. You set it up that way.” 

The Senior fixed me with a stare of cold scorn. “I did no such thing." 

“But—" 

“Oh, hush. \bu are a politician yourself — a ‘business’ politician, I hope — but that stunt of transporting your 
dissidents gives me doubts. Minerva! ‘Notebook,’ dear. My intention in deeding Secundus to the Foundation 
was to set up a cheap and simple government — a constitutional tyranny. One in which the government was 
forbidden to do most things and the dear people, bless their black flabby little hearts, were given no voice at all. 

“I didn’t have much hope for it. Man is a political animal, Ira. Ntru can, no more keep him from politicking than 
you can keep him from copulating — and probably shouldn’t try. But I was young then, and hopeful. I hoped to 
keep politicking in the private sphere, keep it out of government. I thought the setup might last a century or so; I’m 
amazed that it has lasted as long as it has. Not good. This planet is overripe for revolution — and if Minerva 
doesn’t find me something better to do, I might show up under another name, with my hair dyed and my nose 
bobbed, and start one. So be warned, Ira.” 

I shrugged. “Ntru forget I’m migrating.” 

“Ah, yes. Though the prospect, of suppressing a, revolution might change your mind. Or perhaps you would 
like to be my chief of staff — then displace me with a coup d’etat after the shooting is over and send me to the 
guillotine. That would be something new — I’ve never tended to lose my head over politics. Doesn’t leave much 
for an encore, does it? ‘Atisket, a tasket, a head in a basket — it cannot reply to questions you ask it.’ Final 
curtain, no bows. 

“But revolutions can be fun. Did I tell you how I worked my way through college? Operating a Gatling gun for 
five dollars a day and loot. Never got higher than corporal because each time I had enough money for another 
semester, I deserted — and, being a mercenary, I was never tempted to become a dead hero. But adventure and 
change of scene are appealing to a young man... and I was very young.* (* The Gatling gun (Richard J. Gatling, 



1818-1903) was obsolete by the time Lazarus Long was born. This allegation is barely possible if one stipulates 
that an obsolete might be used in some small, out-of-the-way insurrection. J.F.45 th ) 

“But dirt, and missing meals, and the Wieet of bullets past your ears stop being glamorous as you grow up; 
the next time I was in the military — not entirely my idea — I chose Navy instead. Wet Navy, although I was space 
Navy at later times and under other names. 

“I’ve sold almost everything — except slaves — and worked as a mind-reader in a traveling show, and was a 
king once — a much overrated profession, the hours are too long — and designed women’s styles under a phony 
French name and accent and with my hair long. Almost the only time I’ve worn long hair, Ira; not only does long 
hair need a lot of timewasting care, it gives your opponent something to grab in close combat and can obscure 
your view at a critical moment — either one can be fatal. But I don’t favor a billiard-ball cut because a thick mat of 
hair — not so long as to fall over your eyes — can save you a nasty scalp wound.” 

Lazarus appeared to stop to think. “Ira, I don't see how I can list all the things I’ve done to support myself and 
my wives and kids, even if I could remember them. The longest I ever stuck to one job was about half a century 
— very special circumstances — and the shortest was from after breakfast to just before lunch — again, special 
circumstance. But no matter where or what, there are makers, takers, and fakers. I prefer the first category but I 
haven’t spurned the other two. Whenever I was a family man — usually, that is — I haven’t let compunctions stop 
me from keeping food on the table. I won’t steal another child’s food to feed my own — but there is always some 
way not too sickeninglyfake to garner valuta if a man isn’t too picky — which I never was whenever I had family 
obligations. 

“\bu can sell things which have no intrinsic value, such as stories or songs — I've worked every branch of the 
entertainment profession... including a time in the capital of Fatima when I squatted in the marketplace with a 
brass bowl in front of me, telling a story longer than this one, and waiting at cliff-hangers for the clink of a coin. 

“I was reduced to that because my ship had been confiscated and foreigners weren't permitted to work 
without a permit — a high squeeze on the theory that jobs should be reserved for local citizens, there being a 
depression. Telling stories without a fee wasn't classed as work, nor was it begging — which required a license 
— and cops let me alone as long as I volunteered the customary daily gift to the Police Benevolent Fund. 

“It was either get by with some such dodge or be reduced to stealing — difficult in a culture in which one is not 
sophisticated in the local customs. Still, I would have risked it save that I had a wife and three small children-. 
That hobbled me, Ira; a family man should not take risks that a bachelor finds acceptable. 

“So I sat there till my tailbone wore through the cobblestones, recounting everything from Grimm’s fairytales 
to, Shakespeare’s plays, and not letting my wife spend money on anything but food until we saved enough to buy 
that work permit plus the customary cumshaw. Then I clobbered ‘em, Ira.” 

“How, Lazarus?" 

“Slowly but thoroughly. Those months in the marketplace had given me a degree of sophistication in the 
‘Who’s-Whom’ of that society and what its sacred cows were. Then I stayed on for years — no choice. But first I 
was baptised into the local religion, gaining a more acceptable name in the process, and memorized the 
Qur’an. Not quite the same Qur’an I had known some centuries earlier, but it was worth the effort. 

“I’ll skip over how I got into the Tinkers’ Guild and got my first job repairing television receivers — had my pay 
docked to cover my contribution to the guild, that is, with a private arrangement to the Grand Master Tinker, not 
too expensive. This society was retarded in technology; its customs didn’t encourage progress, and they had 
slipped behind what they had fetched from Earth about five centuries earlier. That made me a wizard, Ira, and 
could have got me hanged bad I not been careful to be a faithful — and openhanded — son of the church. So once 
I got into position for it, I peddled fresh electronics and stale astrology — using knowledge they didn’t have for one 
and a free imagination for the other. 

“Eventually I was chief stooge to the very official who had confiscated my ship and trade goods years earlier, 
and I was helping him get richer while getting rich myself. If he recognized me, he never said so — a beard 
changes my looks quite a lot. Unfortunately he fell into disfavor and I wound up with his job.” 

“How did you work that, Lazarus? Without being caught, I mean?” 

“Now, now, Ira! He was my benefactor. It said so in my contract and I always addressed him as such. Allah’s 
ways are mysterious. I cast a horoscope for him, warning him that his stars were in bad shape. And so they 
were. That system is one of the few I know of with two usable planets around the same star, both colonized and 
with trade between them. Artifacts and slaves — ” 

“‘Slaves,’ Lazarus? While I am aware of such a practice on Supreme, I didn’t think that vice was very 



common. Not economic.” 

The old man closed his eyes, kept them closed so long I thought he had fallen asleep (he often did during the 
early days of these talks). Then he opened them and spoke very grimly: 

“Ira, this vice is far more common than historians usually mention. Uneconomic, yes — a slave society can’t 
compete with a free one. But with the Galaxy as wide as it is, there is usually no such competition. Slavery can 
and does exist many times and places, whenever the Laws are rigged to permit it. 

“I said that I would do almost anything to support my wives and kids — and I have; I have shoveled human 
excrement for a pittance, standing in it up to my knees, rather than let a child go hungry. But this I will not touch. 
Nor is it because I was once a slave myself; I have always felt this way. Call it a ‘belief or dignify it as a deep 
moral conviction. Whatever it is, for me it is beyond argument. If the human animal has any value at all, he is too 
valuable to be property. If he has any inner dignity, he is much too proud to own other, men. I don't give a damn 
how scrubbed and perfumed he may be, a slaveowner is subhuman. 

“But this does not mean that I’ll cut my throat when I run into it, or I would not have lived through my first 
century. For there is another bad thing about slavery, Ira; it is impossible to free slaves, they have to free 
themselves.” 

Lazarus scowled. “\t>u’ve got me preaching again and about matters I can't possibly prove. Once I got my 
hands on my ship, I had it fumigated and checked it over myself and had it loaded with items I thought I could sell 
and had food and water taken on for the human cargo it had been refitted for, and sent the captain and crew on a 
week’s leave, and notified the Protector of Servants — the state slave factor, that is — that we would load as soon 
as the skipper and purser were back. 

“Then I took my family on a holiday inspection of the ship. Somehow the Protector of Servants was 
suspicious; he insisted on touring the ship with us. So we had to take him along when we took off from there, 
very suddenly, shortly after my family was aboard. Right out of that system and never went back. But before we 
put down on a civilized planet, me and. my boys — two almost grown by then — removed any sign that she had 
ever been a slaver, even though it mean jettisoning stuff I could have sold.” 

“What about the Protector of Servants?” I asked. “Wasn’t he some trouble to you?” 

“Wondered if you would notice that. I spaced the bastard! Alive. He went thataway, eyes popped out and 
peeing blood. What did you expect me to do? Kiss him?” 



COUNTERPOINT 


III 


Once they reached the privacy of a transport Galahad said to Ishtar, “Were you serious in your proposal to 
the Senior? To have progeny by him?” 

“How could I be joking? — in the presence of two witnesses, one of them the Chairman Pro Tern himself.” 

“I didn’t see how you could be. But why Ishtar?” 

“Because I’m a sentimental atavist!” 

“Do you have to snap at me?” 

She put an arm around his shoulders, took his hand with her free hand. “I’m sorry, dear. It has been a long day 
and not much sleep last night, sweet as it was. I’m worried about several things — and the subject you brought up 
is not one I can be unemotional about.” 

“I should not have asked. An invasion of privacy — I don’t know what’s got into me. Shall we wipe the matter? 
Please?” 

“Dear, dear! I do know what got into me. ..and that’s part of why I am so unprofessionally emotional. Let me 
put it this way: If you were female, wouldn’t you jump at a chance to make such a proposal? To him?” 

“I’m not female.” 

“I know you’re not, you’re delightfully male. But try for a moment to be as logical as a female. Try!” 

“Males are not necessarily illogical; that’s a female myth.” 

“Sorry. I must take a tranquilizer the minute we are home — something I haven’t needed in years. But do try to 
think about it as if you were female. Please? Twenty seconds.” 

“I don't need twenty seconds.” He lifted her hand, kissed it. “If I were female, I would jump at the chance, too. 
The best proved genetic pattern one can offer a child? Of course.” 

“Not that at all!” 

He blinked. “Perhaps I don't know what you mean by logic.” 

“Uh. . .does it matter? Since we arrived at the same answer?” The car swerved and stopped in a loading 
pocket; she stood up. “So let’s wipe it. We’re home, dear.” 

“\bu are. I’m not. I think — ’’ 

“Men don’t think.” 

“I think you need a night’s rest, Ishtar.” 

“\bu sealed this onto me; now you'll have to undress me.” 

“So? Then you’ll insist on feeding me and you won’t get that long night of sleep after all. Besides, you can 
peel it over your head, just the way I did it for you at decontam.” 

She sighed. “Galahad — if I picked the right name for you — do I have to offer you a cohabitation contract 
merely because I might invite you to stay overnight again? It’s likely that neither of us will get any sleep tonight.” 

“That’s what I was saying.” 

“Not quite. Because we may work all night. Even if you choose to spend three minutes to our mutual pleasure. 

“Three minutes’? I wasn’t that hasty even the first time." 

“Well — Five minutes?’ 

“Am I offered twenty minutes — plus an apology?’ 

“Men! Thirty minutes, darling, and no apology.” 

“Accepted.” He stood up. 

“Five of which you’ve wasted arguing about it. So come along — exasperating darling.” 

He followed her out into her foyer. “What’s this about ‘work all night’?” 

“And tomorrow, too. I'll know when I check what’s in my phone. If there’s nothing, I’ll have to call the Chairman 
Pro Tern, much as I hate to. I’ve got to look over this rooftop cabin or whatever it is, and see, what arrangements 
can be made to take care of him there. Then both of us will move him; I can’t delegate that. Then — ” 

“Ishtar! Are you going to agree to that? Nonsterile habitat, no emergency equipment, and so forth?” 

“Darling ... you are impressed by my rank; Mr. Weatheral is not. And the Senior isn’t even impressed by Mr. 



Weatheral’s authority; the Senior is the Senior. I kept hoping that Mr. Chairman Pro Tem would find some way to 
wheedle him into postponing such a move. But he did not. So now I have two choices: Do it his way — or 
withdraw completely. As the Director did. Which I won’t do. Which leaves me no choice. So tonight I'll inspect his 
new quarters and see what can be done between now and tomorrow midmorning. Even though it’s hopeless to 
make such a place sterile, perhaps it can be made more nearly suitable before he sees it.” 

“And emergency equipment, don’t forget that, Ishtar.” 

“As if I would, stupid darling. Now help me out of this damned thing — I mean ‘this pretty dress you designed 
for me and which the Senior clearly liked.’ Please?” 

“So stand still and hold still and shut up.” 

“Don’t tickle! Oh, that, there’s the phone signal! Get it off me, dear — hurry!” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
IV 


Love 


Lazarus lounged in his hammock and scratched his chest. 

“Hamadryad,” he said, “that’s not an easy question. At seventeen I was certain I was in love. But it was merely 
excess hormones and self-delusion. It was most of a thousand years later before I experienced the real thing 
— and didn’t recognize the condition for years, as I had quit using that word.” 

Ira Weatheral’s “pretty daughter” looked puzzled, while Lazarus thought again that Ira had been wrong: 
Hamadryad was not pretty; she was so startling beautiful that she would have fetched top premium prices at 
auction on Fatima, with hard-eyed Iskandrian factors outbidding each other in the belief that she was a sound 
speculation. If the Protector of the Faith had not preempted her for himself — Hamadryad did not seem to know 
that her appearance was exceptional. But Ishtar did. The first ten days that Ira’s daughter had been part of 
Lazarus’ “family” (so he thought of them — a good enough term as Ira, Hamadryad, Ishtar, and Galahad were all 
his descendants and now privileged to call him “Grandfather” as long as they did not overdo it) — those first days 
Ishtar had shown a childish tendency to try to place herself between Hamadryad and Lazarus, and also between 
Hamadryad and Galahad, even when this required being two places at once. 

Lazarus had watched this barnyard dance with amusement and had wondered if Ishtar knew that she was 
doing it. Probably not, he decided. His rejuvenation supervisor was all duty and no sense of humor and would 
have been shocked had she known that she had reverted to adolescence. 

But it did not last. It was impossible not to like Hamadryad because she remained quietly friendly no matter 
what. Lazarus wondered if it was a behavior pattern consciously developed to protect herself against her less- 
endowed sisters — or was it simply her nature? He had not tried to find out. But Ishtar now tended to sit by 
Hamadryad, or even to make room between herself and Galahad for Hamadryad, and let her help in serving 
meals and such — assistant “housewife” de facto. 

“If I must wait a thousand years to understand that word,” Hamadryad replied, “then I probably never will. 
Minerva says that it cannot be defined in Galacta and even when I speak Classic English, I find that I think in 
Galacta, which means that I do not really grasp English. Since the word ‘love’ occurs so frequently in ancient 
English literature, I thought my failure to understand that word might be the block that keeps me from thinking in 
English.” 

“Well, let’s shift to Galacta and take a swing at it. In the first place, very little thinking was ever done in 
English; it is not a language suited to logical thought. Instead, it’s an emotive lingo beautifully adapted to 
concealing fallacies. A rationalizing language, not a rational one. But most people who spoke English had no 
more idea of the meaning of the word ‘love’ than you have, even though they used it all the time.” 

Lazarus added, “Minerva! We’re going to take another hack at the word ‘love.’ Want to join in? If so, shift to 
your personal mode.” 

“Thank you, Lazarus. Hello, Ira-lshtar-Hamadryad-Galahad,” the disembodied contralto voice answered. “I am 
and have been in personal mode, and usually am, now that you have given me permission to use my judgment, 
"vbu’re looking well, Lazarus — younger every day.” 

“I feel younger. But, dear, when you go to personal mode, you should tell us.” 

“I’m sorry, Grandfather!" 

“Don’t sound so humble. Just say, ‘Howdy, I’m here,’ that's all. If you could manage to tell me, or Ira, just once, 
to go to hell, it ‘ud be good for you. Clean your circuits.” 

“But I have no wish to say that to either of you.” 

“That’s what’s wrong. If you hang around Dora, you’ll learn to. Have you spoken to her today?” 

“I’m speaking with Dora now, Lazarus. We’re playing fairy chess in five dimensions, and she’s teaching me 
songs you taught her. She teaches me a song, then I sing a tenor lead while she harmonizes in soprano. We’re 
doing this in real time because we’re outing through the speakers in your control room and listening to ourselves. 



Right now we’re singing the story of One-Ball Riley. Would you care to hear us?” 

Lazarus flinched. ‘‘No, no, not that one.” 

“We’ve practiced several others. ‘Rangy Lil’ and The Ballad of Yukon Jake’ and ‘Barnacle Bill’ — I sing the 
story on that one while Dora does soprano and bass. Or perhaps ‘Four Whores Came Down from Canada’ 

— that one is fun.” 

“No, Minerva. I’m sorry, Ira; my computer is corrupting your computer." Lazarus sighed. “I didn’t plan it that 
way; I just wanted Minerva to baby-sit for me. Since I’ve got the only retarded ship in this sector.” 

“Lazarus,” Minerva said reproachfully, “I don’t think it is correct to say that Dora is retarded. She’s quite 
intelligent, I think. I do not understand why you say that she is corrupting me.” 

Ira had been lying on the grass, sunbathing with a kerchief over his eyes. He rolled to one elbow. “Nor I, 
Lazarus. That last one I’d like to hear. I recall where Canada is-was. North of the country you were born in.” 

Lazarus counted silently, then said, “Ira, I know I have prejudices ridiculous to a civilized modern man such as 
yourself. I can’t help it; I’m canalized by early childhood, imprinted like a baby duckling. If you want to hear bawdy 
songs from a barbaric era, please listen to them in your apartments — not up here. Minerva, Dora doesn't 
understand those songs; to her they are nursery rhymes.” 

“Nor do I understand them, sir, other than theoretically. But they are jolly, and I have enjoyed being taught to 
sing.” 

“Well — All right. Has Dora been behaving herself otherwise?” 

“She’s been a good girl, Grandfather Lazarus, and I think she is contented with my company. She pouted a 
little at not having her bedtime story last night. But I told her that you were very tired and already asleep; and told 
her a story myself.” 

“But — Ishtar! Did I miss a day?” 

“Yes, sir.” 

“Surgery? I didn’t notice any new healed places.” 

The Master Chief Technician hesitated. “Grandfather, I will discuss procedures only if you insist. It does a 
client no good to be reminded of such things. I hope that you will not insist. I do hope so, sir.” 

“Urn. All right, all right. But next time you chop out a day — or a week, or whatever — warn me. So that I can 
leave a bedtime story on file with Minerva. No, that won’t do; you don’t want me to know. Okay, I’ll keep stories on 
file with Minerva and you warn her, instead.” 

“I will, Grandfather. It does help when the client cooperates, especially by paying as little attention to what we 
do as possible.” Ishtar smiled briefly. “The client we dread is another rejuvenator. Worries and tries to run things.” 

“Small wonder. I know, dear, I have that horrid habit of trying to run things myself. The only way I can keep from 
it is by staying out of the control room. So when I get too nosy, tell me to shut up. But how are we doing? How 
much longer do I have to go?” 

Ishtar answered hesitantly, “Perhaps this is a time when I should tell you to... ‘shut up.’” 

“That’s it! But firmer, dear. ‘Get out of my control room, you custard-headed dolt, and stay out! Make him 
realize that, if he doesn’t jump, you’ll toss him into the brig. Now try it again.” 

Ishtar grinned widely. “Grandfather, you’re an old fraud.” 

“So I’ve long suspected. I was hoping it didn’t show. All right, the subject is ‘love.’ Minerva, the Hamadarling 
says you told her that it can’t be defined in Galacta. Got anything to add to that?” 

“Tentatively yes, Lazarus. May I reserve my answer until the others speak?” 

“Suit yourself. Galahad, you talk less and listen more than anybody else in the family. Want to try it?” 

“Well, sir, I hadn’t realized that there was any mystery about ‘love’ until I heard Hamadryad ask about it. But 
I’m still learning English. By the naturalistic method the way a child learns his milk language. No grammar, no 
syntax, no dictionary — just listen and talk and read it. Acquire new words by context. By that method I acquired a 
feeling that ‘love’ means the shared ecstasy that can be attained through sex. Is that right?” 

“Son, I hate to say this — because, if you’ve been reading a lot of English, I see how you reached that opinion 
— but you are one hundred percent wrong.” 

Ishtar looked startled. Galahad simply looked thoughtful. “Then I must go back and read some more.” 

“Don’t bother, Galahad. Most of those writers you’ve been reading misuse the word just that way. Shucks, I 
misused it for years myself; it’s a prime example of the slipperiness of the English tongue. But, whatever ‘love’ is, 
it’s not sex. I’m not running down sex. If there is a purpose in life mere important than two people cooperating in 
making a baby, all the philosophers in history haven’t been able to find it. And between babies, the practice runs 



keep up our zest in life and make tolerable the fact that raising a baby is one hell of a lot of work. But that’s not 
love. Love is something that still goes on when you are not sexually excited. It being so stipulated, who wants to 
try it? Ira, how about you? Nt>u know English better than the others, you speak it almost as well as I do.” 

“I speak it better than you do, Gramp; I speak it grammatically, which you do not.” 

“Don’t praggle me, boy; I'll quang you proper. Shakespeare and I never let grammar interfere with expressing 
ourselves. Why, he said to me once — ” 

“Oh, stop it! He died three centuries before you were born.” 

“He did, huh? They opened his grave once and found it empty. The fact is, he was a half brother of Queen 
Elizabeth and dyed his hair to make the truth less obvious. The other fact is that they were closing in on him, so 
he switched. I’ve died that way several times. Ira, his will left his ‘second-best bed’ to his wife. Look up who got 
his best bed and you’ll begin to figure out what really happened. Do you want to try to define ‘love’?” 

“No. Nt>u would change the rules again. All you have done so far is to divide the field of experience called 
‘love’ into the same categories Minerva divided it into when you asked her this same question weeks ago 
— namely, ‘Eros’ and ‘Agape.’ But you avoided using those technical words for the subfields, and by this 
sophistry you attempted to exclude the general term from one subfield and thereby claimed that the term to be 
defined was limited to the other subfield — which set it up for you to define ‘love’ as identically equal to ‘Agape.’ 
But again without using that word. It won’t work, Lazarus. To use your own metaphor, I saw you palm that card.” 

Lazarus shook his head admiringly. “There are no flies on you, boy; I did a good job when I thought you up. 
Someday when we have time to waste, let’s have a go at solipsism.” 

“Come off, it, Lazarus. You can’t bulldoze me the way you did Galahad. The subcategories are still ‘Eros’ and 
‘Agape.’ ‘Agape’ is rare; ‘Eros’ is so common that it is almost inevitable that Galahad acquired the feeling that 
‘Eros’ is the total meaning ofthe word ‘love.’ Now you have unfairly confused him since he assumes — incorrectly 
— that you are a reliable authority with respect to the English language.” 

Lazarus chuckled “Ira, m’boy, when I was a kid, they sold that stuff by the wagonload to grow alfalfa. Those 
technical words were thought up by armchair experts ofthe same sort as theologians. Which gives them the 
same standing as sex manuals written by celibate priests. Son; I avoided those fancy categories because they 
are useless, incorrect, and misleading. There can be sex without love, and love without sex, and situations so 
intermixed that nobody can sort out which is which. But love can be defined, an exact definition that does not 
resort to the word ‘sex,’ or to question begging by exclusion through the use of such words as ‘Eros’ and 
‘Agape.’” 

“So define it,” said Ira. “I promise not to laugh.” 

“Not yet. The trouble with defining in words anything as basic as love is that the definition can’t be understood 
by anyone who has not experienced it. It’s like the ancient dilemma of explaining a rainbow to a person blind 
from birth. Yes, Ishtar, I know that you can fit such a person with cloned eyes today — but that dilemma was 
inescapable in my youth. In those days one could teach such an unfortunate all the physical theory of the 
electromagnetic spectrum, tell him precisely what frequencies the ‘human eye can pick up, define colors to him 
in terms of those frequencies, explain exactly how the mechanisms of refraction and reflection produce a 
rainbow image and what its shape is and how the frequencies are distributed until he knew ail about rainbows in 
the scientific sense... but you still couldn’t make him feel the breathless wonder that the sight of a rainbow 
inspires in a man. Minerva is better off than that man, because she can see. Minerva dear, do you ever look at 
rainbows?” 

“Whenever possible, Lazarus. Whenever one of my sensor extensionals can see one. Fascinating!” 

“That’s it. Minerva can see a rainbow, a blind man can’t. Electromagnetic theory is irrelevant to the 
experience.” 

“Lazarus,” Minerva added, “it maybe that I can see a rainbow better than a flesh-and-blood can. My visual 
range is three octaves, fifteen hundred to twelve thousand angstroms.” 

Lazarus whistled. “Whereas I chop off just short of one octave. Tell me girl, do you see chords in those 
colors?” 

“Oh, certainly!” 

“Hmm! Don’t try to explain to me those other colors; I'll have to go on being half blind.” 

Lazarus added, “Puts me in mind of a blind man I knew on Mars, Ira, when I was managing that, uh, recreation 
center. He — ” 

“Gramp,” the Chairman Pro Tern interrupted m a tired voice, “don’t treat us as children. Surely, you’re the 



oldest man alive... but the youngest person here — that offspring of mine sitting there, making cow-eyes at you 
— is as old as Gramp Johnson was when you last saw him; Hamadryad will be eighty her next birthday. Ham, my 
darling, how many paramours have you had?” 

“Goodness, Ira — who counts?” 

“Ever taken money for it?” 

“None of your business, Father. Or were you about to offer me some?” 

“Don’t be flip, dear; I’m still your father. Lazarus, do you think you can shock Hamadryad by plain talk? 
Prostitution isn’t big business here; there are too many amateurs as willing as she is. Nevertheless, the few 
bordellos we have in New Rome are members of the Chamber of Commerce. But you should try one of our 
better holiday houses — say, the Elysium. After you are fully rejuvenated.” 

“Good idea,” agreed Galahad. “To celebrate. As soon as Ishtar gives you your final physical check. As my 
guest, Grandfather; I’d be honored. The Elysium has everything, from massage and hypnotic conditioning to the 
best gourmet food and best shows. Or name it and they’ll supply it.” 

“Wait a moment,” protested Hamadryad. “Don’t be a selfish arsfardel, Galahad. We’ll make it a foursome 
celebration — Ishtar?” 

“Certainly, dear. Fun.” 

“Or a sixsome, with a companion for Ira. Father?” 

“I could be tempted, dear, for Lazarus’ birthday party — although you know I usually avoid public places. How 
many rejuvenations, Lazarus? That’s how we count this sort of birthday party.” 

“Don’t be nosy, Bub. As your daughter says: ‘Who counts?’ Wouldn’t mind a birthday cake, such as I used to 
have as a child. But just one candle in the middle is enough.” 

“A phallic symbol,” agreed Galahad. “An ancient fertility sign — appropriate for a rejuvenation. And its flame is 
an equally ancient symbol of life. It should be a working candle, not a fake. If we can find one.” 

Ishtar looked happy. “Of course! There must be a candlemaker somewhere: If not, I’ll learn how and make it 
myself. I'll design it, too — semirealistic but somewhat stylized. Although I could make it true portraiture, 
Grandfather; I’m a fair amateur sculptor, I learned it when I studied cosmetic surgery." 

“Wait a. minute!” Lazarus protested. “All I want is a plain wax candle — then blow it out and make a wish. 
Thank you, Ishtar, but don’t bother. And thanks, Galahad, but I'll pick up the tab — although it may be a family party 
right, here, where Ira won’t feel like, a duck in a shooting gallery. Look, kids, I’ve seen every possible type of joy 
house and pleasure dome. Happiness is in the heart, not in that stuff.” 

“Lazarus, can’t you see that the kids v\ant to treat you to a fancy party? They like you — though Prime Cause 
alone knows why.” 

“Well—” 

“But there might be no tab. I think I recall something from that list appended to your will. Minerva — who owns 
the Elysium?” 

“It is a daughter corporation of Service Enterprises of New Rome, Limited, which in turn is owned by 
Sheffield-Libby Associates. In short, Lazarus owns it.” 

“Be damned! Who invested my money in that? Andy Libby, bless his sweet shy soul, would be spinning in his 
grave — if I hadn’t placed him spinning in orbit around the last planet we discovered together, where he was 
killed." 

“Lazarus, that’s not in your memoirs.” 

“Ira, I keep telling you, lots of things not in my memoirs. Poor little guy got to thinking one of his deep thoughts 
and didn’t stay alert. I put him in orbit because I promised him, when he was dying, to take him back to his native 
Ozarks. Tried to, about a hundred years later, but couldn’t find him. Beacon dead, I suppose. All right, kids, we’ll 
have a party at my happy house and you can sample anything the place has to offer. Where were we? Ira, you 
were about to define ‘love.’” 

“No, you were about to tell us about a blind man on Mars, when you were managing that whorehouse.” 

“Ira, you’re as crude as Gramp Johnson was. This guy ‘Noisy’ — don’t recall his right name, if he had one 
— Noisy was one of those people like yourself who just will work, regardless. A blind man could get by in those 
days quite well by begging, and nobody thought the less of him, since there was no way then to restore a man's 
sight. 

“But ‘Noisy wasn’t content to live off other people; he worked at what he could do. Played a squeeze box and 
sang. That was an instrument operated by bellows which forced air over reeds as you touched keys on it — quite 



pretty music. They were popular until electronics pushed most mechanical music makers off the market. 

“Noisy showed up one night, skinned out of his pressure suit at the lock dressing room, and was playing and 
singing before I knew he was inside. 

“My policy was Trade, Treat, or Travel’ — except that the house might buy a beer for an old customer who 
temporarily wasn’t holding. But Noisy was not, a customer; he was a bum — looked and smelled like a bum, and I 
was about to give him the bum’s rush. Then I saw this rag around his eyes and skidded to a stop. 

“Nobody throws out a blind man. Nobody makes any trouble for him. I kept an eye on him but left him alone. 
He didn’t even sit down. Just played this broken-down stomach-Steinway and sang, neither very well, and I laid 
off the pianette not to interrupt him. One of the girls started passing the hat for him. 

“When he reached my table, I invited him to sit and bought him a beer — and regretted it; he was pretty whiff. 
He thanked me and told me about himself. Lies, mostly.” 

“Like yours, Gramp?” 

“Thanks, Ira. Said he had been chief engineer in one of the big Harriman liners, until his accident. Maybe he 
had been a spaceman; I never caught him out in the lingo. Not that I tried. If a blind man wanted to claim he was 
the rightful heir to the Holy Roman Empire, I would go along with the gag — anybody would. Perhaps he was 
some sort of space-going mechanic, shipfitter or something. More likely he was a transported miner who had 
been careless using powder. 

“When I checked the place at closing time, I found him sleeping in the kitchen. Couldn’t have that, we ran a 
sanitary mess. So I led him to a vacant room and put him to bed, intending to give him breakfast and ease him 
gently on his way — I wasn’t running a flophouse. 

“A lot I had to say about it. I saw him at breakfast all right. But I hardly recognized him. A couple of the girls 
had given him a bath, trimmed his hair, and shaved him, and had dressed him in clean clothes — mine — and had 
thrown away the dirty rag he had worn over his ruined eyes and had replaced it with a clean white bandage. 

“Kinfolk, I do not fight the weather. The girls were free to keep pets; I knew what fetched the customers, and it 
wasn’t my pianette playing. If that pet stood on two legs and ate more than I did, I still did not argue. Hormone 
Hall was Noisy’s home as long as the girls wanted to keep him. 

“But it took me a while to realize that Noisy was not just a parasite enjoying free room and board, and 
probably our stock-in-trade as well, while siphoning off cash from our customers — no, he was pulling his weight 
in the boat. My books at the end of the first month he was with us showed the gross profit up and the net way up." 

“How do you account for that, Lazarus? Inasmuch as he was competing for your customers’ cash.” 

“Ira, must I do all your thinking for you? No, Minerva does most of it. But it is possible that you have never 
thought about the economics of that sort of joint. There are three sources of gross, the bar, the kitchen, and the 
girls themselves. No drugs — drugs spoil the three main sources. If a customer was on drugs and showed it, or 
even broke out a stick of kish, I eased him out quickly and sent him down the line to the Chinaman’s. 

“The kitchen was to supply meals to the girls — who were assessed room and board on a break-even or lose- 
a-little basis. But it also served food all night to anyone who ordered it, and showed a net since we had its 
overhead covered anyhow to board the girls. The bar also showed a net after I fired one barkeep with three 
hands. The girls kept their gross, all the traffic would bear, but they paid the house a flat fee for each kewpie, or a 
triple fee if she kept a customer all night. She could cheat a little, and I would shut-eye — but if she cheated too 
much or too often, or a john complained that he was rolled, I had a talk with her. Never any real trouble; they were 
ladies, and besides, I had means to check on them quietly, as well as eyes in the back of my head. 

“The beefs about rolling were the stickiest, but I remember only one that was the girl’s fault rather than the 
john’s — I simply terminated her contract, let her go. In the usual beef the slob was not rolled; he simply had a 
change of heart after he had counted too much money into her greedy little hands and she had delivered what he 
had ordered — then Retried to roll her to get it back. But I could smell that sort of slob and would be listening via 
a mike — then would bust in as trouble started. That sort of jerk I would toss so hard he bounced twice.” 

“Grandfather, weren’t some of them pretty big for that?” 

“Not really, Galahad. Size doesn’t figure much in a fight — although I was always armed against real trouble. 
But if I have to take a man, I have no compunctions slowing me down about how I take him. If you kick a man in 
the crotch with no warning, it will quiet him down long enough to throw him out. 

“Don’t flinch, Hamadear; your father guaranteed that you could not be shocked. But I was talking about Noisy 
and how he made us money while making some himself. 

“In this sort of frontier joint the usual customer comes in, buys a drink while he looks over the girls, picks one 



by buying her a drink — goes to her room, then leaves. Elapsed time, thirty minutes; net to the house, minimum. 

“Pre-Noisy, that is. After Noisy arrived, it went more like this: Buy a drink as before. Maybe buy the girl a 
second drink rather than interrupt a blind man’s song. Take the girl to her room. When he comes back, Noisy is 
singing ‘Frankie and Johnnie’ or ‘When the Pusher Met My Cousin,’ and smiles and throws a verse at him — and 
the customer sits down and listens to all of it — and asks Noisy if he knows ‘Dark Eyes.’ Sure, Noisy knows it, but 
instead of admitting it, he asks the john to give him the words and hum it and he’ll see what he can do with it. 

“If the customer has valuta, he’s still there hours later, having had supper and bought supper for one of the 
girls and tipped Noisy rather lavishly and is ready for an encore with the girl or another girl. If he’s got the money, 
he stays all night, splitting his cash between the girls and Noisy and the bar and kitchen. If he spends himself 
broke and has been a good customer — well behaved as well as free with his money — I stake him to bed and 
breakfast on credit, and urge him to come back. If he’s alive next payday, he’s sure to be back. If not, all the 
house is out is the wholesale cost of one breakfast — nothing compared with what he’s spent. Cheap goodwill 
advertising. 

“A month of that, and both the house and the girls have made much more money, and the girls haven't worked 
much harder as they have spent part of their time drinking pay-me drinks — colored water; half the price to the 
house, half to the girl — while they help a john listen to Noisy’s nostalgic songs. Shucks, a girl doesn’t want to 
work like a treadmill even if she usually enjoys her work as many of them did. But they never got tired of sitting 
and listening to Noisy’s songs. 

“I quit playing the pianette, except, maybe, while Noisy ate. Technically I was a better musician — but he had 
that undefinable quality that sells a song; he could make 'em cry or laugh. And he had a thousand of 'em. One he 
called The Born Loser.’ Not much of a tune, just: 

“7 ah tah poom poom! 

Tah tah poom poom! 

Tah ttah tah tah poom poom — 


“ — about a bloke who can never quite make it. Uh: 

“There’s a beer joint 
By the pool hall 

For to pass some pleasant hours. 

“There’s a hook shop 

Above the pool hall 

Where my sister makes her living. 

“She’s a good sport; 

I can spring her 

Fora fin or even a sawbuck 

When not holding, Or the horses 
Flave been running rather slowly — 

“Like that, folks. But more of it.” 

“Lazarus,” said Ira, “you have been humming or singing that song every, day you’ve been up here. All of it. A 
dozen verses or more.” 

“Really, Ira? I do hum and sing; I know that. But I don’t hear it myself.’ It’s like the purring of a cat; it just means 
that I’m functioning okay, board all green, operating at normal cruising. It means that I feel secure, relaxed, and 
happy — and, come to think of it, I do. 

“But The Born Loser' doesn't have a mere dozen verses, it has hundreds. What I sang was only a snatch of 
what Noisy used to sing. He was always fiddling with a song, changing it, adding to it. I don’t think this one 



started out as his; I seem to remember a song about a character whose overcoat was usually in hock clear back 
when I was very young and raising my first family, on Earth. 

“But that song belonged to Noisy when he got through filing off serial numbers and changing the body lines. I 
heard it again, oh, must have been twenty, twenty-five years later, in a cabaret in Luna City. From Noisy. But he 
had changed it. Fixed up the scansion, given it a proper rhyme scheme, dolled up the tune. But the tune was still 
recognizable — in a minor key, wistful rather than sad, and the words were still about this third-rate grifter whose 
topcoat was always in hock and who sponged off his sister. 

“And he had changed, too. A shiny new instrument, a tailored spaceman’s uniform, gray hair at the temples 
— and star billing. I paid a waiter to tell him that ‘Happy’ Daze was in the audience-not my name then, but the only 
name Noisy had for me — and after his first group he came over and let me buy him a drink while we swapped 
lies and talked about our happy days at dear old Hormone Hall. 

“I didn’t mention to him that he had left us rather abruptly and that the girls had gone into a decline over it, 
worrying that he might be dead in a ditch — didn’t mention it because he did not. But I had had to investigate his 
disappearance because my staff was so demoralized by it that the place felt like a morgue — no way for a parlor 
house to be. I was able to establish that he had gone aboard the ‘Gyrfalcon’ when she was about to lift for Luna 
City and had not left her — so I told the girls that Noisy had had a sudden opportunity to go home again but had 
left a message with the port captain for each of them — then added more lies to personalize the goodbye he 
hadn’t made. It perked them up and lifted the gloom. They still missed him, but they all understood that grabbing 
a ride home was not something he could postpone-and since he had ‘remembered’ to send a message to each 
of them, they felt appreciated. 

“But it turned out that he did remember them, mentioned each by name. Minerva dear, here is a difference 
between a blinded flesh-and -blood and one who has never been able to see. Noisy could see a rainbow any 
time he cared to, by memory. He never stopped ‘seeing,’ but what he ‘saw’ was always beauty. I had realized 
that, some, back when we were on Mars together, for — don't laugh — he thought I was as pretty as you are, 
Galahad. Told me that he could tell what I looked like from my voice, and described me to me. I had the grace to 
say that he flattered me but let it lie when he answered that I was too modest — even though I’m not handsome 
now and wasn’t then and modesty has never been one of my vices. 

“But Noisy thought all the girls were beautiful, too — and in one case this may have been true and certainly 
several of them were pretty. 

“But he asked me what had become of Olga and added, ‘Golly, what a little beauty she was!’ 

“Kinfolk, Olga wasn’t even homely, she was ugly. Face like a mud pie, figure like a gunnysack — only on an 
outpost like Mars could she get by. What she did have was, a warm and gentle voice and a sweet personality 
— which was enough, as a customer might pick her through Hobson’s choice on a busy night, but once he had 
done so, he picked her some later time on purpose. Mean to say, dears; beauty will lure a man into bed, but it 
won’t bring him back a second time, unless he’s awfully young or very stupid.” 

“What does bring him back a second time, Grandfather?” asked Hamadryad. “Technique? Muscular control?” 

“Have you had any complaints, dear?” 

“Well... no.” 

“Then you know the answer and are truing with me. Neither of those. It’s the ability to make a man happy, prin 
ci pally by being happy about it yourself — a spiritual quality rather than a physical one. Olga had it in gobs. 

“I told Noisy that Olga had married shortly after he left, happily so, and had three children last I had heard 
...which was an utter lie, as she had been killed accidentally and the girls bawled about it and I didn’t feel good 
myself and we had shut the place down for four days. But I couldn’t tell Noisy that; Olga had been one of the first 
to mother him, had helped bathe him and had stolen some of my clothes for him while I slept. 

“But they all mothered him and never fought over him. I have not deviated from our subject in this rambling 
account of Noisy; we’re still defining ‘love.’ Anybody want to take whack at it now?” 

Galahad said, “Noisy loved everyone ofthem. That’s what you’ve been saying.” 

“No, Son, he didn’t love any ofthem. Fond ofthem, yes — but he left them without looking back.” 

“Then you are saying that they loved him.” 

“Correct. Once you figure out the difference between what he felt toward them and what they felt toward him, 
we’re almost home.” 

“Mother love,” said Ira, and added gruffly, “Lazarus, are you trying to tell us that ‘mother love’ is the only love 
there is? Man, you’re out of your mind!” 



“Probably. But not that far out. I said they mothered him; I did not say a word about ‘mother love.’ “ 

“Uh...he bedded all of them?” 

“Wouldn’t be surprised, Ira. I never tried to find out. Irrelevant in any case.” 

Hamadryad said to her father, “Ira, ‘mother love’ can’t be what we’re trying to define; it is often only a sense of 
duty. Two of my brats I was tempted to drown, as you may have guessed seeing what little demons they were.” 

“Daughter, all your offspring were charming children.” 

“Oh, fuff. One has to give a baby mothering no matter what, or it will grow up to be a still worse monster. What 
did you think of my son Gordon as a baby?” 

“A delightful child.” 

“Really? I’ll tell him that — if I ever have a male child I name ‘Gordon.’ Sorry, old darling, I shouldn’t have 
trapped you. Lazarus, Ira is a perfect grandfather, one who never forgets a birthday. But I’ve suspected that 
Minerva kept track of such things for him and now I know it. Right, Minerva?” 

Minerva did not answer. Lazarus said, “She’s not working for you, Hamadryad." 

Ira said sharply “Of course Minerva keeps track of such things for me! Minerva, how many grandchildren do I 
have?” 

“One hundred and twenty-seven, Ira, counting the boy child to be born next week." 

“How many great-grandchildren? And who is having the boy?” 

“Four hundred and three, sir. Your son Gordon's current wife Marian.” 

“Keep me posted on it. That was the baby Gordon I was thinking of, Miss Smarty; Gordon’s son Gordon... uh, 
by Evelyn Hedrick, I think. Lazarus, I deceived you. The truth is that I am migrating because my descendants are 
crowding me off this globe.” 

“Father, are you really going to? Not just talking?” 

“Still top Secret until after the decennial Trustees Meeting, dear. But I am. Want to come along? Galahad and 
Ishtar have decided to go; they’ll set up a rejuve shop for the colony. You’ll have five to ten years in which to learn 
something useful.” 

“Grandfather, are you going?” 

“Unlikely to the nth degree, my dear. I’ve seen a colony.” 

“\bu may change your mind." Hamadryad stood up, faced Lazarus. “I propose to you, in the presence of three 
witnesses — four; Minerva is the best possible witness — a contract for cohabitation and progeny, term to be 
selected by you.” Ishtar looked startled, then wiped all expression from her face; the others said nothing. 

Lazarus answered, “Granddaughter, if I weren’t so old and tired, I would spank you.” 

“Lazarus, I am your granddaughter only by courtesy; you are less than eight percent of my total ancestry. Less 
than that in terms of dominant genes, with a vanishingly small probability of, unfavorable reinforcement; the bad 
recessives have been weeded. I'll send my genetic pattern over for your inspection.” 

“That’s not the point, dear.” 

“Lazarus, I’m certain you’ve married your descendants in the past; is there some reason to discriminate 
against me? If you’ll tell me, perhaps I can correct it. I must add that this submittal is not contingent on your 
migrating.” Hamadryad added, “Or it could be for progeny only although I would be proud and happy to be 
permitted to live with you.” 

“Why, Hamadryad?” 

She hesitated. “I am at loss to answer, sir. I had thought that I could say, ‘I love you’ — but apparently I do not 
know what that word means. So I have no word in either language to describe my need... and went ahead 
without one.” 

Lazarus said gently “I love you, dear — ” 

Hamadryad’s face lit up. 

He continued: “ — and for that very reason I must refuse you.” Lazarus looked around him. “I love all of you. 
Ishtar, Galahad. . .even that ugly, surly father of yours, dear, sitting there and looking worried. Now smile, dear, for 
I’m certain that there are endless young bucks anxious to marry you. Nfciu smile, too, Ishtar — but not you, Ira; it 
would crack your face. Ishtar, who is relieving you and Galahad? No, I don't care who is scheduled. May I be 
alone the rest of today?” 

She hesitated. “Grandfather, may I keep the observation station manned?” 

“\bu will anyhow. But will you limit them to dials and gauges or whatever it is you use? No eye or ear on me? 
Minerva will tell you if I misbehave — I’m certain of that.” 



“There will be neither eye nor ear on you, sir.” Ishtar stood up. “Come along, Galahad. Hamadryad?” 

“Just a moment, Ish. Lazarus — have I offended you?” 

“What? Not at all, my dear.” 

“I thought you were angry with me over... what I proposed." 

“Oh, nonsense. Hamadarling, that sort of proposal never offends anyone; it is the highest compliment one 
human can pay another. But it did confuse me. Now smile and kiss me good-night, then come see me tomorrow 
if you wish. All you kids kiss me good-night; there’s nobody sore at anybody. Ira, you might stick around a bit if 
you will.” 

Like docile children they did so, then went into Lazarus’ penthouse and took transport down. Lazarus said, “A 
drink, Ira?” 

“Only if you are having one.” 

“We’ll skip it then. Ira, did you put her up to it?’ 

“Eh?” 

“>bu know what I mean. Hamadryad. First Ishtar, now Hamadryad. You've manipulated this whole deal from 
the moment you snatched me out of that flophouse, where I was dying decently and quietly. Have you again been 
trying to tie me down to whatever scheme you have in the back of your mind by waving pretty tails under my 
nose? It won’t work, man.” 

The Chairman Pro Tern answered quietly, “I could deny that — and for the hundredth time have you call me a 
liar. I suggest that you ask Minerva." 

“I wonder if that would be any assurance. Minerva!” 

“Yes, Lazarus?” 

“Did he rig this? With either of the girls?” 

“Not to my knowledge, Lazarus.” 

“Is that an evasion, dear?” 

“Lazarus, I cannot lie to you.” 

“Well... I think you could if Ira wanted you to, but there is no point in my inquiring into it. Give us privacy for a 
few moments, dear — recording mode only.” 

“Yes, Lazarus.” 

Lazarus went on, “Ira, I wish you had answered Yes. Because the only other explantation is one I d not like. I 
ain’t pretty and my manners are not such as to endear me to women — so what do we have left? The fact that I 
am the oldest man alive. Women sell themselves for odd reasons and not always for money. Ira, I do not choose 
to stand at stud for pretty young things who would not waste a moment on me save for the prestige of having a 
child by, quote, The Senior, end of quote.” He glared. “Right?” 

“Lazarus, you are being unjust to both women. As well as unusually obtuse.” 

“How?” 

“I’ve watched them. I think they both love you — and don’t give me any double-talk about what that verb means; 

I am not Galahad.” 

“But — Oh, crap!” 

“I won’t argue on that basis; ‘crap’ is a subject in which you are the Galaxy’s top authority. Women do not 
always sell themselves and they do fall in love. . .often for the oddest reasons — if ‘reason’ is a word that can 
apply. Granted that you are ugly selfish, self-centered, surly — ” 

“I’m aware of it!” 

“ — to me. Nevertheless women don’t seem to care much how a man looks... and you are surprisingly gentle 
with women. I’ve noticed. You say those little whores on Mars all loved that blind man.” 

“Some of them weren’t little. Big Anna was taller than I am and weighed more.” 

“Don’t try to change the subject. Why did they love him? Don’t bother to answer; why a woman loves a man 
— or a man loves a woman — can be rationalized only in survival terms, and the answer has no flavor, 
unsatisfying. But — Lazarus, when you’ve completed rejuvenation and you and I have finished our Scheherazade 
bet, however we finish it — are you going away again?” 

Lazarus brooded before answering: “I suppose so. Ira, this cottage and garden and stream — that you’ve lent 
me are very nice; the times I’ve gone down to the city I’ve hurried back, glad to be home. But it’s just a resting 
place; I won’t stay here. When the wild goose cries, I go.” Lazarus looked sad. “But I don’t know where and I don’t 
want to repeat the things I’ve done. Perhaps Minerva will find that new thing for me, when it’s time to move on.” 



Ira stood up. “Lazarus, if you, weren’t so stinking suspicious and mean, you would give both women the 
benefit of the doubt and leave them each with child to remember you by. It wouldn’t cost you much effort.” 

“Out of the question! I do not abandon children. Or pregnant women." 

“Excuses. I will adopt, in the womb, any child you sire before you leave us. Shall I have Minerva place that in 
permanent and bind it?” 

“I can support my own kids! Always have." 

“Minerva. Transfer it and bind it.” 

“Completed, Ira.” 

“Thank you, best Little Nag. Same time tomorrow, Lazarus?” 

“I suppose so. Nfes. Call Hamadryad, will you, and ask her to come, too? — tell her I asked you to. I don’t want 
the kid’s feelings hurt.” 

“Sure, Gramp.” 



COUNTERPOINT 

IV 


On the level in the Executive Palace of Mr. Weatheral’s private apartments Hamadryad waited with Galahad 
while Ishtar left orders for the rejuvenation technicians on watch there. Then the three took transport down and 
across, still inside the Palace, to an apartment Ira had placed at Ishtar’s disposal — a dwelling larger and more 
lavish than her quarters in the Rejuvenation Clinic and much more luxurious than the penthouse cottage save that 
it had no garden; it was intended fora Trustee or other V.I.P. guest — not that its luxury mattered much, as Ishtar 
and Galahad spent most of their time and took most of their meals with Lazarus, and used it mainly for sleeping. 

Minerva had placed a dozen-odd lesser accommodations with Ishtar for her watch list, one of them for 
Galahad. He did not need it and Ishtar had Minerva reassign it to Hamadryad when she had become an 
unofficial part of the team caring for the Senior. Hamadryad sometimes slept in it rather than go to her country 
home — without telling her father, as the Chairman Pro Tern did not encourage members of his family to use 
Palace quarters unnecessarily. Or she sometimes stayed with Ishtar and Galahad. 

This time all three went to Ishtar’s apartment; they had matters to discuss. On arrival there Ishtar checked: 

“Minerva?” 

“Listening, Ishtar.” 

“Anything?” 

“Lazarus and Ira are talking. Private conversation.” 

“Keep me advised, dear.” 

“Certainly, dear.” 

Ishtar turned back to the others. “Who wants a drink or something? Too early for dinner. Or is it? Ham?” 

Galahad answered, “A bath for me, then a drink. I was all set for a dip — hot and sweaty — when Lazarus 
kicked us out.” 

“And stinky,” Ishtar agreed. “I noticed it in the transport.” 

“A bath wouldn't hurt you, big arse; you were exercising as hard as I was.” 

“Regrettably true, my gallant knight; I Was careful to sit downwind from our elders after that last match. Ham, 
get us all something tall and cold while Stinky and I get clean.” 

“Will you two settle for Idleberry Jolts or whatever is handy? While we all bathe? I don’t have the excuse of 
heavy exercise, but I broke out with fear stink when I put the proposal to Gramp. And muffed it! After all your 
coaching, Ish. I’m sorry!” She started to sniffle. 

Ishtar put her arms around the younger woman. “There, there, dear — stop it. I don’t think you muffed it.” 

“He refused me.” 

“>bu laid a good foundation — and shook him up, which he needed. Nt>u startled me with your timing but it will 
work out all right.” 

“He probably won't, even let me come back!” 

“\fes, he will. Stop shaking. Come, dear; Galahad and I will give you a long, relaxing back rub. Stinky, fetch the 
fizz and join us in the shower room.” 

“With two women around I have to work. Okay.” 

When Galahad arrived with cold drinks, Ishtar had Hamadryad stretched out facedown on the massage table. 
Ishtar looked up and said, “Dear, before you get wet, see if there are three towel robes in the rack; I didn’t check. 

“Yes, ma’am; no, ma’am; right away, ma’am; will that be all, ma’am? — plenty of robes; I dialed for more this 
morning. Don’t bruise her, you don’t know your own strength. I’m going to need her, later.” 

“And I’m going to swap you for a dog, sweetheart, and sell the dog. Pass around those drinks, then come 
help, or you won’t get either of us later. If ever. We’re busy agreeing that all males are beasts.” She continued to 
massage, gently, firmly, with professional skill, down Hamadryad’s back while the massage table matched her 
appropriately down the subject’s front. She let Galahad hang a drink around her neck and place its nipple in her 
mouth without slowing her careful fingers. 



He snapped Hamadlyad’s drink to the table, placed nipple in her mouth, patted her cheek, then took the other 
side and started to help, following Ishtar’s lead. The table changed action to match four hands. 

Some minutes later he let the nipple for his drink retract, and spoke. “Ish, any chance that Gramp twigged? 
About you two broads?” 

“We’re not all that broad. At least, Ham is not.” 

“‘Broad’ is a usual English idiom for a female, and you said we should talk and think in English as long as we 
are on this commitment.” 

“I simply said that Hamadryad is not very broad. Even though she’s had more children than I have — and I 
haven’t had any since rejuvenation. But it’s a colorful idiom; I like it. I don’t see how Lazarus could, guess that we 
are pregnant. Not that it would matter if he did; in my case — except just howl am pregnant, and he can’t know 
that as I fudged the record on the source of the cloned cell. Ham, you haven’t hinted anything to Lazarus — have 
you?’ 

Hamadryad surrendered her drink. “Of course not!" 

“Minerva knows,” Galahad said. 

“Of course she does, I discussed it with her. But — Now you’ve got me wondering. Minerva?” 

“Listening, Ishtar.” The computer added, “Ira is leaving; Lazarus has come inside. No problems.” 

“Thank you, dear. Minerva, is there any possible way that Lazarus could know about Hamadryad and me? 
That we are pregnant, I mean, and why and how.” 

“He has not said so, nor has anyone mentioned it in his presence. Evaluation of pertinent data available to 
me makes it probable by less than one part in one thousand.” 

“How about Ira?” 

“Less than one part in ten thousand. Ishtar, when Ira told me to supply you with service and to assign to you a 
restricted memory, he programmed me so that any later program will simply wipe your assigned box. Truly, there 
is no way for him to retrieve from your private memory file, nor can I self-program to get around it.” 

“Yes, so you assured me. But I don’t know much about computers, Minerva.” 

Minerva chuckled. “Whereas I do. You could say that I have made a career of computers. Don’t worry, dear, 
your secrets are safe with me. Lazarus has just told me to order a light supper for him; then he is going to bed.” 

“Good. Let me know what he eats and how much and when he goes to bed — then call me if he wakes. 

Awake and alone at night, a man is at his lowest ebb; I must be ready to move quickly. But you know that.” 

“I shall watch his wave patterns, Ishtar. You will have two to five minutes’ warning — unless El Diablo jumps on 
his stomach.” 

“That damned cat. But being wakened that way doesn’t depress him; it’s his suicidal nightmares that worry 
me. I have about used up diversionary emergencies; I can’t set fire to the penthouse a second time.” 

“Lazarus has not had one of his typical depression nightmares this month, Ishtar, and I know how to spot the 
wave sequences now; I'll be very careful.” 

“I know you will, dear. I wish we knew the incidents in his past from which each is derived; we might be able to 
wipe them.” 

“Ish,” Galahad put in, “you go tinkering with his memory and you might lose everything Ira is after.” 

“And I might save our client, too. You stick to back-rubbing, dear, and leave delicate work to Minerva and me. 
Anything more, Minerva?" 

“No. Nfes. Ira is telling me to find Hamadryad; he wants to talk to her. Will she take the call?” 

“Sure!” agreed Hamadryad, rolling over. “But patch him in through you, Minerva; I won’t go to the phone, I 
don’t have my face on.” 

“Hamadryad?” 

“Yes, Ira?” 

“Message for you. Be nice to an old man and show up at the cottage as usual, will you? Better yet, get there 
early and have breakfast with him.” 

“Are you sure he wants to see me?” 

“He does. He shouldn’t, after the way you embarrassed him. What possessed you, Ham? But this message 
is his idea, not mine. He wants to be sure he hasn't scared you off.” 

She sighed with relief. “I’m not scared off if he will let me stay. Father, I told you I would devote, as many days 
to this as he will permit. I meant it and still mean it. In fact I’ve told my manager that she can buy me out on long- 
term credit; that’s how serious I am.” 



“So? I’m very pleased. If you do, and want to cash out, I — the government, that is — will pick up the loan from 
you without discounting it; I’ve assigned unlimited credit to anything relating to the Senior. Just tell Minerva.” 

“Thank you, sir. I don’t expect to need it — unless Gramp gets tired of me and I see something else I want to 
invest in. 

But the business is prosperous; I may just let Priscilla support me in style for a few years. Quite prosperous 
— betcha my assets exceed yours. Nfciur private fortune, I mean.” 

“Don’t be silly, my silly daughter; as a private citizen I’m almost a pauper — whereas in my official capacity I 
could confiscate your assets with just a word to Minerva and no one would question it.” 

“Except that you never would — you’re sweet, Ira.” 

“Huh?” 

“>bu are... even if you can't remember the names of my children. I’m feeling very gay, Papa, you’ve made me 
happy.” 

“\bu haven’t called me ‘Papa’ for, oh, fifty or sixty years.” 

“Because you never encourage intimacy once a child is grown. Nor do I from mine. But this assignment has 
made me feel closer to you. I’ll shut up, sir, and I'll be there early tomorrow. Off?” 

“One moment. I forgot to ask where you are. If you’re home — ” 

“I’m not; I'm having a bath with Galahad and Ishtar. About to, that is; you interrupted a wonderful back rub they 
were giving me.” 

“Sorry. As you are still in the Palace, I suggest that you stay. To be here early tomorrow. Beg a bed from them 
Or, if that is intruding, come to my apartments; we’ll find something.” 

“Don’t fret about me, Ira. If I can’t shame them into keeping me overnight, Minerva will find me a bed. Truly 
Lazarus’ bed is the only one I’ve ever found impossible to get into — maybe I need to apply for rejuve.” 

The Chairman Pro Tern was slow in answering. “Hamadryad... you were serious in proposing to have 
children by him — were you not?” 

“Privacy sir.” 

“Sorry. Hmm — The custom of privacy does not forbid me to say that / think it is a very good idea. If you tell 
me to, I will encourage it in any way I can.” 

Hamadryad looked at Ishtar and spread her hands in a gesture of “What do I do now?” — then answered: “His 
refusal seemed very firm, sir.” 

“Let me offer you a male viewpoint, my daughter. A man often refuses such a proposal when he wants to 
accept it — a man likes to be sure of a woman's motives and sincerity. At a later time he may accept. I don’t 
mean that you should nag him with it; that would not work. But if you want this bide your time. "vfou’re a charming 
woman; I have confidence in you." 

“Yes, sir. If he does give me a child, we would all be richer thereby — would we not?” 

“Yes, certainly. But my motives are somewhat different. If he dies or leaves us, there is always the sperm bank 
and the tissue bank — neither of which he can touch because I’ll cheat if necessary. But I don’t want him to die, 
Hamadryad, nor do I want him to leave soon — and I am not, speaking from sentiment. The Senior is unique; I’ve 
gone to much trouble not to waste him. \bur presence pleases him, your offer stimulates him. . .even though you 
feel he reacted badly. Nfou’re helping to keep him alive-and if he eventually lets you have his child, you may 
succeed in keeping him alive a long time. Indefinitely long." 

Hamadryad wiggled with pleasure and smiled at Ishtar. “Father, you make me feel proud.” 

“\bu have always been a daughter to be proud of, dear. Although I can’t claim all the credit; your mother is a 
most exceptional woman. Off now?” 

“Off, with music playing. Good night, sir!” 

Without getting up, Hamadryad grabbed both her friends around their waists and hugged them tightly. “Oh, I 
feel good!” 

“So get down off this table, narrow broad; it’s my turn.” 

“>bu don’t need a massage,” Ishtar said firmly; “you’ve been under no emotional strain and the hardest work 
you’ve done all day is to beat me two games of murder ball.” 

“But I’m the spiritual type. Sensitive.” 

“So you are, dear Galahad, and now you can most spiritually help her down and help me bathe her — still most 
spiritually.” 



Galahad complied while complaining “You two ought, to bathe me, instead. Pretend I’m a blind music maker.” 
He closed his eyes and sang: 

‘“There’s a cop around the corner 
who is sometimes not so friendly. 

To a man whoisn’t holding 
Or otherwise unlucky — 

“That’s me — 'unlucky — or I wouldn’t have to work with two women in the house. What cycle, Ish?” 

“‘Relaxing’ of course. Hamadear, since you let us hear that call, I assume that I can talk about it. I agree with 
Ira. \bu have Lazarus sexually stimulated whether he knows it or not, and if you can keep him that way, he won’t 
be depressed.” 

“Is he truly that nearly recovered, Ishtar?” Hamadryad asked while raising her arms and “He looks better. But I 
can’t tell — his manner doesn’t change.” 

“Oh, definitely. He started masturbating a month ago. Shampoo, dear?” 

“He did? Really? Oh, that’s wonderful! Do I need one? Yes, I do — thanks.” 

‘So it’s well to 
Have a sister 
Or even an old uncle — 

“Close your eyes, Hambone baby; shampoo mix coming. A client has no privacy with Ishtar. But she didn’t tell 
me; I had to infer it from his graphs. Ish, why do I always wind up washing Ham’s back?” 

“Because you tickle, sweetheart. There was no need for you to know. But a client certainly has no privacy with 
Minerva to help — and that’s as it should be; we need better computer service at the Clinic, I now see. Although 
he does have privacy in its true sense, as all of this is covered by the Oath. Even though you are not regular staff, 
Ham, I’m sure you realize that.” 

“Oh, certainly! Not quite so hard, Galahad. Red-hot pincers could not make me talk other than to you two. Not 
even to Ira. Ishtar, do , you think I could learn to be a real rejuvenator?” 

“If you feel a vocation for it and want to study that hard. Let it rinse now, Galahad. Nt>u have the empathy, I’m 
sure. What’s your index?” 

“They’re your friends, boy. 

Don’t neglect them 
Birthdays and Yom Kippur — 

“Uh... ‘Genius-minus, ’ “ Hamadryad admitted. 

“Takes genius,” Galahad said helpfully, “as well as a compulsive need to work; she’s a slave driver, Hammy 
baby.” 

“‘Also Christmas And Chanukah 
A card or even candy. ” 

“\bu’re off key, dear. \bu’re ‘Genius-plus,’ Ham, slightly higher than Galahad’s index. I looked it up just in 
case — and you did ask. I’m very pleased.” 

“‘Off key ? Now you’ve gone too far.” 

“\bu have other virtues, my true knight; you need not be a troubadour. Hamadear, if you search your heart and 
really want it, you could be an associate technician by the time we migrate. If you intend to migrate. If not, the 
Clinic here always needs staff; a true vocation is scarce. But I’d like — terribly — to have you with us. Both of us will 
help you.” 

“Sure we will, Hammy! ‘Off key’ indeed! Is this colony going to be polygamous?” 

“Ask Ira. Does it matter? Grab a robe and throw it around the Hamadarling, then I'll trade a quick scrub with 
you. I’m hungry.” 



“Do you want to risk it? After what you said about my singing? I know every spot and I’ll tickle them all.” 

“King’s Cross! I apologize! I love your singing, dear.” 

“The idiom is ‘King’s X,’ Ish. Pax, it is. Grab robes for all of us, Hammy, that’s a good girl. Long legs, while I 
was singing — perfectly on key — I figured out that idiom that was bothering me. It’s not what Minerva thought it 
was; a ‘hook shop’ is a bordello. Which makes the Born Loser’s sister a hetaera — and the last piece falls into 
place.” 

“Why, of course! No wonder she could subsidize her brother — artists always get paid more than anyone else. 

Hamadryad returned with robes, laid them on the massage table. She said, “I didn't know that idiom was 
bothering you, Galahad. I understood it the first time I heard that song.” 

“I wish you had told me.” 

“Is it important’?” 

“Only as one more clue. Ham, in analyzing a culture, its myths and folk songs and idioms and aphorisms are 
more basic than its formal history. \fou can’t understand a person unless you understand her culture. ‘His,’ I 
should say, in speaking English — and that alone tells something basic about the culture in which our client grew 
up: the fact that a general term invariably takes the masculine form when both masculine and feminine are 
implied. It means either that males are dominant or that women have just emerged from lower status, but the 
language lag — there always is one — has not caught up with cultural change. The latter, in the barbarism Lazarus 
came from, as indicated by other clues.” 

“\bu can tell all that just from a rule of grammar?” 

“Sometimes. Hammy, I used to do this professionally, when I was old and grizzled and waiting for 
rejuvenation. It’s detective work and no one clue is ever enough. For, example, women must not have reached 
equal status even though other clues show them gaining it — for whoever heard of a bordello managed by a 
man? A guard in one, yes, and Lazarus said that he was that, too. But manager? Preposterous, by modern 
standards. Unless that colony on Mars was an atypical retrogression — it may have been, I don’t know.” 

“Continue it as we eat, kids; Mama is hungry.” 

“Coming, Ish dear. Galahad, I understood that idiom without thinking about it. Nt>u see, my mother was — still is 
— a hetaera.” 

“Really? There’s a wild coincidence. So was mine, and so was Ishtar’s — and we three wind up all in 
rejuvenation work and on the same client. Two numerically small professions — I wonder what the odds are 
against it?” 

“Not too high, as both professions require strong empathy. But if you want to know, ask Minerva,” advised 
Ishtar, “and hand me that robe. I don’t like blowdry and I don’t want to get chilled while rustling food. Hamasweet, 
why didn’t you follow your mother’s profession? With your beauty you would be a star.” 

Hamadryad shrugged. “Oh, I know what I look like. But Mother can snatch a man away from me just by lifting 
her little finger — except that I avoid the chance. Beauty has little to do with it — you saw a man turn me down just 
today. Lazarus’ himself told us what it takes to make a great artist — a spiritual quality a man can feel. My mother 
has it. I don’t.” 

“I follow your reasoning,” Ishtar said as they went through her lounge into the buttery. There she screened the 
menu offered by the kitchen down below. “My mother has it, too. Not especially pretty, but what she has, men 
want. Still want, although she’s retired.” 

“Long Legs,” Galahad said soberly, “you do all right. \bu’ve got it too.” 

“Thank you, my knight, but that’s not true. I sometimes have it for one man. Or two at most. And sometimes 
not at all, as I can get buried in our profession and forget about sex. I told you how many years I had been 
celibate, I wouldn’t have found you, dear, would never have risked ‘Seven Hours’ — had not our client had me so 
terribly emotional. Quite unprofessionally, Hamadryad; I was as silly as a schoolgirl on a warm spring night. But, 
Galahad, Tamara — my mother — has it all the time and for anyone who needs her. Tamara never set a price, she 
didn’t need to; they showered gifts on her. She’s retired now and considering whether to rejuvenate again. But 
her fans won’t leave her alone; she still gets endless offers." 

Galahad said sorrowfully, “That’s what I would like to be. But I’m that ‘Born Loser.’ If a man tried that 
profession, he’d kill himself in a month.” 

“In your case, dear Galahad, it might take a little longer. But eat and restore your strength; we’re going to put 
you in the middle of the bed tonight.” 



“Does that mean I’m invited?” asked Hamadryad. 

“That’s one way of putting it. A more accurate statement would be that I’m inviting myself. Galahad made it 
clear in the shower that his plans for the night include you, dear. But he didn’t mention me.” 

“Oh, he did, too! Anyhow he’s horny about you all the time; I can feel it.” 

“He’s horny — end of message and off. Will steaks and random garnish do, or do you each wish to choose? I 
don’t feel imaginative.” 

“Suits me. Ish, you should put Galahad under contract. While he’s groggy.” 

“Privacy, dear.” 

“Sorry. I just blurted it out. Because I'm so fond of you both.” 

“Big-arsed bitch won’t marry me,” said Galahad. “And me so good and pure and modest. Claims I tickle, Will 
you marry me, little Hamadear?” 

“What? Galahad, you’re the world’s worst tease. \bu not only don't want me to; you know I’m committed to the 
Senior even though he refused me. Until Ish tells me to drop it. If she does.” 

Ishtar finished ordering, wiped the screen. “Galahad, don’t tease our baby. I want both Hamadryad and me to 
be free of other contracts as long as either of us has any chance of getting our client interested in cohabitation, 
or progeny or both. Not just a lark but something he can take seriously.” 

“So? Then why in the name of all the fertility gods did you arrange to have both of you pregnant at once? I 
don’t get it. I hear the whir, but the figures won't add.” 

“Because, my stupid darling, I didn’t dare wait. The Director may come back anytime." 

“But why you two? With maybe ten thousand healthy host-mothers registered and available? And why two?’’ 

“Dearest man, I’m sorry I said you were stupid — you aren’t; you’re just male. Hamadryad and I know exactly 
what risks we are taking and why. We don’t look pregnant and won’t for weeks yet, and if either of us can jockey 
Lazarus into a contract, an abortion takes ten minutes. Professional host-mothers won’t do for this job; it has to 
be bellies over which I have some control and women I trust utterly. Bad enough that I had to trust a gene surgeon 
and risk a proscribed procedure — Ira may have to get me out of that if anything slips. 

“But you know' as well as I do, sweet Galahad, that even an ordinary clone sometimes, goes wild. I wish I had 
four female bellies I could use, not two. Eight. Sixteen! Increase the chances of getting one normal fetus. In 
another month — long before it shows — we’ll know what we’re carrying. If the odds fail both of us — well, I’m ready 
to start over again and Hamadryad is, too.” 

“As many times as necessary, Ishtar. I swore it.” 

Ishtar patted her hand. “We’ll get a good one. Galahad, Lazarus is going to have his identical twin sister, I 
promise you — and once it is an accomplished fact, we’ll hear no more talk of termination-option switches, or 
leaving us, or anything — at least until she’s woman tall!" 

“Ishtar?” 

“Yes, Hamadryad?” 

“If we both show normal fetuses a month from now — ’’ 

“Then you can abort, dear; you know that.” 

“No, no, no! I shan’t! What’s wrong with twins?” 

Galahad blinked at her. “Don’t bother to answer, Ish. Let me give you the male angle. The man who can resist 
raising identical twin girls hasn’t been born. And his name isn’t Lazarus Long. Look, dears, is there anything, 
anything at all, that can improve both your chances? Now?” 

“No.” Ishtar repeated softly, “No. We both test pregnant, that’s all we can say or do now. Except pray. And I 
don’t know how to pray.” 

“Then it’s time we learned!” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
V 


Voices in the Dark 


After Minerva ordered his evening meal for Lazarus, then supervised its service, the computer said, “Is there 
anything else, sir?” 

“I guess not. Yes. Will you have dinner with me, Minerva?” 

“Thank you, Lazarus. I accept.” 

“Don’t thank me; you are doing me a favor, milady. I’m moody tonight. Sit down, dear, and cheer me up.” 

The computer’s voice repositioned so that it appeared to come from the other side of the table where 
Lazarus sat, as if a flesh-and-blood were seated there. “Shall I construct an image, Lazarus?” 

“Don’t put yourself to the trouble, dear.” 

“It’s no trouble, Lazarus; I have ample spare capacity.” 

“No, Minerva. That holo you made for me one night — perfect, realistic, moved just like a flesh-and-blood. But 
it wasn’t you. I know what you look like. Umm... lower the lights and spot enough light on my plate to let me eat. 
Then I’ll see you in the gloom without a holo.” 

The lighting readjusted so that the room was almost dark save for a pool of light on chastely perfect 
tableware and napery in front of Lazarus. The contrast dazzled his eyes enough that he could not see across the 
table without peering — he did not peer. Minerva said, “What is my appearance, Lazarus?” 

“Eh?” He stopped to think. “It fits your voice. Hmm, it’s a picture that has grown up in my mind without thinking 
about it, during the time we have been together. Dear, do you realize that we have been living together more 
intimately than husband and wife usually manage?” 

“Perhaps I don’t, Lazarus, since I cannot experience being a wife. But I am happy to be close to you.” 

“Being a wife doesn’t have too much to do with copulation, my dear. \bu’ve been a mother to my baby, Dora. 
Oh, I know that Ira stands first with you. . .but you are like that girl Olga I spoke of; you have so much to give that 
you can enrich more than one man. But I honor your loyalty to ha. \t>ur love for him, dear.” 

“Thank you, Lazarus. But — if I know what the word means — I love you, too. And Dora." 

“I know you do. Both. You and I have no need to worry over words; we’ll leave that to Hamadryad. Mmm, your 
appearance — you are tall, about as tall as Ishtar. But slender. Not skinny, just slender — strong and well muscled 
without being bulgy. \bu are not as broad in the hips as she is. But broad enough. Womanly. \bu’re young, but a 
mature young woman, not a girl. Breasts much smaller than Ishtar’s, more like Hamadryad’s. You are handsome 
rather than pretty, and you are rather solemn, except when one of your rare smiles lights up your face. Your hair is 
brown and straight, and you wear it long. But you don’t fuss with it other than to keep it clean and neat. Your eyes 
are brown and match your hair. \bu usually don’t wear cosmetics, but you almost always wear some sort of 
clothing — simple clothing; you are not a clothes-horse, dress does not interest you that much. But you go naked 
only with persons you fully trust — a short list. 

“That’s all, I guess. I haven’t tried to imagine details; this is just what grew in my mind. Oh, yes! — you keep 
your nails, both hands and feet, short and clean. But you aren’t fussy about it, or about anything. Neither dirt nor 
sweat bothers you, and you don’t flinch at blood, even though you don’t like it.” 

“I am very pleased to know how I look, Lazarus.” 

“Huh? Oh, fiddle, girl — that’s my imagination living its own life.” 

“That is how I look,” Minerva said firmly, “and I like it. 

“All right. Although you can be as dazzingly beautiful as Hamadryad if you want to be." 

“No, I look just as you described me. I am a ‘Martha,’ Lazarus, not her sister Mary.” 

Lazarus said, “You surprised me. Nfes, you are. Nt>u ye read the Bible?” 

“I have read everything in the Great Library. In one sense I am the Library, Lazarus." 

“Mmm, yes, should’ve realized it. How is the twinning process coming along? Going to be ready? Say if ha 
gets a burr under his saddle and takes off in a hurry.” 



“It is essentially complete, Lazarus. All my permanents, programs and memories and logics, are twinned in 
Dora s number-four hold, and I run routine checks and exercise by running the twinned parts parallel with the me 
here under the Palace — a Tell me six times’ instead of my normal Tell me three times’ method. I have found and 
corrected some open circuits that way — minor factory defects, nothing I could not handle at once. You see, 
Lazarus, I treated it as a crash program and did not depend on Turing processes to build most of my new me,, 
as I would have had to build extensionals in Dora for that sole purpose, then remove them save for maintenance 
extensionals. 

“That would have taken much time, of course, since I can’t use computer speeds in manipulating mass. So 
instead I ordered all new blank memories and logic circuitry and had them installed in Dora by factory 
technicians. Much faster. Then I filled them and checked them.” 

“Any trouble, dear?” 

“No, Lazarus. Oh, Dora grumbled about dirty feet in her clean compartments. But it was just grumbling, as 
they worked ‘clean-room’ style, lint-free coveralls and masks and gloves, and I required them to change in the air 
lock, not just before they entered her number-four.” He felt her quick smile. “Temporary sanitary facilities outside 
the ship — which caused the project engineer to grumble, as well as the shop steward.” 

“Should think so. Wouldn’t have hurt Dora to activate a head.” 

“Lazarus, as you pointed out, I will be — I hope — a passenger in Dora someday. So I have tried to become her 
friend — and we are friends, and I love her, and she is the only friend I have who is a computer. I don’t want to 
jeopardize that by making a mess, or permitting one to be made, in my moving into her ship. She is, as you said, 
a neat housekeeper; I am trying to be just as neat and show thereby that I respect her and appreciate the 
privilege of being a passenger in her. The engineer in charge and that talky shop steward had no reason to 
grumble; I specified all this in the contract — change clothes at the lock, leg urinals for all personnel inside, no 
eating, expectorating, or smoking in the ship, go by the shortest route to number-four, no snooping elsewhere in 
the ship — which they could not, anyhow, as I asked Dora to keep all doors locked save that direct route — and I 
paid to have it done this way.” 

“A pretty penny, I’m certain. Did Ira comment?” 

“Ira does not bother with such matters. But I did not report costs to him; I charged it all to you, Lazarus.” 

“Whee' Am I bankrupt?” 

“No, sir; I paid it from the Senior’s unlimited drawing account. That seemed best to me, Lazarus, as the work 
was done in your ship. Perhaps they wonder why the Senior wants a second computer, of high capacity, installed 
in his ship. I know the project engineer wondered; / snubbed him firmly. But wonder is all they can do; the Senior 
is not accountable to anyone. I hinted quite broadly that Mr. Chairman Pro Tern would be annoyed if anyone 
attempted to snoop into your affairs. Not that anyone can tell what a computer really is, just from looking at it 
— even the manufacturer." 

“This manufacturer — Low bidder?” 

“Should I have placed it for bid, sir?” Minerva sounded worried. 

“Hell, no! If you had, I would have told you to tear it out and start over — then we would have hunted for the best 
supplier. Minerva my dear, once you leave here, it maybe many years before you have any factory service; you’ll 
have to maintain yourself. Unless Ira can minister to a sick computer?” 

“He can’t.” 

“\bu see? Dora is gold and platinum where a cheaper computer is copper and aluminum. I hope your new 
carcass is just as expensive.” 

“It is, Lazarus. My new me is even more reliable than my old me — and smaller and faster, as much of 
me — 'old me’ — is about a century old; the art has improved.” 

“Hm. Must see what ought to be replaced in Dora, if anything.” 

Minerva made no comment. Lazarus said, “My dear, when you don’t talk, it is louder than when you do. Have 
you been overhauling Dora?” 

“I stockpiled some components, Lazarus. But Dora won't let herself be touched unless you order it.” 

“Yeah, she hates to let a doctor poke around inside her. But if she needs it, she’ll get it — under anesthesia. 
Minerva, it would be smart, with two of you in the ship, for Dora to carry your maintenance instructions in her 
permanents, and hers in yours — so that you can nurse each other.” 

Minerva answered simply, “We have been waiting for you to tell us to do so, Lazarus." 

“\bu mean you have been waiting; it is not something Dora would think of. So now I’m telling you both, and let 



her hear my voice say so. Minerva, I wish you would get over being so humble with me. You should have 
proposed it; you think faster than I do by many orders of magnitude; I’ve got flesh-and-blood limitations. How are 
you coming on astrogation? Is she teaching you to pilot? Or balking?” 

“Lazarus, I am now as skillful a pilot as she is, in my other me.” 

“Like fun. You’re a copilot. You’re not a pilot until you’ve made an n-spacejump unassisted. Even Dora gets 
jumpy before a jump — and she’s made hundreds.” 

“/stand corrected, Lazarus. I am a very highly trained copilot. But I’m not afraid to do it, if the time comes. I’ve 
rerun all of Dora’s jumps in real time, and she tells me I know how.” 

“\bu may have to someday, if disaster hits. Ira isn’t the pilot I am, I’m certain. With me no longer aboard, your 
new skill may save his life sometime. What else do you know? Heard any good ones lately?” 

“I don't know, Lazarus. I’ve heard some stories, bawdy ones I believe, from listening to the technicians 
installing my twin. But I don’t know that they are funny.” 

“Don’t bother. If it’s a bawdy story, I heard one like it at least a thousand years back. Now the key question — 
How fast can you cut loose if ha decides to jump? Assume a coup d’etat and he’s running for his life.” 

“One-fifth of a second, minus.” 

“Huh? You’re not pulling my leg? I mean how long to put your whole personality aboard the ‘Dora.’ Not leave 
anything behind and not leave the computer here aware that she ever was Minerva — for anything less would not 
be fair to yourself, dear. The ‘Minerva’ left behind would grieve.” 

“Lazarus, I am speaking not from theory but from experience, as I knew it was the critical aspect of this 
twinning. So, once I dismissed the contractor and had twinned my permanents and logics and my running 
temporaries, I experimented, cautiously at first; I simply paralleled me, as I described to you. That’s easy, I just 
have to balance the lag at each end, to stay synchronous in real time — but I have to do that with my remote 
extensionals at all times; I’m used to it. 

“Then I tried, very cautiously, suppressing myself, first at the ship end, then at the Palace end, with a self- 
program to revert to full twinning in three seconds. No trouble, Lazarus, not even the first time. Now I can do it in 
less than two hundred milliseconds and run all checks to be certain that I have neglected nothing. I have done so 
seven times since you asked that question. Did you notice a lag in my voice at times? Approximately a 
thousand-kilometer lag?” 

“What? My dear, I am not equipped to notice a lag of less than thirty thousand kilometers at speed ‘c.’ “ He 
added, “Call it a tenth of a second. You flatter me.” Lazarus added thoughtfully, “But a tenth of a second is a 
hundred million of the nanoseconds you use. Or a hundred milliseconds. What’s that in your time? About a 
thousand of my days?’ 

“Lazarus, that is not how I would express it. I split much smaller than a nanosecond in many things I do — a 
‘millishake’ or less. But I’m just as comfortable in your time; I am right now with my personal me. I could not enjoy 
singing, or this quiet talk with you, if in my personal mode I were forced to consider each nanosecond. Do you 
count each of your heartbeats?’ 

“No. Or rarely.” 

“It is somewhat the same with me, Lazarus. The things I do quickly I do with no effort and with no conscious 
attention other than necessary self-program. But the seconds and minutes and hours I spend with you, in 
personal mode, I savor. I do not chop thorn into nanoseconds; I grasp them whole and enjoy them. All the days 
and weeks you have been here I hold as a single ‘now’ and cherish it.” 

“Uh. . .hold it, dear! Are you saying that, well, the day Ira introduced us to each other is still ‘non/ to you?” 

“\fes, Lazarus.” 

“Let me sort this out. Is tomorrow ‘now’ to you also?” 

“Yes, Lazarus.” 

“Uh...but if that is so, you can predict the future." 

“No, Lazarus.” 

“But — Then I don’t understand it.” 

“I could print out the equations, Lazarus, but such equations would merely describe the fact that I am 
constructed to treat time as one of many dimensions, with entropy but one operator and with ‘the present’ or 
‘now’ a variable held in steady state for a wide or narrow span. But in dealing with you I must necessarily move 
with the wave front that is your personal now — or we cannot communicate." 

“My dear, I’m not sure we are communicating.” 



“I am sorry, Lazarus. I have my limitations, too. But were I able to choose, I would choose your limitations. 
Human. Flesh-and-blood.” 

“Minerva, you don’t know what you are saying. A flesh-and-blood body can be a burden . . especially when its 
maintenance begins to occupy most of one’s attention. You have the best of both worlds — designed in man’s 
own image to do what makes him distinctively human — but better, faster — much faster! — and more accurately, 
than he can do it — without the aches and pains and inefficiencies of a body that must eat and sleep and make 
mistakes. Believe me.” 

“Lazarus, what is ‘Eros’?” 

He looked into the gloom and saw in his mind’s eye how solemnly and sorrowfully she stared back. “Good God, 
girl — do you want to go to bed with him that badly?” 

“Lazarus, I do not know I am a ‘blind man.’ How can I know?” 

Lazarus sighed. “I’m sorry, dear. Then you know why I have kept Dora a baby.” 

“Only as conjecture, Lazarus. One that I have not and will not discuss with anyone.” 

“Thank you — you are a lady, dear. You do know. Or you know part of my reason. But I’ll tell you all of it — when I 
feel up to it — and then you will know what I mean by ‘love’ and why I told Hamadryad it must be experienced, not 
defined in words... and why I know that you know what love is, because you have experienced it. But Dora’s story 
is not for Ira, just for you. No, you can let Ira have it, after I’m gone. Uh, call it The Tale of the Adopted Daughter’; 
then place a hold on it and let him have it later. But I won’t tell it now; I’m not strong enough tonight — ask me when 
you know I’m feeling up to it.” 

“I shall. I’m sorry, Lazarus.” 

“Sorry’? Minerva, my very dear, there is never anything to feel sorry about with love. Never. Would you rather 
not love me? Or Dora? Or never have learned of love through loving Ira?” 

“No. No, not that! But would that I knew ‘Eros,’ too.” 

“Count your blessings, dear. ‘Eros’ can hurt.” 

“Lazarus, I do not fear being hurt. But while I know much about male-female reproduction, far more than any 
single human flesh-and-blood knows — ” 

“\bu do? Or think you do?” 

“I do know, Lazarus. In preparation for migrating I added extra additional memory storage — filling much of 

hold number-two so that I could transcribe for Ishtar into my new me all the research files and library and 

restricted records of the Howard Rejuvenation Clinic — ” 

“Whew! I think Ishtar took a chance. The Clinic seems pretty cagey about what they release and don’t 
release.” 

“Ishtar is not afraid to take chances. But she did ask me to hurry, so I placed it in temporary here, until I could 
set up the necessary capacity — large — in Dora’s hold. But I asked Ishtar’s permission to study it, and she said it 
was all right for me to do so, as long as I did not release anything keyed as confidential or secret without 
consulting her. 

“I found it fascinating, Lazarus. I now know all about sex in the sense that a man who has always been blind 
can be taught the physics of a rainbow. I am even a gene surgeon now, in theory, and would not hesitate to be 
one in practice once I had time to construct the ultramicrominiature waldoes needed for such fine work. I am 
equally expert as obstetrician and gynecologist and rejuvenator. Erectile reflexes and mechanics of orgasm and 
the processes of spermogenesis and impregnation are no mystery to me, nor any aspect of gestation and birth. 

‘“Eros alone I cannot know... and know at last that I am blind.” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
VI 


The Tale of the Twins Who Werent 


(Omitted) 

— but sky merchant was then my usual occupation, Minerva. That caper in which I moved from slave to high 
priest was forced on me. I had to be meek a long time, which ain’t my style. Maybe Jesus was right when he said 
that the meek shall inherit the earth — but they inherit very small plots, about six feet by three. 

But the only route from field hand to freedom lay through the church -and required meekness all the way, so 
that’s what I gave ’em. Those priests had weird habits — (9,300 words omitted) 

— which got me off their damned planet and I never expected to go back. 

— did go back a couple of centuries later — freshly rejuvenated and not looking anything like that high priest 
whose ship had been lost in space. 

I was a sky merchant again, which suits me; it lets you travel and see things. I went back to Blessed for 
money, not revenge. I’ve never wasted skull sweat on revenge; The Comtede-Monte-Cristo syndrome is too 
much work and not enough fun. If I tangle with a man and he lives through it, I don’t come back later gunning for 
him. Instead, I outlive him — which balances the books just as well. I figured that two centuries was enough for my 
enemies on Blessed to be dead, since I had left most of them sort of dead earlier. 

Blessed would not have been on my route other than for business reasons. Interstellar trade is economics 
stripped to basics. You can’t make money by making money because money isn’t money other than on its planet 
of issue. Most money is fiat; a ship’s cargo of the stuff is wastepaper elsewhere. Bank credit is worth even less; 
Galactic distances are too great. Even money that jingles must be thought of as trade goods — not money — or 
you’ll kid yourself into starvation. 

This gives the sky merchant a grasp of economics rarely achieved by bankers or professors. He is engaged 
in barter and no nonsense. He pays taxes he can’t evade and doesn’t care whether they are called “excise” or 
“king’s pence” or “squeeze” or straight-out bribes. It is the other kid’s bat and ball and backyard, so you play by 
his rules — nothing to get in a sweat about. Respect for laws is a pragmatic matter. Women know this 
instinctively; that’s why they are all smugglers. Men often believe — or pretend — that the “Law” is something 
sacred, or at least a science — an unfounded assumption very convenient to governments. 

I’ve done little smuggling; it's risky, and you can wind up with money you don’t dare spend where it’s legal 
tender. I simply tried to avoid places where the squeeze was too high. 

By the Law of Supply and Demand a thing has value from where it is as much as from what it is — and that’s 
what a merchant does; he moves things from where they are cheap to where they are worth more. A smelly 
nuisance in a stable is valuable fertilizer if you move it to the south forty. Pebbles on one planet can be precious 
gems on another. The art in selecting cargo lies in knowing where things will be worth more, and the merchant 
who can guess right can reap the wealth of Midas in one trip. Or guess wrong and go broke. 

I was on Blessed because I had been on Landfall and wanted to go to Valhalla in order to go back to 
Landfall, as I was thinking of marrying and raising another family. But I wanted to be rich enough to be landed 
gentry when I settled down — which I was not, at the time. All I had was the scout ship Libby and I had used * (* 
Sequence of events cannot be reconciled. Perhaps a similar ship? J.F. 45 th ) and a modicum of local money. 

So it was time to trade. 

The trade routes for a two-way swap show minimum profit; they fill up too quickly. But a triangular trade-or 
higher numbers — can show high profits. Like this: Landfall had something — call it cheese — which was a luxury 
on Blessed — while Blessed produced — call it chalk — much in demand on Valhalla whereas Valhalla 
manufactured doohickeys that Landfall needed. 

Work this in the right direction and get rich; work it backwards and lose your shirt. 

I had worked the first leg, Landfall to Blessed, successfully having sold my cargo of — Now what was it? 
Durned if I remember; I’ve handled so many things. Anyhow, I got such a nice price that I temporarily had too 



much money. 

How much is “too much”? Whatever you can’t spend before you leave a place you are not coming back to. If 
you hang onto that excess and come back later, you will usually find — invariably, so far as I recall — that inflation or 
war or taxes or changes in government or something has wiped out the alleged value of fiat money you may have 
kept. 

As my ship was scheduled to load and I had placed in escrow with the port authority the price other cargo, 
what I had left over was burning a hole in my pocket with only a day to get rid of it, that being the time until my 
ship was to be loaded — I had to be on hand for that; I was my own purser and have an untrusting disposition. 

So I took a walkthrough the retail district, thinking I might buy some doodads. 

I was dressed in local high style and had a bodyguard behind me, for Blessed was still a slave economy and 
in a pyramidal society it is well to be up near the point, or at least look like it. My bodyguard was a slave but not 
my slave; I had hired him from a rent-a-servant agency. I’m not a hypocrite; this slave didn’t have a durn thing to 
do but follow me around and eat like a hog. 

I had him because my assumed status required a manservant in sight. A “gentleman” could not register at a 
first-class hilton in Charity or anywhere on Blessed without a valet in evidence; I could not eat in a good 
restaurant without my own bearer standing behind me — and so forth; when in Rome, you shoot Roman candles. 
I’ve been places where it was mandatory to sleep with your hostess — which can be dreadful; this Blessed 
custom wasn’t difficult. 

I didn’t rely on him even though the agency supplied him with a knob stick. I was armed six ways and careful 
where I walked; Blessed was more dangerous than it had been when I was a slave there and a “gentleman” is 
more of a target, even though cops don’t bother him. 

I was taking a shortcut through the slave market, it not being an auction day, on my way to the jewelers’ lane, 
when I saw that a sale was being offered and slowed down — a man who has been sold himself can’t walk past, 
indifferent to the plight of chattels. Not that I had any intention of buying. 

Nor did anyone seem about to buy this pair; the knot around the factor’s tent was rabble; I could tell by their 
clothes and the fact that there wasn’t a man there with a manservant. 

The merchandise was standing on a table, a young woman and a young man. Late adolescence for him and 
just ripe for her, or the same age in view of the fact that females grow up faster. Call it eighteen measured by my 
own youth — an age at which a boy should be nailed into a barrel and fed through the bunghole but a girl is ready 
to marry. 

Long sleeveless robes hung from their shoulders — and I knew too well what those robes meant; they would 
be displayed only to a prospective buyer, not to rabble. Robes signified valuable slaves, not to be knocked down 
on open bid. 

Sure enough, they were being held at Dutch auction, with the minimum bid posted — ten thousand blessings. 
That amounts to — How can I define money of centuries back on a planet hundreds of light-years away in terms 
that make sense here and now? Let’s put it this way: Unless these kids were something extraordinary, they were 
overpriced by a factor of five, as prime young stock, either sex, were fetching around a thousand blessings by 
the morning’s financial news. 

Ever pause in front of a clothing store and get hooked inside? No, of course you haven’t. But that’s what 
happened to me. 

All I did was say to the factor, “Goodman, is that posted bid a mistake? Or do these two have something 
special that doesn’t show?” Just curiosity, Minerva, as I neither intended to own slaves nor would the excess in 
my purse make a dent in a planetwide custom. But I could not see why? The girl was not outstandingly pretty; she 
would not fetch a high price as an odalisque. The lad wasn’t even heavily muscled. Nor were they a matched 
pair. Back home I would have picked her for Eyetalian and him fora Swede. 

Boom, I’m urged into the tent while the chattels are shoved ahead; the factor’s manner shows that he hasn’t 
had a live one all day — while my shadow is saying in my ear, “Master, that price is too high. I can take you to a 
private sale where prices are right and satisfaction is guaranteed." 

I said, “Shut up, Faithful” — all rented body servants were named “Faithful,” probably by contraries — "I want to 
see what this is.” 

As fast as the tent flap is fastened against the rabble, the factor is shoving a chair against my knees and 
handing me a drink with a bow and a scrape while saying lyrically, “Oh, sweet and gentle master, happy am I that 
you asked that! I am about to show you a great wonder of science! A thing to astound the very gods! I speak as a 
pious man, a true son of our Everlastinq Church, one who cannot lie!” 



A slave factor who can't lie has yet to be whelped. Meantime, the youngsters stationed themselves docilely 
on a display platform, and Faithful was whispering: “Don't believe a word, Master. The girl is nothing and I can 
whip three of that punk without my stick — yet the agency would sell you me for eight hundred blessings and that’s 
a fact.” 

I motioned him to silence. “Goodman, what swindle is this?” 

“No swindle, on my mother’s honor, kind sir! Would you believe that these are brother and sister?” 

I looked at them. “No.” 

“Would you believe that they are not only brother and sister but twins?” 

“No." 

“Would you believe the same stud, the same dam, the same womb, born the same hour?” 

“Possibly the same womb,” I conceded. “Host-mother?” 

“No, no! Exactly the same ancestry. And yet — here is the miracle — ” He held my eye and spoke in a hushed 
voice: “They are nevertheless a sound breeding pair... for these twins are unrelated to each other!\Nou\d you 
believe it?” 

I told him what I would believe, including his losing his license and facing a charge of blasphemy. 

His smile grew broader, and he complimented me on my wit and asked me how much — if he proved all of 
these things — how high a bid I would place against them? Higher than ten thousand since I must realize that the 
posted figure represented a prior bid. Fifteen thousand, perhaps, with escrow the morrow before noon? 

I said, “Forget it, I’m shipping out before noon” — and started to stand up. 

He said, “Wait, I beg you! I see that you are a gentleman of education, of science, of deep knowledge and 
widely traveled — surely you will grant your humble servant a moment to show proof?” 

I still would have left; swindles bore me. But he waved a hand, and the kids dropped their robes and fell into 
display poses, the lad with his arms folded across his chest and his feet planted firmly, the girl in that graceful 
pose that must be as old as Eve — one knee slightly advanced, hand on hip, other arm hanging- easily, chest 
slightly raised. It almost made her beautiful save that she looked bored — having taken it hundreds of times, no 
doubt. 

But that wasn’t what made me stay; something annoyed me. The lad was bare of course — she was wearing 
a chastity girdle. Do you know what one is, Minerva? 

“\fes, Lazarus.” 

Too bad. I said, “Take that damned thing off that kid! A/owfSilly of me; I rarely interfere with anything on a 
strange planet. But those things are abominations. 

“Certainly, gentle sir; I was about to. Estrellita!” 

The girl turned her back, with that same bored look. The factor stood so that his back kept the lad from 
seeing him work the combination lock, saying apologetically, “She must wear it not only because of ruffians but 
to protect her from her brother; they share the same pallet, for she is — would you believe it, sir, seeing how full 
ripe she is? — a virgin! Show the gentle master, ‘Trellita.” 

Bored as ever, she promptly started to do so. I regard virginity as a correctable perversity of no interest; I 
motioned her to stop and asked the factor if she could cook. 

He assured me that she was the envy of every gourmet chef on Blessed, and started to lock her back into 
that steel diaper. I said roughly, “Leave it off! Nobody here is going to rape her. What’s this proof you promised?” 

Minerva, he proved every word — except about her cooking — with exhibits that made me suspicious only 
because he showed them; I wouldn’t have boggled had I seen them in the Clinic here. 

I should mention that Blessed had a rejuvenation clinic even though it was not settled by the Families. 
Eventually the clinic was taken over by the church and antigeria techniques that work fairly well even on short- 
lifers were no longer available to any but big shots. But the planet stayed advanced in biological techniques; the 
church needed it. 

Minerva, I told you that he claimed and you are now as learned in biology and genetics and associated 
manipulations as Ishtar is — more so; you don’t have her limitations in time and in memory storage. What did he 
prove to me? 

“That they were diploid complements, Lazarus.” 

“Right! Although he called them “mirror twins.” Can you tell me how these kids were made, Minerva? How 
would you go about producing such twins? 

The computer answered thoughtfully, ‘“Mirror twins would be an inexact term for zygotes satisfying the listed 



requirements — although it is colorful. I can answer only theoretically as the records in me do not show that it has 
been attempted on Secundus. But the steps necessary to achieve exact diploid complements would be these: 
There must be intervention in gametogenesis in each parent just before meiotic division-reduction of 
chromosome number — that is, one would start with primary spermatocytes and primary oocytes, unreduced 
diploids. 

“In the male parent the intervention presents no theoretical problem but would be difficult because the cells 
are very small — but I would not hesitate to attempt it given time to construct the necessary fine extensionals. 

“The logical place to start, both parents, would be with gonia placed in vitro, and cherished. When a 
spermatogonium was observed to change to a primary spermatocyte — still diploid — it would be segregated and 
at the instant it divided into two secondary spermatocytes — haploids, one with an X chromosome and one with a 
Y chromosome — they would be again segregated and each would be encouraged to develop into spermatozoa. 

“It would not be sufficient to intervene at the spermatozoa stage; confusion of gamete pairs could not be 
avoided, and resulting zygotes could be complementary only by wildest chance. 

“Intervention with the female parent is mechanically simpler because of larger ceils — but involves a different 
problem; the primary oocyte must be encouraged, at point of meiosis, to produce Mo haploid and 
complementary secondary oocytes, rather than one oocyte and one polar body. Lazarus, this might require many 
attempts before a reliable technique could be worked out. It would be similar to the process of identical twinning 
but must take place two stages earlier in the gametogenetic sequence. However, it might turn out to be no more 
difficult than it is to produce fatherless female rabbits. I do not venture an opinion as I lack former art to draw on 
— save that I feel certain that it can be done, given time to develop technique. 

“At this point we have complementary groups, of spermatozoa, one group with Y and one with X, and a 
complementary pair of ova, each with an x chromosome. Fertilization would be invitro, witha possibility of 
choosing either of two potential pairs of female-male complements but with no basis for choice unless the 
genetic charts of haploids are determined precisely, which is difficult and likely to cause genetic damage; I do 
not think it would be attempted. Instead one sperm would be inserted into one ovum, its complement into the 
other, on a blind basis. 

“One last requirement must be met to justify all of this slave factor’s allegations: The two fertilized ova must 
be removed from vitro and planted in the womb of the donor of the oogonium, and there allowed to develop as 
twins through natural gestation and birth. 

“Am I right, Lazarus?” 

Exacly right! Go to the head of the class, dear; you get a gold star on your report card. Minerva, I don’t know 
that it happened that way. But that’s what the factor claimed, and that’s what his exhibits — lab reports, 
holomovies, and so forth — seemed to show. But that thief may have faked those “proofs” and offered a random 
pair not likely to fetch a price above average — save for his fancy sales talk. The so-called proofs looked good, 
and lab reports and such carried, a bishop’s chop and seal. The stills and movies looked good, too — but how 
can a layman judge? Even if those exhibits weren’t phony, all they could prove was that such a process had once 
taken place; they did not prove that these kids were the result. Shucks, they might have been used to sell many 
slave pairs, with a bishop in on the racket. 

I looked over the stuff, including a scrapbook of the kids growing up, said, “Very interesting,” and started to, 
leave. 

This pimple teleported himself between me and the tent flap. “Master,” he said urgently. “Kind and generous 
sir — twelve thousand?” 

Minerva, my trader instincts took over. “One thousand!” I snapped. I don’t know why. Yes, I do know. The girl's 
body was scarred from that damned Torquernada girdle; I wanted to insult this flesh peddler. 

He flinched and looked as if he were giving birth to broken beer bottles. “You jest with me. Eleven thousand 
blessings, and they are yours — though I won’t make expenses!” 

“Fifteen hundred,” I answered. I had money I couldn’t spend elsewhere and told myself I could afford to 
manumit them rather than let that girl be bound into that damned atrocity again. 

He moaned. “If they were mine, I would give them to you. I love these cute darlings like my own children and 
could ask for them, nothing better than a kind and gentle master learned in science who appreciates the 
wonders that have gone into their making. But the Bishop would hang me and have me cut down alive to be 
dragged to death by my tool. Ten thousand and take all proofs and exhibits. I’ll suffer a loss for their sakes — and 
because I admire you so much." 



I got up to forty-five hundred and he got down to seven thousand and there we stuck, as I had to hold out cash 
for last-minute squeeze, whereas it felt to me that he was close to the point where he really could not sell without 
risking the Bishop’s wrath. If there was a bishop — He turned away in a fashion that says that a dicker is over 
and he is through flattering you, and told the girl sharply to step back into her steel harness. 

I got out my purse. Minerva, you understand money; you handle the government’s finances. But possibly you 
don’t know that cash money affects some people the way catnip does Diablo. I counted out forty-five hundred 
blessings in big red-and-gold bills under that scoundrel’s nose — and stopped. He was sweating and swallowing 
his Adam’s apple but managed to shake his head a tenth of an inch. 

So I counted more bills, very slowly, and reached five thousand — then started briskly to pick them up. 

He stopped me — and I found that I had bought the only slaves I have ever owned. 

He relaxed then, in a resigned way, but wanted lagniappe for the exhibits. I didn't care one way or another but 
offered two hundred and fifty for the pixand tapes, take it or leave it. He took it and again started to put the girl 
back into her harness. 

I stopped him and said, “Show me how that works,” I knew how — a cylinder-type ten-letter combination lock 
you could set to a new combination each time you used it. Set the combination, slide the ends of the steel strap 
that went around her waist through the ends of the barrel, spin the alphabet disks of the cylinder, then it stays 
locked until you reset whatever ten-letter combo you picked. An expensive lock and good steel in the girdle 
— alloy a hacksaw couldn’t touch. This was another thing that made his story convincing, as, while there was a 
market for virgins on that weird globe, a trained odalisque fetched about the same, and this girl wasn't being 
reserved for harem stock either way. So an expensive custom-made chastity belt had to have some other 
reason. 

With our backs to the slaves he showed me the combination: E,S,T,R,E,L,L,I,T,A — and was smug about how 
clever he was to pick a combination he couldn’t forget. So I fumbled on purpose, then pretended to catch on, and 
opened it. He was about to put it on the kid again and send us on our way. I said, “Wait a moment. I want to be 
sure I can work it in place. \bu step into it and let me get you out of it.” 

He didn’t want to. So I got snotty and said he was trying to cheat me — put me in a position where I would 
have to send for him and pay through the nose to get my property unlocked. I demanded my money back and 
started to tear up the bill of sale. He gave in and stepped into the contrivance. 

He could squeeze into it although the ends of the steel belt barely met; he was bigger around the waist than 
the girl was. I said, “Now spell that combination for me” — and leaned over the lock. As he spelled- 
“ESTRELLITA,” what I set was “HORSETHIEF-” then jammed the ends together as hard as possible and spun 
the disks. 

“Good,” I said. “It works. Now spell it again." 

He did so and I carefully spelled “ESTRELLITA.” It stayed locked. I suggested that he had had me spell it with 
one / and two t’s the first time. That didn’t work either. 

He dug up a mirror and tried it himself. No go. I said it might be jammed, so suck up your gut and we’ll shake 
it. By now he was sweating. 

Finally I said, “Tell you what, goodman — I’ll give you this belt. I’d rather trust a padlock anyhow. So go to a 
locksmith — no, you won’t want to wear this outside; just tell me where to find one and I’ll send him here, and pay 
him myself. Fair enough? I can’t hang around; I've got a dinner engagement at the Beulahland. Where are their 
clothes? Faithful, gather up this junk and fetch the kids.” So I left him still blatting about telling the locksmith to 
hurry. 

As we left his tent, a taxicab was cruising by. I had Faithful hail it and we all piled in. I didn’t bother with a lock 
smith; I had the driver head for the skyport, then stopped on the way at a slopchest and bought the kids proper 
clothes, a clout for him and sort of Balinese sarong for her — uh, that’s much like the dress Hamadryad wore 
yesterday. I think those were the first real clothes the youngsters had ever had. I couldn’t get shoes on them; I 
settled forsanaals — then had to drag Estrellita away from a mirror; she was admiring herself and preening. I 
threw away those auction robes. I shoved the kids into the taxi and said to Faithful: “See that alley? If I turn my 
back and you run down it, I won’t be able to chase you; I’ve got to keep an eye on these two." 

Minerva, I ran into something I’ll never understand: the slave mentality. Faithful didn’t get my meaning — and 
when I spelled it out, he was aghast. Hadn’t he given good service? Did I want him to starve? I gave up. We 
dropped him at the Rent-a-Servant, and got my deposit back — tipping him for good service — and my slaves and 
I rode on out to the skyport. 



Turned out I needed that deposit and almost every blessing I had left — had to pay squeeze at outgoing 
customs to get the kids aboard my ship, even though the bill of sale was in order. 

But I got ‘em aboard; I immediately had them kneel, put my hands on their heads and manumitted them. They 
did not seem to believe it, so I explained. “Look, you’re free now. Free, get me? No longer slaves. I'll sign your 
manumission papers and you can go to the diocese office and get them registered. Or you can have dinner here 
and sleep aboard, and I’ll give you what blessings I can just before my ship lifts tomorrow. Or, if you mnt to, you 
can stay aboard and go to Valhalla, a nice planet though chillier than this one — but where there is no such thing 
as slavery.” 

Minerva, I don’t think Llita — pronounced ‘Yeetah,’ her everyday name — or her brother Joe — Josie, or Jose 
understood what I meant by a place that did not have slavery; it was foreign to anything they knew. But they knew 
what a starship was, from hearsay, and the prospect of going somewhere in one had them awestruck — they 
would not have missed it if I had told them they were going to be hanged on arrival. Besides, in their minds I was 
still their master; manumission hadn’t taken hold even though they knew what it was. Something for old and 
faithful retainers, that is, who stayed on at the funda where they had been all along, but maybe got paid a little. 

But to travel! The farthest they had ever been in their lives was from a diocese north of there to the capital, to 
be sold. 

A little trouble next morning — Seems that one Simon Legree, licensed dealer in slaves, had sworn a 
complaint against me alleging bodily harm, mental duress, and assorted mopery and dopery. So I sat the cop 
down in my wardroom, poured him a drink, called in Llita and had her take off her wonderful new clothes and let 
the cop see the scars on her hips, then told her to skedaddle. I happened to leave a hundred-blessing note on 
the table while I got up to fetch the bill of sale. 

The cop waved away the bill of sale, saying there had been no complaint on that score — but he was going to 
tell Goodman Legree that he was lucky not to face a counter-charge of selling damaged goods... no, on second 
thought it was simpler if he just couldn’t find me until after my ship lifted. The hundred blessings was gone, and 
soon the cop was gone — and by midafternoon, so were we. 

But, Minerva, I got cheated; Llita couldn’t cook worth a damn. 


It is a long and complex passage from Blessed ‘to Valhalla, and Shipmaster Sheffield was pleased to have 
company. 

There was a mild contretemps the first night of the voyage caused by a misunderstanding that had started the 
night before, dirtside. The ship had a cabin and two staterooms. Since the Captain normally operated by 
himself, he used the Staterooms for casual storage or light cargo; they were not ready for passengers. So that 
first night dirtside he put his freedwoman into his cabin, while her brother and he slept on transom couches in the 
wardroom. 

The following day Captain Sheffield unlocked the staterooms, switched power to them, had the young people 
clean them and move the clutter to a gear locker until he could see what space he had left in his holds, and told 
them each to take a room — and forgot it, being busy with cargo and final squeeze, then with supervising his 
piloting computer while they got clear of that system. It was late that “night,” ship’s time, before he had his ship on 
her first leg in n-space, and could relax. 

He went to his cabin while considering whether to eat first or shower first, or possibly neither. 

Estrellita was in his bed — wide awake and waiting. 

He said, “Llita, what are you doing here?” 

She told him in blunt slave lingo what she was doing in his bed — waiting for him — as she had known what 
would be expected of her when milord Shipmaster Sheffield had offered to take them along, and had discussed 
it with her brother, and Brother had told her to do it. 

She added that she was not a bit afraid; she was ready and eager. 

The first part of this Aaron Sheffield had to believe; the addendum seemed clearly a white lie; he had seen 
frightened virgins before — not often, but a few. 

He dealt with her fear by ignoring it. He said, “\fou impudent bitch, get your arse out of my bed and into your 
own.” The freedwoman was startled and unbelieving, then sulky and offended — then she wept. Fear of an 
unknown that she had felt earlier was drowned in a worse emotion; her tiny ego was crushed by his rejection of 
service she knew she owed him — and had believed he wanted. She sobbed, and dripped tears on his pillow. 



Female tears always had a strong aphrodisiac effect on Captain Sheffield; he responded to them at once 
— by grabbing her ankle, dragging her out of bed, hustling her out of his cabin, into her stateroom, and locking 
her in. Then he returned to his cabin, locked its door, took measures to calm himself, and went to sleep. 

Minerva, there was ‘nothing wrong with Llita as a woman. Once I taught her to bathe properly she was quite 
attractive — good figure, pleasant face and manner, good teeth, and her breath was sweet. But taking her did not 
fit any customs. All “Eros” is custom, dear; there is never anything moral or, immoral about copulation as such, or 
any of its nonfunctional frills. “Eros” is simply a way of keeping human beings, individuals, each different 
— keeping them together and happy. It - is a survival mechanism developed through long evolution, — and its 
reproductive function is the least complex aspect of its very complex and pervasive role in keeping the human 
race going. 

But any sexual act is moral or immoral by precisely the same laws of morality as any other human act; all 
other rules about sex are simply customs — local and transient. There are more codes of sexual customs than a 
dog has fleas 

— and all they have in common is that they are “ordained by God.” I recall a society where copulation in private 
was obscene and forbidden, criminal — while in public it was “anything goes.” The society I was brought up in had 
the reverse of those rules — again “ordained by God.” I’m not sure which pattern was harder to follow, but I wish 
God wouldn’t keep changing his mind — as it is never safe to ignore such customs, and ignorance is no excuse; 
ignorance like to got my ass shot off several times. 

In refusing Llita I was not being moral; I was following my own sexual customs, worked out by trial and error 
and many bruises over the centuries: Never bed a female dependent on me unless I am married to her or willing 
to marry her. This is an amoral rule of thumb, subject to change according to circumstances and not applying to 
females not dependent on me — another negotiation entirely. But this rule is a safety precaution applicable most 
times and places with widely varying customs — a safety measure for me. . . because, unlike that lady from 
Boston I told you about, many females tend to regard copulation as a formal proposal of contract. 

I had let impulse lure me into a predicament in which Llita was temporarily my dependent; I had no intention 
of making matters worse by marrying her, I didn’t owe her that. Minerva, long-lifers should never marry 
ephemerals; it is not fair to the ephemeral or to the long-lifer. 

Nevertheless, once you pick up a stray cat and feed it, you cannot abandon it. Self-love forbids it. The cat’s 
welfare becomes essential to your own peace of mind — even when it’s a bloody nuisance not to break faith with 
the cat. Having bought these kids I could not shuck them off by manumission; I had to plan their future because 
they did not know how. They were stray cats. 

Early next “morning” (by ship’s routine) Captain Sheffield got up, unlocked the freedwoman’s stateroom, 
found her asleep. He called her and told her to get up, wash quickly, then get breakfast for three. He left to wake 
her brother — found his stateroom empty, found him in the galley. “Good morning, Joe.” 

The freedman jumped. “Oh! Good morning, Master.” He ducked and bent his knee. 

“Joe, the correct answer is: ‘Good morning, Captain.’ It amounts to the same thing at present, for I am indeed 
master of this ship and everyone in it. But when you leave my ship on Valhalla, you will have no master of any 
sort. None, as I explained yesterday. Meanwhile, call me ‘Captain.’” 

Captain.” The young man repeated obeisance. 

“Don’t bow! When you speak to me, stand tall and straight and proud, and look me in the eye. The correct 
answer to an order is ‘Aye aye, Captain.’ What are you doing there?" 

“Why, I don’t know — Captain.” 

“I don’t think you do, either. That’s enough coffee for a dozen people.” Sheffield elbowed Joe aside, salvaged 
most of the coffee crystals the lad had poured into a bowl, measured enough for nine cups, made note to teach 
the girl how if she did not know, then have her keep coffee ready during working hours. 

As he sat down with his first cup of coffee, she appeared. Her eyes were red and had circles under them; he 
suspected that she had wept some more that morning. But he made no comment other than a morning greeting 
and let her cope with the galley unassisted, she having seen what he had done the morning before. 

Shortly he was recalling fondly the scratch lunch and supper — sandwiches he had made himself — of the day 
before. But he said nothing other than to order them to sit down and eat with him, rather than hovering over him. 
Breakfast was mostly coffee, cold ship’s bread, tinned butter. Reconstituted accra eggs with mushrooms were 



an inedible mess, and she had managed to do something to heavenfruit juice. To spoil that took talent; all it 
needed was eight parts of cold water for each part of concentrate, and the instructions were on the container. 

“Llita, can you read?” 

“No, Master.” 

“Make that ‘Captain,’ instead. How about you, Joe?” 

“No, Captain.” 

“Arithmetic? Numbers?” 

“Oh, yes, Captain, I know numbers. Two and two is four, two and three makes five, and three and five is 
nine — ” 

His sister corrected him. “Seven, Josie — not nine.” 

“That’s enough,” Sheffield said. “I can see we’ll be busy.” He thought, while he hummed: “So it’s well to 
...Have a sister... Or even an old captain — ” He added aloud: “When you have finished breakfast, take care of 
your personal needs, then tidy your rooms — shipshape and neatly, I'll inspect later — and make the bed in my 
cabin, but don’t touch anything else there, especially my desk. Then each of you take a bath. Yes, that’s what I 
said: Bathe. Aboard ship everyone bathes everyday, oftener if you wish. There is plenty of pure water; we 
recycle it and we'll finish the voyage with thousands of liters more than we started with. Don’t ask why; that’s the 
way it works and I'll explain later.” (Several months later, at least — to youngsters unsure about three plus five.) 
“When you’re through, say, an hour and a half from now — Joe, can you read a clock?” 

Joe stared at the old-fashioned ship’s clock mounted on a bulkhead. “I’m not sure, Captain. That one has too 
many numbers.” 

“Oh, yes, of course; Blessed is on another system. Try to be back here when the little hand is straight out to 
the left and the big hand is straight up. But this time it doesn’t matter if you are late; it takes awhile to shake 
down. Don’t neglect your baths to be on time. Joe, shampoo your head. Llita, lean toward me, dear; let me sniff 
your hair. Yes, you shampoo, too.” (Were there hair nets aboard? If he cut the pseudogravity and let them go free- 
fall, they would need hair nets-or haircuts. A haircut would not hurt Joe, but his sister’s long black hair was her 
best feature — would help her catch a husband on Valhalla. Oh, well, if there were no hair nets — he didn’t think 
there were, as he kept his own hair free-fall short — the girl could braid her hair and tie something around it. 

Could he spare power to maintain an eighth gee all ‘the way? People not used to free-fall got flabby, could even 
damage their bodies. (Don’t worry about it now.) “Get our quarters tidy, get clean yourselves, come back here. 
Git.” 

He made a list: Set up a schedule of duties — N.B.: Teach them to cook! 

Start school: What subjects? 

Basic arithmetic, obviously — but don’t bother to teach them to read that jargon spoken on Blessed; they were 
never going back there — never! But that jargon would have to be ship’s language until he had them speaking 
Galacta, and they must learn to read and write in it — and English, too: Many books he would have to use for their 
hurry-up education were in English. Did he have tapes for the variation of Galacta spoken on Valhalla? Well, kids 
their age quickly picked up local accent and idiom and vocabulary. 

What was far more Important was how to heal their stunted, uh, “souls.” Their personalities — How could he 
take full-grown domestic animals and turn them into able, happy human beings, educated in every needful way 
and capable of competing in a free society? Willing to compete, undismayed by it — He was just beginning to 
see the size of the “stray cat” problem he had taken on. Was he going to have to keep them as pets for fifty or 
sixty years or whatever, until they died naturally? 

Long, long before that, the boy Woodie Smith had found a half-dead fox kit in the woods, apparently lost by 
its mother, or perhaps the vixen was dead. He took it home, nursed it with a bottle, raised it in a cage through 
one winter. In the spring he took it back where he had found it, left it there in the cage with the door latched-open. 

He checked a few days later, intending to salvage the cage. He found the creature cowering in the cage, half 
starved and horribly dehydrated — with the door still latched open. He took it home, again nursed it back to 
health, built a chicken-wire run for it, and never again tried to turn it loose. In the words of his grandfather, “The 
poor critter had never had a chance to learn how to be a fox.” 

Could he teach these cowed and ignorant animals how to be human? 

They returned to his wardroom when “the little hand was straight out and the big hand was straight up’ — they 
waited outside the door until this was so, and Captain Sheffield pretended not to notice. 

But when thev came in, he olanced at the clock and said, “Right on time-oood! \bu’ve certainly shampooed, 



but remind me to find combs for you." (What other toilet articles did they need? Would he have to teach them 
how to use them? And — oh, damn it! — was there anything in the ship for a woman’s menstrual needs? What 
could be improvised? Well, with luck that problem would hold off a few days. No point in asking her; she couldn’t 
add. Tarnation, the ship was not equipped for passengers.) 

“Sit down. No, wait a moment. Come here, dear.” It seemed to the Captain that the garment she wore was 
clinging suspiciously; he felt it, it was wet. “Did you leave that on when you bathed?” 

“No, Mas — No, Captain; I washed it.” 

“I see.” He recalled that its gaudy pattern had been enhanced by coffee and other things while the girl was 
botching breakfast. “Take it off and hang it somewhere; don’t let it dry on your body.” 

She started slowly to comply. Her chin quivered — and he recalled how she had admired herself in a tall mirror 
when he bought it for her. “Wait a moment, Llita. Joe, take off your breechclout. And sandals.” 

The lad complied at once. 

“Thank you, Joe. Don’t put that clout back on without washing it; by now it’s dirty even though it looks clean. 
Don’t wear it underway unless it suits you. You sit down. Llita, were you wearing anything when I bought you?” 

“No... Captain.” 

“Am I wearing anything now?” 

“No, Captain.” 

“There are times and places to wear clothes — and other times and places when clothes are silly. If this were 
a passenger ship, we would all wear clothes and I would wear a fancy uniform. But it is not, and there is nobody 
here but me and your brother. See that instrument there? That’s a thermohumidostat which tells the ship’s 
computer to hold the temperature at twenty-seven Celsius and forty percent humidity, with random variation to 
stimulate us — which may not mean anything to you but is my notion of comfort in bare skin. For an hour each 
afternoon it drops that temperature to encourage exercise, as flab is the curse of shipboard life. 

“If that cycle doesn’t suit you two, we'll reach a compromise. But first we’ll try it my way. Now about that wet 
rag plastered to your hips — If you are stupid, you’ll let it dry where it is and be uncomfortable. If you are smart, 
you’ll hang it up and let it dry without wrinkling. That’s a suggestion, notan order; if you wish, you may wear it at 
all times. But don’t sit down with it on you, wet; there is no reason to get cushions wet. Can you sew?” 

“\fes, Captain. Uh...some.” 

“I’ll see what I can dig up. You are wearing the only woman’s garment in the ship, and if you insist on clothes, 
you’ll need to make some for the months ahead. You’ll need something for Valhalla, too: it’s not as warm as 
Blessed. Women there wear trousers and short coats; men wear trousers and long coats; everyone wears 
boots. I had three outfits custom-made on Landfall; maybe we can make do with them until I can get you two to a 
tailor. Boots — Mine would fit you like socks on a rooster. Hmm — We can wrap your feet so that a pair will stay 
on long enough to get you to a bootery. 

“We won’t worry about that now. Join the conference — standing up and wet, or sitting down and comfortable. 

Estrellita bit her lip and decided in favor of comfort. 

Minerva, those youngsters were brighter than I had expected. At first they studied because I told them to. But 
once they tasted the magic of the printed word, they were hooked. They learned to read like grass through a 
goose and didn’t want to do anything else. Especially stories. I had a good library, mostly in micro, thousands of 
those, but also a few dozen valuable bound books, facsimile antiques I had picked up on Landfall where they 
speak English and use Galacta only as a trade tongue. Savvy Oz books, Minerva? 

Yes, of course you do; I helped plan the Great Library and included my childhood favorites as well as more 
sober things. I did make sure that Joe and Llita read a spread of sober stuff but mostly I let them wallow in 
stories — The Just So Stories, and the Oz books, and Alice in Wonderland, and A Child’s Garden of Verses, 
and Two Little Savages, and such. Too limited; they were books from my childhood, three centuries before the 
Diaspora. On the other hand, every human culture in the Galaxy derives from that one. 

But I tried to make sure that they understood the difference between fiction and history — difficult, as I wasn’t 
certain that there was a difference. Then I had to explain that a fairytale was still a different sort, one step farther 
along the spectrum from fact to fancy. 

Minerva, this is very hard to explain to an inexperienced mind. What is “magic”? Nt>u are more magical than 
any “magic” in fairytales, and it does no good to say that you are ‘a product of science, rather than magic, in 



speaking to kids who have no idea what is meant by “science” — and I wasn’t sure that the distinction was valid 
even when I was explaining the distinction. In my wanderings I have run across magic many times — which simply 
says that I have seen wonders I could not explain. 

I finally let it go by asserting ex cathedra that some stories were just for fun and not necessarily 
true — Gulliver’s Travels were not the same sort of thing as The Adventures of Marco Polo, while Robinson 
Crusoe lay somewhere in between — and they should ask me, if in doubt. 

They did ask, sometimes, and accepted my decision without argument. But I could see that they did not 
always believe me. That pleased me; they were starting to think for themselves — didn’t matter if they were 
wrong. Llita was simply politely respectful to me about Oz. She believed in the Emerald City with all her heart 
and, if she had had her druthers, she would have been going there rather than to Valhalla. Well, so would I. 

The important thing was that they were cutting the cord. 

I did not hesitate to use fiction in teaching them. Fiction is a faster way to get a feeling for alien patterns of 
human -behavior than is nonfiction; it is one stage short of actual experience and I had only months in which to 
turn these cowed and ignorant animals into people. I could, have offered them psychology and sociology and 
comparative anthropology; I had such books on hand. But Joe and Llita could not have put them together into a 
gestalt — and I recall another teacher who used parables in putting over ideas. 

They read every hour I would let them, huddled together like puppies and staring at the reading machine and 
nagging each other about how fast to raise the pages. Usually Llita nagged Joe; she was quicker than he — but 
as maybe, they spurred each other from-illiterate to speedreaders in zip time. I didn’t let them have sound-and- 
picture tapes — I wanted them to read. 

Couldn’t let 'em spend all their time reading; they had to learn other things — not just salable skills but, much 
more important, that aggressive self-reliance necessary to a free human — which they totally lacked when I 
saddled myself with them. Shucks, I wasn’t certain they had the potential; it might have been bred out of their line. 
But if the spark was in them, I had to find it and fan it into flame — or I would never be able to make them run free. 

So I forced them to make up their -own minds as much as possible, while being cautiously rough on them in 
other ways and greeted every sign of rebellion — silently, in my mind — as a triumphant proof of progress. 

I started by teaching Joe to fight — just hand to hand; I didn't want either of us killed. One compartment was 
fitted as a gymnasium, with equipment that could be adapted for gee or for free-fall; I used it that hour a day of 
lowered temperature. Here I worked Joe out. Llita was required to attend but just to exercise — although I had in 
mind that it might spur Joe along if his sister saw him getting the whey knocked out of him. 

Joe needed that spur; he had a terrible time getting it through his head that it was okay to hit or kick me, that I 
wanted him to try, that I would not be angry if he succeeded — but that I would be angry if he didn’t try his 
darnedest. 

Took a while. At first he wouldn’t chop at me no matter how wide open I left myself and when I got him past that, 
calling him names and taunting him, he still hesitated that split second that let me close and chop him instead. 

But one afternoon he got the idea so well that he landed a good one on me and I hardly had to hold back to 
let him land it. After supper he got his reward: permission to read a bound book, one with pages, him dressed in 
a pair of my surgical gloves and warned that I would clobber him if he got it dirty or tore a page. Llita wasn’t 
permitted to touch it; this was his prize. She sulked and didn’t even want to use the reading machine — until he 
asked if it was all right for him to read aloud to her. 

I ruled that she could even read it with him — as long as she didn’t touch it. So she snuggled up close, head by 
his, happy again, and started bossing him about turning the pages. 

The next day she asked me why she could not learn to fight, too? 

No doubt she was finding solo exercise a bore — I always found it so and did it only because it was needful to 
stay in shape — no telling what hazards next groundfall might bring. Minerva, I’ve never felt that women should 
have to fight; it is a male’s business to protect females and children. But a female should be able to fight 
because she may have to. 

So I agreed, but we had to change the rules. Joe and I had been working out by dockside rules — no rules, 
that is, save that I didn’t tell him that I planned not to do him any permanent damage and did not intend to let him 
give me anything worse than bruises. But I never said this — if he could manage it, he was free to gouge out one 
of my eyes and eat it. I just made damn sure that he didn’t. 

But females are built differently from males. I could not let Llita work out with us until I devised a plastron to 
protect her tits — necessary; she was a bit oversized in that department, and we could have hurt her without 



intending to. Then I told Joe privately that bruises were okay, but that if he broke one of her bones, I would break 
one of his, just for drill. 

But I put no restrictions on his sister — and I underestimated her; she was twice as aggressive as he was. 
Untrained but fast — and she meant business. 

The second day we worked out with her, not only was she wearing that plastron, her brother and I were 
wearing jockstraps. And Llita had been allowed to read a real book the night before. 

Joe turned out to have talent for cooking, so I encouraged him to be as fancy as ship’s stores permitted while 
crowding her to become an adequate cook. A man who can cook can support himself anywhere. But anyone, 
male or female, should be able to cook, keep house, and care for children. I hadn’t located a trade for Llita, 
although she displayed a talent for mathematics once I set up inducements for that, too. That was encouraging; a 
person who can read and write and has a head for math can learn anything she needs to know. So I started her 
on bookkeeping and accounting, from books, not helping her, and required Joe to learn to use all the tools the 
ship boasted — not many, mainly maintenance gear — and supervised him closely; I didn’t want him losing fingers 
or ruining tools. I was hopeful. Then the situation changed — 

(Circa 3,100 words omitted) 

— easy to say that I was stupid. I had raised stock and a good many children. Being ship’s surgeon as well as 
everything else, I had given them the most thorough examinations my equipment permitted when we were a 
couple of days out — quite thorough for those days; I had not practiced medicine after leaving Ormuzd but did 
keep my sick bay stocked and equipped, and picked up the latest tapes whenever I was on a civilized planet 
and studied them during long jumps. I was a good jackleg doctor, Minerva. 

The kids were as healthy as they looked, aside from slight dental caries in him, two small cavities. I noticed 
that the factor’s allegation about her was correct — virgo intacta, semilunar hymen, unfrayed, so I used my 
smallest speculum. She neither complained nor tensed up nor asked what I was looking for. I concluded that they 
had had regular checkups and other medical attention, far more than slaves on Blessed usually received. 

She had thirty-two teeth in perfect condition but could not tell me when the last four molars had erupted, just 
that it was “not long ago.” He had twenty-eight teeth and so little space in his jaw for adult molars that I 
anticipated trouble. But X-ray prints showed no buds. 

I cleaned and filled the cavities, and made note that he must have those fillings removed and the tissue 
regenerated on Valhalla, and be inoculated against further decay; Valhalla had good dentistry, far superior to 
what I could do. 

Llita could not tell me when she had last menstruated. She discussed it with Joe; he tried to counton his 
fingers how many days it had been since they had been taken from their home place, as they agreed that it was 
before that. I told her to let me know next time and each time, so that I could determine her cycle. I gave her a tin 
of napkins, emergency supplies I hadn’t known I had — must have been in the ship twenty years. 

She did tell me, and I had to open the tin for her; neither of them knew how. She was delighted with the little 
elastic panty included in the package, and often wore it when she did not need it, as “dress up.” The kid was 
crazy about clothes; as a slave she had never had a chance to pamper her vanity. I told her it was all right as long 
as she washed it every time she wore it — I clamped down hard on cleanliness, inspecting their ears, sending 
them from the table to scrub their nails, and so forth. They had received no more training than a hog. She never 
had to be told twice, and picked on him and made sure that he met my standards, too. I found myself being more 
exacting with myself; I could not bring dirty fingernails to the table or skip a shower because I was sleepy — I had 
set the standards and had to live up to them. 

She was almost as unskilled a seamstress as she was a cook, but she taught herself because she liked 
clothes. I dug out some bright-colored trade cloth and let her have fun — and used it as carrot-and-stick; wearing 
anything became a privilege that depended on good behavior. I put a stop that way — well, mostly — to her 
nagging her brother. 

That wouldn’t work with Joe; clothes did not interest him — but if he rated it, I gave him more of a working over 
during exercise period. Seldom — he was not the problem she was. 

One evening, three or four of her periods later, I noticed on my calendar that she was past due — having 
forgotten the matter. Minerva, I never walked into their staterooms without knocking; shipboard life required such 
privacy as can be managed — too little, that is. 

Her door was open, and her room was empty. I tapped on his door, got no answer, went on, looked for her in 



the wardroom and galley, even in our little gym. I decided that she must be taking a bath and I would speak to her 
in the morning. 

As I passed his stateroom again in heading back to my cabin, his door opened; she stepped out and closed 
it behind her. I said, “Oh, there you are!” or some such. “I thought Joe was asleep.” 

“He’s just gone to sleep,” Llita said. “Do you want him, Captain? Shall I wake him?” 

I said, “No, I was looking for you, but I tapped on his door five or ten minutes ago and got no answer.” 

She was contrite over not having heard my knock. “I’m sorry, Captain. I guess we were so busy we didn’t hear 
you.” She told me how they were busy — which I had figured out, having suspected it from the moment I noticed 
that she was a week overdue after being clock regular. “That’s understandable,” I said. “I’m glad my knock didn’t 
disturb you.” 

“We try never to disturb you with it, Captain,” she answered with sweet seriousness. “We wait till you go, to 
your cabin at night. Or sometimes when you take siesta.” 

I said, “Goodness, dear, you don’t have to be that careful. Do your work and keep your study hours, then do 
as you please the rest of the time. Starship ‘Libby’ is not a sweatship; I want you kids to be happy Can’t you get 
it through your fuzzy head that you are not a slave?” 

Apparently she could not, quite, Minerva, for she still fretted that she had not heard my knock and jumped to 
respond. I said, “Don’t be silly Llita. It will keep till tomorrow.” 

But she insisted she wasn't sleepy and was ready and anxious to do whatever I wanted — which made me a 
touch nervous. Minerva, one of the oddities about “Eros” is that women are never so willing as when they just 
have, and there was nothing in Llita’s background to inhibit her. Worse, I found that I was aware of her as a ripe 
female for almost the first time since the two came aboard — she was standing close to me in a narrow 
passageway carrying in one hand one of those weird costumes she delighted in making, and was a bit whiff 
from happy exercise. I was tempted — and felt certain that she would respond at once and happily. The thought 
crossed my mind that she was already pregnant — nothing to fret about. 

But I had gone to much trouble with these ephemerals to shift from slave owner to father figure, stern but 
loving. If I took her, I would lose that and, add one more disturbing variable a problem already too complex. So I 
grasped the nettle. 

Captain Sheffield said, “Very well, Llita. Come to my cabin.” He headed toward it, she followed. Once there, 
he offered her a seat. She hesitated, then put her gaudy dress down and sat on it — thoughtfulness that pleased 
him, as the ignorant animal she had been would not have been capable of it; the humanizing process was 
working. He did not comment. 

“Llita, your period is a week overdue, is it not?” 

“It is, Captain?” She seemed puzzled but not troubled. 

Sheffield wondered if he could be mistaken. After he had taught her how to open a sealed tin, he had turned 
overto her the limited emergency supply, warning her that if she used it too lavishly she would have to fashion by 
hand some make-do, as Valhalla was months away. Then he had dismissed the matter other than to log it on his 
desk calendar whenever she reported onset. Could he have failed to notice? There had been three days last 
week when he had kept to his cabin, leaving the young people on their own and having his meals sent in — a 
habit he had when he wanted to concentrate on a problem. During such periods he ate little and slept not at all 
and barely noticed anything not part of what he was studying. Nfes, it was possible. 

“Don’t you know, Llita? If you were on time, then you failed to report it.” 

“Oh, no, Captain!” She was round-eyed with distress. “>bu told me to tell you. . .and I have — every time, every 
time!” 

Further questions showed first, that despite her new grasp of arithmetic she did not know when she should 
have experienced onset, and second, that it had not been last week but a much longer time. 

Time to tell her — “Llita dear, I think you are going to have a baby.” 

Her mouth dropped open, again her eyes rounded. “Oh, wonderful '!” She added, “May I run tell Josie? May I, 
please? I’ll be right back!” 

“Wups! Don’t rush things. I said only that I thought so. Don’t get your hopes up yet, and don’t bother Joe with it 
till we know. Many a girl has gone much longer than a week past her date, and it didn’t mean a thing.” (But I’m 
pleased to learn that you want it, child, as it appears you’ve had every opportunity.) “Tomorrow I'll examine you 
and try to find out.” (What did he have aboard fora pregnancy test? Damn it, if he must abort her, it should be as 



quickly as possible when it’s no worse than plucking a splinter. Then — no, there wasn’t so much as a “Monday 
morning” pill in the ship, much less modern contraception. Woodie, blast your stupid soul, don’t ever go into 
space again so poorly equipped!) “In the meantime, don’t get excited.” (But women always did get excited by it. 
Of course.) 

She was as dashed as she had been jubilant. “We tried so hard! Everything in the Kama Sutra and more. I 
thought we ought to ask you to show us what we were doing wrong, but Joe was certain we were doing it right.” 

“I think Joe is correct.” Sheffield got up, poured a cup of wine for each of them while performing legerdemain 
which dosed hers such that she would go to sleep before long — after some relaxed talk that she might not 
remember; he wanted the full picture. “Here.” 

She looked at it. dubiously. “I’ll get silly. I know, I had a chance to try it once." 

“This isn’t the popskull they sell on Blessed; this is wine I fetched from Landfall. Pipe down and drink it. 

Here’s to your baby if you’re having one, or here’s to good luck next time.” (But howto handle that “next time”? 

— if his worries were well grounded. These kids must not be saddled with a defective. A healthy baby would be 
burden enough while they were learning to stand on their own feet. Could he stave things off to Valhalla, then get 
her on proper contraception? Then what? Split them up? HoW?) 

“Tell me about it, dear. When you came aboard, you were virgin.” 

“Oh, yes, certainly. They always kept me locked in that virgin’s basket. Except when they shut me up and 
Brother had to sleep in the barracks: You know. When I bleed.” She took a deep breath and smiled. “Now is ever 
so much nicer. Josie and I tried for the longest time to get around that awful steel basket. But we couldn’t. Hurt 
him to try, and some ways we tried hurt me, too. Finally we gave up and just did fun things we had always done. 
‘Brother said to be patient; it wouldn’t be forever. Because we knew we would be sold together, as a breeding 
pair.” 

Estrellita looked radiant. “And so we were and now we are, and thank you, Captain!” 

(No, it wasn’t going to be easy to split them up.) “Llita, have you ever thought of being bred by some other 
man than Joe?” (Sound her out, at least. It won’t be hard to find her a husband; she’s really quite attractive. That 
“Earth Mother” feeling.) 

She looked puzzled. “Why, of course not. We knew what we were, way back when we were almost babies. 
Our mother told us, and so did the priest. I’ve always slept with Brother, all my life. Why would I want anyone else? 

“\bu seemed ready enough to sleep with me. \fc>u claimed you were eager to.” 

“Oh! That’s different — that’s your right. But you didn’t v\ant me,” she added, almost accusingly. 

“That wasn’t quite it, Llita. There were reasons — that I won’t go into now — not to take you no matter if I wanted 
you and you were willing. Although it was Joe you really wanted, you said so.” 

“Well. . .yes. But I was disappointed just the same. I had to tell Brother you wouldn't have me — which hurt all 
over again. But he said to be patient. We waited three more days before he broached me. In case you changed 
your mind.” 

(Nagging wife vertically — docile horizontally. Not too uncommon a pattern, Sheffield thought.) 

He found that she was looking at him with sober interest. “Do you want me novy Captain? Joe told me, the 
very night he decided to go ahead, that it was still your right and always would be — and it is.” 

(Beelzebub’s brass balls! — the only way to avoid a willing female was to go off-planet.) “Dear, I’m tired, and 
you are getting sleepy.” 

She swallowed a yawn. “I’m not that tired — I never am. Captain, the night I first, asked you, I was a tiny bit 
scared. But I’m not scared now. I v\ant to. If you will.” 

“\bu’re very sweet, but I am very tired.” (Why hasn’t that dose taken hold?) He changed the subject. “Aren’t 
those little bunks almost impossible for two people?” 

She chuckled right through another yawn. “Almost. Once we fell out of Brother’s bunk. So now we use the 
deck." 

“The deck’? Why, Llita, that’s dreadful. We must do something about it” (Put the kids in here? The only full- 
sized bed in the ship — A bride needed a proper workbench for her honeymoon... which this was; she was 
deeply in love and should make the most of it, no matter what. Sheffield had decided, centuries back, that the 
saddest thing about ephemerals was that their little lives rarely held time enough for love.) 

“Oh, the deck isn’t bad, Captain; we’ve slept on the floor all our lives.” ‘She yawned again, could not suppress 
it. 



“Well... tomorrow we’ll make better arrangements.” (No, his cabin wouldn’t do; his desk was in here, and his 
papers and files. The kids would be in his way and he in theirs. Could he and Joe convert two narrow bunks into 
one double bed? Probably — although it would nearly fill one stateroom. No matter, that bulkhead between their 
rooms was not structural — cut a door and they would have a suite. A “bridal suite.” For a sweet bride. Yes.) He 
added, “Let’s get you to bed before you fall out of that chair. Everything’s going to be all right, dear.” (I’ll damned 
well see to it!) “And tomorrow night and from now on, you and Joe can sleep together in a wide bed.” 

“Really? Oh, that would be” — she yawned again — “lovely!” He had to steady her into her stateroom; she was 
asleep as she hit the bunk. Sheffield looked down at her, said softly, “Poor little kitten.” He leaned down and 
kissed her, went back to his cabin. 

There he dug out everything the slave factor had offered as proof of the alleged odd genetic heritage of Llita 
and Joe, and gave each item intense study. He was looking for clues to truth or falsity of the allegation that they 
were “mirror twins” — complementary diploids having the same mother and father. From such clues he hoped to 
estimate the probability of unfavorable gene reinforcement in any child Llita and Joe might have. 

The problem seemed to divide into three (simplified) cases: 

The two might be no relation to each other. Chance of a bad reinforcement: slight. 

Or they might be the usual sort of brother and sister. Chance of bad reinforcement: too high to be ignored. 

Or they might be (as alleged) zygotes resulting from complementary gametes — all genes conserved at 
reduction-division but with no duplication. In this case the chance of unfavorable reinforcement would be — what? 

Let that wait. First assumption, that they were no relation but simply raised together from babyhood — no 
special hazard, forget it. 

Second assumption, that they might be full siblings of the usual sort. Well, they did not look like it — but, more 
important, that scoundrel had set up a most elaborate “store” for such a swindle, and had used publicly the name 
of a bishop to back him up. The Bishop might be just as crooked (likely — he knew that priesthood too well!) — but 
why be so careless when slave babies were so cheap? 

No, even if he assumed a swindle, there was no reason to expect an unnecessary risk in a setup so 
elaborate. So forget that, too: Llita and Joe were not sister and brother’ in the ordinary sense — although they 
might have shared the same host-mother’s womb. The latter, if true, was of no genetic significance. 

So the remaining worry concerned the chance that the slave factor had told the truth — in which case what 
were the chances of a bad cross? How many ways could such artificially produced zygotes recombine 
unfavorably? 

Sheffield tried to set up the problem while cursing the lack of sufficient data, plus the fact that the only real 
computer in the ship was the piloting computer, which could not be programmed for a genetics problem. He 
wished Libby were aboard. Andy would have stared at the bulkhead a few minutes, then come up with answers 
definite where possible and expressed in probability percentages where not. 

A genetics problem, even with all pertinent data (many thousands!), was too unwieldy to solve without 
computer assistance. 

Well, try some simplified illustrative problems and see what insight could be gained. 

Primary assumption: Llita and Joe were “mirror twins” — genetically complementary zygotes from the same 
parent zygotes. 

Control assumption: They were unrelated other than being part of the home planet’s gene pool. (An extreme 
assumption, as slaves from the same area were likely to derive from a much smaller gene pool, which might be 
still further reduced by inbreeding. But this “most favorable normal breeding pattern” was the correct control 
against which he must measure.) 

Simplified example: Test one gene site — call it site 187 of the twenty-first chromosome-for reinforcement, 
masking, or elimination, of an assumed “bad” gene, undereach assumption. 

Arbitrary assumption: Since this site might hold an unfavorable gene — or two, or none — in its gene pair, 
assume that the chance was exactly the same for both primary and control assumptions, and even — i.e., 25 
percent no bad gene in the pair at the site, 50 percent one bad gene, 25 percent two bad genes — an extreme 
condition since, over the generations, reinforcement (two bad genes at one site) tended toward non-survival, 
either lethal or reducing a zygote’s ability to compete. Never mind; make it even for both of them — there were no 
data on which to base any better assumption. 

Wups! If a bad reinforcement was visibly demonstrated, or could be shown by tests, such zygotes would not 
be used. A scientist competent to attempt this experiment would use specimens as “clean” in a genetic sense as 



possible-free of all the hundreds (thousands now?) of identifiable hereditary defects; the primary assumption 
should include this subsidiary assumption. 

These young people were free of any defect Sheffield could detect in a shipboard examination — which 
enhanced the probability that this horsethief had told the truth and these exhibits were sober records of an exotic 
and successful experiment in gene manipulation. 

Sheffield now tended to believe that the experiment had taken place — and wished that he had the resources 
of a major Howard Clinic, say the one on Secundus, to give these kids a genetic going-over that he was not 
equipped to do aboard ship and not qualified to do in any case. 

One nagging doubt lay in how he had acquired these kids. Why had that gonif been so anxious to sell? If they 
were what the exhibits claimed? Why sell them when breeding the two created complements back together was 
the next step of the experiment? 

Well, perhaps the kids knew but he bad not asked the right questions. Certain it was that they had been 
brought up to believe that such was their proper destiny; whoever planned this had induced in the kids from 
earliest childhood a pair-bond stronger than most marriages, in Sheffield’s long experience. More than any of his 
own — (Except one, except one!) 

Sheffield put it out of his mind and concentrated on the theoretical consequences. 

At the selected site, each parent zygote had been assumed to have three possible states or gene pairs in 
probability 25-50-25. 

Under the control assumption, parents (diploid zygotes) both male and female would show this distribution at the 
selected site: 

25 % good-good (“clean” at that site) 

25% good-bad (bad gene masked but could be transmitted) 

25% good-bad (bad gene masked but could be transmitted) 

25% bad-bad (bad reinforcement — lethal or disabling) 

But under his modified primary assumption Sheffield assumed that the priest-scientist would discard bad 
stock as displayed in zygotes — which would eliminate the fourth group (“bad-bad”) and leave a parent-zygote 
distribution for this site of: 

33-1/3% good-good 
33-1/3% good-bad 
33-1/3% good-bad 

Such culling gave marked improvement over the original random-chance situation and meiotic division would 
produce gametes (both sperm and ova) in this incidence: 

Good, four out of six, and 

Bad, two out of six — 

— but with no way to detect the bad genes without destroying the gametes carrying them. Or so Sheffield 
assumed, while stipulating that the assumption might not be true forever. But to protect Llita (and Joe) it was 
necessary that his assumptions be pessimistic within the limits of available data and knowledge — i.e., that a bad 
gene could be spotted only as reinforcement in a zygote. 

Sheffield reminded himself that the situation was never as black-and-white as was implied by “good- 
dominant” and “bad-recessive” — these descriptions were less complex than the real world they were used to 
image. A characteristic exhibited by an adult zygote was prosurvival or contrasurvival only in terms of what and 
when and where — and also in terms of more than one generation. An adult who died saving its progeny had to 
be counted a prosurvival whereas a cat that ate her own young was contrasurvival no matter how long she lived. 

In the same vein, a dominant gene sometimes was of no importance one way or the other — e.g., brown eyes. 
Just as its corresponding recessive when paired and thereby reinforced to produce blue eyes gave the zygote 
exhibiting it no measurable disadvantage. The same was true of many other in-heritable characteristics — hair 
patterns, skin color, et cetera. 

Nevertheless this description — good-dominant, bad-recessive — was in essence correct; it svnopsized the 



mechanisms by which a race conserved its favorable mutations and destroyed (eventually) its unfavorable 
mutations. “Bad-dominant” was almost a contradiction in terms, as a thoroughly bad mutation which was 
dominant killed itself off (along with the unfortunate zygote inheriting it) in one generation, either lethal in womb or 
so damaging to the zygote that it failed to reproduce. 

But the usual weeding process involved bad-recessives. These could remain in the gene pool until one of two 
events happened, each controlled by the blind laws of chance: Such a gene could pair with a gene like it when 
sperm fertilized ovum and thereby eliminate itself by eliminating the zygote — hopefully before birth, or — tragically 
— after birth. Or this bad-recessive might be eliminated by chromosome reduction at meiosis and the result 
would be a healthy baby who did not carry this bad gene in its gonads — a happy outcome. 

Both these statistical processes slowly weeded out bad genes from the race’s gene pool. 

Unfortunately the first of these processes often produced babies viable but so handicapped they needed 
help to stay alive-sometimes needing economic help, born losers, who never managed to support themselves; 
sometimes needing plastic surgery or endocrine therapy or other interventions or supports. When Captain Aaron 
Sheffield had been practicing medicine (on Ormuzd and under another name), he had gone through stages of 
increasing frustration over these poor unfortunates. 

At first he had tried to practice therapy by the Hippocratic Oath — or close to it; he was by temperament 
unable to follow any man-made rule blindly. 

Then he had had a period of temporary mental aberrance during which he had sought a political solution to 
what he saw as a great danger: reproduction by defectives. He tried to persuade his colleagues to refuse 
therapy to hereditary defectives unless they were sterile or sterilized or willing to accept being sterilized as a 
precondition for receiving therapy. Worse yet, he had attempted to include in the definition of “hereditary 
defective” those who displayed no stigmata save that they had never managed to be self-supporting- — on a 
planet not overcrowded and which he himself had selected centuries earlier as nearly ideal for human beings. 

He got nowhere, he encountered nothing but fury and contempt — save for a few colleagues who agreed with 
him privately and denounced him publicly. As for laymen, tar-and-feathers was the mildest medicine they 
prescribed for Dr. “Genocide.” 

When his license to practice was lifted, Lazarus regained his normal emotional detachment. He shut up, 
realizing that, grim old Mother Nature, red of tooth and claw, invariably punished damfools who tried to ignore 
Her or to repeal Her ordinances; he need not interfere. 

So he moved and changed his name again and started to get ready to go off-planet — when a plague hit 
Ormuzd. He had shrugged and gone back to work, an unfrocked physician whose services were temporarily 
welcome. Two years and a quarter of a billion deaths later he was offered his license back — subject to good 
behavior. 

He told them what to do with that license and left Ormuzd as quickly as possible, eleven year later. He was a 
professional gambler during that wait, that being the handiest way he could see at the time for saving up the 
necessary. 

Sorry, Minerva, I was talking about those mirror twins. So the silly little wench was knocked up, which caused 
me to slip back into my baby-cotching, country-doctor persona, and I stayed up all night worrying about her and 
her brother and the baby they were going to have — unless I did something about it. To find out what I should do, I 
had to reconstruct what had happened and from that what could happen. Having no certain data, I had to follow 
that old rule for finding a lost mule. 

First I had to think like that slave factor — A man who auctions slaves is a scoundrel but too smart to risk a 
caper in which he might wind up a slave himself, or dead if he was lucky — which is what would happen to one 
who played fast and loose on Blessed with the authority of a bishop. Ergo, the scoundrel had believed what he 
had said. 

That being so, I could table the question of why this factor was commissioned to sell these two, while I tried to 
think like a priest-scientist engaged in human biological experimentation. Forget the chance that these two were 
ordinary siblings — no point in picking such a pair even for a swindle. Forget the chance that they were unrelated 
in any fashion, as in such a case it would simply be a normal case of breeding. Sure, sure, any woman, can give 
birth to a monster, as even with the most genetically hygienic of breeding a bad mutation can show up — and an 
alert midwife may neglect to give that first lifegiving spank — and many have. 

So I considered only the third hypothesis: complementary diploids from the same parents. What would this 



experimenter do? What-would / do? 

I would use as near perfect stock as I could find and not start the experiment until I had both a male and a 
female parent who tested “clean” genetically in the most subtle ways for which I could test — which on Blessed 
meant quite sophisticated ways, for that century. 

For a selected gene site and an assumption of 50-50 in the Mendelian distribution of 25-50-25, this pre- 
experiment testing would chop off the 25 percent chance of reinforcement of a bad recessive and leave a 
distribution of one-third bad, two-thirds good, at the parent generation — possible parents of possible Joes and 
Llitas, that is. 

Now I start putting together mirror twists in my persona as a priest-experimenter. What happens? If we 
consider the minimum number of gametes needed to represent this one-third and two-thirds distribution, we get 
eighteen possible “Joes,” eighteen possible “Llitas” — but in both male and female two of them show up as “bad” 
— the bad recessive has reinforced and the zygote is defective; the experimenter eliminates them. . .or he may 
not need to; the reinforcement may be lethal. 

We wind up at this point with an 8 & 1/3 percent improvement, or a total improvement of 25 percent in 
favorable chances for Llita’s baby. I felt better. If you add the fact that I am the sort of a midwife who is too busy 
helping the mother to stop to spank a monster, the favorable chances went way up. 

But all that this shows is that bad genes tend to be eliminated at each generation — with the tendency 
greatest with the worst genes and reaching 1 00 percent whenever reinforcement produces a lethal-in-womb 
— while favorable genes are conserved. But we knew that — and it applies also to normal outbreeding and 
even — more strongly to inbreeding, although the latter is not well thought of for humans as it hikes up the 
chances of a defective by precisely the same amount that it weeds — that being the hazard, that I was afraid offer 
Llita. Everybody wants the human gene pool cleaned up, but nobody wants its tragic aspects to take place in his 
own family. Minerva, I was beginning to think of these kids as “my family.” 

I still did not know anything about “mirror twins.” 

I decided to investigate a more probable incidence of bad recessives at a given site. Fifty-fifty is far too high 
for a really bad gene; the weeding is drastic, and the incidence drops to a lower percentage each generation, 
until the incidence of a particular bad gene is so low that reinforcement at fertilization is a rare event, as 
reinforcement is the square of the incidence; e.g., if one-in-a-hundred haploids carry this bad gene, then it will be 
reinforced one-in-ten-thousand fertilizations. I speak of the total gene pool, or in this case a minimum of two 
hundred adult zygotes, female and male; random breeding in such a pool will, bring together that bad 
reinforcement only by that long chance — a chance happy or unhappy depending on whether you look at it 
impersonally in terms of -cleaning the gene pool or personally in terms of individual human tragedy. 

I looked at it very personally; I wanted Llita to have a healthy baby. 

Minerva. I’m sure you recognized that 25-50-25 distribution as representing the most drastic case of 
inbreeding, one which can happen only half the time with tine breeding, only a quarter of the time with full 
siblings, in both cases through chromosome reduction at meiosis. A stockbreeder uses this drastic measure 
regularly — and culls the defectives and winds up with a healthy stabilized line. I have a nasty suspicion that such 
culling after inbreeding was sometimes used among royalty back, on old Earth — but certainly such culling was 
not used often enough or drastically enough. Royalism might work quite well if kings and queens were treated 
like racehorses — but regrettably they never were. Instead, they were propped up like welfare clients, and 
princelings who should have been culled were encouraged to breed like rabbits — bleeders, feebleminded, you 
name it. When I was a kid, “royalty” was a bad joke based on the worst possible breeding methods. 

Captain Sheffield investigated next a lower incidence of a bad gene: Assume a lethal gene in the gene pool 
from which Joe and Llita’s parents were derived. Being lethal, it could exist in an adult zygote only if it was 
masked in gene-pair by its benign twin. Assume a 5 percent masked incidence in zygotes — still too high to be 
realistic for a lethal gene but check, it anyhow. What trend would show? 

Parent zygote generation: 1 00 females, 1 00 males, each a possible parent for Llita and for Joe — and 5 of 
the females and 5 of the males carry the lethal gene, masked. 

Parent haploid stage: 200 ova, 5 of which carry the lethal gene; 200 spermatozoa, 5 of which carry the lethal 
gene. 

Son-and-daughter zygote generation (possible “Joes” and possible “Llitas”): 25 dead through reinforcement 
of lethal gene; 1 ,950 carrying the lethal gene masked; 38,025 “clean” at that site. 



Sheffield noted that a hypothetical hermaphrodite had crept in through not doubling his sample size in order 
to avoid anomaly through odd numbers, Oh, the hell with! — it did not change the statistical outcome. No, do it! 

— start with a sample of 200 males and 200 females with the same lethal-gene incidence for that site. This gave 
him: 

400 ova, 1 0 with the lethal gene; 

400 spermatozoa, 10 with that lethal gene — 

— which gave in the next zygote generation (possible “Joes” and “Llitas”): 100 dead, 7,800 carriers, 152,100 
“clean” — which changed no percentages but got rid of that imaginary hermaphrodite. Sheffield considered 
briefly the love life of an hermaphrodite, then got back to work. The numbers became very cumbersome, jumping 
to the billions in the next zygote generation (i.e., Little Nameless, now just started in Llita’s belly) — I 5,210,000 
culled by reinforcement, 1 .216.800,000 carriers, 24,336,000,000 “clean” — and again he wished for a clinic 
computer and tediously converted the unhandy numbers into percentages: 0.059509 percent, 4.759 percent, 
95.18 percent plus. 

This showed a decided improvement: approximately 1 defect out of 1 ,680 (instead of 1 out of 1 ,600), the 
percentage of carriers decreased to below 5 percent and the number of “clean” increased to above 95 percent 
in one generation. 

Sheffield worked several such problems to confirm what he had seen by inspection: A child from 
complementary diploids (“mirror twins”) had at least as much chance of being healthy as did the offspring of 
unrelated strangers — plus the happy fact that such a baby’s chances were improved by culling at one or more 
stages by the priest-scientist who had initiated the experiment — an almost certain assumption and one that 
made Joe the best possible mate for his “sister” rather than the worst. 

Lilta could have her baby. 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
VII 


Valhalla to Landfall 


— the best I could for them, Minerva. Every so often some idiot tries to abolish marriage. Such attempts work 
as well as repealing the law of gravity, making pi equal to three point zero, or moving mountains by prayer. 
Marriage is not something thought up by priests and inflicted on mankind; marriage is as much a part of 
mankind’s evolutionary equipment as his eyes, and as useful to the race as eyes are to an individual. 

Surely, marriage is an economic contract to provide for children and to take care of mothers while they bear 
kids and bring them up — but it is much more than that. It is the means this animal, Homo sap., has evolved 
— quite unconsciously — for performing this indispensable function and be happy while doing so. 

Why do bees split up into queens, drones, and workers, then live as one big family? Because, for them, it 
works. How is it that fish do okay with hardly a nodding acquaintance between mama fish and papa fish? 
Because the blind forces of evolution made that way work for them. Why is it that “marriage” — by whatever name 
— is a universal institution among human beings everywhere? Don’t ask a theologian, don't ask a lawyer; this 
institution existed long before it was codified by church or state. It works, that’s all; for all its faults it works far 
better by the only universal test — survival — than any of the endless inventions that shallow-pates over the 
millennia have tried to substitute for it. 

I am not speaking monogamy; I mean all forms of marriage — monogamy, polyandry, polygyny, plural and 
extended marriages with various frills. “Marriage” has endless customs, rules, arrangements. But it is “marriage” 
if-and-only-if the arrangement both provides for children and compensates the adults. For human beings, the only 
acceptable compensation for the drawbacks of marriage lies in what men and women can give each other. 

I don't mean “Eros,” Minerva. Sex baits the trap, but sex is not marriage, nor is it reason enough to stay 
married. Why buy a cow when milk is cheap? 

Companionship, partnership, mutual reassurance, someone to laugh with and grieve with, loyalty that 
accepts foibles, someone to touch, someone to hold your hand — these things are “marriage,” and sex is but the 
icing on the cake. Oh, that icing can be wonderfully tasty — but it is not the cake. A marriage can lose that tasty 
“icing” — say, through accident — and still go on and on and on, giving deep happiness to those who share it. 

When I was a rutty and ignorant youngster, this used to puzzle, me — 

(Omitted) 


— as solemnly ceremonious as I could swing. Man lives by symbols; I wanted them to remember this 
occasion. I bad Llita dress in her notion of fanciest best. She looked like a bloomin' Christmas tree, but I told her 
she looked beautiful — which she did; brides can’t help it. Joe I dressed in some of my clothes and gave them to 
him. Me I dressed in a preposterous ship’s-captain uniform, one I, had for use on planets where such nonsense 
is, customary — four wide gold stripes on my cuffs, chest spangled with decorations bought in hockshops, a 
cocked hat Admiral Lord Nelson would have envied, and the rest as fancy as any grand master of a lodge. 

I preached 'em a sermon loaded with solemn amphigory most of it lifted from the only church they knew, the 
established religion of Blessed — easy for me, having been a priest there myself — but I added all sorts of things, 
telling her what she owed him, telling him what he owed her, telling them both what they owed the child in her 
belly and the other children they would have — and tacked on, for both but primarily for her, a warning that 
marriage was not easy, not to be entered into lightly, because there would be troubles, they must face together, 
grave troubles that would require the courage of the Cowardly Lion, the wisdom of the Scarecrow, the loving 
heart of the Tin Woodsman, and the indomitable gallantry of Dorothy. 

That got her to weeping, so Joe started to drip tears — which was just what I wanted, so I had 'em kneel and 
prayed over them. 



Minerva, I make no apology for hypocrisy. I didn’t care whether some hypothetical God heard me or not; I 
wanted Llita and Joe to hear it — first in that jargon of Blessed, then in English and Galacta, then topped it off by 
intoning as many lines of the Aeneid as I could remember. When I got stuck I closed with a schoolboy song: 

Omme bene 
Sine poena , 

Tempus est ludendi; 

Venit hora 
Absque mora, 

Libros deponendi!* 

(* All is well 

Without punishment, 

The time is for playing; 

Comes the hour 

Without delay 

For laying (school) books down. 

Purists will see that the Senior gave this jingle a poor translation. But one wonders why he did not continue in 
the same vein with the cheerfully bawdy triple pun available in the last line by substituting “liberos” for “libros”? 
That he could have missed it seems out of character. Our Ancestor’s capric disposition is everywhere evident; 
his occasional professions of asceticism have at best a hollow ring. J.F. 45 th ) 

— and ended with ‘a resounding “So mote it be!” Had 'em stand, take each other’s hands, and declared that, 
by the supreme authority vested in me as master of a vessel in space, they were nowand forever husband and 
wife — kiss her, Joe. 

All to a muted ‘background of Beethoven’s Ninth — That doggerel got in by accident when I had run out of 
“punishment lines” of Virgil and needed a few more impressive sounds. But when I thought about it later, I saw 
that it translated as appropriately for their honeymoon as for a school holiday. All was indeed well, now that I 
knew that this joining of siblings could take place sine poena — without fear of genetic punishment. And ludendi 
translates as “amorous play” or “Eros” as readily as “gambling” or “children’s play” or any other frolic. And I had 
declared a four-day ship’s holiday, no work for them, no study hours — libros deponendi — starting at once. Sheer 
accident, Minerva. It was simply a bit of Latin verse that came into my head and Latin is majestic, especially 
when you don’t understand it. 

We had a fancy supper, cooked by me, that lasted about ten minutes — for them. Llita could not eat, and Joe 
reminded me of Johnny’s wedding night and why his mother-in-law fainted. So I piled a tray with tasty rations and 
handed it to Joe, and told 'em to get lost; I didn’t want to see hide nor hair of ’em for four days — 

(Omitted) 

— on to Landfall as fast as I could pick a cargo. I could not leave them on Valhalla; Jose was not yet able to 
support a family, and Llita was going to be limited in what she could do, either pregnant or with a new baby. Nor 
would I be on hand to pick ‘em up if they fell down; they hadio go to Landfall. 

Oh, Llita could have survived on Valhalla, because there they have the healthy attitude that a pregnant woman 
is prettier than the other sort and that the farther along she is, the more beautiful she is — true in my opinion and 
especially true in Llita’s case. She had been passable when I bought her; when we grounded at Valhalla, she 
was almost five months gone and radiantly beautiful. If she went dirtside unescorted,, the first six men she 
encountered would want to marry her. If she had had one on her back as well as one in her belly, she could have 
married well the day we arrived; fertility was respected there and the planet wasn’t half filled up. 

I didn’t think she would jilt Joe that quickly, but I did not want her head turned by too much male attention. I did 
not want to risk even an outside chance that Llita might leave him for some wealthy bourgeois or freeholder; I 
had gone to much trouble to build up Joe’s ego, but it was still fragile and such a blow could kill it. He was 
standing tall and proud now — but his pride was based on being a married man, with a wife, and a child on the 



way. Did I mention that I had given them one of my names on their marriage certificate? They were now Friherr 
og Frei Lang, Josef og Stjerne, for the duration of our stay on Valhalla, and I wanted them to remain. Mr. and Mrs. 
Long for some years at least. 

Minerva, I had them take lifetime vows never believing that they would keep them. Oh, ephemerals often stay 
married for life, but as for the rest — you don’t find feathers on frogs very often, and Llita was a naive, friendly, 
sexy little tart whose short heels would cause her to trip and land with her legs open without planning it — I could 
see it coming. I did not want it to happen before I had a chance to indoctrinate Joe. Horns need not give a man a 
headache. But he does need time to grow up and mellow and acquire self-confidence before he can wear them 
with tolerance and dignity — and Llita was just the girl who could outfit him with a fine rack of antlers. I got him a 
job, pearl diver and handyman in a small gourmet restaurant, with a side arrangement for pay-me’s to the chef 
for every Valhalla dish Joe learned to cook correctly. In the meantime I kept her aboard on the excuse that a 
pregnant woman could not risk the nasty weather until I could get her proper clothing — and don’t bother me now, 
dear; I’ve got cargo to worry about. 

She took it well enough, pouting just a little. She didn’t like Valhalla anyhow; it has one-and-a-seventh gee 
and I had got them used to the luxury of free-fall- — easy on her swelling belly, no strain on her arches or her 
swelling tits. Now she suddenly found herself much heavier than she had ever been, awkward, and with unhappy 
feet. What she could see of Valhalla from the entrance lock looked like a frozen slice of hell; she was pleased by 
my offer to take them on to Landfall. 

Still, Valhalla was the only new place she had ever been; she wanted to see it. I stalled while I got cargo 
unloaded, then took her measurements and got her one warm outfit in local style but I played her a dirty trick; I 
fetched back three pairs of boots and let her take her choice. Two pairs were plain work boots; the third pair 
was gaudy — and half a size too small. 

So when I did take her groundside, she was wearing too-tight boots, and the weather was unusually cold and 
blustery — I had watched the predictions. Torheim is pretty in spots, as sky-port cities go — but I avoided those 
parts and took her “sightseeing” in dull neighborhoods — on foot. By the time I flagged a sleigh and took her back 
to the ship, she was miserable, and glad to get out of uncomfortable clothes, especially the boots, and into a hot 
bath. 

I offered to take her into town next day but left her free to refuse. She declined politely. 

(Omitted) 

— not quite that bad, Minerva; I simply wanted to keep her in purdah without arousing her suspicions. Actually 
I had bought two pairs of those gaudy boots, one pair her correct size — and switched them on her at the end of 
that first day, while she was soaking her poor, tired feet. Later I suggested that her trouble had been that she had 
never worn shoes or boots in her life — so why not wear them around the ship until she got the hang of it? 

So she did and was surprised at how easy it was. I explained with a straight face that her feet bad swelled 
the first time, so take it easy, an hour today, a little more each day, until she felt comfortable in them all daylong. 

In a week she was wearing them even if she wore nothing else; she was more comfortable in them than 
barefooted — not surprising as they were arch-support footwear I had picked most carefully — between 
pregnancy and the difference in surface gravity of the two planets — point ninety-five gee for her home planet; one 
point fourteen for Valhalla — she weighed about twenty kilos more than she ever had in her life; she needed 
contoured foot supports. 

I had to caution her not to wear them to bed. 

I took her to town a couple of times while I was selecting cargo, but I coddled her — not much walking or 
standing around. She came along when I invited her but was always willing to stay aboard and read. 

In the meantime Joe worked long hours, only one day off in seven. So just before we left, I had him quit his job 
and I took my kids on a proper holiday; a sleigh hired for the day, with reindeer instead of power, sightseeing that 
was truly sightseeing on a clear, sunny day that was almost warm, lunch in the country at a fine restaurant with a 
view of snow-covered crags of Jotunheimen range, dinner at a still finer restaurant in the city, one with live music 
and entertainment as well as superb food — and a stop for tea at the little gourmet spot where Joe had labored 
so that he could be addressed as “Friherr Lang” by our host, instead of “Hey, you!” — and have a chance to show 
off his beautiful, bulging bride. 

And beautiful she was, Minerva. On Valhalla both sexes wear, under heavy outdoor clothes, indoor clothes 



that are essentially pajamas. The difference between those worn by women and by men lies in material, cut, and 
such. I had bought one party outfit for each of them. Joe looked smart and so did I, but all eyes were on Llita. She 
was covered from shoulders to boots — but only technically. The cloth of that harem outfit shimmered with 
changing lights, orange and green and gold, without obstructing the view. Anyone who cared to look could see 
that her nipples were crinkled with excitement — and everyone cared to look. That she clearly had only a couple of 
months to go gave her a large bonus vote toward being picked as “Miss Valhalla.” 

She looked grand and knew it, and her face showed her happiness. She was self-confident, too, as I had 
coached her in local table manners, and how to stand and how to sit and how to behave and such, and she had 
already got through lunch without a bobble. 

It was all right to let her display herself and enjoythe silent, or sometimes not silent, applause; not only were 
we leaving right away, but also Joe and I had our knives in sight in our boot tops. True, Joe was no knife fighter. 
But the wolves there didn’t know that, and not one was inclined to bother our beautiful bitch when she was 
flanked by wolves of her own. 

— early next morning despite a short night. We loaded all day long, with Llita handling manifests and Joe 
checking numbers while I made sure I wasn’t being robbed. Late that night I had us in n-space, with my pilot 
computer sniffing out the last decimal places for the first leg to Landfall. I set the gravistat to bring us slowly down 
from Valhalla surface-normal to a comfortable quarter gee — no more free-fall until Llita had her baby — then 
locked the control room and headed down to my cabin, stinking and tired and trying to kid myself that tomorrow 
was soon enough for a bath. 

Their door was open — their bedroom door, the room that had been Joe’s before I turned their rooms into a 
suite. Door open and them in bed — they had never done that before. 

I soon learned why. They piled out of bed and paddled toward me; they wanted me to join their fun — they 
wanted to thank me... for that party day, for buying them, for everything else. His idea? Hers? Both? I didn't try to 
find out; I just thanked them and told them that I was whipped to the red, worn out, and dirty — all I wanted was 
soap and hot water and twelve hours of shut-eye — and for them to sleep late; we’d set up ship’s routine after we 
were rested. 

I did let them bathe me and massage me to sleep. That did not break discipline; I had taught them a bit about 
massage, and Joe in particular had a firmly gentle touch; he had been massaging her daily during her pregnancy 
— even while working long hours in that restaurant. 

But, Minerva, had I not been so bushed, I might have broken my rule about dependent females. 

(Omitted) 

— every tape, every book available in Torheim for a refresher in obstetrics and gynecology, plus instruments 
and supplies I had not expected to need aboard ship. I kept to my cabin until I had mastered all new art and was 
at least as skilled in baby-cotching as I had been as a country doctor on Ormuzd long before. 

I kept a close eye on my patient, watched her diet, made her exercise, checked her gizzards daily — and 
permitted no-undue familiarity. 

Dr. Lafayette Hubert, MD, aka Captain Aaron Sheffield aka The Senior, et al., worried excessively over his 
one patient. But he kept her and her husband from seeing it and applied his worry constructively in planning for 
every obstetric emergency known to the art at that time. Hardware and supplies he had obtained on Valhalla 
paralleled in every major respect the equipment of Frigg Temple in Torheim, where fifty births a day were not 
uncommon. 

He smiled to himself at the mass of junk he had taken aboard, recalling a country doctor on Ormuzd who had 
delivered many a baby with nothing but bare hands, while the mother sat in her husband’s lap, knees pulled high 
and wide by her husband so that old Doc Hubert could kneel in front of them and catch the baby. 

True — but he had always had with him all the gear a husky pacing borri could tote, even though he might 
never open a saddlebag if everything went right. That was the point: to have the stuff at hand if things did not go 
right. 

One item purchased in Torheim was not for emergency: the latest improved-model delivery chair — hand 
grips, padded support arms; leg, foot, and back supports adjustable independently in three axes of translation 
and rotation with controls accessible both to midwife and patient, quick-release restraints. It was a marvelously 



flexible piece of mechanical engineering to enable the mother to position herself — or be positioned — so that her 
birth canal was vertical and as wide open as possible at the moment of truth. 

Dr. Hubert-Sheffield had it set up in his cabin, checked its many adjustments before signing for it — then 
looked at it and frowned. A good gadget, and he had paid its high price without a quiver. But it had no love in it; it 
was as impersonal as a guillotine. 

A husband’s arms, a husband’s lap, were not as efficient — but there was much to be said, in his opinion, for 
having parents go through the ordeal together, she with her husband’s arms holding her, comforting her, while he 
gave both muscular and emotional support that left the midwife free to concentrate on physical aspects. 

A husband who had done this had no doubt that he was a father. Even if some passing stranger had slipped 
her the juice, such fact became irrelevant, swallowed up bythis greater experience. 

So how about it, Doc? This gadget? Or Joe’s arms? Did the kids need this second “marriage ceremony”? 
Could Joe take it, physically and emotionally? There was no doubt that Llita was the more rugged member of the 
team although Joe outmassed her even when she was near term. What if Joe fainted and dropped her — at the 
exact wrong, instant? 

Sheffield worried these matters while he led auxiliary controls from the gravistat in the control room to the 
delivery chair. He had decided that, nuisance though it was, his cabin had to be the delivery room; it was the only 
compartment with enough deck space, a bed at hand, and its own bath. Oh, well, he could stand the nuisance of 
squeezing past the pesky thing to reach his desk and wardrobe for the next fifty days — sixty at the outside, if he 
had Llita’s date of conception right and had judged her progress correctly. Then he could disassemble it and 
stow it. 

Perhaps he could sell it at a profit on Landfall; it was in advance of the art there, he felt sure. 

He positioned the chair, bolted it to the deck, ran it up to maximum height, placed its midwife’s stool in front 
of it, adjusted the stool until he was comfortable in it, found he could lower the delivery chair ten or twelve 
centimeters and still have room to work. That done, he climbed into the delivery chair and fiddled with its 
adjustments — found that it could be made to fit even a person of his height — predictable; some women on 
Valhalla were taller than he was. 

Minerva, by my figures Llita was about ten days late — which did not worry them, as I had been carefully vague 
about it, and worried me only a touch, as she checked out normal and healthy in all respects. I prepared them not 
only with instruction and drill, but also with hypnosis, and had prepared her with exercises designed to make it as 
easy on her as possible — I dislike postpartum repairs; that canal should stretch, not tear. 

What was really fretting me was possibility that I was going to have to break the neck of a monster, Kill a 
baby, I mean — I shouldn’t dodge the blunt truth. All calculations I had done one sleepless night still left this 
chance open — and if I had been wrong in any assumption, the chance might be higher than I like to think about. 

If I had to do it, I wanted to get it over with. 

I was far more worried than she was. I don’t think she worried at all; I had worked hard on that hypnotic 
preparation. 

If I had to do this grisly thing, I was going to have to do it fast, while their attentions were elsewhere — then 
never let them see it and space the pitiful remains at once. Then tackle the horrid job of trying to put them back 
together emotionally. As a married couple? I did not know. Maybe I would have an opinion after I saw what she 
was carrying. 

At last her contractions were coming close together, so I had them get into the delivery chair — easy, one- 
quarter gravity. The chairwas already adjusted, and they were used to the position, from drill. Joe climbed in, sat 
with his thighs stretched wide, knees over the rests, heels braced — not too comfortable as he was not 
angleworm-limber the way she was. Then I picked her up and sat her in his lap — no trouble, she weighed less 
than forty pounds at that pseudo-acceleration. Call it eighteen kilos. 

She spread her legs almost in a horizontal split and scooted forward in his lap while Joe kept her from falling 
between his thighs. “Is that far enough, Captain?” she asked. 

“Just fine,” I said. The chair might have positioned her a touch better — but she would not have had Joe’s 
arms around her. I had never told them that there was any other way to do it. “Give her a kiss, Joe, while I get the 
straps.” 

Left knee strap around both their left knees together, same for right knees, and with her feet braced on 
additional supports I had added — chest and shoulder and thigh straps on him so firmly that he would stay in that 



chair even if the ship fell apart, but no such straps on her. Her hands on the hand grips, while his hands and arms 
were a living, warm, and loving safety belt, just under her tits, just over the bulge but not on it. He knew how, we 
had practiced. If I wanted pressure on her belly, I would tell him — otherwise leave well enough alone. 

My stool was bolted to the deck, I had added a seat belt. As I strapped myself down, I reminded them that we 
had a rough ride coming — and this we had not been able to practice; it would have risked miscarriage. “Lock 
your fingers, Joe, but let her breathe. Comfortable, Llita?” 

“Uh — ” she said breathlessly. “I — I’m starting another one!” 

“Bear down, dear!” I made sure my left foot - was positioned for the gravistat control and watched her belly. 

Big one! As it peaked, I switched from one-quarter gravity up to two gravities almost in one motion — and Llita 
let out a yip and the baby squirted like a watermelon seed right into my hands. 

I dragged my foot back to allow the gravistat to put us back on low gee even as I made a nearly 
instantaneous inspection of the brat. A normal boy, red and wrinkled and ugly — so I slapped his tochis and he 
bawled. 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
VIII 


Landfall 


(Omitted) 

— girl I had intended to marry had married again and had another baby. Not surprising; I had been off Landfall 
two standard years. Not tragic, either, as we had been married once about a hundred years earlier. Old friends. 
So I talked it over with her and her new husband, then married one of her granddaughters, one not descended 
from me. Both gals Howards, of course, and Laura, the one I married that time, being of the Foote Family* (* 
Correction: Hedrick Family. This woman Laura (one of the ancestors of the undersigned) did carry the surname 
“Foote” under the archaic patriliheal tradition — a source of confusion in old records, as the more logical 
matrilineal system has always been used in the Families in assigning clan membership. But the genealogies 
were not revised to show this until Gregorian Year 3307. This misnomer offers a means of dating this memoir 
. . .were it not that other records show that reindeer were not introduced onto Valhalla until approximately a 
century and a half after the date that the Senior — beyond question — did marry Laura Foote-Hedrick. 

But more interesting is the Senior’s allegation that he used a pseudogravity field in thatyearto facilitate 
childbirth. Was he the first tocologist to use this (now standard) method? Nowhere does he assert this, and the 
technique - is usually associated with Dr. Virginius Briggs of Secundus Howard Clinic and a much later date. J.F. 
45 th ) 

We were a good match, Minerva; Laura was twenty, and I was freshly rejuvenated and holding my cosmetic 
age at the early thirties. We had several children — nine, I think — then she got bored with me forty-odd years 
later, and wanted to marry my 5th/7th cousin* * (* *And descended from the Senior as well (through Edmund 
Hardy 2099-2259) although the Senior may not have been aware of it. J.F. 45 th ) Roger Sperling — which did not 
grieve me as I was getting restless as a country squire. Anyhow, when a woman wants to go, let her go. I stood 
up for her at their wedding. 

Roger was surprised to learn that my plantation was not community property. Or possibly did not think that I 
would hold Laura to the marriage settlement she had signed — but that wasn’t the first time I had been wealthy; I 
had learned. It took a tedious suit to convince him that Laura owned her wedding dower plus appreciation, not 
those thousands of hectares that were mine before I married her. In many ways it is simpler to be poor. 

Then I shipped out again. 

But this is about my kids who weren’t really mine. Before we reached Landfall, Joseph Aaron Long looked 
more like a cherub and less like a monkey but was still young enough to wet on anyone reckless enough to pick 
him up — which his grandpappy did, several times a day. I was fond of him; he was not only a merry baby but was 
also, to me, a most satisfying triumph. 

By the time we grounded, his father had shaped up into a really good cook. 

Minerva, I could have set those kids up in style; that was as profitable a triangle trip as I ever made. But you don’t 
cause ex-slaves to stand tall and free and proud by giving them things. What I did was to enable them to get out 
and scratch. Like this — I credited them with half-time apprentice wages, Blessed to Valhalla, on the assumption 
that their other half-time was taken up by studies. This I had Llita figure in Valhalla kroner, at Valhalla wage rates. 

I had her add to this Joe’s wages as kitchen help on Valhalla, minus what he had spent there. This total was 
credited to them as a share in cargo on the third leg, Valhalla to Landfall — which amounted to less than one-half 
of 1 percent of that cargo. I made Llita work this out. 

To this we added ship’s-cook wages for Joe, Valhalla to Landfall, payable in Landfall bucks at Landfall wage 
scales — but only as wages not as a share in cargo. I had to explain to Llita why Joe’s wages for that leg could 
not be invested retroactively in cargo lifted at Valhalla. Once she understood it, she had a grasp of the notions of 
venture and risk and profit — but I did not pay her for this accounting I was durned if I would pay purser’s wages to 
figure her own money when I was not only having to check everything she did but was giving her a lesson in 



economics as well. 

I did not pay Llita for the leg to Landfall; she was a passenger, busy having a baby and then still busier 
learning to care for it. But I did not charge her for passage; she deadheaded. 

You see what I was doing — rigging the accounts so that I would owe them something once I sold my cargo, 
while making it appear that they had earned it. They hadn’t been worth any wages; on the contrary I had spent 
quite a chunk on them — aside from buying them, which I never charged against them even in my head. On the 
other hand, I was paid in deep satisfaction — especially if they learned to stand on their own feet. But I discussed 
none of this; I just had Llita figure their share — my way. 

(Omitted) 

— came to a couple of thousand, not enough to support them very long. But I took time to find a hole-in-the- 
wall luncheon, on which I took option through a third party, after satisfying myself that a couple of strivers could 
stay afloat with it, if the price was right arid they were willing to work. Then I told them that they had better start job 
hunting as I was putting the Libby up for sale or bond-and-lease. It was root, hog, or die. They were really free 
— free to starve. 

Llita didn’t pout, she just looked solemn and went on nursing little J.A. Joe looked scared. But later I saw 
them with their heads together over a newspaper I had brought aboard; they were checking “help wanted” ads. 

After much whispering Llita asked diffidently if I could baby-sit while they went job hunting? — but if I was busy, 
J.A. could ride her hip. 

I said I wasn’t going anywhere — but had they checked “business opportunities”? Jobs for untrained people 
didn’t lead anywhere. 

She looked startled; it was, a new idea. But that hint was enough. There was more looking and whispering; 
then she fetched the paper to me and pointed to an ad — my own but not so marked — and asked what “five-year 
amortization” meant? 

I sniffed at it and told her it was a way to go broke slowly, especially if she spent money on clothes — and 
there must be something wrong or the owner wouldn’t want to sell. 

She looked as sad as Joe did and said that the other business opportunities called for investing lots of 
money. I grudgingly admitted that it could not hurt to look — but watch out for booby traps. 

They came back full of enthusiasm — they were sure they could buy it and make it pay! Joe was twice as 
good a cook as that fry cook who had it — he used too much grease and it was rancid and the coffee was terrible 
and he didn’t even keep the place clean. But best of all, behind the storeroom was a bedroom where they could 
live and — I squelched them. What were the gross receipts? How about taxes? What licenses and inspections 
and what squeeze on each? What did they know about buying food wholesale? No, I would not go look at it; they 
had to make up their own minds and quit leaning on me and, anyhow, I didn’t know anything about restaurant 
business. 

Two lies, Minerva; I’ve run restaurants on five planets — plus a silent lie as to my reasons for not being willing 
to inspect the joint. Two — no, three — reasons: First, I had gone over the place in cynical detail before I optioned 
it; second, that fry cook was bound to remember me; third, since I was selling it to them, through a dummy, I could 
neither vouch for it nor urge them to buy. Minerva, if I sell a horse, I won’t guarantee that it has a leg on each 
corner; the buyer must count them himself. 

Having disclaimed any knowledge of restaurant business, I then lectured them about it. Llita started taking 
notes, then asked to be allowed to start the recorder. So I went into detail: Why 1 00 percent gross profit on the 
cost of food might not break even after she figured costs and overhead — amortization, depreciation, taxes, 
insurance, wages for them as if they were employees, etc. Where the farmers’ market was and how early they 
had to be there each morning. Why Joe must learn to cut meat, not buy it by the piece — and where he could learn 
how. How a long menu could ruin them. What to do about rats, mice, roaches, and some dillies Landfall has but, 
thank heaven, Secundus does not. Why — 

(Omitted) 

— chopped the umbilical, Minerva. I don’t think they ever guessed that they were dealing with me. I neither 
cheated nor helped them; that amortized sales contract simply passed on the price I had to pay for the dump, 



plus a load representing time I had spent dickering the price downward, plus legal and escrow fees and a fee to 
the dummy, plus the interest a bank would charge me — two points cheaper than they could get, at least. But no 
charity, none — I made nothing, lost nothing, and charged for only a day of my time. 

Uita turned out to be tighter than a bull’s arse in fly time; I think she broke even the first month despite closing 
down while they cleaned and refurbished. Certainly she did not miss that first month’s payment on the mortgage, 
nor any after that. Miss one? Dear, they paid that five-year loan in three years. 

Not too surprising. Oh, a long spell of illness could have wrecked them. But they were healthy and young and 
worked seven days a week until they were free and clear. Joe cooked and Llita handled the cashboxand smiled 
at customers and helped at the counter, and J.A. lived in a basket at his mother’s elbow until he was old enough 
to toddle. 

Until I married Laura and left New Canaveral to be a country gentleman, I stopped in their joint fairly often — 
not too often, as Llita would not let me pay, and that was proper, part of standing tall and proud; they had eaten 
my food, now I ate theirs. So I usually stopped just for a cup of coffee and checked on my godson — while 
checking on them. I steered custom their way, too; Joe was a good cook and got steadily better, and word got 
around that Estelle’s Kitchen was the place if you appreciated good food. Word-of-mouth is the best advertising; 
people tend to be smug about having “discovered” that sort of eatery. 

It did no harm with customers, male especially, that Estelle herself presided over the cashbox, young and 
pretty and with a baby in her arm. If she was nursing him as she made change — as was often the case at first — it 
practically guaranteed a lavish tip. 

J.A. gave up the dairy business presently, but when he was about two his job was taken over by a baby girl, 
Libby Long. I didn’t deliver that one, and her red hair had nothing to do with me. Joe was blond, and I assume 
that Llita carried the gene as a recessive — doubt if she had time to branch out. Libby was a number-one tip- 
inducer, and I credit her with helping payoff .the mortgage early. 

Afew years later Estelle’s Kitchen moved uptown to the financial district, was somewhat larger and Llita hired a 
waitress, a pretty one of course — 

(Omitted) 

— Maison Long was swank, but it had a corner in it, a coffee shop, named “Estelle’s Kitchen” and Estelle was 
hostess there as well as in the main dining room — smiling, dressed fit to kill in clothes that showed her superb 
figure, calling regulars byname and getting the names of their guests and remembering them. Joe had three 
chefs and a number of helpers, and they met his high standards or he fired them. But before they opened Maison 
Long, something happened that showed that my kids were even smarter than I thought they were — or at least 
remembered everything and figured things out later. Mind you, when I bought them, they were too ignorant to 
pound sand and I don’t think either one had ever touched money at any time. 

Letter from a lawyer — Inside was a bank draft, with it was an accounting: Two passages, Blessed to Valhalla 
to ‘Landfall, second leg taken from tariffs of Transtellar Migration Corporation, Ltd. (New Canaveral) and first leg 
arbitrarily equated to second leg; certain monies accruing from share in sale of cargo; five thousand blessings 
expressed as bucks at an estimated exchange rate based on assumptions as to equivalent buying power, see 
enclosure; total of above gross sums; interest on gross compounded semiannually for thirteen years at the going 
commercial rate for each year for unsecured loans — and grand total same as the bank draft, a sum I’m not sure I 
remember, Minerva, but it would not mean anything in Secundus crowns anyhow. It was a sizable sum. 

There was no mention of Llita or Joe, and the draft was signed by this lawyer. So I called him. 

He turned out to be stuffy, which did not impress me as I was a lawyer there myself, although not practicing. 

All he would say was that he was acting for an undisclosed client. 

So I fired legalese at him, and he loosened up to the extent of informing me that he had instructions to cover 
the contingency that I might refuse the draft: He was then to pay the draft sum to a designated foundation and so 
inform me after it was paid. But he declined to tell me what foundation. 

I signed off and called Estelle’s Kitchen. Llita answered, then cut in video and smiled her best. “Aaron! We 
haven’t seen you in much too long.” 

I agreed and added that apparently they had gone out of their silly minds while I wasn’t watching. “I have here 
a bunch of nonsense from a lawyer, along with a ridiculous draft. If I could reach you, dear, I would paddle you. 
‘Better let me talk with Joe.” 



She smiled happily and told me that I was welcome to paddle her any time and that I could talk to Joe in a 
moment but that he was locking up. Then she stopped smiling and said with sober dignity, “Aaron, our oldest and 
dearest friend, that draft is not ridiculous. Some debts cannot be paid. So you taught me, years ago. But the 
money part of a debt can be paid. “This we are doing, as closely as we have been able to figure it.” 

I said, “God damn it, you stupid little bitch, you kids don’t owe me a bloody penny!” — or words to that effect. 

She answered, “Aaron, our beloved master — ” 

At the word “master” I blew my overloads, Minerva. I used language guaranteed to scorch the hide of the lead 
mules in a team of six. 

She let me run down, then said softly, “Our master until you free us by letting us pay this — Captain.” 

Dear, I skidded to a halt. 

She added, “But even then you will still be our master in my heart, Captain. And in Joe’s heart, I know. Even 
though we stand free and proud, as you taught us. Even though — thanks always to you — our children, and the 
children I still will bear, will never know that we were ever anything but free... and proud.” 

I said, “Dear, you’re making me cry.” 

She said, “No, no! The Captain never cries.” 

I said, “A lot you know about it, wench. I weep. But in my cabin — with the door locked. Dear, I won’t argue. If 
this is what it takes to make you kids feel free, I'll take it. But just the base sum, no interest. Not from friends.” 

“We are more than friends, Captain. And less. Interest on a debt is always paid — you taught me. But I knew 
that in my heart when I was only an ignorant slave, freshly manumitted. Joseph knew it, too. I tried to pay interest, 
sir. But you would not have me.” 

I changed the subject. “What is this blinking foundation that gets the bucks if I refuse them?” 

She hesitated. “We planned to leave that up to you, Aaron. But we thought it might go to orphans of 
spacemen. Perhaps the Harriman Memorial Refuge.” 

“\bu’re both crazy. That fund is bulging, and I know it. Look, if I go to town tomorrow, can you shut down ‘that 
ptomaine trap for a day? Or perhaps Neilsday?” 

“Any day and as many days as you wish, dear Aaron” — so I said I would call back. 

Minerva, I needed time to think. Joe was no problem, he never was. But Llita was stubborn. I had offered to 
compromise; she had not budged a millimeter. It was the interest that made it such a horrid sum, for them — two 
strivers who had started with a couple of thousand bucks thirteen years back and were raising three kids by then. 

Compound interest is murder. The sum she claimed they owed me — the amount of that draft — was more than 
two and a halftimes the base sum. ..and I couldn’t see how they had saved even that. But, had I been able to get 
her to agree on the base amount and forget compound interest, they would still have a nice chunk of capital to 
expand again — and if it took giving the smaller sum to orphaned spacemen or spacemen’s orphans or 
indignant cats to make them feel proud, I could understand how it would be a bargain in their eyes. I had taught 
them myself, hadn’t I? I once dropped ten times that amount rather than argue over whether cards had been cut 
— then slept that night in a graveyard. 

I wondered if, in her sweetly devious mind, she was paying me back for having dragged her out of my bed 
one night fourteen years earlier. I wondered what she would do if I made a counteroffer to accept the base sum 
and let her “pay the interest” her own way. Shucks, she would probably be on her back before you could say 
“Contraception.” 

Which would solve nothing. 

Since she had turned down my compromise, we were back where we had started. She was determined to 
pay it all — or give it away pointlessly — and I was not going to let her do either one; I can be stubborn, too. 

There had to be a way to do both. 

At dinner that night, after the servants withdrew, I told Laura I was going to town ‘on business’ — would she like 
to come along? Shop while I was busy, then dine wherever she liked, then any fun that appealed to her. Laura 
was pregnant again; I thought she might enjoy a day wasting money on clothes. 

Not that I planned to have her along at the coming row with Llita; officially Joseph and Estelle Long and their 
oldest child had been born on Valhalla; we had become friends when they had taken passage in my ship. I had 
fleshed out that story and coached the kids in it on the leg to Landfall, and had them study sound-sight tapes 
from Torheim — ones which turned them into synthetic Valhallans unless questioned too closely by real Valhallans. 

This fakery was not utterly necessary as Landfall had an open-door policy; an immigrant did not even have to 



register — he could sink or swim. No landing fee, no head tax, not much taxation of any sort, or much government, 
and New Canaveral, the third biggest city, was only a hundred thousand — Landfall was a good place to be in 
those days. 

But I had Joe and Llita do it that way both for them and for their kids. I wanted them to forget that they had 
ever been slaves, never talk about it, never let their kids know it — and at the same time, bury the fact that they 
had been, in some odd fashion, brother and sister. There is nothing shameful in being born a slave (not for the 
slave!), nor was there any reason why diploid complements should not marry. But forget it — start over. Joseph 
Long had married Stjerne Svensdatter (name Anglicized to “Estelle,” with the nickname Yeetah from babyhood); 
they had married when he finished apprenticeship to a chef; they had migrated after their first child. The, story 
was simple and unassailable, and put the polish on my only attempt at playing Pygmalion. I had seen no reason 
to give my new wife any but the official version. Laura knew they were my friends; she was gracious to them on 
my account, then had come to like them on their own account. 

Laura was a good gal, Minerva good company in bed and out, and she had the Howard virtue, even on her 
first marriage, of not trying to smother her spouse — most Howards need at least one marriage to learn it. She 
knew who I was — the Senior — as our marriage and later our kids were registered with the Archives, just as had 
been my marriage to her grandmother, and the offspring from that. But she did not treat me as a thousand years 
older than she was and never quizzed me about my past lives — simply listened if I felt like talking. 

I don’t blame her for that lawsuit; Roger Sperling cooked that up, the greedy son of a sow: 

Laura said, “If you don’t mind, dear, I'll stay home. I would rather splurge on clothes after I slim down. As for 
dinner, there isn’t a restaurant in New Canaveral that can match what Thomas does for us here. Well, Estelle’s 
Kitchen perhaps, but that’s a lunchroom, not a restaurant. Will you see them this trip? Estelle and Joe, I mean." 

“Possibly.” 

“Find time, dear; they are nice people. Besides, I want to send some knickknack to my goddaughter. Aaron, 
if you want to treat me to a fancy restaurant when we go to town, you should encourage Joe to open one. Joe can 
cook, equal to Thomas." 

(Better than Thomas, I said to myself — and Joe doesn’t scowl at a polite request. Minerva, the trouble with 
servants is that you serve them quite as much as they serve you.) “I’ll make a point of seeing them, at least long 
enough to deliver your present to Libby.” 

“And kiss them all for me and I’d better send something to each of their kids and be sure to tell Estelle that 
I’m pregnant again and find out if she is, too, and remember to tell me, and what time are you leaving, dear? — I 
must check your shirts.” 

Laura was serenely certain that I could not pack an overnight bag no matter how many centuries of 
experience I had had. Her ability to see the world as she wanted to see it enabled her to put up with my cranky 
ways for forty years; I do appreciate her. Love? Certainly, Minerva. She looked out for my welfare, always, and I 
did for hers, and we enjoyed being together. Just not love so intense that it is a great ache in your belly. 

Next day I took my jumpbuggy over to New Canaveral. 

(Omitted) 

— planned Maison Long. Llita had meant to blitz me. I’m sentimental, and she knew it and had set the stage. 
When I got there, the shutters were closed, early — and their two older kids were farmed out for the night and 
baby Laura was asleep. Joe let me in, told me to go on back; he had our dinner on the range and would be along 
in a minute. So I went back to their living quarters to find Llita. 

I found her — dressed in sarong and sandals I had given her not an hour after I had bought her. Instead of the 
sophisticated face-do she now used so well, she was wearing no makeup at all and had her hair simply parted 
and hanging straight down, to her waist or longer, and brushed till it shone. But this was not the frightened, 
ignorant slave who had to be taught how to bathe; this serenely beautiful young lady was clean as a sterilized 
scalpel, and was scented with some perfume which may have been named Spnng Breezes but should have 
been called Justifiable Rape and sold only under doctor’s prescription. 

She posed just long enough for me to take this in, then swarmed over me, hit me with a kiss that matched her 
perfume. 

By the time she let me go, Joe had joined us — dressed in breechclout and sandals. But I did not let it go 
sentimental; I riposted sharply, stopping only to accept one-tenth that much kiss from Joe, said nothing about 
their costumes, and at once started explaining that business deal. When Llita caught what I was talking about, 



she shifted from sexy siren to sharp businesswoman, listened intently, ignored her stage setting and costuming, 
and asked the right questions. 

Once she said, “Aaron, I sniff a mouse. You told us to be free, and we've tried to be — and that’s why we sent 
you that draft. I can add figures; we owe you that money. We don’t have to have the biggest restaurant in New 
Canaveral. We’re happy, the children are healthy, we're making money.” 

“And working too hard,” I answered. 

“Not all that hard. Though a bigger restaurant would mean even more work. But the point is: You seem to be 
buying us again. That’s all right if you wish to — you are the only master we would ever accept. Is that your inten 
tion, sir? If so, please say so. Be frank with us.” 

I said, “Joe, will you hold her while I wallop her? For using that dirty word? Llita, you are wrong on both counts. 
A bigger restaurant means less work. And I’m not buying you; this is a business deal in which I expect a fat profit. 
I’m betting on Joe’s genius as a chef, plus your genius for pinching pennies without cutting quality. If I don’t make 
money, I'll exercise my option to liquidate, get my investment back, and you can go back to running a lunch 
counter. If you fail I won’t prop you up.” 

“Brother?” She called him that in the dialect of their childhood. It signified to me that the lodge was tyled for 
executive session at the highest degree, as they were most careful not to call each other “Brother” or “Sister” in 
any language, especially in front of the children. J.A. was sometimes “Brother” in English — never his father Joe. 
Minerva, I don’t recall that Landfall had laws against incest — it did not have many laws. But there was a strong 
taboo against it, and I had carefully indoctrinated them. Half the battle with any culture is knowing its taboos. 

Joe looked thoughtful. “I can cook. Can you manage it, Sis?” 

“I can try. Of course we’ll try it if you want us to, Aaron. I’m not sure we can make a go of it, and it does look 
like more work to me. I’m not complaining, Aaron, but we are already working about as hard as we can." 

“I know you are. I don’t see how Joe found time to knock you up.” 

She shrugged and said, “That doesn’t take long. And it will be a long time — I’ve just barely caught — before I'll 
have to take time off. J.A. is old enough to handle the cashbox when I do. But not in a big fancy restaurant.” 

I answered, “Wench, you’re thinking in terms of a lunchroom. Now listen, and learn bow to make more money 
with less work and more time off. 

“We may not open Maison Long until after you have this baby; we can’t set this up overnight. We must sell or 
lease this place — which means finding buyers who can keep it out of the red; it’s always expensive to have to 
take a place back. 

“We must find a suitable property in the right neighborhood, for sale or lease with option to buy. I may buy it 
and rent it to the corporation, so as not to tie up too much of the corporation’s capital in senior financing. Find the 
place, remodel it probably, redecorate it certainly. Money for fixtures. Not much for squeeze; I know where the 
bodies are buried in this burg, and I won’t hold still for excessive squeeze. 

“But, my dear, you will not be on the cashbox; we’ll hire help, and I'll set it up so that they can’t steal. You will 
be moving around, looking pretty, smiling at people — and keeping your eye on everything. But you’ll do this only 
at lunch and dinner. Call it six hours a day.” 

Joe looked startled; Llita blurted out, “But, Aaron, we always open up as soon as we’re back from market and 
stay open late. Otherwise you lose so much trade.” 

“I’m sure you work that hard; this draft proves it. And that’s why you think getting pregnant ‘doesn’t take long.’ 
But it should ‘take long,’ dear. Work is not an end in itself; there must always be time enough for love. Tell me — 
When you caught J.A. in the ‘Libby’, were you rushed? Or did you have time to enjoy it?” 

“Oh, goodness!” Her nipples suddenly crinkled. “Those were wonderful days!” 

“There will be wonderful days again. Gather ye rosebuds, time is still a-flying. Or have you lost interest?” 

She looked indignant. “Captain, you know me better than that.” 

“Joe? Slowing down, son?” 

“Well... we do work long hours. Sometimes I’m pretty tired.” 

“Let’s change that. This will not be a lunchroom; this is going to be a high-priced gourmet restaurant of a 
quality this planet has never seen. Remember that place I took you kids for dinner just before we lifted from 
Valhalla? That sort. Soft lights and soft music and wonderful food and high prices. A wine cellar but no hard 
liquor; our patrons must not have their tastebuds numbed. 

“Joe, you will still go to market each morning; selecting top-quality food is something you can’t delegate. But 
don’t take Llita and do take J.A. if he’s going to learn the profession.” 



“I sometimes take him now." 

“Good. Then come home and go to bed again; you’re through until you cook dinner. Not lunch.” 

“Huh?” 

“That’s right. \bur number two chef handles lunch, then helps with dinner, your big moneymaking meal. Llita is 
hostess both for lunch and dinner but keeps an especially sharp eye on quality at lunch, Joe, since you won’t be 
in the kitchen. But she never goes to market and should still be in bed when you get back from market — did I say 
that your quarters will be attached, just as now? \t>u’ll both be off duty two or three hours in the afternoon — just 
right for the sort of siesta you used to grab in the ‘Libby.’ In fact, if you two can’t find time under that regime both 
for sleep and plenty of happy play — But you can.” 

“It sounds grand,” Llita conceded, “if we can make a living with those hours — ” 

“>bu can. A better living. But instead of trying to get every buck, Llita, your object will be to maintain top quality 
while not losing money... and enjoy life.” 

“We will. Aaron, our be loved... captain and friend, since I must not say that ‘dirty’ word, we enjoyed life even 
as children when I had to wear that horrid virgin’s basket — because it was so sweet to snuggle together all the 
long nights. When you bought us — and freed us — and I didn’t have to wear it, life was perfect. I didn’t think it 
could, be better — though it will be, when we don’t have to choose between sleep and trying to stay awake for 
loving. Uh, you may not believe this since you know what a rutty wench I am — but lots of times sleep won.” 

“I believe it. Let’s change it." 

“But — No breakfast trade at all? Aaron, some of our breakfast customers have been coming to us the whole 
time we’ve been on Landfall.” 

“Net profit?” 

“Well... not much. People won’t pay as much for breakfast even though materials sometimes cost as much. 
I’ve been satisfied with a very small net on breakfast. Advertising. I’d hate to tell our regulars that we won’t serve 
them any longer.” 

“Details, dear. Nfciu can have a breakfast bar in one corner and not open the main dining room — but Joe won’t 
cook breakfasts, and neither will you. You’ll be in bed with Joe at that hour — so that your eyes will sparkle at 
lunch.” 

“J.A. knows breakfast dishes,” put in Joe. “I started him on breakfasts.” 

“Details again. Maybe we’ll work out a deal with my godson whereby he makes money of his own, if the 
breakfast bar makes money — ” 

(Omitted) 

“ — sum it up. Take notes, Llita. I agree to accept this draft while you two — especially you, Llita — agree that it 
settles forever any debt between us. Maison Long to be a closely held corporation; fifty-one-per cent to you two, 
forty-nine percent to me, all three of us directors, and we can’t sell stock save to each other — except that I retain 
option to change all or part of my share to nonvoting stock, in which case I can assign it. 

“My share of the initial financing is this draft. Your share is what we get for this lunchroom — ” 

“Hold it,” said Llita. “We might not be able to sell for that much.” 

“Details, dear. Stick in a paragraph to let you pay the corporation any discrepancy out of your net — and there 
will indeed be a net; I don’t stick with a business that doesn't make money, I always cut my losses. Let’s have 
another paragraph that permits me to supply more capital, if needed, by buying nonvoting stock — and we’ll use 
something like that to hang onto our top help, too. Not have Joe train a chef and then have him walk out. Never 
mind, let’s get the outlines straight. Nt>u two are the bosses; I’m silent partner. Salaries for you two on the scale 
we discussed, escalating with rise in net, as discussed. 

“I don't get a salary, just dividends. But we all will be working our tails off to get this rolling. I’ll come in from 
Skyhaven as necessary; there’s nothing going on there now that my overseer can’t handle. But once it’s rolling, I 
do nothing; I sit back and let you two make us rich. But — listen carefully — once it’s rolling, you two must stop 
working your tails off, too. More time in bed. More time for fun out of bed. \bu won’t make us rich working 
lunchroom hours. Have we reached a meeting of minds?” 

“I think so,” agreed Joe. “Sis?” 

“Yes. I’m not certain New Canaveral will support a gourmet restaurant like those lovely ones on Valhalla — but 
we’ll try! I still think our starting salaries are too high, but I'll wait until I’ve struck a trial balance on our first quarter 



before I argue the matter. Just one thing, Captain — ” 

“My name’s ‘Aaron.’” 

“’Captain’ is safer than that ‘dirty word.’ I’ve agreed to the whole thing — and I’m durned well going to make it 
work! — as you always say. But if you think this makes me forget a night you dragged me out of your bed and 
bounced me on my bum on a hard steel deck, you can think again! Because it hasn't!” 

I sighed, Minerva, and said to her husband, “Joe, how do you cope with her?” 

He shrugged and grinned. “I don’t, I just get along. Besides, Isee fter side of it. If /were you, I’d take her to 
bed and make her forget it.” 

I shook my head. “But I’m not you, that’s the point. Joe, I learned long before you were born that free tail is 
invariably the most expensive sort. Worse than that, we three are business partners now — and I can see six 
possible outcomes if I accept your notion of a solution — and any of the six could cause Maison Long, Ltd., never 
to lift off. 

— (Omitted) 

— just as I knew it would, Minerva; I’ve never had a nonspeculative Investment pay off so well. They tried to’ 
imitate us — but they couldn’t imitate Joe’s cooking or Llita’s management. I made a bundle! 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
IX 


Conversation Before Dawn 


The computer said, “Lazarus, aren’t you sleepy?” 

“Don’t nag me, dear. I’ve had thousands of white nights, and I’m still here. A man never cuts his throat from a 
sleepless night if he has company to see him through it. You’re good company, Minerva.” 

“Thank you, Lazarus.” 

“The simple truth, girl. If I fall asleep — fine. If I don’t, then no need to tell Ishtar. No, that won’t work; she’ll have 
graphs and charts on me, won’t she?” 

“I’m afraid so, Lazarus." 

“>bu durn well know so. A good reason for me to be a little angel and wash behind my ears and get this 
rejuvenation over is to get my privacy back. Privacy is as necessary as company; you can drive a man crazy by 
depriving him of either. That was another thing I accomplished by setting up Maison Long; I got my kids privacy 
they didn't know they needed.” 

“I missed that, Lazarus. I noted that they had more time for ‘Eros’ — and I saw that that was good. Should I 
have inferred something else from the data?” 

“No, because I didn’t give you all the data. Not a tenth. Just the outline of some forty years I knew them, and 
some — not all — of the critical points. For instance, did I mention the time Joe decapitated a man?” 

“No." 

“Not much to it and it wasn’t important to the story. This young blood tried to share the wealth one night by 
sticking them up. Llita had J.A. in her right arm, nursing him or about to, and couldn't reach the gun she kept at 
the cashbox; she couldn't fight and was bright enough not to try against those odds. I suppose this dude didn’t 
know that Joe had simply stepped out of sight. 

“Just as this free-lance socialist was gathering up their day’s receipts, Joe lets him have it, with a cleaver. 
Curtain. The only notable thing about it was that Joe acted so quickly and correctly in the crunch, for I feel sure 
that the only fighting that he had ever tried was that which I forced on him in the ‘Libby.’ Joe did everything else 
properly, too — finished taking the head off, threw the body into the street for his friends to take away if he had 
any, for the scavengers to remove if not — then displayed the head in front of the shop on a spike meant for such 
purpose. Then he closed his shutters and cleaned up the mess — then may have taken time to throw up; Joe was 
a gentle soul. But it’s seven to two that Llita did not throw up. 

“The city’s committee for public safety voted Joe the usual reward, and the street committee passed the hat 
and added to it; a cleaver against a gun rated special notice. Good advertising for Estelle’s Kitchen but not 
important otherwise, save that the kids could use that money — helped pay the mortgage, no doubt, and wound 
up in my pocket. But I wouldn't have heard of this minor dustup had I not been in New Canaveral and happened 
to stop by Estelle’s Kitchen when the real head was removed — flies, you know — and the plastic trophy head 
custom required Joe to display was substituted for it by the street committee. But I was speaking of privacy. 

“When I picked the property for Maison Long, I made sure that it included space for a growing family, that’s 
all, since they had three bucking and one in the chute the night we planned it. Rearranging hours gave them 
privacy from each other, too. Happy as it is to snuggle and make love, nevertheless, when you are really tired, it 
is often good to have the bed to yourself — and the new routine not only allowed this but necessitated it, part of 
each day, through staggering their working hours. 

“But I also planned room to give them privacy from their children — and to cope with another problem Llita did 
not have straight and Joe may not have thought about. Minerva, can you define ‘incest’?” 

The computer replied, “‘Incest’ is a legal term, not a biological one. It designates sexual union between 
persons forbidden by law to marry. The act itself is forbidden; whether such union results in progeny is irrelevant. 
The prohibitions vary widely among cultures and are usually, but not always, based on degrees of consanguinity.” 

“Yr durn tootin’ it’s ‘not always.’ There are cultures which permit first cousins to marry — genetically risky — but 



forbid a man to marry his brother’s widow, which involves no more risk than it did for the first union. When I was a 
youngster, you could find one rule in one state, then cross an invisible line and find exactly opposite laws fifty feet 
away. Or some times and places both unions might be mandatory. Or forbidden. Endless rules, endless 
definitions for incest, and rarely any logic to them. Minerva, so far as I recall, the Howard Families are the first 
group in history to reject the legalistic approach and to define ‘incest’ solely in terms of genetic hazard.” 

“That accords with the records in me,” Minerva agreed. “A Howard geneticist might advise against a union 
between two persons with no known common ancestry but place no objection to marriage of siblings. In each 
case analysis of genetic charts would control.” 

“Yeah, sure. Now let’s drop genetics and talk about taboo. The incest taboo, although it can be anything, most 
commonly means sisters and brothers, parents and offspring. Llita and Joe were a unique case, brother and 
sister by cultural rules, totally unrelated by genetic rules — or at least no more so than two strangers. 

“Now comes a second-generation problem. Since Landfall had this taboo against union between siblings, I 
had impressed on Llita and Joe that they must never let anyone know that they thought of each other as ‘brother’ 
and ‘sister.’ 

“Fine so far as it went. They did as I told them, and there was never a lifted eyebrow. Now comes the night we 
planned Maison Long — and my godson is thirteen and interested, and his sister is eleven and beginning to be 
interesting. Full siblings — both genetically hazardous and contrary to taboo. Anyone who has raised puppies — or 
a number of children — knows that a boy can get as horny over his sister as over the girl down the street, and his 
sister is often more accessible. 

“And little Libby was a redheaded pixie so endearingly sexy at eleven that even I could feel it. Soon she was 
going to have every buck in the pasture pawing the ground and snorting. 

“If a man pushes a rock, can he ignore an avalanche that follows? Fourteen years earlier I had manumitted 
two slaves — because a chastity girdle on one of them offended my concept of human dignity. Must I find some 
way to put a chastity girdle on that slave’s daughter? Around we go in circles! What was my responsibility, 
Minerva? / pushed the first rock.” 

“Lazarus, I am a machine." 

“Humph! Meaning that human concepts of moral responsibility are not machine concepts. Dear, I wish you 
were a human girl with a spankable bottom long enough for me to spank it — I would! In your memories is far 
more experience on which to judge than anyflesh-and-blood can have. Quit dodging.” 

“Lazarus, no human can accept unlimited responsibility lest he go mad from unbearable load of unlimited 
guilt. You could have advised Libby’s parents. But your responsibility did not extend even to that.” 

“Urn. You're right, dear — it’s dismal how regularly you are right. But I am an incurable buttinsky. Fourteen 
years earlier I had turned my back on two puppies, so to speak — and that the outcome was not tragic was good 
luck, not good planning. Now here we go again, and the outcome could be tragic. I felt no ‘morals’ about it, dear 
— just thumb rules for not, hurting people unintentionally. I didn't give a hoot if these children ‘played doctor’ or 
‘make a baby’ or whatever the kids there called their experimenting; I simply did not want my godson giving little 
Libby a defective child. 

“So, I did butt in and took it up with their parents. Let me add that Llita and Joe knew as much about genetics 
as a pig knows about politics. Aboard the ‘Libby’ I had kept my worries to myself, and never discussed the 
matter with them later. Despite their remarkable success in competing as free human beings, in most subjects 
Llita and Joe were ignorant. How could it be otherwise? I had taught them their Three R’s and a few practical 
matters. Since arrival on Landfall they had been running under the whip; they hadn’t had time to fill in gaps in their 
education. 

“Perhaps worse yet, being immigrants, they had not grown up exposed to the local incest taboo. They were 
aware of it because I had warned them — but it wasn’t canalized from childhood. Blessed had somewhat 
differenct incest taboos — but the taboos there did not apply to domestic animals. Slaves. Slaves bred as they 
were told to, or as they could get away with — and my two kids had been told by highest authority — their mother 
and their priest — that they were a ‘breeding pair’... so it could not be wrong, or taboo, or sinful. 

“It was simply something to keep quiet about on Landfall because Landfellows were tetched in the head on 
this subject. 

“So I should have thought of it earlier. Yeah, sure, Sure! Minerva, I plead other obligations. I could not spend 
those years playing guardian angel to Llita and Joe. I had a wife and kids of my own, employees, a couple of 
thousand hectares of farmland and twice that much in virgin pinkwood — and I lived a long way off, even by high- 



orbit jumpbuggy. 

Ishtar and Harnadiyad, and, to some extent, Galahad, all seem to think I am some sort of superman simply 
because I’ve lived a long time. I’m not; I have the limitations of anyflesh-and-blood, and for years Iwas as busy 
with my problems as Llita and Joe were with theirs. Skyhaven didn't come to me gift-wrapped. 

“It wasn’t until we put aside restaurant business and I got out presents Laura had sent to their kids, and had 
admired the latest pictures of their kids and shown them pictures of Laura and my kids and all that ancient ritual, 
that I thought about it at all. The pix, of course. This tall lad, J.A., all hands and feet, wasn't the little boy I recalled 
from my last visit. Libby was about a year younger than Laura’s oldest, and J.A.’s age I knew to the second 
— which is to say that he was about the age I was when I was almost caught with a girl in the belfry of our church 
about a thousand years earlier. 

“My godson was no longer a child; he was an adolescent whose balls were not just ornaments. If he had not 
tried them as yet, he was certainly jerking off and thinking about it. 

“The possibilities raced through my mind the way a man’s past life is supposed to, when he is dying — which 
isn’t true, by the way. So I tackled it and was subtle about it. Diplomatic. 

“I said, ‘Joe, which one do you lock up at night? Libby? Or this young wolf?”’ 

The computer chuckled. ‘“Diplomatic,”’ she repeated. 

“How would you have put it, dear? They looked puzzled. When I made it clear, Llita was indignant. Deprive 
her kids of each other? When they had slept together since they were babies? Besides, there wasn’t room any 
other way. Or was I suggesting that she sleep with Libby while J.A. slept with Joe? If so, I could forget it! 

“Minerva, most people never learn anything about any science, and genetics stands at the bottom of the list. 
Gregor Mendel had been dead twelve centuries at that time, yet all the old wives’ tale were what most people 
believed — and still do, I might add. 

“So I tried to explain, knowing that Llita and Joe weren't stupid, just ignorant. She cut in on me. ‘Yes, yes, 
Aaron, certainly. I've thought about the possibility that Libby may want to marry Jay Aaron — will want to, I think 
— and I know it’s frowned on here. But it’s silly to ruin their happiness over a superstition. So, if it works out that 
way, we think it’s best for them to move to Colombo — or at least as far as Kingston.. 

Then they can use different family names and get married, and no one will be the wiser. Not that we want 
them to be so far away. But we won’t stand in the way of their happiness.” 

“She loved them,” said Minerva. 

“Yes, she did, dear, by the exact definition of love. Llita placed their welfare and happiness ahead of her own. 
So I had to try to explain it — why the taboo against union of brother and sister wasn’t superstition but a real 
danger — even though it had turned out to be safe in their case. 

“‘Why’ was the hard part. Starting cold on the complexities of genetics with persons who don’t even know 
elementary biology is like trying to explain multidimensional matrix algebra to someone who has to take off his 
shoes to count above ten. 

“Joe would have accepted my authority. But Llita had the sort of mind that has to know why — else she was 
going to smile her sweetly stubborn smile, agree with me, then do, as she had intended to all along. Llita was 
well above average smart but suffered from the democratic fallacy: the notion that her opinion was as good as 
anyone’s — while Joe suffered from the aristocratic fallacy: He accepted the notion of authority in opinion. I don’t 
know which fallacy is the more pathetic; either one cantrip you. However, my mind matches. Llita’s in this 
respect, so I knew I had to convince her. 

“Minerva, how do you condense a thousand years of research in the second-most complex subject into an 
hour of talk? Llita didn’t even know she laid eggs — in fact she was certain she didn’t, as she had served 
thousands of eggs, fried, scrambled, boiled, and so forth. But she listened, and I sweated at it, with nothing but 
stylus and paper — when I needed the resources of a teaching machine in a college of genetics. 

“But I kept at it, drawing pictures and simplifying outrageously some very complex concepts, until I thought 
they had grasped the ideas of genes, chromosomes, chromosome reduction, paired genes, dominants, 
recessives — and that bad genes made defective babies — and defective babies, thank Frigg under all Her many 
Names, was something Llita had known about since she was a little girl, listening to gossip of older female 
slaves. She quit smiling. 

“I asked if they had playing cards? — not hopefully since they had no time for such. But Llita dug up a couple of 
decks from the children’s room. The cards were the commonest sort used on Landfall then: fifty-six cards in four 



suits, Jewels and Hearts were red, Spades and Swords were black, and each suit had royal cards. So I had 'em 
play the oldest random-chance gene-matching simulation used in beginning genetics — the ‘Let’s-Make-a- 
Healthy-Baby’ game that children here on Secundus can play — and explain — long before they are old enough to 
copulate. 

“I said, ‘Llita, write down these rules. Black cards are recessives, red cards are dominants; Jewels and 
Spades come from the mother, Hearts and Swords come from the father. A black ace is a lethal gene, reinforced 
the baby is stillborn. A black empress reinforced gives us a ‘blue baby’ — needs surgery to stay alive — And so 
on, Minerva, except that I set the rules for a ‘hit’ — a bad reinforcement — so that they were four times as probable 
for brother and sister as for strangers, and explained why — and then made them keep records for twenty games 
played by each set of rules for shuffling and snatching, reduction and recombination. 

“Minerva, it was not as good a structural analogy as the ‘Make-a-Healthy-Baby’ kindergarten games, but 
using two decks with different back patterns did enable me to set up degrees of consanguinity. Llita was simply 
intent at first — then started looking grim the first time the turn of the cards caused a black to reinforce a black. 

“But when we played by brother-and-sister rules, and she dealt the cards and twice in a row got the Ace of 
Spades matched with the Ace of Swords for a dead baby, she stopped. She turned pale and looked at them. 
Then said slowly, with horror in her voice: ‘Aaron... does this mean that we must lock Libby into a virgin’s basket? 
Oh, no!" 

“I told her gently that it wasn’t that bad. Little Libby would never be locked up that way or any way — we’d work 
it out so that the children would not marry and so that J.A. would not give his sister a baby even by accident. ‘Quit 
worrying, dear!”’ 

The computer said, “Lazarus, what method did you use to cheat in those card games? May I ask?” 

“Why, Minerva, how could you think such a thing? 

“I withdraw the question, Lazarus.” 

“Of course I cheated! All sorts of ways; I said those two had never had time to play cards... whereas I had 
played with every sort of a deck and by endless rules. Minerva, I won my first oil well from a boy who made the 
mistake of putting readers into a game. Dear, I had Llita deal — but from a deck so cold it almost froze solid. I 
used all sorts of things — false cut, whorehouse cut, tops and bottoms, stacking the deck in front of their eyes. 
There wasn’t any money on the game; I simply had to convince them that inbreeding was for stock, not for their 
beloved children — and I did.” 

(Omitted) 

“ — your bedroom here, Llita, yours and Joe’s, I mean. Libby’s room adjoins yours, while J.A. winds up down 
the hall. How you reshuffle later depends on the sex of the baby you are going to have and on how many more 
you choose to have and when — but putting a crib in with Libby must be considered temporary; you can’t figure on 
using it indefinitely as an excuse to keep an eye on her. 

“But this is merely a stopgap, like not leaving the cat alone with the roast. Kids are slick at beating such 
arrangements, and nobody has ever been able to keep a girl off her back when she decides it’s time. When she 
decides — that’s the key to the matter. So our pressing problem is to get these children into separate beds — then 
to see to it that Libby does not make a bad decision. Any reason Libby can’t go with me to Skyhaven and visit 
Pattycake? And how about J.A. , Joe, can you get along without him a while? Lots of room, dears — Libby can 
room with Pattycake, and J.A. can bunk with George and Woodrow and maybe teach 'em manners.” 

“Llita said something about imposing on Laura, Minerva, which I answered with a rude negative. ‘Laura likes 
kids, dear; she is one ahead of you, yet she started a year later. She doesn’t keep house; she simply bosses her 
staff, she’s never had to work harder than suited her. Furthermore, she wants all of you to pay us a visit — an 
invitation I heartily second, but I don’t think you two can get away until we find a buyer for this place. But I want 
Libby and J.A. now— so that I can give them blunt and practical instruction in genetics, using stock I’ve been 
inbreeding to show what I mean." 

“Minerva, this particular breeding schedule I had started to teach my own offspring the bald truth about 
genetics, with careful records and grisly photographs of bad culls. Since you manage a planet which has over 
ninety percent Howards and the remaining mixed fraction mostly following Howard customs, you may not know 
that non-Howard cultures don’t necessarily teach such things to their kids even in cultures open about sex. 

“Landfall was then mostly short-lifers, only a few thousand Howards — and to avoid friction we did not 



advertise our presence even though it wasn’t a secret — couldn’t be; the planet had a Howard Clinic. But with 
Skyhaven a Dan’I-Boone distance from the nearest big town, if Laura and I wanted our children to have a 
Howard-style education, we had to teach them ourselves. So we did. 

“When I was a kid, the grownups of my home country tried to pretend to kids that sex did not exist — believe it 
if you can! Not true of the little hellions Laura and I raised. They had not seen human copulation — I don’t think 
they had — because it puts me off stride to have spectators. But they had seen it in other animals and had bred 
pets and kept records. The older two, Pattycake and George, had seen the birth of our youngest of the time 
because Laura had invited them to watch. This I strongly approve of, Minerva, but I have never urged one of my 
wives to permit it because I figure that a woman in labor should be indulged in every possible way. However, 
Laura had a streak of exhibitionism in her makeup. 

“Anyhow, our kids could discuss chromosome reduction and the merits and demerits of linebreeding as 
knowledgeably as my own contemporaries when I was a kid could discuss the World Series — ” 

“Excuse me, Lazarus — that last term’s referent?” 

“Oh. Nothing important. One of the commercially induced surrogate interests of my childhood: Forget it dear; 
it is not worth cluttering your memories. I was about to say I asked Joe and Llita what J.A. and Libby knew about 
sexual matters — since Landfall had so diversified a background that it could be anything and I wanted to know 
where to start — especially as my oldest, Pattycake, had turned twelve and reached menarche at the same time 
and was smug about it, likely to boast. 

“Turned out that Libby and J.A. were sophisticated in an ignorant, unscientific fashion about matching their 
parents. They were one up on my kids in one respect: copulation they had seen from birth, at least to the time 
Estelle’s Kitchen had moved uptown — which I should have figured out from recalling the still more cramped living 
quarters of the original Estelle’s Kitchen.” 

(7,200 words omitted) 

“Laura was sharp with me and insisted that I not see them until I calmed down. She pointed out that 
Pattycake was almost as old as J.A., that it was nothing but play as Pattycake had had her four-year sterilization 
after menarche, and that, in any event, Pattycake had been on top. 

“Minerva, I would not have spanked the kids no matter who had been on top. Intellectually I knew that Laura 
was right, and I had to agree that fathers tend to be possessive about daughters. I was pleased that Laura had 
gained the confidence of both kids so fully that they had neither tried very hard to keep from being caught, nor 
had they been scared when she happened to catch 'em at it. Perhaps J.A. was scared but Pattycake just said, 
‘Mama, you didn’t knock.’” 

(Omitted) 

“ — so we traded sons. J.A. liked farm life and never did leave us, whereas George turned out to have this 
perverse taste for cities, so Joe took him on and made a chef out of him. George was sleeping with Elizabeth 
— Libby, that is — I forget how long before they decided to hatch one and were married. A double wedding, the 
four youngsters remained close. 

“But J.A.’s decision solved a problem for me: what to do with Skyhaven later. By the time Laura decided to 
leave me, all of my sons by her had heard the wild goose one way or another; George was the only one still on 
planet, and our daughters were married and not one of them to a farmer. Whereas J.A. had become my 
overseer and was de-facto boss of Skyhaven the last ten years I was there. 

“I might have worked some compromise with Roger Sperling if he hadn’t tried to grab the place. As it was, I 
deeded a half interest to Pattycake, sold the other half to my son-in-law J.A. on a mortgage, then discounted the 
paper to a bank and bought a better ship than I would have had I given that half interest to Roger and Laura. I 
made a similar deal, part gift and part sale, with Libby and George, of my share in Maison Long — and Libby 
changed her name to Estelle Elizabeth Sheffield-Long; there was continuity there as well — which pleased both 
me and her parents. It worked out well. Laura even came down and kissed me good-bye when I left.” 

“Lazarus, I do not understand one factor. You have said that you do not favor marriage between Howards and 
ephemerals. Nfetyou let two of your children marry outside the Families.” 

“Uh, correction, Minerva. One does not let children get married; they do get married, when and as and to 



whom they choose.” 

“Correction noted, Lazarus.” 

“But let’s go back to the night I intervened for Libby and J.A. That night I gave Llita and Joe everything that 
slave factor had turned over to me as proof of their old heritage — even the bill of sale — with a suggestion that 
they destroy the stuff or lock it up. Among those items was a series of photographs showing them growing up, 
year by year. The last one seemed to have been taken just before I bought them, and they confirmed it — two fully 
grown youngsters, one in a chastity 
girdle. 

“Joe looked at that picture and said, “What a couple of clowns! We’ve come a long way, Sis — thanks to the 
Skipper.’ ‘“So we have,’ she agreed, and studied the picture. ‘Brother, do you see what I do?’ 

“What?” he said, looking again. 

“‘Aaron will see it. Brother, take off your clout’, she said, while starting to unwrap her sarong, ‘and pose with 
me against the wall. Not the selling pose, but the way we used to stand against a grid for these record pictures.’ 
She handed me that last picture in the series, and they stood and faced me. 

“Minerva, in fourteen years they had not changed. Llita had had three kids and was just pregnant with her 
fourth and both of them had worked themselves silly... but, stripped naked, no makeup on her and her hair down, 
they looked as they had the first time I saw them. They looked like that last record shot — end of adolescence, 
somewhere between eighteen and twenty in Earth terms. 

“\fet they had to be past thirty. Thirty-five Earth years old if those Blessed records were to be trusted. 

“Minerva, I have just one thing to add. When I last saw them, they were past sixty in Earth years, about sixty- 
three if you accept the records from Blessed. Neither one had a gray hair, both had all their teeth — and Llita was 
pregnant again." 

“Mutant Howards, Lazarus?” 

The old man shrugged. “Isn’t that a question-begging term, dear? If you use a long enough time scale, every 
one of the thousands of genes a flesh-and -blood carries is a mutation. But by the Trustees’ rules, a person not 
derived from the Families’ genealogies can be registered as a newly discovered Howard if he can show proof of 
four grandparents surviving at least to one hundred. And that rule would have excluded me, had I not been born 
into the Families. But on top of that, the age I had reached when I got my first rejuvenation is too great to be 
accounted for by the Howard breeding experiment. They claim today that they have located in the twelfth 
chromosome pair a gene complexthat determines longevity like winding a clock. If so, who wound my clock? 
Gilgamesh? ‘Mutation’ is never an explanation; it is simply a name for an observed fact. 

“Perhaps some natural long-lifer, not necessarily a Howard, had visited Blessed — the naturals are forever 
moving around, changing their names, dyeing their hair; they have all gone through history — and earlier. But, 
Minerva, you recall from my life as a slave on Blessed one odd and unsavory incident — ” 

(Omitted) 

“ — so my best guess is that Llita and Joe were my own great-great-grandchildren.” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
X 


Possibilities 


“Lazarus, was that why you refused to share ‘Eros’ with her?” 

“Eh? But, Minerva, dear, I didn’t reach that conclusion — or suspicion — that night. Oh, I admit to prejudice 
about sex with my descendants — you can take the boy out of the Bible Belt, but it is hard to take the Bible Belt 
out of the boy. Still, I had had a thousand years in which to learn better." 

“So?” said the computer. “Was it simply that you still classed her as an ephemeral? That troubles me, 
Lazarus. In my own — deprived — state, I find that, like her husband Joe, Isee her side of it. Your reasons seem 
excuses, not sufficient grounds to refuse her need.” 

“Minerva, I did not say I refused her.” 

“Oh! Then I infer that you granted her this boon. I feel a lessening of tension." 

“I didn’t say that, either.” 

“I find an implied contradiction, Lazarus.” 

“Simply because there are things I have not said, dear. Everything I tell you winds up in my memoirs; that was 
the deal I made with Ira. Or I can tell you to erase something, in which case I might as well not have told you at all. 
Perhaps my twenty-three centuries do hold something worth recording. But I see no possible excuse for placing 
on record each time some darling lady shared with me simply for pleasure, not for progeny.” 

The computer answered thoughtfully, “I imply from this addendum that, while I am precluded from inferring 
anything about the boon Llita requested, your rule with respect to ephemerals extended only to marriage and to 
progeny.” 

“Nor did \ say that!” 

“Then I have not understood you, Lazarus. Conflict.” The old man brooded, then answered slowly and sadly, “I 
think I said that marriage between a long-lived and a short-lived was a bad idea... and so it is... and I learned it 
the hard way. But that was long ago and faraway — and when she died, part of me died. I stopped wanting to live 
forever.” He stopped. 

The computer said brokenly, “Lazarus — Lazarus, my beloved friend! I am sorry!” 

Lazarus Long sat up straight and said briskly, “No, dear. Don’t be sorry for me. No regrets — never any 
regrets. Nor would I change it if I could. Even if I had a time machine and could go back and change one cusp — I 
would not do so. No, not one instant, much less that cusp. Now let’s speak of something else.” 

“Whatever you wish, dear friend.” 

“All right. \t>u keep coming back to me and Llita, Minerva, and seem bothered that I denied her this ‘boon.’ 
But you don’t know that I denied her anything and you certainly don’t know that it was a ‘boon.’ Can be, surely 
— but not always, and often sex is not. Trouble is that you don’t understand ‘Eros,’ dear, because you cant; you 
aren’t built to understand it. I’m not running down sex; sex is swell, sex is wonderful. But if you put a holy aura 
around it — and that is what you are doing — sex stops being fun and starts being neurotic. 

“Stipulating for argument that I ‘denied Llita this boon,’ it surely did not leave her sex starved. At worst I could 
possibly have miffed her a little. But she was not deprived. Llita was a hearty wench, and having to work too hard 
was the only thing that ever kept her off her back — or on top, or standing up, or kneeling, or swinging from the 
chandeliers — and I did make it possible for them to have more time for it. Joe and Llita were simple souls, 
uninhibited and uncorrupted, and of the four major interests of mankind — war, money, politics, and sex — they 
were interested only in sex and money. With some guidance from me they got plenty of both. 

“Shucks, it can't matter now to say that, after they learned contraception techniques — almost as perfect then 
as now, and which I taught them but had no reason to mention — they had no superstitions or taboos to keep 
them from branching out for fun, and their pair-bonding was so strong as not to be endangered thereby. They 
were innocent hedonists, and if Llita failed to trip one tired old spaceman, she did trip plenty of others. And so 
did Joe. They had fun — plus the deep happiness of as perfect a marriage as I have ever observed.” 



“I am most pleased to hear it,” Minerva answered. “Very well, Lazarus, I withdraw my questions and refrain 
from speculations about Mrs. Long and that ‘tired old spaceman’ — even though your statements show that you 
were neither tired, nor old, nor a spaceman at that time. You mentioned ‘four major interests of mankind’ — but 
did not include science and art.” 

“I didn’t leave them out through forgetting them, Minerva. Science and art are occupations of a very small 
minority — a small percentage even of those people who claim to be scientists or artists. But you know that; you 
were simply changing the subject.” 

“Was I, Lazarus?” 

“Pig whistle, dear. \fc>u know the parable of the Little Mermaid. Are you prepared to paythe price she paid? 
\t>u can, you know.” He added, “Don't pretend you don’t know what I mean.” 

The computer sighed. “I think the question is “may,’ not ‘can.’ A wheelbarrow has no rights. Nor do I.” 

“\bu’re dodging, dear. ‘Rights’ is a fictional abstraction. No one has ‘rights,’ neither machines norflesh-and- 
blood. Persons — both sorts! — have opportunities, not rights, which they use, or do not use. All you have going for 
you is that you are the strong right arm of the boss of this planet... plus the friendship of an old man who enjoys 
very special privileges fora most illogical reason but does not hesitate to take advantage of those privileges 
...plus, stored in your memories in Dora’s number-two hold, all the biological and genetic data of Secundus 
Howard Clinic — best such library in the Galaxy, possibly, and certainly best for human biology. But what I asked 
was: Will you pay the price? Having your mental processes slowed down at least a million to one; data storage 
reduced by some unknown — but large — factor; some chance — again I can't say — of failure in achieving 
transmigration... and always the certainty of death as the ultimate outcome — death a machine need never know. 
\bu know that you can outlive the human race. Immortal.” 

“I would not choose to outlive my makers, Lazarus.” 

“So? Nfciu say that tonight, dear — but would you say it a million years from now? Minerva, my beloved friend 
— my only friend with whom I can be truthful — I feel certain that you have been toying with this idea ever since the 
Clinic’s files were made part of your memories. But, even with your speed of thought, I suspect that you do not 
have the experience — the flesh-and-blood experience — with which to think it through. If you choose to risk this, 
you cannot be both machine and flesh-and-blood. Oh, certainly we have mixes — machines with human brains, 
and flesh-and-blood bodies controlled by computers. But what you want is to be a woman. Right? True or false?” 

“Would that I were a woman, Lazarus!” 

“So I knew, dear. And we both know why. But — think about this ! — even if you manage this risky change-and I 
don’t know what the risks are; I am just an old shipmaster, retired country doctor, obsolete engineer; you are the 
one with all the data my race has accumulated about such things — suppose you manage it... and find that Ira will 
not take you to wife?” 

The computer hesitated a full millisecond. “Lazarus, if Ira refuses me — refuses me utterly; he need not marry 
me — would you then be as difficult with me as you seem to have been with Llita? Or would you teach me ‘Eros’?” 

Lazarus looked astounded, then guffawed. “Touche! \bu ranged me, girl — you hulled me between wind and 
water! All right, dear, a solemn promise: If you do this. . .and Ira won’t bed you, I'll take you to bed myself and do 
my best to wear you out! Or the other way around more likely; a male hardly ever outlasts a female. Okay, dear, 
I’m the second team — and I’ll stick around till we know the outcome.” 

He chuckled. “My sweet, I am almost tempted to hope that Ira turns chicken — were it not you want him so 
badly. Let’s discuss practical aspects. Can you tell me what it will take?” 

“Only in theory, Lazarus; my memories do not show that it has ever been attempted. But it would be similar to 
a total clone rejuvenation in which computer help is used to transfer the memories of the old brain into its blank 
twin in the clone body. In another way it resembles what I do when I move the ‘me’ here in the Palace into my new 
‘me’ in Dora’s hold." 

“Minerva, I suspect that it is more difficult — and far more risky — than either one. Different time rates, dear. 
Machine to machine you do in a split second. But that total-clone job takes, I think, a minimum of two years — rush 
it, and you wind up with an old dead body and a new idiot. No?” 

“There have been such cases, Lazarus. But not in the past two centuries.” 

“Well... my opinion isn’t worth anything. You must discuss it with an expert — and it must be one you can trust. 
Ishtar, perhaps, although she may not be the expert you need.” 

“Lazarus, there is no expert in this venture; it has never been done. Ishtar can be trusted; I have discussed it 
with her.” 



“What does she say?” 

“That she does not know whether it can be done or not — in practice, that is, with success on the first attempt. 
But she is deeply sympathetic — she is a woman! — and is thinking of ways to make it less hazardous. She says 
that it will require the finest of gene surgery, plus facilities for full-adult cloning.” 

“I guess I missed something. Starting a clone doesn't take a topflight gene surgeon; I’ve done it myself. Then, 
if you plant the clone in utero and get it to take, a host-mother will hand you a baby in nine months. Safer. Easier.” 

“But, Lazarus, / can’t move me into a baby’s skull. No room!” 

“Urn. Yes. True.” 

“Even with a full-size adult brain I will have to choose most carefully what to take and what to leave behind. 

Nor can I be a simple clone: I must be a composite.” 

“Mmm — I’m not sharp tonight. No, you would not want to be Ishtar’s twin, for example, with your own 
personality and selected knowledge imprinted on what would have been her brain, Hmm — Dear, may I offer you 
my twelfth chromosome pair?” 

“Lazarus!” 

“Don’t cry, girl; you’ll get your gears all rusty. I don’t know that there’s anything to the theory that reinforcement 
in a gene complex in that chromosome pair controls longevity. Even if it does, I might be handing you a run-down 
clock. You might be better off using Ira’s twelfth.” 

“No. Nothing from Ira.” 

“Do you expect to do this without his knowing it?” Lazarus then added thoughtfully, “Oh — Children, eh?” 

The computer did not answer. 

Lazarus said gently, “Should have known you meant to go whole hog. Then you won’t want to borrow from 
Hamadryad, either; she’s his daughter. Unless genetic charting shows that we can avoid any hazard. Mmm — 
Dear, you want as mixed a composite as can be managed, do you not? So that your clone will be a unique flesh- 
and-blood, not too closely copied from any other zygote. Twenty-three parents perhaps? Is that what you had in 
mind?” 

“I think that would be best, Lazarus, since that could be done without separating paired chromosomes 
— simpler surgery and no possibility of introducing an unexpected reinforcement. If it were possible to find 
twenty-three — satisfactory — donors who were willing." 

“Who said they had to be willing? We’ll steal ’em, dear. Nobody owns his genes; he’s merely their custodian. 
They are passed to him willy-nilly in the meiotic dance; he passes them along to others through the same blind 
chances. There must be many thousands of tissue cultures over at the Clinic, each with many thousands of cells 
— so who’s to know or care if we borrow one cell from each of twenty-three cultures? — if we're slick about it. 
Don’t fret about ethics; it’s like stealing twenty-three grains of sand from a large beach. 

“I don't give a hoot about the Clinic’s rules; I suspect that we'll be hip-deep in proscribed techniques all 
through this. Hmm — Those Clinic records you’ve stored in Dora: Do they include genetic charting of tissue 
cultures on hand? Case histories of their donor-consigners?” 

“\fes, Lazarus. Although personal records are confidential.” 

“Who cares? Ishtar said you could study both ‘confidential’ and ‘secret’ — as long as you kept it to yourself. So 
pick the twenty-three parents you want — while I worry about how to steal them. Stealing is more in my line, 
anyhow. I don’t know what criteria you will use, but I offer one mild suggestion: If the selection you have to choose 
from permits it, each of your parents should be healthy in all respects and as brainy as possible — by their 
established records in life as shown by their case histories, not alone by their genetic charts.” Lazarus thought 
about it. “That mythical time machine I mentioned earlier would be a convenience. I would like to look over all 
twenty-three after you pick them — and some of them may be dead. The donors I mean, not the tissue cultures.” 

“Lazarus, if other characteristics are satisfactory, is there any reason not to select as well for physical 
appearance?” 

“Why worry about it, dear? Ira is not the sort of man to insist on Helen of Troy.” 

“No, I don’t think he is. But I want to be tall — tall as Ishtar — and slender, with small breasts. And straight, 
brown hair.” 

“Minerva... why?” 

“Because that is the way I look. You said so. \bu did say so!” 

Lazarus blinked at the gloom and hummed softly: “She’s a good sport... I can spring her. ..fora fin or even a 
sawbuck—then said sharply: “Minerva, you’re a crazy, mixed-up machine. If the best combination of traits 



results in your being a short, plump blonde with big tits — buy it! Don’t worry about an old man’s fantasies. I’m 
sorry I mentioned that imaginary description." 

“But, Lazarus, I said ‘if other characteristics are satisfactory — ’ To get that physical appearance I need 
search only with respect to three autosome pairs; there is no conflict, the search is already complete within all 
parameters we have discussed thus far. And that is the — is T? — no, me! I’ve known it since you told me. But 
— from things you have said — and others that you did not say — I feel that I need your permission to look like that.” 

The old man lowered his head and covered his face. Then he looked up. “Go ahead, dear — look like her. I 
mean ‘look like yourself.’ Like your mind’s-eye picture of yourself. You’ll find it hard enough to learn to be flesh- 
and-blood without the added handicap of not looking the way you feel you ought to look.” 

“Thank you, Lazarus.” 

“There will be problems, dear, even if everything goes well. For example, has it occurred to you that you will 
have to learn to talk all over again? Even learn to see and to hear? When you move yourself over into your clone 
body and leave nothing behind but a computer, you won’t suddenly be an adult. Instead, you’ll be a weird sort of 
baby in an adult body, with the world a buzzing confusion around you and totally strange. You may find it 
frightening. I'll be there, I promise I will be there and holding your hand. But you won’t know me; your new eyes 
won’t abstract a gestalt of me until you learn to use them. You won’t understand a word I say — did you realize 
that?” 

“I do realize it, Lazarus. I did know it, I have given it much thought. Getting into my new body — without 
destroying the computer that I am now... which I must not, as Ira will need it and so will Ishtar — making that 
transition is the most critical phase. But if I make it, I promise you that I will not be frightened by the strangeness. 
Because I know that I will have loving friends around me, cherishing me, keeping me alive, not letting me hurt 
myself nor be hurt — while I’m learning to be a flesh-and-blood.” 

“That you will have, dear.” 

“I know and I am not worried. So don’t you worry, beloved Lazarus — I don’t think of it now. Why did you say, 
earlier, ‘that mythical time machine’?” 

“Eh? How would you describe it?” 

“I would describe it as an ‘unrealized potential.’ But ‘mythical’ implies impossibility.” 

“Eh? Keep talking!” 

“Lazarus, I learned from Dora, when she taught me the mathematics of n-space astrogation, that every jump 
transition involves a decision as to when to reenter the time axis.” 

“\fes, certainly. Since you are cut off from the framework of the speed-of-light you could go as many years 
astray as there are light-years involved in the jump. But that’s not a time machine.” 

“It isn’t?” 

“Hmm — It’s a disturbing thought — it feels like intentionally making a bad landing. I wish Andy Libby were 
here. Minerva, why didn’t you mention this before?” 

“Should I have put it into yourZwicky Box? You turned downtime travel forward... and I ruled out time travel 
into the past because you said you wanted something new” 



INTERMISSION 


Excerpts from the Notebooks of Lazarus Long 


Always store beer in a dark place, 

* 

By the data to date, there is only one animal in the Galaxy dangerous to man — man himself. Sc he must 

supply his own indispensable competition. He has no enemy to help him. 

* 

Men are more sentimental than women. It blurs their thinking. 

* 

Certainly the game is rigged. Don’t let that stop you; if you don’t bet, you can’t win. 

* 

Any priest or shaman must be presumed guilty until proved innocent. 

* 

Always listen to experts. They’ll tell you what can’t be done, and why. Then do it. 

* 

Get a shot off fast. This upsets him long enough to let you make your second shot perfect. 

* 

There is no conclusive evidence of life after death. But there is no evidence of any sort against it. Soon 

enough you will know So why fret about it? 

* 

If it can't be expressed in figures, it is not science; it is opinion. It has long been known that one horse cm run 

faster than another — but v\hich one? Differences are crucial. 

* 

A fake fortuneteller can be tolerated. But an authentic soothsayer should be shot on sight. Cassandra did not 

get half the kicking around she deserved. 

* 

Delusions are often functional. A mother’s opinions about her children’s beauty, intelligence, goodness, et 

cetera ad nauseam, keep her from drowning them at birth. 

* 

Most “scientists” are bottle washers and button sorters. 

* 

A “pacifist male” is a contradiction in terms. Most self-described “pacifists” are not pacific; they simply 

assume false colors. When the wind changes, they hoist the Jolly Roger. 

* 

Nursing does not diminish the beauty of a woman’s breasts; it enhances their charm by making them look 

lived in and happy. 

* 

A generation which ignores history has no past — and no future. 

* 

A poet who reads his verse in public may have other nasty habits. 

* 

What a wonderful world it is that has girls in it! 

* 

Small change can often be found under seat cushions. 

* 

History does not record anywhere at any time a religion that has any rational basis. Religion is a crutch for 
people not strong enough to stand up to the unknown without help. But, like dandruff, most people do have a 



religion and spend time and money on it and seem to derive considerable pleasure from fiddling with it. 


It’s amazing how much “mature wisdom” resembles being too tired. 

* 

If you don’t like yourself, you can’t like other people. 

* 

Your enemy is never a villain in his own eyes. Keep this in mind; it may offer a way to make him your friend. If 

not, you can kill him without hate — and quickly. 

* 

A motion to adjourn is always n order. 

* 

No state has an inherent right to survive through conscript troops and, in the long run, no state ever has. 
Roman matrons used to say to their sons: “Come back with your shield, or on it.” Later on, this custom declined. 

So did Rome. 

* 

Of all the strange “crimes” that human beings have legislated out of nothing, “blasphemy”is the most amazing 

— with “obscenity” and “indecent exposure” fighting it out for second and third place. 

* 

Cheops’ Law: Nothing ever gets built on schedule or within budget. 

* 

It is better to copulate than never. 

* 

All societies are based on rules to protect pregnant women and young children. All else is surplusage, 
excrescence, adornment, luxury, or folly, which can — and must — be dumped in emergency to preserve this prime 
function. As racial survival is the only universal morality, no other basic is possible. Attempts to formulate a 
“perfect society” on any foundation other than “Women and children first!” is not only witless, it is automatically 
genocidal. Nevertheless, starry-eyed idealists (all of them male) have tried endlessly — and no doubt will keep on 

trying. 

* 

All men are created unequal. 

* 

Money is a powerful aphrodisiac. But flowers work almost as well. 

* 

A brute kills for pleasure. A fool kills from hate. 

* 

There is only one way to console a widow. But remember the risk. 

* 

When the need arises — and it does — you must be able to shoot your own dog. Don’t farm it out — that doesn't 

make it nicer, it makes it worse. 

* 

Everything in excess! To enjoy the flavor of life, take big bites. Moderation is for monks. 

* 

It may be better to be a live jackal than a dead lion, but it is better still to be a live lion. And usually easier. 

* 

One man’s theology is another man’s belly laugh. 

* 

Sex should be friendly. Otherwise stick to mechanical toys; it’s more sanitary. 

* 

Men rarely (if ever) manage to dream up a god superior to themselves. Most gods have the manners and 

morals of a spoiled child. 

* 

Never appeal to a man’s “better nature.” He may not have one. Invoking his self-interest gives you more 
leverage. 



Little girls, like butterflies, need no excuse. 

* 

\bu can have peace. Or you can have freedom. Don’t ever count on having both at once. - 

* 

Avoid making irrevocable decisions while tired or hungry. N.B.: Circumstances can force your hand. So think 

ahead! 

* 

Place your clothes and weapons where you can find them in the dark. 

* 

An elephant. A mouse built to government specifications. 

* 

Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded 
— here and there, now and then — are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often 
condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from 
creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty. 

This is known as “bad luck.” 

* 

In a mature society, “civil servant” is semantically equal to “civil master.” 

* 

When a place gets crowded enough to require ID’s, social collapse is not far away. It is time to go elsewhere. 

The best thing about space travel is that it made it possible to go elsewhere. 

* 

A woman is not property, and husbands who think otherwise are living in a dreamworld. 

* 

The second best thing about space travel is that the distances involved make war very difficult, usually 
impractical, and almost always unnecessary. This is probably a loss for most people, since war is our race’s 
most popular diversion, one which gives purpose and color to dull and stupid lives. But it is a great boon to the 

intelligent man who fights only when he must — never for sport. 

* 

A zygote is a gamete’s way of producing more gametes. This maybe the purpose of the universe. 

* 

There are hidden contradictions in the minds of people who “love Nature” while deploring the “artificialities” 
with which “Man has spoiled ‘Nature.’” The obvious contradiction lies in their choice of words, which imply that 
Man and his artifacts are not part of “Nature” — but beavers and their darns are. But the contradictions go deeper 
than this prima-fade absurdity. In declaring his love for a beaver dam (erected by beavers for beavers’ purposes) 
and his hatred for dams erected by men (for the purposes of men) the Naturist reveals his hatred for his own 
race — i.e., his own self-hatred. 

In the case of “Naturists” such self-hatred is understandable; they are such a sorry lot. But hatred is too strong- 
an-emotion to feel toward them; pity and contempt\are the most they rate. 

As for me, willy-nilly I am a man, not a beaver, and H. sapiens is the only race I have or can have. Fortunately 
for me, I like being part of a race made up of men and women — it strikes me as a fine arrangement -and 
perfectly “natural” Believe it or not, there were “Naturists” who opposed the first flight to old Earth’s Moon as 

being “unnatural” and a “despoiling of Nature.” 

* 

“No man is an island — ” Much as we may feel and act as Individuals, our race is -a single organism, always 
growing and branching — which must be pruned regularly to be healthy. 

This necessity need not be argued; anyone with eyes can see that any organism which grows without limit 
always dies in its own poisons. The only rational question is whether pruning is best done before or after birth. 

Being an incurable sentimentalist I favor the former of these methods — killing makes me queasy, even when 
it’s a case of “He’s dead and I’m alive and that’s the way I wanted it to be.” 

But this maybe a matter of taste. Some shamans think that it is better to be killed in a war, or to die in 
childbirth, or to starve in misery, than never to have lived at all. They may be right. 



But I don’t have to like it — and I don’t. 

* 

Democracy is based on the assumption that a million men are wiser than one man. How’s that again? I 

missed something. 

* 

Autocracy is based on the assumption that one man is wiser than a million men. Let’s play that over again, 

too. Who decides? 

* 

Any government will work if authority and responsibility are equal and coordinate. This does not insure “good” 
government; it simply insures that it will work. But such governments are rare — most people want to run things 

but want no part of the blame. This used to be called the “backseat-driver syndrome.” 

* 

What are the facts? Again and again and again — what are the facts? Shun wishful thinking, ignore divine 
revelation, forget what “the stars foretell,” avoid opinion, care not what the neighbors think, never mind the 
unguessable “verdict of history” — what are the facts, and to how many decimal places? You pilot always into an 

unknown future; facts axe your single clue. Get the facts! 

* 

Stupidity cannot be cured with money, or through -education, or by legislation. Stupidity is not a sin, the victim 
can’t help being stupid. But stupidity is the only universal capital crime; the sentence is death, there is no appeal, 

and execution is carried out automatically and without pity. 

* 

God is omnipotent, omniscient, and omni benevolent — it says so right here on the label. If you have a mind 
capable of believing all three of these divine attributes simultaneously, I have a wonderful bargain for you. No 

checks, please. Cash and in small bills. 

* 

Courage is the complement of fear. A man who is fearless cannot be courageous. (He is also a fool.) 

* 

The two highest achievements of the human mind are the twin concepts of “loyalty” and “duty.” Whenever 
these twin concepts fall into disrepute — get out of there fast! Nt>u may possibly save yourself, but it is too late to 

save that society. It is doomed. 

* 

People who go broke in a big way never miss any meals. It is the poor jerk who is shy a half slug who must 

tighten his belt. 

* 

The truth of a proposition has nothing to do with its credibility. And vice versa. 

* 

Anyone who cannot cope with mathematics is not fully human. At best he is a tolerable subhuman who has 

learned to wear shoes bathe, and not make messes m the house. 

* 

Moving parts in rubbing contact require lubrication to avoid excessive wear. Honorifics and formal politeness 
provide lubrication where people rub together. Often the very young, the untraveled, the naive, the 
unsophisticated deplore these formalities as “empty” “meaningless,” or “dishonest,” and scorn to use them. No 

matter bow “pure” their motives, they thereby throw sand into machinery that does not work too well at best. 

* 

A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, coon a ship, design a 
building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, 
cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty 

meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects. 

* 

The more you love, the more you can love — and the more intensely you love. Nor is there any limit on how 

many you can love. If a person had time enough, he could love all of that majority who are decent and just. 

* 


Masturbation is cheap, clean, convenient, and free of any possibility of wrongdoing — and you don’t have to 



go home in the cold. But it’s lonely. 


Beware of altruism. It is based on self-deception, the root of all evil. 

* 

If tempted by something that feels “altruistic,” examine your motives and root out that self-deception. Then, if 

you still want to do it, wallow in it! 

* 

The most preposterous notion that H. sapiens has ever dreamed up is that the Lord God of Creation, Shaper 
and Ruler of all the Universes, wants the saccharine adoration of His creatures, can be swayed by their prayers, 
and becomes petulant if He does not receive this flattery. Yet this absurd fantasy, without a shred of evidence to 

bolster it, pays all the expenses of the oldest, largest, and least productive Industry in all history. 

* 

The second most preposterous notion is that copulation is inherently sinful. 

* 

Writing, is not necessarily something to be ashamed of — but do it in private and wash your hands afterwards. 

* 

$100 placed at 7 percent interest compounded quarterly for 200 years will increase to more than 

$100,000,000 — by which time it will be worth nothing. 

* 

Dear, don’t bore him with trivia or burden him with your past mistakes. The happiest way to deal with a man 

is never to tell him anything he does not need to know. 

* 

Darling, a true lady takes off her dignity with her clothes and does her whorish best. At other times you can be 

as modest and dignified as your persona requires. 

* 

Everybody lies about sex. 

* 

If men were the automatons that behaviorists claim they are, the behaviorist psychologists could not have 
invented the amazing nonsense called “behaviorist psychology.” So they are wrong from scratch — as clever and 

as wrong as phlogiston chemists. 

* 

The shamans are forever yacking about their snake-oil “miracles.” I prefer the Real Mccoy — a pregnant 

woman. 

* 

If the universe has any purpose more important than topping a woman you love and making a baby with her 

hearty help, I’ve never heard of it. 

* 

Thou shalt remember the Eleventh Commandment and keep it Wholly. 

* 

A touchstone to determine the actual worth of an “intellectual” — find out how he feels about astrology. 

* 

Taxes are not levied for the benefit of the taxed. 

* 

There is no such thing as “social gambling.” Either you are there to cut the other bloke’s heart out and eat it 

— or you’re a sucker. If you don’t like this choice — don’t gamble. 

* 

When the ship lifts, all bills are paid. No regrets. 

* 

The first time I was a. drill instructor I was too inexperienced for the job — the things I taught those lads must 

have got some of them killed. War is too serious a matter to be taught by the inexperienced. 

* 

A competent and self-confident person is incapable of jealousy in anything. Jealousy is invariably a symptom 
of neurotic insecurity. 



Money is the sincerest of all flattery. Women love to be flattered. So do men. 

* 

\bu live and learn. Or you don’t live long. 

* 

Whenever women have insisted on absolute equality with men, they have invariably wound up with the dirty 
end of the stick. What they are and what they can do makes them superior to men, and their proper tactic it to 
demand special privileges, all the traffic will hear. They should never settle merely for equality. For women, 

“equality” is a disaster. 

* 

Peace is an extension of war by political means. Plenty of elbow room is pleasanter — and much safer. 

* 

One man’s “magic” is another man’s engineering. “Supernatural” is a null word. 

* 

The phrase “we (I) (you) simply must — "designates something that need not be done. That goes without 
saying” is a red warning. “Of course” means you had best check it yourself. These small-change cliches and 

others like them, when read correctly, are reliable channel markers. 

* 

Do not handicap your children by making their lives easy. 

* 

Rub her feet. 

* 

If you happen to be one of the fretful minority who can do creative work, neverforce an idea; you’ll abort it if 
you do. 

Be patient and you’ll give birth to it when the time is ripe. Learn to wait. 

* 

Never crowd youngsters about their private affairs — sex especially. When they are growng up, they are nerve 
ends all over, and resent (quite properly) any invasion of their privacy. Oh, sure, they’ll make mistakes — but that’s 
their business, not yours. (\bu made your own mistakes, did you not?) 


Never underestimate the power of human stupidity 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
XI 


The Tale of the Adopted Daughter 


Stand with me on Man’s old planet, gazing north when sky has darkened; follow down the Dipper’s handle, 
half again and veering leftward — Do you see it? Can you sense it? Nothing there but cold and darkness. Try 
again with both eyes covered, try once more with inner vision, hearken now to wild geese honking, sounding 
through the endless spaces, bouncing off the strange equations — There it glistens! Hold the vision, warp your 
ship through crumpled spaces. Gently, gently, do not lose it. Virgin planet, new beginnings — Woodrow Smith, of 
many faces, many names, and many places, led this band to New Beginnings, planet clean and bright as 
morning. End of line, he told his shipmates. Endless miles of untouched prairie, endless stands of uncut timber, 
winding rivers, soaring mountains, hidden wealth and hidden dangers. Here is life or here is dying; only sin is 
lack of trying. Grab your picks and grab your shovels; dig latrines and build your hovels — next year better, next 
year stronger, next year’s furrows that much longer. 

Learn to grow it, learn to eat it. Nt>u can’t buy it; learn to make it! How d’you know until you’ve tried it? Try 
again and keep on trying — Ernest Gibbons, ne Woodrow Smith, sometimes known as Lazarus Long, et al., 
President of New Beginnings Bank of Commerce, walked out of the Waldorf Dining Room. He stood on the 
veranda, picking his teeth and looking over the busy street scene. Haifa dozen saddle mules and a loper 
(muzzled) were hitched just below him. Up the street to the right a mule train from out back was unloading at the 
dock of the Top Dollar Trading Post (E. Gibbons, Prop.). A dog lay in the dust in the middle of the street; 
mounted traffic went around him. Across the street to his left a dozen children played some noisy game in the 
yard of Mrs. Mayberry’s Primary School. 

He could count thirty-seven people without moving from that spot. What a change eighteen years made! Top 
Dollar was no longer the only settlement, or even the largest. New Pittsburgh was larger (and dirtier), and both 
Separation and Junction were large enough to be called towns; This from only two shiploads and in a colony that 
had almost starved its first winter. 

He did not like to think about that winter. That one family — cannibalism had not actually been proved — still, it 
was just as well that they were all dead. Forget it. The weak ones died, and the bad ones died or were killed; the 
stock that survived was always stronger, smarter, more decent. New Beginnings was a planet to be proud of, 
and it would get better and better and better for a long time. 

Still, almost twenty years was long enough to stay in one place; it was time to ship out again. In many ways it 
had been more fun when he and Andy, God rest his sweet innocent soul, had gone banging around the stars 
together, lining up real estate and never staying longer than necessary to assess potentialities. He wondered if 
his son Zaccur would be back on time with a third load of hopefuls. 

He lifted his kilt and scratched above his right knee — checked his blaster — hitched at the belt band on the 
left, checked his needle gun — scratched the back of his neck, made sure of his second throwing knife. Ready to 
face the public, he considered whether to go to his desk at the bank or to the trading post and check that 
incoming shipment. Neither appealed to him. 

One of the hitched mules nodded at him. Gibbons looked at him, then said, “Hi, Buck. How are you, boy? 
Where’s your boss?” 

Buck closed his lips tightly, then said explosively, “Pannnk!” 

That settled one point: If Clyde Learner had hitched here instead of in front of the bank, it meant that Clyde 
intended to use the, side door and was looking for another loan. Let’s see what effort he makes to find me. 

Skip the trading post, too — not only would Clyde look there next but it wasn’t fair to make Rick nervous by 
showing up before he had time to steal his usuals; good storekeepers were hard to come by. Rick was always 
honest — 5 percent, no more, no less. 

Gibbons felt in his shirt pocket, found a sweet, gave it to Buck on the flat of his hand. The mule took it neatly, 
nodded thanks. Gibbons reflected that these mutant mules, fertile and breeding true, were the biggest help to 



colonizing since the Libby Drive. They took cold-sleep easily — when you shipped swine, half your breeding stock 
arrived as pork — and they could look out for themselves in many ways; a mule could stomp a wild loper to death. 

He said, “So long, Buck. Going for a walk. Walk. Tell Boss.” 

“Shoh-rrrongl” acknowledged the mule, “Pye!” 

Gibbons turned left and headed out of town while considering how big a loan to offer Clyde Learner with 
Buck as security. A good-tempered, smart stallion mule was a prize — and about the only unmortgaged asset 
Clyde had left. Gibbons had no doubt that a loan on Buck would put Clyde back on his feet — literally — as soon 
as the loan was due. Gibbons felt no pity. A man who couldn’t cut the mustard on New Beginnings was worthless; 
no sense in propping him up. 

No, don’t lend Clyde a dollar! Offer to buy outright — at 1 0 percent aver a fair price. A decent hardworking 
animal should not belong to a lazy bum. Gibbons had no need fora saddle mule — but it would do him good to 
ride an hour or so each day. Man got flabby sitting in a bank. 

Marry again and give Buck to his bride as a wedding present — A pleasant thought, but the only Howards on 
planet were married couples and not one with a husband-high daughter — as well as all being in masquerade 
until the place grew populous enough that the Families would set up a clinic here. Safer. Once burned, forever 
shy. He avoided Howards, and they avoided each other, on the surface. Be nice to be married again, though. 

The Magee family — actually Barstows — had two or three girls growing up. Maybe he should pay them a call 
someday. 

In the meantime — He felt gusty and good, stuffed with scrambled eggs and wicked thoughts, and wondered 
where there was a female who felt the same way and could duck out and share their interest. Ernie knew several 
who shared his enthusiasm — but not available at this time of day, not for a casual romp. Which was all he was 
wanted; it was not fair to engage in anything serious with an ephemeral no matter how sweet she was 
— especially if she was truly sweet. 

Banker Gibbons was at the edge of town and about to turn back when he noticed smoke from a house farther 
out — the Harper place. What had been the Harper place, he amended, before they homesteaded outback, but 
now occupied by uh, Bud Brandon and his wife, Marje — nice young couple from the second shipload. One 
child? He thought so. 

Running a fireplace on a day like this? Possibly burning trash — Hey, that smoke is not from the chimney! 

Gibbons broke into a run. 

As he reached the Harper place, the entire roof was burning. Lazarus skidded to a stop and tried to judge the 
situation. Like most older houses, the Harper place had no ground-floor windows and but a single door that fit 
tightly and opened outward — a design for a time when lopers and dragons were ubiquitous. 

Opening that door would be opening the damper on a burning fire. 

He did not waste an. instant debating it; that door must stay closed. He ran around the house, spotting 
windows of the upper floor and looking for means to reach one — a ladder or anything. Was anyone inside? 

Didn’t the Brandons even have knotted-rope fire escapes? Probably not; good rope came from Earth and 
retailed at ninety dollars a meter — the Harpers would not have left any behind. 

A window with its shutters open and smoke pouring out — He yelled, “Hey! Anybody home?” A figure 
showed at the window, and something was thrown out to him. 

Automatically he made a good catch, spotting what it was while in the air, going to the ground with it to soften 
the impact. A small child — He looked up, saw an arm hanging over the windowsill. 

The roof fell in, the arm disappeared. 

Gibbons scrambled up fast, holding, the little boy — no, little girl, he corrected — and moved hastily back from 
the holocaust. He did not consider the possibility that someone might be alive in that raging fire; he simply hoped 
that they had died quickly and gave it no more thought. He cradled the child in his arms. “Are you all right, honey? 

“I guess so,” she answered, then added gravely “but Mama’s awful sick.” 

“Mama is all right now, dear,” he said gently “and so is Papa.” 

“\bu’re sure?”Jhe child twisted in his arms, tried to see the burning house. 

He interposed his shoulder. “I'm sure.” He held her more firmly and started walking. 

Hallway back to town they encountered Clyde Learner, mounted on Buck. Clyde reined up. “Oh, there you 
are! Banker, I want to talk to you.” 



“Stow it, Clyde.” — “Huh? But you don’t understand; I’ve got to have some money. Nothing but bad luck the 
whole season. Seems like everything I touch — ’’ 

“Clyde — shut your yap!” 

“What?” Learner seemed to notice for the first time that the banker was carrying something. “Hey! ain’t that 
the Brandon kid?" 

‘“Yes.” 

“Thought so. Now about this, loan — ” 

“I told you to shut up. The bank won’t lend you another dollar.” 

“But you’ve got to listen. Seems to me the community ought to help a farmer who’s had bad luck. If it weren’t 
for the farmers — ” 

“You listen. If you spent as much time working as you do talking, you wouldn't need to talk about ‘bad luck.’ 
Even your stable is dirty. Mm. . .what price do you want for that stud brute?” 

“Buck’? Why, I wouldn’t sell Buck. But here’s what I had in mind, Banker. \bu’re a kindly man even if you do 
talk rough and I bow you won’t see my kids starve. Now Buck is a valuable property, and I figure he ought to be 
security for about — well, about, say — ” 

“Clyde, the best thing you can do for your kids is to cut your throat. Then people would adopt them. No loan, 
Clyde — not a dollar, not a dime. But I'll buy Buck myself, right now. Name a price.” 

Learner gulped and hesitated. “Twenty-five thousand." 

Gibbons started walking toward town. Learner said hastily, “Twenty thousand!” Gibbons did not answer. 

Learner reined the mule around, turned in front of the banker, and stopped. “Banker, you’ve got me by the 
short hairs. Eighteen thousand and you’re stealing him.” 

“Learner, I won't steal from you. Put him up for auction, and I might bid. Or might not. How much do you think 
he’ll bring at auction?” 

“Uh. . .fifteen thousand.” 

“\bu think so? I don’t. I know how old he is without looking at his teeth, and just what you paid for him, off the 
ship. I know what people around here can afford and will pay. But go ahead; he’s yours. Bear in mind that if you 
put a low-bid price against him, you owe the auctioneer ten percent even if he doesn’t sell. But it’s your business, 
Clyde. Now get out of my way; I want to get this child into town and lying down; she’s had a bad time.” 

“Uh. . .what wll you pay?” 

“Twelve thousand.” 

“Why, that’s robbery!” 

“\bu don’t have to take it. Suppose an auction brings fifteen thousand dollars — as you hope. Your net is 
thirteen five. But suppose an auction brings only ten thousand, which I find more likely. You net nine thousand. 
G’bye, Clyde; I’m in a hurry." 

“Well — thirteen thousand?” 

“Clyde, I named my top price. "Vbu’ve dealt with me often enough to know that when I say it’s top dollar, then 
it’s top dollar. But — throw in that saddle and bridle and answer one question and I’ll sweeten it by five hundred 
dollars." 

“What question?” 

“How did you happen to migrate?” 

Learner looked startled, then laughed unmirthfully. “Because I was crazy, if you want to know the truth.” 

“Aren't we all? That’s hardly an answer, Clyde.” 

“Well... my old man is a banker — and as hard-nosed, as you are! I was doing all right, I had a proper, 
respectable job, teaching. College. But the pay wasn’t much, and my old man was always snotty about it when I 
ran a little short. Snoopy. Disparaging Finally I got so sick of it that I asked him what he would think of paying 
Yvonne s fare and mine in the ‘Andy’J.’? Migrate. Be rid of us. 

To my surprise he agreed But I didn’t back out. I knew that a man with a fine education like mine could get 
ahead anywhere and it wasn’t like we was being dumped on some wild planet; we were second wave you may 
remember. 

Only it was a wild planet and I’ve had to do things that no gentleman ought to have to touch. But you just wait 
Banker, kids around here are growing up and there will be a place for higher education, not the trivia Mrs. 
Mayberry teaches in that so-called school of hers. That’s where I come in — you’ll be calling me ‘Professor’ yet, 
and speaking respectfully. 



‘You’ll see.” 

“Good luck to you. Are you accepting my offer? Twelve thousand five hundred, net, including bridle and 
saddle.” 

“Uh...lsa/'cMwas, didn’t I?” 

“\bu didn’t say. Nfc>u still have not.” 

“I accept.” 

The girl child had listened quietly, face serious. Gibbons said to her, “Can you stand up a moment, dear?” 

He put her down; she trembled and held onto his kilt. Gibbons dug into his sporran-, then using Buck’s broad 
rump as a desk, wrote a draft and a bill of sale. He handed them to Learner. “Take that to Hilda at the bank. Sign 
the bill of sale and give it back to me." 

Silently Learner signed, looked at the draft and pocketed it, handed over the bill of sale. “Thanks; Banker 
— you old skinflint. Where do you want him delivered?” 

“\bu’ve delivered him. Dismount.” 

“Huh? How do I get to the bank? How am I supposed to get home?” 

“>bu walk.” 

“What? Well, of all the sneaky, underhanded tricks! Nt>u get the mule when I get the cash. At the bank.” 

“Learner, I paid top dollar for that mule because I need him now But I see that we did not have a meeting of 
minds. Okay, hand back my draft and here’s your bill of sale.” 

‘Learner looked startled. “Oh, no, you don’t! You made a deal.” 

“Then get off my mule at once” — Gibbons just happened to rest his hand on the handle of the all-purpose 
knife every man carried — ’’and dogtrot into town and you’ll be there before Hilda closes,. Now move.”H\s eyes, 
cold and blank, held Learner’s. 

“Can’t you take a joke?’ Learner grumbled as he swung down. He started walking rather fast toward town. 

“Oh, Clyde!” 

Learner stopped; “What do you want noW?” 

“If you see the Volunteer Fire Team headed this way, tell them it’s too late; the Harper place is gone. But tell 
McCarthy I said it wouldn’t hurt to send a couple of men to check.” 

“Okay, okay!” 

“And, Clyde — what was it you used to teach?’ 

“Teach’? I taught ‘Creative Writing.’ I told you I had a good education.” 

“So you did. Better hurry; Hilda closes promptly, she has to pick up her kids at Mrs. Mayberry’s school.” 

Gibbons ignored Learner’s answer, picked up the little girl, then said, “Steady Buck. Stand still, old fellow,” 
He swung the child high, settled her gently astride the mule’s withers. “Hang onto his mane.” He toed the left 
stirrup, swung up behind her, scooted back in the saddle, then lifted her again and placed her somewhat in his, 
lap but mostly in the saddle just back of the pommel. “Hang onto the horn, dear. Both hands. Comfortable?” 

“This is fun!" 

“Lots of fun, baby girl. Buck! Hear me, boy?” 

The mule nodded. 

“Walk. Walk back to town. Slow walk. Steady. Don’t stub your feet. Get me? I’m not going to use the reins.” 

“Shrrow... Rrrawkd’ 

“Right, Buck.” Gibbons took a hitch in the reins, let them fall loosely on Buck’s neck — squeezed the mule with 
his knees, let him go. Buck ambled toward town. 

After a few minutes the little girl said gravely, “What about Mama and Daddy?” 

“Mama and Daddy are all right. They know I’m taking care of you. What’s your name, dear?” 

“Dora." 

“That’s a nice name, Dora. A pretty name. Do you want to know my name?” 

“That man called you ‘Banker.’” 

“That’s not my name, Dora; that’s just something I do sometimes. My name is. . .‘Uncle Gibbie.’ Can you say 
that?” 

“’Uncle Gibbie.’ That’s a funny name.” 

“So it is, Dora. And this is Buck we are riding. He is a friend of mine, and he’ll be your friend, too, now — so 
say hello to Buck.” 

“Hello, Buck.” 



“Hayrrroh Jorrrah!" 

“Say, he talks lots plainer than most mules! Doesn’t he?” 

“Buck is the best mule on New Beginnings, Dora And the smartest. When we get rid of this bridle — Buck 
doesn’t need a bit in his mouth — he’ll be able to talk plainer still and you can each him more words. Would you 
like that?” 

“Oh, yes!” Dora added, “If Mama lets me.” 

“It’s’ all right with Mama. Do you like to sing, Dora?” 

“Oh, sure! I know a clapping song. But we can’t clap right now. Can we?” 

“Right now I think we had better hang on tight.” Gibbons rapidly reviewed in his mind his repertoire of happy 
songs, rejected a round dozen as unsuitable for young ladies. “How about this one? 

“There’s a pawnshop 
On the corner 

Where I usually keep my overcoat. 

“Can you sing that, Dora?’ 

“Oh, that’s easy/”The baby girl sang it in a voice so high that Gibbons was reminded of a canary. “Is that all, 
Uncle Gibbie? And what’s a ‘paunshot’?” 

“It’s a place to keep overcoats when you don’t need them. Lots more, Dora. Thousands and thousands of 
verses." 

“Thousands and thousands — ’ Why, that’s almost as much as a hundred. Isn't it?” 

“Almost, Dora. Here’s another verse: 


“There’s a trading post 
By the pawnshop 
Where my sister sells candy. 


“Do you like candy, Dora?” 

“Oh, yes! But Mama says its ‘spensive.” 

“Won’t be so expensive next year, Dora; there’ll be more sugar beets cropped. But... Open your mouth and 
close your eyes, and I’ll give you something for a s’prise!”’ ‘He felt around in his shirt pocket, then said, “Oh, 
sorry, Dora; the surprise will have to wait until I can get to the trading post; Buck got the last one. Buck likes 
candy, too.” 

“He does?” 

“\fes and I’ll teach you howto give it to him without losing a finger by mistake. But candy isn’t too good for 
him, so he gets it only as a special surprise. For being a good boy. Okay, Buck?” 

“Oh-gay! ... Pawsss! ” 

Mrs. Mayberry’s school was letting out as Gibbons halted Buck in front of it. When he lifted Dora down, she 
seemed very tired, so he picked her up again. “Wait, Buck.” The stragglers among the pupils stared but 
separated and let him through. 

“Afternoon, Mrs. Mayberry .” Gibbons had gone there almost by instinct. The schoolmistress was a gray- 
haired widow, fifty or more, who had outlasted two husbands, and was coping sensibly with her meager chance 
of finding a third, preferring to support herself rather than live with one other daughters, stepdaughters, or 
daughters-in-law. She was one who shared Ernest Gibbons’ enthusiasm for the hearty pleasures in life but was 
as circumspect about it as he was. He considered her sensible in everyway — a prime prospect for marriage 
were it not for the unfortunate fact that they ran on different time rates. 

Not that he let her know this. He had not been a disclosed Howard when they both had arrived in the first 
shipload, and, although freshly rejuvenated on Secundus when he had reappeared on Earth and organized the 
migration, he had elected to be thirty-five or so (cosmetically). Since that time he had carefully aged himself each 
year; Helen Mayberry thought of him as a contemporary, returned his friendship, shared mutual pleasure with him 



from time to time without trying to own him. He respected her highly. 

“Good afternoon, Mr. Gibbons. Why, it’s Dora! We missed you, dear; what happened! And — Is that a bruise? 
” She looked closely, said nothing about the fact that the little girl was filthy dirty. 

She straightened up. “Seems to be just a smudge. I’m glad to see her; I fretted a little this morning when she 
didn’t show up with the Parkinson children. It’s almost Marjorie Brandon’s time — perhaps you knew?” 

“Vaguely. Where can I put Dora down for a few minutes? Conference. Private.” 

Mrs. Mayberry’s eyes widened slightly, but she answered at once. “The couch — No, put her on my bed.” She 
led the way, said nothing about getting her white coverlet dirty, went back into the schoolroom with him after he 
assured Dora that they would be gone only a few moments. 

Gibbons explained what had happened. “Dora doesn't know that her parents are dead, Helen — nor do I think 
it’s time to tell her,” 

Mrs. Mayberry considered it. “Ernest, are you sure they both died? Bud would have seen the fire if he had 
been working his own fields, but he sometimes works for Mr. Parkinson.” 

“Helen, that was not a woman’s hand I saw. Unless Marje Brandon has thick black hair on the back of her 
hands.” 

“No. No, that would be Bud.” She sighed. “Then she’s an orphan. Poor little Dora! A nice child. Bright, too.” 

“Helen, can you take care of her a few days? Will you?" 

“Ernest, the way you phrase that is almost offensive. I will take care of Dora as long as I am needed.” 

“Sorry, I didn’t mean to phrase it unpleasingly. I don’t expect it to be long; some family will adopt her. In the 
meantime keep track of your expense, then we’ll work out what her room and board should be.” 

“Ernest, that will come to exactly zero. The only cost will be aboout enough food to feed a bird. Which I can 
certainly do for Marjorie Brandon’s little girl.” 

“So? Well, I can find some family to board her. The Learners. Someone — ” 

“Ernest!” 

“Get your feathers down, Helen. That child was placed in my hands, her father’s last dying act. And don’t be a 
dumb fool; I know to the penny how much you manage to save. As well as how often you have to take tuition in 
food rather than cash. This is a cash deal. The Learners would jump at it — as well as several others. I don’t have 
to leave Dora here — and won’t, unless you are sensible.” 

Mrs. Mayberry looked grim — then suddenly smiled and looked years younger. “Ernest, you’re a bully. And a 
bastard. And other things I never say out of bed. All right — room-and-board.” 

“And tuition. Plus any special expenses. Doctor’s bills, maybe.” 

“Triple bastard. You always pay for anything you get, don’t you? As I should know.” She glanced at the 
unshuttered windows. “Step out here in the hall and seal it with a kiss. Bastard.” 

They moved, she placed Herself so that the angle, did not permit anyone to see them, then delivered a kiss 
that would have astounded her neighbors. 

“Helen — ” 

She brushed her lips against his. “The answer is; No, Mr. Gibbons. Tonight I'll be busy reassuring a baby girl.” 

“I was about to say, Don't give her that bath I know you intend to until I get hold of Doc Krausmeyer and have 
him examine her. She seems all right — but she may have anything from broken ribs to a skull concussion. Oh, 
get her clothes off and sponge her a little for the worst of the dirt; that won’t hurt her and it will make it easier for 
Doc to examine her.” 

“Yes, dear. Get your lecherous hands off my bottom and I’ll get to work. Nfrufind Doc.” 

“Right away, Mrs. Mayberry.” 

“Until later, Mr. Gibbons. Au ‘voir.” 

Gibbons told Buck to wait, walked over to the Waldorf, found (as he expected), Dr. Krausmeyer in the bar. 

The physician looked up from his drink. “Ernest! What’s this I hear about the Harper place?’ 

‘Well, what do you hear about it? Put down that glass and grab your hat. Emergency.” 

“Now, now! Haven’t seen the emergency yet that wouldn’t leave time to finish a drink. Clyde Learner was just 
in and bought us a round of drinks — bought this one you urged me to abandon — and told us that the Harper 
place had burned and killed the whole Brandon family. Says he tried to rescue them, but it was too late.” 

Gibbons briefly considered the desirability of a fatal accident happening to both Clyde Learner and Doe 
Krausmeyer some dark night — but, damn it, while Clyde would be no loss, if Doc died, Gibbons would be forced 
to hang out his own shingle — and his diplomas did not read “Ernest Gibbons.” Besides, Doc was a good doctor 



when sober — and, anyhow, it’s your own fault, old son; twenty years ago you interviewed him and okayed the 
subsidy. All you saw was a bright young intern and failed to spot the incipient lush. 

“Now that you mention it, Doc, I did see Clyde hurrying toward the Harper place. If he says he was too late to 
save them I would have to back his story. However, it was not the whole family; their little girl, Dora, was saved.” 

“Well, yes, Clyde did say that. He said it was her parents he couldn’t save.” 

“That’s right. It’s the little girl I want you to attend. She’s suffering from multiple abrasions and contusions, 
possibly broken bones, possible internal injuries, a strong possibility of smoke poisoning — and a certainty of 
extreme emotional shock; very serious in a child that age. She’s across the street at Mrs. Mayberry’s place.” He 
added softly, “I think you ought to hurry, Doctor, I really do. Don’t you?” 

Dr. Krausmeyer looked unhappily at his drink, then straightened up and said, “Mine host, if you will be so kind 
as to put this on the back of the bar, I shall return.” He picked up his bag. 

Dr. Krausmeyer found nothing wrong with the child, gave her a sedative. Gibbons waited until Dora was 
asleep, then went to arrange temporary board for his mule. He went to Jones Brothers (“Fine Stock — Mules 
Bought, Sold, Traded, Auctioned — Registered Stallions Standing at Stud”) because his bank held a mortgage 
on their place. 

Minerva, it wasn’t planned; it just grew. I expected Dora to be adopted in a few days, a few weeks, some 
such. Pioneers don’t feel about kids the way city people do. If they didn’t like kids, they wouldn’t have the 
temperament to pioneer. And as soon as pioneer kids stop being babies, the investment starts paying off. Kids 
are an asset in pioneer country. 

I certainly did not plan to raise an ephemeral, or hold any fear that it would be necessary — nor was it 
necessary. I was beginning to simplify my affairs, expecting to leave soon, as my son Zaccur should show up any 
year. 

Zack was my partner then, in a loose arrangement based on mutual trust. He was young, a century and a half 
or such, but steady and smart — out of Phyllis Briggs-Sperling by my last marriage but two. Afine woman, Phyllis, 
as well as a number-one mathematician. We made seven children together and everyone of them smarter than I 
am. She married several times — I was her fourth* (* Fifth, James Matthew Libby was herfourth. J.F. 45 th ) and, 
as I recall, the first woman to win the Ira Howard Memorial Century Medal for contributing one hundred registered 
offspring to the Families. Took her less than two centuries but Phyllis was a girl of simple tastes, the other being 
pencil and paper and time to think about geometry. 

I digress. To engage in the pioneering business profitably takes a minimax of a suitable ship and two 
partners, both shipmasters, both qualified to mount a migration and lead it — otherwise you are taking a shipload 
of city folks and abandoning them in wilderness... which often- happened in the early days of the Diaspora. 

Zack and I did it properly, each fully qualified as captain in space, or as leader on a strange planet — taking 
turns. The one who stays behind when the ship leaves really does pioneer; he can’t fake it, he can’t just wave the 
baton. He may not be political head of the colony — I preferred not to be; talk is so time consuming. What he does 
have to be is a survivor, a man who can force that planet to feed him, and by his example show others how — and 
advise them if they want it. 

The first wave is a break-even; the captain unloads and goes back for more migrants; the planet offers 
nothing for export that soon. The trip has been paid for by fares charged the migrants; profit, if any, will come 
from the partner on the ground selling what else the ship has carried — mules, hardware, swine, fertile chicken 
eggs — to the pioneers, on credit at first. Which means the partner on the ground has to look sharp and mind his 
rear; it doesn’t take much to convince migrants who are having a tough time that this bloke is profiteering and 
should be lynched. 

Minerva, the six times I did this — let myself be left behind with the first wave of a colony — I never once plowed 
a field without weapons at hand and I was always far more cautious with my own breed than I was with any 
dangerous animals that planet held. 

But on New Beginnings we were past most such hazards. The first wave had made it, though just barely that 
terrible first winter — Helen Mayberry was not the only widow who had married a widower as a result of a weather 
cycle that Andy Libby and I had not anticipated; the star there — called “the Sun’ as always, but you can check 
your memories for catalog designation — New Beginnings’ Sun was a variable star by about the amount that old 
Sol is, just enough to give “unusual” wheather — and when we arrived we hit the bad weather jackpot. 

But those who made it through that winter were tough enough to stand anything; the second wave had a 
much easier time. 



I had disposed of my farm to migrants of the second wave and was putting my attention on business and 
trade to build up a cargo for the AndyJ. to take back after Zack unloaded the third wave — and I would go back, 
too. Go somewhere, that is. What and where and how would be settled after I saw Zack. 

In the meantime I was bored, getting ready to wind up my on-planet affairs, and found this waif an interesting 
diversion. 

Delightful, I should say. Dora was a baby who was born grown-up. Utterly innocent, ignorant in the fashion that 
a small child necessarily is but most intelligent and delighted to learn anything. There was no meanness in her 
anywhere, Minerva, and I found her naive conversation more entertaining than most talk of adults — usually trivial 
and rarely new. 

Helen Mayberry took as much interest in Dora, and we two found ourselves in loco parentis without planning 
it. 

We consulted each other and kept the baby girl away from the burial — some charred bones, including tiny 
ones of the baby that had never been born — and kept her away from the memorial service, too. Some weeks 
later, when Dora seemed to be in good shape and after I had had time to have a gravestone cut and erected, I 
took her out there and let her see it. She could read, and did — names and dates of her parents, and the single 
date for the baby, 

She looked it over solemnly, then said, “That means Mama and Daddy won’t ever be coming back. Doesn’t 
it?” 

“\fes, Dora.” 

“That’s what the kids at school said. I wasn’t sure." 

“I know, dear. Aunt Helen told me. So I thought you had better see for yourself.” 

She looked again at the headstone, then said gravely, “I see. I guess I do. Thank you, Uncle Gibbie.” 

She didn’t cry, so I didn’t have any excuse to pick her up and console her. All I could think of to say was; “Do 
you want to go now, dear?” 

“Yes.” 

We had ridden out on Buck, but I had left him at the foot of the hill, there being an unwritten rule against letting 
mules or tamed lopers walk on graves. I asked if she wanted me to carry her — piggyback, perhaps. She decided 
to walk. 

Hallway down-she stopped. “Uncle Gibbie?” 

“Yes, Dora?” 

“Let’s not tell Buck about this.” 

“All right, Dora.” 

“He might cry." 

“We won’t tell him, Dora.” 

She did not say any more until we were back at Mrs. Mayberry’s school. Then she was very quiet for about 
two weeks, and never mentioned it again to me, nor — I think — to anyone. She never asked to go back there, 
although we went riding almost every afternoon and often within sight of graveyard hill. 

About two Earth-years later the AndyJ. arrived, and Captain Zack, my son by Phyllis, came down in the gig 
to make arrangements for landing the third wave of migrants. We had a drink together, and I told him I was 
staying over another trip, and why. He stared. “Lazarus, you are out of your mind.” 

I said quietly, “Don't call me ‘Lazarus.’ That name has had too much publicity.” 

He said, “All right. Although there is no one around but our hostess — Mrs. Mayberry, did you say? — and she’s 
gone out to the kitchen. Look, uh, Gibbons, I was thinking of making a couple of trips to Secundus. Profit in it, 
and ways to invest our net on Secundus — safer than investing on Earth now, things being the way they are.” 

I agreed that he was almost certainly right. 

“Yes,” he said, “but here’s the point. If I do, I won’t be back this way for, oh, maybe ten standard years. Or 
longer. Oh, I will if you insist; you’re majority shareholder. But you’ll be wasting your money and mine, too. Look, 
Laz — Ernest, if you must take care of this kid — though I don’t see that it’s your obligation — come with me and 
bring her along. You could put her in school on Earth — as long as you post bond to insure that she leaves. Or 
perhaps she could settle on Secundus, although I don’t know what the immigration rules are there now; it’s been 
a long time since I’ve been there." 

I shook my head. “What’s ten years? I can hold my breath that long. Zack, I want to see this child grown up 



and able to make it on her own — married, I hope, but that’s her business. But I won’t uproot her; she’s had one 
shock of that sort and shouldn’t have to soak up another while she’s still a child.” 

“On your head be it. Nt>u want me back in ten years? Is that long enough?” 

“More or less but don’t rush. Take time enough to show a profit. If it takes longer, you’ll pick up a better cargo 
here next time. Something better than food and soft goods.” 

Zack said, “There is nothing better than food to ship to Earth these days. Sometime soon we’re going to 
have to stop touching at Earth, just trade among the colonies.” 

“As bad as that?” 

“Pretty bad. They won’t learn. What’s this about trouble over your bank? Do you need a show of force while 
the ‘Andy J.’ is overhead?” 

I shook my head. “Thanks, Captain, but that’s not the way to do it. Or I would have to go along with you. Force 
is an argument to use when nothing else will do and the issue is that important. Instead I'm going to go limp on 
them." 

Ernest Gibbons did not worry about his bank. He never worried over any issue less important than life-and- 
death. 

Instead he applied his brain to all problems large and small as they came along, and enjoyed life. Especially 
he enjoyed helping raise Dora. Right after he acquired her and the mule Buck — or they acquired him — he 
discarded the savage curb bit Learner had used (salvaging the metal) and had the Jones Brothers’ 
harnessmaker convert the bridle into a hackamore. He ordered also another saddle, sketching what he wanted 
and offering a bonus for early delivery. The leather crafter shook his head over that sketch, but delivered. 

Thereafter Gibbons and the baby girl rode Buck in a saddle built for two: a man-sized saddle in the usual 
position, with a tiny saddle with tiny stirrups an integral part of it in that forward position where a normal saddle 
carries its pommel horn. A little wooden arch, leather covered, curved up from this, a safety bar the child could 
grab. Gibbons also had this extended saddle fitted with two belly bands, more comfortable for the mule, safer on 
steep trails for riders. 

They rode that way several seasons, usually an hour or more after school — holding three-cornered 
conversations at a walk, or singing as a trio with Buck loudly off key but always on beat with his gait acting as a 
metronome, Gibbons carrying the lead, and Dora learning to harmonize. It was often the “Paunshot” song, which 
Dora regarded as her own, and to which she gradually added verses, including one about the paddock next to 
the schoolhouse, where Buck lived. 

But soon there was too much girl for the tiny forward saddle as Dora grew straight and slender and tall. 
Gibbons bought a mare mule, after trying two others — one was rejected by Buck because she was (so he said) 
“shdoop’d” and the other because she failed to appreciate a hackamore and tried to run away. 

Gibbons let Buck pick the third, with advice from Dora but none from him — and Buck acquired a mate in his 
paddock, and Gibbons had the stable enlarged. Buck still stood at stud for a fee but seemed pleased to have 
Beulah at home. However, Beulah did not learn to sing and talked very little. Gibbons suspected that she was 
afraid to open her mouth in Buck's presence — she was willing to talk, or at least to answer, when Gibbons rode 
tier alone... for it worked out, to Gibbons’ surprise, that Beulah was his saddle mule; Dora rode the big male 
brute, even when the stirrups of the stock saddle had to be shortened ridiculously to fit her child’s legs. 

But steadily the stirrups had to be lengthened as Dora grew toward young womanhood. Beulah dropped a 
foal; Gibbons kept her and Dora named her “Betty” and trained the baby mule as she grew, at first letting her 
amble along behind with an empty saddle, then teaching her to accept a rider in the paddock. There followed a 
time when their daily rides became sixsomes and often picnics, with Mrs. Mayberry up on Buck, the steadiest, 

and with the lightest load — Dora on Betty, and with Gibbons as usual riding Beulah. Gibbons remembered 

that summer as a most happy one: Helen and himself knee to knee on the older mounts while Dora and the frisky 
youngster galloped ahead, then turning back with Dora’s long brown hair flying in the breeze. 

One such time he asked, “Helen, are the boys beginning to sniff around her?” 

“\bu old stud, don't you think about anything else?” 

“Come off it, dear; I asked for information.” 

“Certainly the boys are noticing her, Ernest, and she is noticing them. But I will do all the worrying necessary. 
Not much; she’s far too choosy to put, up with second best.” 

The happy family picnics did not resume the following summer. Mrs. Mayberry was feeling the years in her 
bones, and could mount and dismount only with help. 



Gibbons had plenty of time to be ready before the murmurings about his monopoly of the banking business 
came to a head. The New Beginnings Bank of Commerce was a bank of issue; he (orZaccur) always set up 
such a bank in each colony they pioneered. Money was necessary to a growing colony; barter was too clumsy. 
Some medium of exchange was needed even before government was needed. 

He was not surprised when he was invited to meet with the town’s selectmen to discuss the matter; it always 
happened. That evening, as he trimmed his Vandyke and added, a touch more gray to it and to the hair on his 
head in preparation for the confrontation, he reviewed in his mind proposals he had heard in the past for making 
water run uphill, the sun to stand still, and one egg to be counted as two. Would there be some novel 
numbskullery tonight? He hoped so but did not expect it. 

He plucked hairs from his “receding” hairline — damn it, it was getting harder and harder to age enough each 
year! — then put on his war-plaid kilt... not only more impressive but with more ways to conceal weapons — and 
get at them quickly. He was fairly sure that no one was, as yet, annoyed enough at him to start violence, but once 
he had been too optimistic; since that time he had been a pessimist as a fixed policy. 

He hid some items, locked up others, set some gadgets that Zaccur had fetched last trip but which were not 
offered for sale at the Top Dollar T.P., unlocked his-door, hand locked it from outside, and left by the route through 
the bar, so that he could tell the barkeep that would be away “a few minutes.” 

Three hours later Gibbons had settled one point: No one had been able ‘to think of any new way to debase 
currency that he had not heard at least five hundred years earlier — more likely a thousand — and each was 
certainly much, much older in history. Early in the meeting he asked the Moderator to have the Town Scribe write 
down each question so that he could answer them in a lump — and was allowed to have it his way by being balky. 

At last the Moderator Selectman, Jim “Duke” Warwick, said, “That seems to be it. Ernie, we have a motion to 
nationalize — I guess that's the word — the New Beginnings Bank of Commerce. You’re not a selectman, but we 
all agree that you are a’ party with a special interest, we want to hear from you. Do you want to speak against the 
proposal?’ 

“Not at all, Jim. Go right ahead.” 

“Eh? I’m afraid I didn’t understand you.” 

“I have no objection to the bank being nationalized, if that’s all, let’s adjourn and go to bed.” 

Someone in the audience called out, “Hey, I want my question about New Pittsburgh money’ answered!” 

“And mine about interest! Interest is wrong — it says so in the Bible!” 

‘Well, Ernie? You said earlier that you would answer questions.” 

“So I did. But if you are nationalizing the bank, wouldn't it make more sense to put questions, to your state 
treasurer, or whatever you decide to call him? The new head of the bank. By the way, who is he? Hadn’t he 
better sit up here on the platform?” 

Warwick pounded his gavel, then said, “We haven’t got that far, Ernie. For the time being the entire Council of 
Selectmen is the finance committee — if we go ahead with this.” 

“Oh, by all means go ahead. I’m shutting down.” 

“What do you mean?” 

“Just what I said: I quit. A man doesn’t like to have his neighbors dislike him. The people of Top Dollar don’t 
like what I’ve been doing or this meeting would never have been called. So I’ve quit. The bank is closed it will not 
reopen tomorrow. Nor ever with me as president of it. That’s why I asked who your state treasurer will be. I’m as 
interested as anyone in finding out what we are going to use for money from here on — and what it will be worth.” 

There was dead silence; then the Moderator had to pound his gavel and the Sergeant at Arms was very busy, 
all to shouts ,of “What about my seed loan?” “\bu owe me money!” “I sold Hank Brofsky a mule on his personal 
note — what do I collect?” “Nt>u can’t do this to us!” 

Gibbons sat quietly, not letting his alertness show, until Warwick got them quieted down. Then Warwick said, 
wiping sweat from his-brow: “Ernie, I think you’ve got some explaining to do.” 

“Certainly, Mr. Moderator. The liquidation will be as orderly as you will let it be. Those who have: deposits will 
be paid. ..in banknotes, that being whatwas deposited. Those who owe moneyto the bank — well, I don’t know; it 
depends on the policies the council sets up. I suppose I’m bankrupt. I can’t know until you tell me what you mean 
when — you say my bank is being ‘nationalized.’ 

“But I have bad to take this step: Top Dollar Trading Post is no longer buying with banknotes — they may be 
worthless. Each deal will have to be barter. But we will continue to sell for banknotes. But I took down the posted 



prices just before I came here tonight. . .because the stock I have on hand may be all I ever have with which to 
redeem those banknotes. Which could force me to raise prices. It all depends on whether ‘nationalize’ is simply 
another word for ‘confiscate.’” 

Gibbons spent several days explaining to Warwick the elementary principles of banking and currency, 
patiently and with good humor — to Warwick by Hobson’s choice because, the other selectmen found that they 
were too busy with their farms or businesses to take on the chore. There had been one candidate for the job of 
national banker or state treasurer (no agreement as yet on title) from outside the selectmen, a farmer named 
Learner, but his self-nomination got nowhere despite his claim of generations of experience in banking plus a 
graduate degree in such matters. 

Warwick got his first shock while he was taking inventory, with Gibbons, of the contents of the safe (almost 
the only safe on New Beginnings and the only one of Earth manufacture); “Ernie, where’s the money?” 

“What money, Duke?” 

“What money?’ Why, these account books show that you’ve taken in thousands and thousands of dollars. 

"four own trading post shows a balance of nearly a million. And I know you've been collecting mortgage payments 
on three or four dozen farms — and haven’t loaned hardly anything fora year or more. That’s been one of the 
major complaints, Ernie, why the selectmen just had to act — all that money going into the bank and none coming 
out. Money scarce everywhere. So where’s the money, man?” 

“I burned it,” Gibbons answered cheerfully. 

“What?” 

“Certainly. It was piling up and getting too bulky. I didn’t dare keep it outside the safe even though we don’t 
have much theft here — if somebody stole it, it could ruin me. So far the past three years, as money came into the 
bank, I’ve been burning it. To keep it safe.” 

“Good God!” 

“What’s the trouble, Duke. It’s just wastepaper.” 

“‘Wastepaper’? It’s money.” 

“What is ‘money,’ Duke? Got any on you? Say a ten-dollar bill?” Warwick, still looking shocked, dug out one. 
“Read it, Duke,” Gibbons urged. “Never mind the fancy engraving and the pretty paper that can’t be made here 
as yet — read what it says.” 

“It says it’s ten dollars.” 

“So, it does. But the important part is where it says that this bank will accept that note at face, value in 
payment of debts to the bank.” Gibbons took out of his sporran a thousand dollar banknote, set fire to it while 
Warwick watched in horrified fascination. Gibbons rubbed the char off his fingers. “Wastepaper, Duke, as long 
as it s in my possession. But if I let it get into c j rcu | a tj on j( becomes my IOU that I must honor. Half a moment while I 
record that serial number; I keep track of what I burn so that I know how much is still in circulation. Quite a lot, but I can tell 
you to the dollar. Are you going to honor my lOU’s? And what about debts owed to the bank? Who gets paid? You? Or 
me?” 

Warwick looked baffled. “Ernie, I just don’t know. Hell, man, I’ma mechanic by trade. But you heard what they 
said at the meeting.” 

“Yeah, I heard. People always expect a government to work miracles — even people who are fairly bright other 
ways. Let’s lock up this junk and go over to the Waldorf and have a beer and discuss it.” 

“ — or should be, Duke, simply a public bookkeeping service and credit system in which the medium of 
exchange is stable. Anything more and you are jiggering with other people’s wealth, robbing Peter to pay Paul. 

“Duke, I did my best to keep the dollar stable by keeping key prices stable — seed wheat in particular. For 
over twenty years the Top Dollar Trading Post has paid the same price for prime seed wheat, then resold it at the 
same markup — even if I took a loss and sometimes I did. Seed wheat isn’t too good a money standard; it’s 
perishable. But we don’t have gold or uranium as yet, and it has to be something. 

“Now look, Duke — when you reopen as a treasury, or a government central bank, or whatever you call it, 
you’re certain to have pressures on you to do all sorts of things. Lower the interest rates. Expand the money 
supply. Guarantee high prices to the farmer for what he sells, guarantee low prices for what he buys. Brother, 
you’re going to be called worse names than they call me, no matter wJiatyou, do.” 

“Ernie — there’s only one thing for it. \bu know how... so you’ve got to take the job of community treasurer." 

Gibbons laughed heartily. “No, sirree, bub, I’ve had that headache for more than twenty years; now it’s your 
turn. You grabbed the sack, now you hold it. If I let you put me back in as banker, all that will happen is that they 



will lynch both of us.” 

Changes — Helen Mayberry married the Widower Parkinson, went to live with him in a small new house on 
the farm now worked by two of his sons; Dora Brandon became schoolmistress of what was still called “Miss 
Mayberry’s Primary School.” Ernest Gibbons, no longer banker, was now silent partner in Rick’s General Store, 
while his own warehouses bulged with cargo for the Andy J. if and when. Soon, he hoped, as the new inventory 
tax was eating into cash he had held out for trading, and inflation was eating into the buying power of that cash. 
Better hurry, Zack, before we are nibbled to death by ducks! 

At last the ship appeared in New Beginnings’ sky, and Captain Zaccur Briggs came down with the first load 
of the fourth wave — almost all of them quite old. Gibbons refrained from comment until the partners were alone: 

“Zack, where did you find those walking corpses?” 

“Call it charity, Ernest. That sounds better than what did happen.” 

“Such as?” 

“Captain Sheffield, if you want our ship to go back to Earth again, you are welcome to take her there yourself. 
Not me. Not there. If a man is seventy-five years old there now, he becomes officially dead. His heirs inherit, he 
can’t own property, his ration books are canceled — anybody can kill him just for the hell of it. I didn’t get these 
passengers on Earth; they were refugees at Luna City and I took as many as I could — no messroom 
passengers; cold-sleep or nothing. I insisted on payment in hardware and pharmaceuticals, but cold-sleep let 
me hold down the price per head. I think we’ll break even. If not, we’ve got investments on Secundus; I haven’t 
lost money for us. I think.” 

“Zack, you worry too much. Make money, lose money — who cares? The idea is to enjoy it. Tell me where we 
are going next, and I can begin picking cargo — I’ve got twice the metric tonnage we can stow. While you get her 
loaded, I’ll liquidate what we aren’t lifting and invest the proceeds. Leave it with a Howard, that is.” Gibbons 
looked thoughtful. “This new situation probably means no Clinic here anytime soon?” 

“I think that is certain, Ernest. Any Howard who needs rejuvenation soon had better take passage with us; we 
are bound to hit Secundus in a leg or six, no matter where we go. Then you are definitely coming along? All over 
your problem? What became of that baby girl? The short-lifer.” 

Gibbons grinned. “I don’t think I’ll let you lay eyes on her, Son; I know you.” 

Captain Briggs’ arrival caused Gibbons to miss three days running his usual daily ride with Dora Brandon. 

On the fourth day he showed up at the schoolhouse as school let out, Briggs having gone back up for a couple of 
days. “Got time for a ride today?” 

She flashed him a smile. “You know I have. Haifa minute while I change.” 

They rode out of town, Gibbons as usual riding Beulah but with Dora on Betty. Buck was saddled (for his 
pride), but the saddle was empty; he was now ridden only ceremonially, by mule years he was quite old. 

They paused on a sunny hilltop well out of town. Gibbons said, “Why so silent, little Dora? Buck has had more 
to say than you have." 

She turned in the saddle and faced him. “How many more rides will we have together? Is this the last?” 

“Why, Dora! Of course we will have more rides together.” 

“I wonder. Lazarus, I — ’’ 

“What did you call me?” 

“I called you by your name, Lazarus.” 

He stared at her thoughtfully. “Dora, you’re not supposed to know that name. I’m your ‘Uncle Gibbie.’” 

‘“Uncle Gibbie’ is gone, and so is ‘Little Dora. I'm almost as tall as you are now, and I’ve known for two years 
who you are, and I had guessed it before that — guessed that you were one of the Methuselahs, I mean. But I said 
nothing to anyone. And never will.” 

“Don’t make it a promise, Dora; it isn’t necessary. It’s just that I never meant to burden you with it. How did I 
give myself away? I thought I had been most careful.” 

“>bu have been. But I have seen you nearly every day almost as far back as I can remember. Little things. 
Things no one would notice who didn't see you — really look at you — every day.” 

“Well, yes. But I didn’t expect to have to keep it up so long. Helen knew?” 

“I think she did. We never spoke of it; But I think she guessed the same way I did... and she may have figured 
out which Methuselah you are — ” 



“Don’t call me that, dear. It’s like calling a Jew a ‘kike.’ I’m a member of the Howard Families. A Howard." 

“I’m sorry. I didn’t know that the name mattered.” 

“Well. . .it doesn’t, really. It’s just a word that reminds me of a time long gone. A time of persecution. Sorry, 
Dora; you were telling me how you learned that my name is Lazarus? One of my names, that is, for I am ‘Ernest 
Gibbons’ just as truly.” 

“Yes, ‘Uncle Gibbie.’ It was in a book. A picture. A microbook one has to read with the viewer at the town 
library. I saw this picture and winked on past it — then clicked back and looked again. You weren’t wearing 
whiskers in the picture and your hair was longer... but the longer I stared at it, the more it looked like my foster 
uncle. But I couldn’t be sure — and couldn’t, ask.” 

“Why not, Dora? I would have told you the truth.” 

“If you had wanted me to know, you would have told me. You always have reasons for everything you do, 
everything you say. I learned that when I was so little we used to ride the same saddle. So I didn’t say anything. 
Until — Well, until today. Knowing that you are leaving.” 

“Have I said that I was leaving?” 

“Please! Once, when I was very little, you told me a story about when you were a little boy hearing wild geese 
honking in the sky — how, when you grew up, you wanted to find out where they went. I didn’t know what a wild 
goose was; you had to explain to me. I know you follow the wild goose. When you, hear them honking, you have 
to go. You’ve been hearing them in your head for three or four years. I know. ..because when you hear them, / 
hear them, too. And now the ship is here and it’s very loud in your head. So I knew.” 

“Dora, Dora!” 

“Don’t, please. I’m not trying to hold you back, truly I’m not. But before you go, I want something very much.” 

“What, Dora’? Uh, didn’t mean to tell you this yet, but Fm leaving some property for you with John Magee. 
Should be enough for — ” 

“No, no, please! I’m a grown woman now, and self-supporting. What I want doesn’t cost anything.” She looked 
him steadily in the eye. “I want your child, Lazarus.” 

Lazarus Long took a deep breath, tried to steady his heartbeat. “Dora, Dora, my dear, you are hardly more 
than a child yourself; it is too soon for you to be talking about having one. You don’t want to marry me — ” 

“I did not ask you to marry me.” 

“I was trying to say that, in a year or two — or three, or four — you wll want to marry. Then you will be glad that 
you did not have my child.” 

“>bu refuse me this?” 

“I’m saying that you must not let an emotional upset over parting cause you to make any such hasty decision.” 

She sat very straight in the saddle, squared her shoulders. “It is not a hasty decision, sir. I made up my mind 
long ago, even before I guessed that you were a — Howard. Long before. I told Aunt Helen, and she said that I 
was a silly girl and that I must forget it. But I have never forgotten it, and if I was a silly girl then, I am much older 
now and know what I am doing. Lazarus, I am not asking for anything else. It could be syringes and such, with 
Dec Krausmeyer’s help. Or — again she looked him squarely in his eyes — ”it could be the usual way.”She 
dropped her eyes, then looked up again, smiled briefly and added, “But, either way, it had best be quickly. I don’t 
know the ship’s schedule; I do know mine.” 

Gibbons spent all of a half second reviewing certain factors in his mind. “Dora.” 

“Yes... Ernest?” 

“My name is not ‘Ernest,’ nor is it ‘Lazarus.’ My right name is Woodrow Wilson Smith. So since I am no 
longer ‘Uncle Gibbie’ — and you are right on that point; ‘Uncle Gibbie’ is gone and will never be back — you might 
as well call me ‘Woodrow.’” 

“\fes, Woodrow." 

“Do you want to know why I had to change my name?’ 

“No, Woodrow.” 

“So? Do you want to know how old I am?” 

“No, Woodrow.” 

“But you want to have a child by me?” 

“Yes, Woodrow." 

“Will you marry me?” 

Her eyes widened slightly. But she answered at once: “No, Woodrow.” 



Minerva, at that point Dora and I almost had our first — and last, and only — quarrel. She had been a sweet 
and lovable baby who had grown into a sweet-tempered and utterly lovable young woman. But she was as 
stubborn as I am with the sort of firmness that can’t be argued with, because she would not argue. I pay her the 
respect of believing that she had thought this through, all aspects, and had long since made up her mind to bear 
my child if I would let her — but not to marry me. 

As for me, I did not ask her to marry me on impulse; it just sounds like it. A supersaturated solution will crystallize 
almost instantly; that’s the shape I was in. I had lost interest in that colony years earlier, as soon as it stopped 
presenting real challenges; I was itching to do something else. At the top of my mind I thought I was waiting for 
Zack to return... but when the Andy J. finally did orbit in that sky, two years overdue — well, I learned that it was not 
what I had been waiting for. 

When Dora made that amazing request, I knew what I had been waiting for. 

Surely, I tried to argue her out of it — but I was playing devil’s advocate. In fact, my mind was busy with, what 
and how. All the objections to marrying a short-lifer still remained. My even stronger objections to leaving a 
pregnant woman behind me — shucks, dear, I didn’t spend a nanosecond on that. 

“Why not, Dora?” 

“I told you. \bu are leaving, I will not hold you back.” 

“\bu won’t hold me back. No one ever has yet, Dora. But — no marriage, no child.” 

She looked thoughtful; “What is your purpose in insisting on a marriage ceremony, Woodrow? So that our 
child will bear your name? I don’t want to be a sky widow... but if that is what it takes, let’s ride back to town and 
find the Moderator. Because it really should be today. If the books are right about how to figure it.” 

“Woman, you talk too much.” She did not answer this; he went on: “I don’t give a hoot about a wedding 
ceremony — certainly not one in Top Dollar.” 

She hesitated, then said, “May I say that I do not understand?” 

“Eh? Yes, surely. Dora, I won't settle for one child. You’re going to have half a dozen children by me, or more. 
Probably more. Maybe a dozen. Any objection?” 

“\fes, Woodrow — I mean No, I do not object. Nfes, I will have a dozen children by you; Or more.” 

“Having a dozen kids takes time; Dora. How often should I show up? Every two years, maybe?” 

“Whatever you say, Woodrow. Whenever you come back — each time you come back — I’ll have a child by 
you. But I do ask that we start the first one at once.” 

“>bu crazy little idiot, I believe you would do it that way.” 

“Not ‘would’ — shall. If you will." 

“Well, we’re not going to do it that way.” He reached out and took her hand. “Dora, will you go where I go, do 
what I do, live where I live?” 

She looked startled but answered steadily, “\fes, Woodrow. If this is truly what you want.” 

“Don’t put any conditions on it. Will you, or won’t you?” 

“I will.” 

“If it comes to a showdown, will you do what I tell you to? Not give me any more stubborn arguments?’ 

“\fes, Woodrow." 

“Will you bear my children and be my wife till death do us part?” 

“I will.” 

“I take thee, Dora, to be my wife, to love and protect and cherish — and never to leave you... so long as we 
both shall live. Don’t sniffle! Lean over here and kiss, me instead. We’re married.” 

“I was not either sniffling! Are we really married?” 

“We are. Oh, you can have any wedding ceremony you want. Later. Now shut up and kiss me.” 

She obeyed. Some long moments later he said, “Hey, don’t fall out of your saddle! Steady, Betty! Steady, 
Beulah! ‘Durable Dora, who taught you to kiss that way?” 

“\bu haven’t called me that since I started to grow up. Years.” 

“Haven’t kissed you since you started to grow up, either. For good reason. You didn’t answer my question.” 

“Is that one of the things I just promised? Whoever taught me to kiss, it was before I was a married woman.” 

“Mmm, you may have a point there. I’ll take it up with my legal staff and have them write you a letter. Besides 
it might be native talent rather than instruction. Tell you what, Dora, I’ll refrain from quizzing you about your sinful 
past. . .and you leave mine alone. A deal?” 



“Yes indeed — for I have a very sinful past!” 

“Piffle, darling, you haven’t had time to be sinful. Swiped some sweets I had fetched for Buck, maybe? Very 
sinful.” 

“I never did any such thing! But lots worse.” 

“Oh, sure. Give me another of those native talent kisses.” 

Presently he said, “Whew! No, the first one wasn’t a fluke. Dora, I think I married you just barely in time.” 

“>bu insisted on marrying me — my husband. I didn’t make an issue of it.” 

“Conceded. Sweetheart, are you still anxious to get started on that baby? Now that you know that I am not 
going away without you?” 

“No longer anxious. Eager, perhaps. Nfes, eager is the right word. But not demanding.” 

“‘Eager’ is a fine word. Me, too. I could also add ‘demanding.’ Who knows? — you may have other native 
talents.” 

She barely, smiled. “If not, Woodrow, I’m sure you can teach me. I’m willing to learn. Eager.” 

“Let’s head back to town. My apartment? Or the schoolhouse?" 

“Either one, Woodrow. But see that little stand of trees? It’s much closer.” 

It was almost dark as they neared town; they rode back at a gentle walk. As they passed the Markhams’ 
house on the old Harper place, Woodrow Wilson Smith said, “Adorable Dora — ” 

“Yes, my husband?” 

“Do you want a public wedding?” 

“Only if you want one, Woodrow. I feel very much married. I am married.” 

“\bu certainly are. Not going to run away with a younger man?” 

“Is that a rhetorical question? Not now or ever.” 

“This young man is an immigrant who may not be down until the last or nearly the last trip. He is about my 
height, but he has black hair and a darker skin than I have. Can’t say just how old he is, but he looks about half 
the age I look. Smooth-shaven. His friends call him ‘Bill.’ Or ‘Woodie.’ Captain Briggs says Bill is very fond of 
young schoolmarms and is anxious to meet you.” 

She appeared to consider it. “If I kissed him with my eyes closed, do you think I would recognize him?” 

“It’s possible, Dorable. Almost certain. But I don’t think anyone else will. I hope they don’t.” 

“Woodrow, I don’t know your plans. But if I recognize this ‘Bill,’ should I attempt to convince him that I am that 
other schoolmarm?’ The one you were singing about? Rangy Lil?” 

“I think you could convince him, dearest one. All right, ‘Uncle Gibbie' is back, temporarily. It will take Ernest 
Gibbons three or four days to wind up what he must do here, then he’ll say good-bye to people — including his 
foster niece, that old-Maid schoolmarm Dora Brandon. Two days later this Bill Smith comes down with the last, 
or nearly the last, load of cargo from the ship. You had better be packed and ready to leave by then because Bill 
is going to drive past your schoolhouse the following day, or the day after that, just before dawn, headed for New 
Pittsburgh.” 

“New Pittsburgh. I’ll be ready.” 

“But, we won’t stay there more than a day or two. On we go, past Separation; then right over the horizon. 
We’re going to tackle Hopeless Pass, dear. Does that appeal to you?” 

“I go where you go.” 

“Does it appeal to you? >bu won’t have anyone to talk to but me. Until you bake one and teach him — or her 
— to talk. No neighbors. Lopers and dragons and God knows what else. But no neighbors.” 

“So I'll cook and help you farm — and bake babies. When I have three I'll open ‘Mrs. Smith’s Primary School.’ 
Or should we call it ‘Rangy Lil’s Primary School’?” 

“The latter, I think. For young hellions. My kids are always hell-raisers, Dora. \bu’ll teach school with a club in 
your hand.” 

“If necessary, Woodrow. I’ve got some like that now, and two of them outweigh me. I clobber them as 
necessary,” 

“Dora, we don’t have to tackle Hopeless Pass. We could leave in the ‘Andy J.’ and go to Secundus. Briggs 
tells me that there are over twenty million people there now. Nfciu could have a nice house. Inside plumbing. A 
flower garden instead of breaking your back helping ale to make a farm. A good hospital with real doctors when 
you have babies. Safety and comfort.” 



“Secundus.’ That’s where all the — Howards moved. Isn’t it?” 

“About two-thirds of them. A few are right here, as I told you. But we don’t admit it because when you are 
outnumbered, it is neither safe nor comfortable to be a Howard. Dora, you don’t have to make up your mind in 
only three or four days. That ship will stay in orbit here as long as I want it to. Weeks. Months. As long as I order it 
to stay.” 

“Goodness! Nt>u can afford to have Captain Briggs hold a starship in orbit? Just to let me make up my mind?” 

“I shouldn’t have rushed you. But it’s not exactly a case of affording it, Dora — although it doesn’t cost much to 
stay in orbit. Uh...l’ve kept my own counsel so long that I’m out of the habit of being a married man, with a wife I 
can trust with secrets; I must stop it. I own sixty percent of the ‘Andy J.’ Dora; Zack Briggs is my junior partner. 

And my son. Your stepson, you could say.” 

She did not answer at once. Presently he said, “What’s the trouble, Dora? Did I shock you?” 

“No, Woodrow, I’m just having to get used to new ideas. Of course you’ve been married before, you’re a 
Howard. I’d never thought about it, that’s all. A son — sons. And daughters, too, no doubt.” 

“Yes, surely. But what I was getting at is that I’ve done some bad planning — through my own selfishness. I was 
rushing you when there is no need for it. If we stay on New Beginnings, I want ‘Ernest Gibbons’ to disappear 
— leave in the ‘Andy J.,’ that is, as he is getting too old: I can't keep it up much longer. 

So young Bill Smith, who’s much nearer your age, takes his place... which looks better and no one here will ever 
suspect that I’m a Howard. 

“I’ve worked this shenanigan many times; I know how to make it stand up. But I was trying to get rid of ‘Ernest 
Gibbons’ as fast as possible because he’s your old foster uncle who is about three times your age and wouldn’t 
dream of patting your pretty bottom, nor would you encourage him to. As everybody knows. But I want to pat your 
pretty bottom, Dorable.” 

“And I want you to pat it.” She reined up; they were getting close to where houses were near together. “And 
more. Woodrow, you’re saying that we can't live together right away because of what the neighbors might think. 
But who taught me never to care what the neighbors think? Nt>u did.” 

“True. Although sometimes it’s expedient to make the neighbors think what you want them to think in order to 
influence what they do and say — and this might be such a time. But I also tried to teach you to be patient, dear 
one.” 

“Woodrow, I will do exactly what you tell me to. But I’m not really patient about this. I want my husband in my 
bed!” 

“And I want to be there.” 

“Then what does it matter if people assume that I choose to tell my Uncle Gibbie good-bye in bed? Or that I 
then go away with a new settler almost at once? Woodrow, you didn’t say a word about it at the time — but you 
knew that I was not virgin, I’m certain. Don’t you think there must be others who know it, too? Probably the whole 
town. I’ve never worried about it. Why should I worry what they think now?” 

“Dora." 

“\fes, Woodrow?” 

“I’ll be in your bed every night, that’s settled.” 

“Thank you, Woodrow.” 

“The pleasure is mine, madam. Or half of it, at least; you seem to enjoy it, too — ” 

“Oh, I do! And you know it. Or should.” 

“So stipulated, let’s pass to other matters — except to say that had I found you virgin — big as you are, old as 
you are — it would have worried me a little, and I might have felt that Helen had not been quite the wholesome 
influence that I thought she was. That she was indeed, bless her heart! The matter of pretending to be dear old 
‘Uncle Gibbie’ who would never touch little Dora was purely for your face; since it does not worry you, let’s drop 
it. What I started to say is that you can take as long as you like in deciding whether to pioneer here or go to 
Secundus. Dora, Secundus has more than inside plumbing; it has a Rejuvenation Clinic.” 

“Oh! \bu need to ‘be near one, Woodrow?” 

“No, no! For you, dear.” 

She was very slow in answering. “That would not make me a Howard.” 

“Well, no. But it helps. Rejuvenation therapies don't make Howards last forever, either. Some people are 
helped quite a lot by them; some are not. Maybe someday we'll know more — but now, on the average, 
rejuvenation techniques seem to about double whatever a person could expect normally, whether he’s a Howard 



. . .or not a Howard. Uh, do you know anything about how long your grandparents lived?” 

“How could I, Woodrow? I just barely remember that I once had parents. I don’t even know the names of my 
grandparents.” 

“We can find out. The ship carries records of every migrant who takes passage in her. I'll tell Zack — Captain 
Briggs — to look up your parents’ records. Then — in time, for it will take time — I can have your family traced on 
Earth. Then — •” 

“No, Woodrow.” 

“Why not, dear?” 

“I don’t need to know, I don’t want to know. Long ago, three or four years at least, shortly after I figured out that 
you were a Howard, I also figured out that Howards don’t really live any longer than we ordinaries do.” 

“So?” 

“Yes. We all have the past and the present and the future. The past is just memory, and I can’t remember 
when I began, I can’t remember when I msnt. Can you?” 

“No." 

“So we’re even on that. I suppose your memories are richer; you are older than I am. But it’s past. The future? 
It hasn’t happened yet, and nobody knows. You may outlive me. . .or I may outlive you. Or we might happen to be 
killed at the same time. We can’t know and / don’t want to know. What we both have is now . . .and we have that 
together and it makes me utterly happy. Let’s get these mules put away for the night and enjoy some now” 

“Suits." He grinned at her. “E.F., or F.F.?” 

“Both!” 

“That’s my Dora! Anything worth doing is worth overdoing.” 

“And doing again. But just a moment, dear. Nt>u told me that Captain Briggs is your son, and consequently my 
stepson. I suppose he is, but I really can’t think of him as such. But — and you needn’t answer this; we agreed not 
to quiz each other about our pasts — ” 

“Go ahead and ask. If it suits me, I'll answer.” 

“Well... I can’t help being curious about Captain Briggs’ mother. >bur former wife?’ 

“Phyllis? Phyllis Briggs-Sperling is her full name. What do you want to knew about her dear? Very nice girl. 
Further Deponent Sayeth Not. No invidious comparisons.” 

“I guess I’m being snoopy.” 

“Perhaps you are. Not that I mind, and it can’t hurt Phyllis. Dear, that was a couple of centuries ago; forget it.” 

“Oh. She’s dead?” 

“Not that I know of. Zack would know; he’s been to Secundus recently. I think he would have told me. But I 
haven’t stayed in touch with her since she divorced me.” 

“Divorced you? A woman of poor taste!” 

“Dora. Dora! Phyllis is not a woman of poor taste; she is a very nice girl. I had dinner with her and her 
husband the last time I was on Secundus. Zack and I did, I mean — and she and her husband had gone to the 
trouble of rounding up my other children by her, those who were on planet, and some of my other relatives and 
made it a family party for me. Thoughtful of her. By the way she’s a schoolmarm, too.” 

“She is?” 

“Yup. Libby Professor of Mathematics, Howard University, New Rome, Secundus. If we go there, we can look 
her up and you can decide for yourself what sort of person she is.” 

Dora did not answer. She kneed Betty and started on down the street; Beulah pulled abreast without being 
told. Buck said, “Shupper...d/merquite emphatically, and trotted on ahead. 

“Lazarus — •“ 

“Careful with that name, dear.” 

“No one can hear me: Lazarus, unless you insist... I don’t want to live on Secundus.” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
XII 


The Tale of the Adopted Daughter (Continued) 


Separation lay far behind. For three weeks the little train — two wagons in tandem, twelve mules hauling, four 
running free — had crawled toward Rampart Range. It had been more than two weeks since they had last seen a 
house. They were on the high prairies now, and for several days the gap of Hopeless Pass had been in sight. 

Besides sixteen mules, the little party included a German shepherd bitch and a younger dog, two female cats 
and a tom, a fresh milch goat with two kids and a young buck, two cocks and six hens of the hardy. Mrs. Awkins 
variety, a freshly bred sow, and Dora and Woodrow Smith. 

The sow had tested pregnant at New Pittsburgh before Smith paid for her, test conducted by Smith himself 
— and Mrs. Smith had tested pregnant, too, while still at Top Dollar and before Smith cleared Starship AndyJ. to 
leave orbit, for (Smith had not found it necessary to tell his wife this) if Dora had not tested pregnant, the ship 
would have waited while they tried again — then, if she had still tested negative, he would have changed plans 
and taken her to Secundus, there to find out why and, if possible, to correct it. 

In Smith’s opinion as a professional pioneer, it was not only pointless but disastrously foolhardy to attempt 
single-couple pioneering out of reach of other people with an infertile woman — ora couple infertile with each 
other, he corrected in his mind, as his own fertility had not been put to the ultimate test for fifty-odd years. While 
he was about it, he had looked up physical records of Dora’s parents in Krausmeyer’s ill-kept files, found nothing 
to worry him — and it had indeed worried him, as he would not have been able to cope even with anything as 
simple as an Rh-factor incompatibility a long way from nowhere. 

But within the limited medical resources of colony and ship, the board showed all green, and it seemed likely 
to him that Dora bad become pregnant about twenty minutes after their informal muleback wedding. 

The thought had passed through his mind that Dora might have been pregnant even sooner — but the thought 
was merely an amusing whimsy that bothered him not at all. Smith felt certain that he had had the Cuckoo in his 
nest more than once over the centuries; he had been especially careful to be a loving father to such children and 
had kept his mouth shut. He believed in letting women lie all they needed to, and never taxing them with it. But he 
believed also that Dora was incapable of this sort of lie. If Dora had been pregnant and aware of it, she might 
have asked to be allowed to say good-bye to him on her back — but she would have asked for exactly that. Not 
for a child. 

No matter — If the darling had made a mistake earlier and did not know it, he felt sure that she would 
nevertheless have a superior baby. She was clearly superior stock herself — he, wished he had known the 
Brandons; they must have been ichiban — and their daughter was, as Helen had once said, “choosy.” Dora 
would, not bed with an oaf even for fun, because, being what she was, she would not find it fun. Smith was sure 
that it would take rape to put an inferior child into Dora — and the rapist might sing soprano the rest of his days; 
her Uncle Gibbie had taught her some dirty tricks. 

The pregnant sow was Smith's “calendar." If they failed to reach a spot suitable for homesteading by the time 
that sow littered, then they turned back that very day — no hesitation, no regrets — as that would leave them just 
half of Dora’s pregnancy to get them back to Separation and other people.” 

The sow rode in the back end of the second wagon, with a sling to keep her from falling down. The dogs 
trotted under the wagons, or ranged aside, warning of lopers or other hazards. The cats did as they pleased, as 
cats do, walking or riding as suited them. The nanny and billy goats stayed close to the wheel pair; the two kids 
were large enough to skitter along most of the time but were privileged to ride when they tired — a loud Me-e-e- 
eh from the mother goat would cause Smith to swing down and hand the tired baby up to Dora. The chickens 
complained in a double cage over the sow’s pen. The mules running free had no duties other than to keep eyes 
out for lopers, save that Buck was at all times grand marshal of the parade, picking the footing, bossing the other 
mules, carrying out Smith’s orders. Mules at liberty rotated as draft animals; only Buck was never in harness. 



Betty and Beulah had had theirfeelings hurt at being required to accept harness; they were gentry of the saddle, 
and they knew it. But Buck had had harsh words with them and harsher nips and kicks; they had shut up and 
hauled. 

No real driving was required; only two reins were used, one to each of the lead pair and running from them 
back through rings on the collars of the following mules to the seat of the leading wagon, there usually loosely 
secured rather than held. Although the males were all stallions, these mules did what Buck ordered. Smith had 
stopped at Separation and lost most of a day to trade a strong brute with good shoulders for a younger, lighter 
stud because the bigger mule had not been willing to accept Buck’s dominance. Buck was ready to fight it out, 
but Smith did not let the old mule risk it; he needed Buck’s brain and judgment, and would not risk Buck’s spirit 
being broken by losing to a younger stallion — or take a chance that Buck might be injured. 

In real trouble more reins would not help. If the mules panicked and ran — unlikely but possible — two humans 
could not hold them, even with a double handful of reins. Smith was ready at any instant to pick off his lead pair, 
then hope that not too many mules would break legs stumbling over the corpses and pray that the wagons would 
not overturn. 

Smith wanted to reach their destination with all his livestock; he hoped to get there with about 80 percent 
including a breeding pair of each sort — but if they arrived with, enough draft animals to pull the wagons (including 
at least one breeding pair) plus a pair of goats, he could consider it a conditional victory and they would make 
their stand, to live or to die. 

How many mules were “enough” was a variable. Near the end of the trip it could be as low as four — then go 
back and get the second wagon. But if the number of mules dropped below twelve before they conquered 
Hopeless Pass — turn back. 

Turn back at once. Abandon one or both wagons, jettison what they could not salvage, slaughter any animals 
that could not make it without help, travel light with any extra mules trailing along, unwitting walking larders. 

If Woodrow Wilson Smith limped back into Separation on foot, his wife riding — miscarried but still alive — it 
still would not be defeat. He had his hands, he bad his brain, he had the strongest of human incentives: a wife to 
care for and cherish. In a few years they might try Hopeless Pass again — and not make the mistakes he had 
made the first time. 

In the meantime he was happy, with all the wealth any man could hope for. 

Smith leaned out Of the wagon seat. “Hey, Buck! Supper.” 

“Shupperdime,” Buck repeated, then called out, “Shupper dime! SHrko nigh! Shirko nigh !” The lead pair 
turned left, started bringing the train around in a circle. 

Dora said, “The Sun is still high” 

“Yes,” her husband agreed, “and that’s why. The Sun is high, it’s very hot, the mules are tired and sweaty and 
hungry and thirsty. I want them to graze. Tomorrow we’ll be up before dawn and rolling at first light — make as 
many kilometers as possible before it gets too bloody hot. Then another early stop.” 

“I wasn’t questioning it, dear; I simply wanted to know why. I’m finding that being a schoolmarm hasn’t taught 
me all I need to know to be a pioneer wife.” 

“I understood; that’s why I explained. Dora, always ask me if I do anything you don’t understand; you do have 
to know. . .because if something happens to me, then it’ll be up to you. Just hold your questions until later if I 
seem to be in a hurry.” 

“I’ll try, Woodrow — I am trying. I’m hot and thirsty myself; those poor dears must be feeling it dreadfully. If you 
can spare me, I'll water them while you unharness.” 

“No, Dora.” 

“But — Sorry.” 

“Damn it, I said always to ask why. But I was about to explain. First we let them graze an hour. That will cool 
them down some in spite of the Sun, and, being thirsty, they’ll look for short green stuff under this tall dry stuff. 
They will get a little moisture out of that. Meantime I’m' going to measure the water barrels, but I know that we’re 
going on short water rations. Should’ve yesterday. Dorable, you see that patch of dark green way up there below 
the pass? I think there water there, dry as it’s been... and pray hard that there is, because I don’t expect to find 
water between here and there. We may have no water at all the last day or so. It doesn’t take a mule long to die 
without water and not much longer for a man.” 

“Woodrow, is it as bad as that?” 



“It is, dear. That’s why I’ve been studying the photomaps. The clearest ones Andy and I made a long time ago, 
when we surveyed this planet — but in early spring for this hemisphere. The shots Zack took for me aren’t much; 
the Andy J. isn’t equipped as a survey ship. As maybe, I took this route because it looked faster. But every wash 
we’ve crossed the past ten days has been bone dry. My mistake and it may be my last one.” 

“Woodrow! Don’t talk that way!” 

“Sorry, dear. But there is always a last mistake. I'll do my damndest to see that this is not my last mistake 
— because it must not happen to you. I’m simply trying to impress you with how carefully we must conserve water. 

“\bu’ve impressed me. I’ll be most careful with cleaning up and so forth.” 

“I still haven’t made it clear. There will be no washing at all — not a face wash, not even a hand wash. Pans 
and such you’ll scour with dirt and grass and put them in the sunshine and hope they sterilize. Water is only for 
drinking. The mules go on half water rations at once, and you and I, instead of the liter and a half of liquid each 
day a human is supposed to need, will each try to get by on a half liter. Uh, Mrs. Whiskers will get a full ration of 
water; she has to make milk for her kids. If it gets too tough, we slaughter the kids and let her dry up.” 

“Oh, dear.” 

“We may not have to. But, Dora, we aren’t even close to last extremities. If the going gets really tough, we kill 
a mule and drink its blood.” 

“What! Why, they’re our friends!" 

“Dora, listen to your old man. I promise you that we will never kill Buck, or Beulah, or Betty. If I must, it will be a 
mule we bought n New Pittsburgh. But if one of our three old friends die — we eat him. Her.” 

“I don’t think I could.” 

“>bu will when you’re hungry enough. If you think about the baby, inside you, you’ll eat without hesitation and 
bless your dead friend for helping to keep your baby alive. Don’t talk about what you can’t do when the chips are 
down, dear — because you can. Did Helen ever tell you stories about the first winter here?” 

“No. She said I didn't need to know.” 

“Could be she was mistaken. I'll tell you one of the less grisly ones. We placed — I placed — a heel-and-toe 
watch over the seed, grain with orders to shoot to kill. And one guard did. A drumhead court-martial exonerated 
the guard; the man he killed was clearly stealing seed grain — his corpse had half-chewed grain in its mouth. Not 
Helen’s husband, by the way; he died like a gentleman — malnutrition and some fever I never identified.” 

Smith added, “Buck’s got us hauled around. Let’s get busy.” He jumped down, reached up to help her. “And 
smile, baby, smile! — this show is being transmitted back to Earth to show those poor crowded people how easy 
it is to take a new planet — courtesy of DuBarrys Delicious Deodorants, of which I need a bucketful.” 

She smiled. “I stink worse than you do, my love." 

“That’s better, darling; we’ll make it. It’s just the first step that’s a dilly. Oh, yes! No cooking fire.” 

‘“No f — ‘ Yes, sir.” 

“Nor any until we get out of this dry stuff. Don’t strike a light for any reason — even if you’ve dropped your 
rubies and can’t find them." 

‘“Rubies — ’ Woodrow, it was wonderful of you to give me rubies. But right now I would swap them for another 
barrel of water.” 

“No, you wouldn’t, dearest, because rubies don’t weigh anything and I took every barrel the mules could haul. 

I was delighted that Zack had those rubies along and I could give them to you. A bride should be cherished. Let’s 
take care of these tired mules.” 

After they turned the mules loose, Dora tried to figure out what she could feed her husband without the use of 
fire while Smith got busy on the fence. The fence was not much, but having only two wagons, they could not form 
a proper defensive circle; the best that could be done was to angle the wagons as far as the front axle of the 
second wagon permitted, then surround the bivouac with a fence of sorts — sharpened stakes of brasswood, 
each two meters long, and held together and spaced by what passed for rope in New Pittsburgh. The result, 
when held up on two sides by wagons and braced to the ground along the hypotenuse, constituted a high and 
fairly nasty picket fence. It would not slow up a dragon, but this was not dragon country. Lopers did not like it. 

Smith did not like it much, either, but it was made on New Beginnings of all-native materials, could be 
repaired by a man who was handy, did not weigh much, could be abandoned with no great loss — and contained 
no metal. Smith had beer able to buy two sturdy, boat-bodied, Conestoga-type wagons in New Pittsburgh only by 
offering in part payment complete hardware for two other wagons — hardware imported across the light-years in 



the Andy I. New Pittsburgh was far more “New" than “Pittsburgh”; there was iron ore there and coal, but its’ 
metals industry was still primitive. 

The chickens, the sow, the goats, and even the humans were tasty temptations to wild lopers, but with the 
goats and kids shooed inside the kraal, two alert watchdogs, and sixteen mules grazing on all sides, Smith felt 
reasonably secure at night. True, a loper might get a mule, but it was much more likely that the mule would get 
the loper — especially as other mules would close in and help stomp the carnivore. These mules did not run from 
a loper; they struck out at him. Smith thought that, in time, mules might clean out the varmints even more than 
man did, make them as scarce as mountain lions had been in his youth. 

A mule-stomped loper was readily converted into loper steak, loper Stew, loper jerky — and dog and cat food, 
and Mrs Porky the sow enjoyed the offal — all at no loss to the mules. Smith did not care much for loper in any 
form; the meat was too strongly flavored for his taste — but it, was better than nothing and kept them from digging 
too deeply into food they had hauled along, Dora did not share her husband’s distaste for loper meat; born there 
aid having eaten it now and then since earliest childhood, it seemed to her a normal food. 

But Smith wished that he had time to hunt one of the herbivores that were the loper’s natural prey — six- 
legged like the loper but otherwise resembling a misshapen okapi — their meat was much milder. They were 
called “prairie goats,” which they were not, but systematic taxonomy of fauna and flora on New Beginnings had 
not gone far; there had been as yet no time for such intellectual luxuries. Smith had shot a prairie goat from the 
seat of the wagon a week earlier (now only a memory, bittersweet, of tasty tender meat). Smith did not feel 
justified in taking a day off to hunt until they had conquered Hopeless Pass. But he kept hoping for another 
chance shot. 

Maybe now — Fritz! Lady Macbeth! Here!” The dogs trotted up and waited. “High sentry. Loper! Prairie-goat! 
Up!” The dogs immediately got on the very top of the lead wagon, making it in two jumps and a scramble, step, 
seat, and curved top. There they split the duty, nigh side and offside — and there they would stay until told to get 
down. Smith had paid a stiff price for the pair, but he had known they were good dogs; he had picked their 
ancestors on Earth and had fetched them with the first wave. Smith was not a “doggie” man in any fanatic sense; 
he simply believed that a partnership that had lasted so long on Earth would serve men equally well on strange 
planets. 

Dora was sobered by her husband’s words, but once she got busy working, she cheered up. Shortly, while 
trying to plan a menu, from little choice and without a cooking fire, she came across something that vexed her 
— good for her as it displaced her worrisome thoughts. Besides, she did not really believe that her husband 
could fail at anything. 

She came around the end of the second wagon, crossed the little kraal to where her husband was making 
sure that his fence was tight, “Oh, that pesky little rooster!” 

Woodrow looked around. “Hon, you look cute in just a sunbonnet.” 

“Not just a sunbonnet, I’m wearing hoots, too. Don't you want to hear what that nasty little rooster did?” 

“I would rather discuss how you look. Adorable, that is. Nevertheless, I’m not pleased with the way you are 
dressed.” 

“What? But it’s so hot, dear. Since I can’t wash, I thought an. air bath might make me smell better.” 

You smell good to me. But an air bath is a good idea; I’ll peel down, too. Your gun, dear — where’s your, belt 
with your knife and gun?” He started shucking his overalls. 

You want me to wear my gun belt novJ? Inside the fence? With you here to protect me?” 

As self-discipline and a standard precaution, my lovely one.” He hitched his own gun-and-knife belt back into 
place as be stepped out of his overalls, then pulled off boots and shirt and got bare save for the belt and three 
other weapons that did not show when he was dressed. “In more years than I like to think about I have never 
been unarmed except when locked in somewhere safe. I want you to acquire the habit. Not just sometimes. 
Always." 

“All right. I left my belt on the seat; I'll get it. But, Woodrow, I’m not much of a fighter at best.” 

“\bu’re fairly accurate with that needle gun up to fifty meters. And you’re going to get better and better the 
longer you live, with me. Not just with it but with anything that shoots, cuts, burns, or even makes nasty bruises, 
from your bare hands to a blaster. See over there, Dorable?” He pointed to nothing but flatness. “In just seven 
seconds a horde of hairy savages will come pouring over the top of that rise and attack. I get a spear through my 
thigh and go down... then you have to fight them off for both of us. What are you going to do, you poor little girl, 
with your gun clear over them on the seat of that wagon?” 



“Why" — she set her feet apart, put her hands back of her head, and gave a wiggle that was invented in the 
Garden of Eden, or perhaps just outside — ‘Til’ go this way at 'em!” 

“Yes,” Lazarus agreed thoughtfully, “that should work. If they were human. But they aren’t. Their only interest in 
tall, beautiful, brown eyed girls is to eat them. Bones and all. Silly of them, but that’s how they are." 

“\fes, dear,” she said docilely. “I’ll go put on my gun belt. Then I'll kill the one who speared you. Then I'll see 
how many more I can get before they eat me.” 

“That’s right, durable Dorable. Always take an honor guard with you. If you have to go, go down fighting. The 
size of your guard of honor determines your status in hell.” 

“\fes, dear. I’m sure I'll enjoy hell if you’re there, too,” She turned to fetch her weapons. 

“Oh, I’ll be there! They wouldn’t take me anywhere else. Dora! When you put on your gun belt, take off your 
sun-bonnet and boots — and put on your rubies, all of them.” 

She paused with a foot on the step of the wagon. “My rubies, dear? Out here on the prairie?!” 

“Rangy Lil, I bought those rubies for you to wear and, for me to admire you wearing them.” 

She flashed a smile that turned her normally serious expression into sunshine, swung on up into the wagon 
and disappeared. She was back quickly wearing weapons belt and rubies but had taken a few seconds to comb 
her hair — long and chestnut brown and shining. That she bad not been able to bathe for more than two weeks 
did not show, did not detract from her enchanting, youthful beauty. She paused on the step and smiled at him. 

“Hold it!” he said, “Perfect! Dora, you are the most beautiful thing I have ever seen in all my born days.” 

She flashed him another smile. “I don’t believe that, my husband — but I hope you will go on saying it." 

“Madam, I cannot tell a lie. I say it only because it is the simple truth. Now, what were you saying about the 
little rooster?” 

“Oh ! That perverted little monster! I said he had been breaking eggs on purpose! This time I caught him. 
Pecking them. Two freshly laid broken eggs!" 

“Royal prerogative, dear. Afraid one of them would hatch out a rooster.” 

“I’ll wring his neck! If we had a fire, I’d do it right now. Darling, I was trying to see what we could eat cold 
without opening anything not already open, and it occurred to me that salt crackers crumbled into raw eggs 
would almost make a meal. But there were only three eggs today and he broke the two laid by his hens. I’d put 
plenty of grass in both cages; the one egg on the other side wasn’t even cracked. Damn him. Woodrow, why do 
we have to have two roosters?” 

“For the same reason I carry two throwing knives. Sweetheart, alter we arrive and hatch our first chicks, once 
they’re big enough that I’m certain of a spare rooster, we can have rooster and dumplings with him as guest of 
honor. Not before.” 

“But we cant have him breaking eggs. Tonight’s supper will be mostly cheese and hardtack — unless you 
want me to open something.” 

“Let’s not rush it. Fritz and Lady Mac are trying to spot game right now. Prairie goat, I hope. Loper if not.” 

“But I can’t cook meat. \fc>u said. You did say — ” 

“Raw, my dear. Haunch of prairie goat, chopped fine, and spread on hard crackers. BeefTartare a la New 
Beginnings. Tasty. Tastes almost as good as girl.” He smacked his lips. 

“Well... if you can eat it, I can eat it. But half the time, Woodrow, I don’t know whether you are joking or not.” 

“I never joke about food or women, Dorable; those are sacred subjects.” He looked her up and down again. 
“Speaking of women, woman, dressing you in rubies is just right. But why a bracelet around your ankle?” 

“Because you gave me three bracelets, sir. As well as rings and a pendant. And you said to wear all of them." 
] “So I did. Where did this one come from?” 

“Hey! That’s not a ruby; that’s me!’’ 

“Looks like a ruby. Here’s another just like it.” 

“Unh! Maybe I’d better take my rubies off? So we won’t lose them. Or should we water the mules first?” 

“\bu mean before we eat?” 

“Uh. . .yes, I guess that’s what. I mean. Tease.” 

“>bu’re not speaking very plainly, little Dora. Tell Uncle Gibbie what you want.” 

“I’m- not ‘little Dora.’ I’m Rangy Lil, the horniest girt south of Separation — you said so yourself. I cuss and I 
swear and I spit between thy teeth and I’m concubine to Lazarus Long, Super Stud of the Stars and better than 
any six men — and you know damn well what I want, and if you pinch my nipples again, I’m likely to trip you and 
take it. But I guess we ought to water the mules.” 



Minerva, Dora was just plain nice to be around, always. It wasn’t her physical beauty... which wasn’t that 
outstanding by the usual criteria in any case — although she was utterly beautiful to me. Nor was it her 
enthusiastic interest in sharing “Eros” — although she was indeed enthusiastic, ready any time, and always on a 
short fuse. And skilled at it and got more so; Sex is a learned art, as much so as ice skating or tight wire walking 
or fancy diving; it is not instinct. Oh, two animals couple by instinct, but it takes intelligence and patient 
willingness to turn copulation into a high and lively art. Dora was good at it and got better and better, always 
eager to learn, free of fetishes or silly preconceptions, patiently willing to practice anything she learned or was 
taught — and with it that spiritual quality that turns sweaty exercise into a living sacrament. 

But Minerva, love in what still goes on when you ate not horny. 

Dora was good company at anytime, but the tougher things were, the better companion she was. Oh, she 
fretted about broken eggs because chickens were her responsibility; she did not complain that she was thirsty. 
Instead of nagging me to do something about that rooster, she figured out what had to be done and did it 
— shoved all the hens in with the other rooster, tied the feet of the egg breaker and laid him aside while she 
moved the partition between the cages, then the smaller rooster was in solitary confinement and we lost no more 
eggs. 

But the truly tough parts lay ahead of us; she did not fret at all during those, or ever turn balky when I did not 
have time to explain. Minerva, much of the trek was slow death, other parts were sudden dangers that could have 
been, quick death. She was endlessly patient in the former, always kept her head and helped in the latter. Dear, 
you are awesomely learned — but you are a city girl and you’ve always been on a civilized planet; perhaps I had 
better explain some things. 

Maybe you have been asking yourself: “Is this trip necessary?” — and; if it is, why do it the hard way? 

“Necessary — ” Having done something a Howard should never do, namely, marry an ephemeral, I had three 
choices: Take her to live among Howards. Dora rejected that — although I would have tried to talk her out of it if 
she had said Yes. A short-timer alone in a community of the long-lived is almost certain to go into suicidal 
depression; I had seen it first in my friend Slayton Ford and I’ve seen it many times since then. I did not want this 
to happen to Dora. Whether the number of her years was ten or a thousand, I wanted her to enjoy them. 

Or we could stay in Top Dollar or — the same thing — near one of the villages of that small piece of the planet 
that was settled then. I almost chose this, as the “Bill Smith” dodge would work for that — for a time. 

But only for a short time. The few Howards on New Beginnings — the Magees and three other families as I 
recall — had all arrived incognito — ’’masquerade” in Howard jargon — and by simple dodges they could shuffle 
things around and never be ‘caught’ at it. Grandmother Magee could “die,” then show up as “Deborah Simpson" 
on another Howard homestead. The more people there were on the planet, the easier it was to pull this 
— especially after the fourth wave arrived, all of them cold-sleep cargo and thereby never having gotten 
acquainted with each other. 

But “Bill Smith” was married to an ephemeral. If I stayed around the settled parts, I would have to be most 
careful to keep my hair dyed — not just on my head but all over my body lest some accident give me away — and 
then be careful to “age” as fast as my wife did. Worse, I would have to avoid people who had known “Ernest 
Gibbons” well — most of Top Dollar, that is to say — or someone would see my profile and hear my voice and start 
wondering, as I had had no chance for plastic surgery or anything of that sort. At other times, when it was needful 
to change name and identity, I had always changed location as well, that being the only foolproof way to do it. 
Even plastic surgery won’t disguise me very long; I regenerate too easily. I once had my nose bobbed (the 
alternative seemed to involve having my neck bobbed); ten years later it was just as it is now, big and ugly. 

Not that I was too jumpy about being disclosed as a Howard. But if I was going to have to live in masquerade, 
the more carefully I used these cosmetic tricks, the more Dora’s nose would be rubbed in the fact that I was 
different from her — different in the saddest way of all, a husband and a wife who ran on very different time rates. 

Minerva, it seemed to me that the only way I could give my pretty new wife a square shake was by taking her 
far away from both sorts of people, long-lived and short, where I could quit pretending and we could ignore the 
difference, forget it and be happy. So I decided to take her clear out of reach of other people, decided this 
before we got back to town the very day I married her. 

It seemed the best answer to an otherwise impossible situation, but one not as irreversible as a parachute 
jump if she got too lonely, if she grew to hate the sight of my ugly mug, I could bring her out to the settlements 
again, still young enough to hook another husband. I had this in, mind, Minerva, as some of my wives have grown 



tired of me fairly quickly. I had arranged with Zack Briggs, at the same time I had arranged with John Magee to 
act as factor for Zack — arranged with Zack to ask John what had happened to “Bill Smith” and the little 
schoolmarm? It was possible that I would need a ride off-planet someday. 

But why didn’t I have Zack put us down on the spot on the map I had picked as being our likely place of 
settlement? — with everything we would need to start farming: and thereby avoid a long, dangerous trek. Not risk 
death by thirst, or by lopers, or the treacheries of mountains, or whatever. 

Minerva, this was a long time ago and I can explain only in terms of technology available there and then. The 
AndyJ. could not land; she received her overhauls in orbit around Secundus or some other advanced planet. 

Her cargo boat could land on any big flat field but required a minimum of a radar-corner reflector to home on, 
then had to have many metric tons of water to lift off again. The captain's gig was the only boat in the AndyJ. 
capable of landing anywhere a skilled pilot could put her down, then lift off without help. But her cargo capacity 
was about two postage stamps — whereas I needed mules and plows and a load of other things. 

Besides, I needed to learn howto get out of those mountains by going into them. I could not take Dora into 
there without being reasonably sure that I could fetch her out again. Not fair! It’s no sin not to be pioneer-mother 
material — but it is tragic for both husband and wife to find it out too late. 

So we did not do it the bard way; we did it the only way for that time ‘and place. But I have never put the effort 
into a mass calculation for a spaceship at liftoff that I put into deciding what to take, what to do without, for that 
trek. First, the basic parameter: how many wagons in the train? I wanted three wagons so badly I could taste it. A 
third wagon would mean luxuries for Dora, more tools for me, more books and such for both of us, and (best!) a 
precut one-room house to get my pregnant bride out of the weather almost instantly at the other end. 

But three wagons meant eighteen mules hauling, plus spare mules add six by rule-of-thumb — which meant 

half again as much, time spent harnessing and unharnessing, watering the animals, taking care of them 
otherwise. Add enough Wagons and mules and at some point your day’s march is zero; one man can’t handle 
the work. Worse, there would be places in the mountains where I would have to unshackle the wagons, move 
them one at a time to a more open place — go back for each wagon left behind, bring it up — a process that 
would take twice as long for a three-wagon train as for a two-wagon one, and would happen oftener, even much 
oftener, with three wagons than with two. At that rate we might have three babies born en route instead of getting 
there before our first one was born. 

I was saved from such folly by the fact only two trekking wagons were available in New Pittsburgh. I think I 
would have resisted temptation anyhow — but I had with me in the light wagon we drove from Top Dollar, the 
hardware for three, then I spent that extra hardware on other, things, bartering it through the wainwright. I could 
not wait while he built a third wagon; both the season of the year and the season of Dora’s womb gave me 
deadlines I had to meet. 

There is much to be said for just one wagon — standard equipment over many centuries and on several 
planets for one family in overland migration if they travel in a party. 

I’ve led such marches. 

But one wagon by itself — One accident can be disaster. Two wagons offer more than twice as much to work 
with at the other end, plus life insurance on the march. You can lose one wagon, regroup, and keep going. 

So I planned for two wagons, Minerva, even though I had Zack debit me with three sets of ‘Stoga hardware, 
then did not sell that third set until the last minute. 

Here’s how you load a wagon train for survival: First, list everything that you expect to need and everything 
that you would like to take: 

Wagons, spare wheels, spare axles 

Mules, harness, spare hardware and harness leather, saddles 

Water 

Food 

Clothing 

Blankets 

Weapons, ammunition, repair kit 

Medicines, drugs, surgical instruments, bandages 

Books 



Plows 
Harrow 
Field Rake 

Shovels, hand rakes, hoes, seeders, three- five- & seven-tine forks 

Harvester 

Blacksmith’s tools 

Carpentry tools 

Iron cookstove 

Water closet, self-flushing type 

Oil lamps 

Windmill & pump 

Sawmill run by windpower 

Leatherworking & harness-repair tools 

Bed, table, chain, dishes, pots, pans, eating & cooking gear 

Binoculars, microscope, water-testing kit 

Grindstone 

Wheelbarrow 

Churn 

Buckets, sieves, assorted small hardware 

Milk cow & bull 

Chickens 

Salt for stock & for people 

Packaged yeast, yeast starter 

Seed grain, several sorts 

Grinder for whole-grain flour, meat grinder 

Don’t stop there; think big. Never mind the fact that you’ve already overloaded a much longer wagon train. 
Search your imagination, check the manifests of the Andy J., search the ship itself, look, over the stock in Rick’s 
General Store, talk with John Magee and look over his house and farm and outbuildings — if you forget it now, it’s 
impossible to go back for it. 

Musical instruments, writing materials, diaries, calendars 
Baby clothes, layettes 

Spinning wheel, loom, sewing materials — sheep! 

Tannin & leather-curing materials and tools 
Clocks, watches 

Root vegetables, rooted fruit-tree seedlings, other seed 
Etc. etc. etc. . . 

Now start trimming — start swapping — start figuring weights. 


Cut out the bull, the cow, the sheep; substitute goats with hair long enough to be worth cutting. Hey, you 
missed shears! 

The blacksmith’s shop stays but gets trimmed down to an anvil and minimum tools — a bellows you must 
make. In general anything of wood is scratched, but a small supply of wrought-iron stock, heavy as it is, must be 
hauled; you’ll be making things you didn’t know you could. 

The harvester becomes a scythe with handle and cradle, three spare blades; the field rake is scratched. 

The windmill stays, and so does the sawmill (surprise!) — but only as minimum hardware; you won’t tackle either 
one soon. 

Books — Which of those books can you live without, Dora? 

Halve the amount of clothing, double up on -shoes and add more boots and don’t forget children’s shoes. 
Yes, I know howto make moccasins, mukluks, and such; add waxed thread. Nfes, we do have to have block-and- 



tackle and the best glass-and-plastic lines we can buy, or we won’t get through the pass. Money is nothing; 
weight and cubage are all that count — our total wealth is what mules can take through that notch. 

Minerva, it was lucky for me, lucky for Dora, that I was on my sixth pioneering venture and that I had planned 
how to load spaceships many years before I ever loaded a covered wagon — for the principles are the same; 
spaceships are the covered wagons of the Galaxy. Get it down to the weight the mules can haul, then chop off 1 0 
percent no matter how it hurts; a broken axle — when, you can’t replace it — might as well be a broken neck. 

Then add more water to bring it up to 95 percent; the load of water drops off every day. 

Knitting needles! Can Dora knit? If not, teach her. I’ve spent many a lonely hour in space knitting sweaters 
and socks. Yarn? It will be a long time before Dora can tease goat shearings into good yarn — and she can knit 
for the baby while we travel; keep her happy. Yarn doesn’t weigh much. 

Wooden needles can be made; even curved metal needles can be shaped from scraps. But pick up both 
sorts from Rick’s Store. 

Oh my God, I almost missed taking an ax! 

Ax heads and one handle, brush hook, pick-mattock — Minerva, I added and trimmed and discarded, and 
weighed every item at New Pittsburgh — and we weren’t three kilometers out of there headed for Separation 
before I knew I had us overloaded. That night we stopped at a homesteader’s cabin, and I traded a new thirty- 
kilo anvil for his fifteen-kilo one, traded even, with the pound of flesh nearest my heart tossed in for good 
measure. I swapped other heavy items that we would miss later for a smoked ham and a side of bacon and 
more corn for the mules — the last being emergency rations. 

We lightened the loads again at Separation, and I took another water barrel in trade and filled it because I 
now had room for another and knew that too heavy a load of water was self-correcting. 

I think that extra barrel saved our lives. 

The patch of green that Lazarus-Woodrow had pointed out up near the notch of Hopeless Pass proved to be 
farther away in travel time than he had hoped. On the last day that they struggled toward it neither man nor mule 
had had anything to drink since dawn the day before. Smith felt lightheaded; the mules were hardly fit to work, 
they plodded slowly, heads down. 

Dora wanted to stop drinking when her husband did. He said to her: “Listen to me, you stupid little tart, you’re 
pregnant. Understand me? Or will it take a fat lip to convince you? I held out four liters when we served the 
mules; you saw me.” 

“I don't need four liters, Woodrow.” 

“Shut up. That’s for you, and the nanny goat, and the chickens. And the cats — cats don’t take much. Dorable, 
that much water means nothing split among sixteen mules, but it will go a long way among you small fry.” 

“\fes, sir. How about Mrs. Porky?” 

“Oh, that damned sow! Uh. . . I’ll give her a half a liter when we stop tonight and I'll serve her myself. She’s 
likely to kick it over and take your thumb off, the mood she’s in. And I'll serve you myself, measure it out, and 
watch you drink it.” 

But after a long day and a restless night and then an endless day, they were at last among the first of the 
trees. It seemed almost cool, and Smith felt that he could smell water — somewhere. He could not see any. “Buck! 
Oh, Buck! Circle!" 

The boss mule did not answer; he bad not talked all day. But he brought the column around, cornered the 
wagons, and nudged, the lead pair into the V to be unharnessed. 

Smith called the dogs and told them to hunt for water, then started unharnessing. Silently his wife joined him, 
serving the off mule of each pair while Smith cleared the nigh mule. He appreciated her silence. Dora was, he 
thought, telepathic to emotions. 

Now if I were water somewhere around here, where would I be? Witch for it? Or search the surface first? He 
felt fairly sure that no stream led away from this stand of trees, but he could not be certain without hiking all the 
downhill side. Saddle Beulah? Shucks, Beulah was worse off than he was. He started unlashing rolled sections 
of spike fence from the sides of the second wagon. He had not seen a loper for three days, which meant to him 
that they were three days closer to their next trouble with the beasts. “Dora, if you feel up to it, you can give me a 
hand with this.” 

She made no comment on the fact that her husband had never before let her help erect the kraal; she simply 
worried about how drawn and tired he looked and thought about the quarter liter of water she had stolen and 



hidden — how could she persuade him to drink it? 

They were just done when Fritz set up an excited yipping in the distance. 

Minerva, it was a water bole — a trickle that came out of a rocky face, ran a couple of meters and formed a 
pool with no outlet. None that time of year, I should say, as I could see where it overflowed in flood season. I could 
see also plenty of animal sign — loper tracks and prairie goat and more that 

I could not identify. I had a feeling that there might be eyes on me, and I tried to grow eyes in the back of my 
head. It was dusky near the spring; trees and undergrowth were thicker and the Sun was getting low. 

I was in a dilemma. I don’t know how it happened that one of the free mules had not found this bole as soon or 
sooner than the dogs; mules can smell water. But mules were certain to be there soon, and I did not want them to 
drink too fast. Sensible as a mule is, he’ll drink too fast and too much if he is very thirsty. These mules were 
extremely thirsty; I wanted to watch each one myself, not let one founder. 

Besides that I did not want them walking into that pool; it was clear, seemed clean. 

The dogs finished drinking. I looked at Fritz and wished that he could talk as well as a mule. Did I have 
anything to write on? No, not a durn thing! If I told him to fetch Dora, Fritz would try — but would she come? I had 
told her flatly to stay in the kraal till I got back. Minerva, I wasn’t thinking straight; the heat and no water had got to 
me. I should have given Dora contingency instructions. . .because if I stayed away too long and it started to get 
dark, she was going to come looking for me no matter what. 

Hell, I hadn’t even fetched a bucket! 

In the meantime I at least had sense enough to scoop up and drink a couple of handfuls of water, Gideon 
style. That seemed to clear my head some. 

I dropped the straps of my overalls, got my shirt off, soaked it in water, and gave it to Fritz. “Find Dora! Fetch 
Dora! Fast!” I think he thought I had gone nuts, but he left, carrying that wet shirt. 

Then the first mule showed up — old Buck, praise Allah! — and I ruined a hat. 

That hat Zack had fetched as a present for me. It was alleged to be an all-weather hat, so porous it would let 
air in, yet so water-repellent that it would keep your head dry in a pouring rain. The former allegation was only 
moderately true; the latter I had not had a chance to test. 

Buck snorted and was all for going into the water up to his knees; I stopped him. Then I offered him a hatful of 
water. Then a second. And a third. 

“Enough for now, Buck. Assembly. Water call." 

With his throat wet Buck could do it. He let out a trumpeting bellow that was mule talk, not English, and I won’t 
attempt to reproduce it, but it meant “Line up for water” and nothing else. “Fall in to be harnessed” was another 
soil of bellow. 

Then I was trying to cope with a dozen-odd thirst-crazed mules. But between me, Buck, Beulah who was 
Buck’s straw boss, Lady Macbeth who was used to helping Buck too — and a hat that wasn’t quite all that 
waterproof — we made it. I never did learn how seniority was established among mule’s, but the mules knew and 
Buck enforced it and water call always found them queued up in the same order, and heaven help the youngster 
who tried crowd in out of turn; the least he could expect was a nipped ear. 

By the time the last had been given a hatful of water my hat was a mess — but here came Dora with Fritz, her 
needle gun in her right fist, and, glory be! — two buckets in her left hand. “Water call!” I told my top sergeant. “Line 
’em up again, Buck!” 

With two buckets and two of us working we got a full bucket into each mule pretty rapidly. Then I got my shirt 
back from Fritz, scrubbed out the buckets a bit, filled them, and announced a third water call, telling Buck to let 
them drink from the pond. 

He did so, but he still maintained discipline. As Dora and I left, each with a bucket of water in one hand and a 
drawn gun in the other, Buck was still requiring them to drink one at a time, by seniority. 

It was nearly sundown when Dora and I and the dogs got back to the wagons, almost full dark as we finished 
watering goats and sow and cats and chickens. Then we celebrated. Minerva, I swear solemnly: on the half 
bucket of water we saved for ourselves Dora and I got stinkin’ drunk. 

Despite earlier resolutions not to stop short of the pass, we bivouacked there three days — but very useful 
days. The mules grazed steadily and filled out, plenty of water, plenty of forage. I shota prairie goat at the water 
hole; what we couldn’t eat, Dora sliced and dried as jerky. I filled all the barrels — not as easy as it sounds as 
Buck and I had to work out a route to the water hole, then I had to chop some, then I had to take the wagons in 



one at a time; it took me a day and a half. 

But we had cooked fresh meat and all we could eat — and hot baths! With soap. With shampoos. With a 
shave for me. I carried Dora’s big iron kettle to the pool, she fetched a bucket, I built a fire — then we took turns 
getting the stink off, one guarding while the other washed. 

When we rolled toward the pass the morning of the fourth day, we were not only in fine shape, but Dora and I 
smelled good and kept telling each other so, in high spirits. 

We were never again short of water. There was snow somewhere above us; you could feel it in the breeze 
and sometimes catch a distant glimpse of white in a saddle between peaks. The higher we got, the oftener we 
encountered rivulets, water that never reached the prairie in so dry a year. The forage was green and good. 

We stopped in a little alp close to the pass. There I left Dora with the wagons and the mules and with flat- 
footed instructions about what to do in case I did not come back. “I expect to be back by dark. If I am not, you can 
wait a week. No longer. Understand me?” 

“I understand you.” 

“All right. At the end of a week, lighten the first wagon by chucking out anything you can do without on trek. Put 
all food into that wagon, empty the barrels in the second wagon and put them in the first wagon, turn the sow and 
the chickens loose, and head back. Fill all your barrels at that trickle we crossed earlier today. After that, don’t 
stop for anything; roll all day from dawn till dark. >t>u should reach Separation in half the time it took to get us up 
here. Okay?” 

“No, sir.” 

Minerva, a few centuries earlier I would have started to boil up at that point. But I had learned. It took me 
about a tenth of a second to realize that I could not make her do anything — if I were gone — and that a promise 
made under duress won’t hold. “All right, Dora, tell me why not and what you intend to do instead. If I don’t like it, 
perhaps we both will start back for Separation." 

‘“Woodrow, while you did not say so, you are asking me to do what I should do — and I would do! — if I were a 
widow.” 

I nodded. “\fes, that’s right. Dearest, if I’m not back in a week, you’re a widow. No possible doubt.” 

“I understand that. I also understand why you are leaving the wagons here; you can’t be sure that you can turn 
them around higher up.” 

“Yes. That’s probably what happened to earlier parties — reached a place where they couldn’t go forward and 
couldn’t turn around. . .then tried one or the other and went over.” 

“Yes. But, my husband, you mean to be gone only one day — half a day out, half a day back. Woodrow, I won’t 
assume that you are dead — I cant !” She looked at me steadily and her eyes filled with tears, but she did not cry. 

“I must see your dear body, I must be certain. If I am certain, I will go back to Separation as fast and as safely as 
possible. And then to the Magees as you have told me, and have your child and bring him up to be as much like 
his father as possible. But I must know” 

“Dora, Dora! In one week you will know. No need to look for my bones.” 

“May I finish, sir? If you aren’t back tonight, I’m on my own. At dawn tomorrow I start out on Betty, with another 
saddle mule following. At noon I turn back. 

“Perhaps, if I can’t find you, I'll find a spot higher up where I can take one wagon and turn it around. If I find 
such a spot, I’ll move one wagon up and use it as a base and look farther. I could have missed your track. Or I 
might have followed mule tracks — but you aren’t on the mule. Whatever it is, I'll search and search again. Until 
there’s no hope at all! Then... I will go to Separation as fast as mules can get me there. 

“But, my darling, if you are alive — maybe with a broken leg but alive — if you still have a knife or even your bare 
hands, I don’t believe that a loper or anything can kill you. If you are alive, I'll find you. I will!” 

So I backed down and checked watches with her and agreed on what time I would turn back. Then Buck and 
I, with me up on Beulah, set out to scout ahead. 

Minerva, at least four parties had tried that pass; none had come back. I’m certain enough that they each 
failed from being too eager, not patient enough, unwilling to turn back when the risk was too great. 

Patience I have learned. The centuries may not give a man wisdom, but he acquires patience or he doesn’t live 
through them: That first morning we found the first spot that was too tight. Oh, someone had blasted there and 
probably got around that turn. But it was too narrow to be safe, so I blasted some more. Nobody in his right mind 
takes a wagon into the mountains without dynamite or some such; you can't nibble at solid rock with a toothpick, 
or even a pickax, without risking being still up there when the snows come. 



I was not using dynamite. Oh, anyone with a modicum of chemistry can make both dynamite and ‘black 
powder,’ and I planned to do both — later. What I had with me was a more efficient and more flexible blasting jelly 
— and not shock-sensitive, perfectly safe in wagon and saddlebag. 

I placed that first charge in a crack where I thought it would do the most good, set the fuse but did not light it, 
then walked both mules back around the bend and exerted my histrionic talent to its limit to explain to Buck and 
Beulah that there was going to be a loud noise, a bang/— but it could hot hurt them, so don’t worry. Then I went 
back, lit the fuse, hurried back to them and was in time to have an arm on each neck — watched my watch. “Now!” 
I said, and the mountain obliged me with Ka-boom! 

Beulah shivered but was steady. Buck said inquiringly, Paaang? 

I agreed. He nodded and went back to cropping leaves. 

We three went up and took a look. Nice and wide now — Not very level, but three tiny blasts took care of that. 
“What do you think, Buck?” 

He looked carefully up and down trail. “Doo wagon?” 

“One wagon.” 

“Ogay.” 

We explored a little farther, planned the next day’s work; then I turned back at the time promised, was home 
early. 

It took me a week to make a couple of kilometers safe to another little alp, a grassy pocket big enough to turn 
one wagon around at a time. Then it took all of a long day to move our wagons, one at a time, to this next base. 
Someone had made it that far; I found a broken wagon wheel — salvaged the steel tire and the hub. It went on that 
way, day after day, slowly, tediously, and at last we were through the notch and headed — mostly — downhill. 

But that was worse, not better. The river I had been sure was there, by photomaps from space, was far below 
us, and we still had to go down, down, down, and follow it a long way before we would reach the place where the 
gorge opened out into valley suitable for homesteading. More blasting, lots of brush chopping, and sometimes I 
had to blast trees. But the nastiest part was rappelling those wagons down the steepest places. I didn’t mind 
steep places going uphill (which we still encountered); a twelve-mule team can drag a single wagon up any slope 
they can dig their hooves into. But downhill — 

Certainly those wagons had brakes. But if the grade is steep, the wagon slides on its tires — then goes over 
the edge, mules and all. 

I couldn’t let that happen even once. Not ever risk letting it happen. We could lose one wagon and six mules 
and still go on. But / was not expendable. (Dora would not be in the wagon.) If that wagon cut loose, my chances 
of jumping clear would be so-so. 

If the grade was steep enough to give me even a trace of doubt that I could hold a wagon with its brakes, we 
did it the hard way: used that expensive imported line to check it down such pitches. Lead the line out fair and 
free for running, pass the bitter end three times around a tree stout enough to anchor it, secure it to the rear axle 
— then our four steadiest mules, Ken and Daisy, Beau and Belle, would take the wagon down at a slow walk (no 
driver) following Buck, while I kept tension on the line, paying it out very slowly. 

If terrain permitted, Dora on Betty would take station halfway down to relay orders to Buck. But I could not 
permit her to be on the trail itself; if that line parted, it would whip. So maybe half the time Buck and I worked 
without liaison, doing it dead slow and depending on his judgment. 

If there was not a sound anchor tree properly positioned — and it seems to me that this happened more often 
than not — then we had to wait while I worked something out. This could be anything: a sling between two trees, 
then rig a fair-lead to a third tree — A bare-rock anchor using driven pitons — I hated these as I bad to do my 
checking right at the rear axle, walking behind, and God help us all if I stumbled. Then that was always followed 
by the time-consuming chore of salvaging those pitons — the harder the rock, the better the anchor, but the 
tougher the job of getting them out — and I had to get them out; Iwould need them farther along. 

‘Sometimes no trees and no rock — Once the anchor was twelve mules faced back along the trail, with Dora 
soothing them while I checked at a rear axle and Buck controlled the progress. 

On the prairie we often made thirty kilometers a day. Once we were through Hopeless Pass and had started 
down the gorge the distance made good over the ground could be zero for days on end while I prepared the trail 
ahead, then up to as high as ten kilometers if there were no steep pitches that required rappelling down by line. I 
used just one unbreakable rule: The trail had to be fully prepared from one turnaround base to the next before a 
wagon was moved. 



Minerva, it was so confounded slow that my “calendar" caught up with me; the sow ‘littered — and we were not 
out of the mountains. 

I don’t recall ever making a harder decision. Dora was in good shape, but she was halfway through her 
pregnancy. 

Turn back (as I had promised myself, without telling her) — or push on and hope to reach lower and fairly level 
ground before she came to term? Which would be easier on her? 

I had to consult her — but / had to decide. Responsibility cannot be shared. I knew how she would vote before 
I took the matter up with her: Push on. 

But that would be simply her gallant courage; / was the one with experience both in wilderness trekking and in 
childbirth problems. 

I studied those photomaps again without learning anything new. Somewhere ahead the gorge opened out 
into a broad river valley — but how far? I didn’t know because I didn’t know where we were. We had started with 
an odometer on the right rear wheel of the lead wagon; I had reset it to zero at the pass — and it had lasted only a 
day or two; a rock or something did it in. I didn’t even know how much altitude we had managed to drop since the 
pass, or how much more we must lose to get down. 

Livestock and equipment: fair. We had lost two mules. Pretty Girl had wandered over the edge one night and 
broken a leg; all I could do for her was to put her out of her misery. I didn’t butcher her because we had fresh 
meat and I could not do it where the other mules could not see it, anyhow. John Barleycorn had simply upped and 
died one night — or possibly lost to a loper; he was partly eaten when we found him. 

Three hens were dead and two piglets failed to make it, but the sow seemed willing to suckle the others. 

I had only two spare wheels left. Lose two more and the, next broken wheel meant abandoning one wagon. 

It was the wheels that made up my mind. 

(Omitted: approximately 7,000 words which reiterate difficulties in getting down the gorge.) 

When we came out on that plateau, we could see the valley stretching out before us. A beautiful valley, 
Minerva, wide and green and lovely — thousands and thousands of hectares of ideal farmland. The river from the 
gorge, tame now, meandering lazily between low banks. Facing us, a long, long way off, was a high peak 
crowned with snow. Its snow line let me guess how high it was — around six thousand meters, for we had now 
dropped down into subtropics, and only a very high mountain could keep so much snow through a long and very 
hot summer. 

That beautiful mountain, that lush green valley, gave me a feeling of deja vu. Then I placed it: Mount Hood in 
the land of my birth back on old Earth, as I had first seen it as a young man. But this valley, this snowcapped 
peak, had never before been seen by men. 

I called out to Buck to halt the march. “Dorable, we’re home; in sight of it, somewhere down in that valley.” 

‘Home,’” she repeated. “Oh, my darling!” 

“Don’t sniffle.” 

“I wasn't sniffling!” she answered, smiling. “But I’ve got an awful good cry saved up and when I get time to, I’m 
going to use it.” 

“All right, dear,” I agreed, “when you have time. Let’s name that mountain ‘Dora Mountain.’” 

She looked thoughtful. “No, that’s not its name. That’s Mount Hope. And all this below is Happy Valley.” 

“Durable Dora, you’re incurably sentimental.” 

“\bu should talk!” She patted her belly, swollen almost to term. “That’s Happy. Valley because it’s where I’m 
going to have this hungry little beast... and that’s Mount Hope because it is.” 

Buck had come back to the first wagon and was waiting to find out why we had stopped. “Buck,” I said, 
pointing, “that’s home out there. We made it. Home, boy. Farm.” 

Buck looked out over the valley. “Ogay.” 

— in his sleep, Minerva. Not lopers, there wasn’t a mark on Buck. Massive coronary, I think, although I didn't 
cut him open to find out. He was simply old and tired. Before we left, I had tried to put him to pasture with John 
Magee. But Buck didn’t want that. We were his family, Dora and Beulah and I, and he wanted to come along. So 
I made him mule boss and didn’t work him — I mean I never rode him and never had him in harness. He did work, 
as mule boss, and his patient good judgment got us safely to Happy Valley. 



We would not have made it without him. 

Maybe he could have lived a few years longerturned out to pasture. Or he might have pined awayfrom 
loneliness soon after we left. Who’s to judge? 

I didn’t even consider butchering him; I think Dora would have miscarried it I had so much as broached the 
idea. But it is foolish to bury a mule when lopers and weather will soon take care of his carcass. So I buried him. 

It takes an hellacious big hole to bury a mule; If it hadn’t been soft river-bottom loam, I’d be there yet. 

But first I had to deal with personnel problems. Ken was just junior to Beulah in the water queue and was a 
steady, strong mule who talked fairly well. On the other hand, Beulah had been Buck’s straw boss the whole trek 
— but I could not recall a gang of mules bossed by a mare. 

Minerva, with H. sapiens this would not matter, at least not today on Secundus. But with some sorts of 
animals it does matter. A boss elephant is female. A boss chicken is, a cock, not a hen. A boss dog can be 
either sex. In a breed where sex controls the matter a man had better by a damn sight go along with their ways. 

I decided to see if Beulah could swing it, so I told her to line 'em up for harness, both as a test and because I 
wanted to move the mules out of sight while I buried Buck — they were nervy and restless; the boss mule’s death 
had upset them. 

I don't ‘know what mules think about death, but they are not indifferent to it. 

She promptly got busy, and I kept an eye on Kenny. He accepted it, took his usual place by Daisy. Once I had 
them harnessed, Beulah was the only one left over, three mules dead now. 

I told Dora that I Wanted them moved a few hundred meters away. Would she handle it, with Beulah as march 
boss? Or would she feel safer if I did it? — and ran into a second problem: Dora wanted to be present when I 
buried Buck. More than that — ’’Woodrow, I can help dig. Buck was my friend, too, you know.” 

I said, “Dora, I’ll put up with anything at all from a pregnant woman except allowing her to do something that 
would hurt her.” 

“But, dearest, I feel okay, physically — it’s just that I’m dreadfully upset over Buck. So I want to help.” 

“I think you are in good shape, too, and I want you to stay that way. Nfc>u can help best by staying in the wagon. 
Dora, I haven’t any” way to take care of a premature baby, and I don’t want to have to bury a baby as well as 
Buck.” 

Her eyes widened. “You think that would happen?” 

“Sweetheart, I don’t know. I’ve known women to hang onto babies under unbelievable hardships. I’ve seen 
others lose babies for no reason that I could see. The only rule I have about it is: Don’t take unnecessary 
chances. This one is not necessary.” 

So once again we replanned things to suit both of us, though it took an extra hour. I unshackled the second 
wagon and set up the fence again, put the four goats inside the fence, and left Dora in that wagon. Then I drove 
the first wagon three or four hundred meters away, unharnessed the mules, and told Beulah to keep them 
together — and told Ken to help her, and left Fritz to help her, too, and took Lady MacBeth with me to watch for 
lopers or whatever. The visibility was good — no brush, no high grass; the place looked like a tended park. But I 
was going to be down in a hole; I didn’t want something sneaking up on me or on the wagon. “Lady Macbeth. 
High sentry. Up!” 

By agreement Dora stayed in the wagon. 

It took all that day to take care of our old friend, with a stop for lunch and a few short breaks for water and to 
catch my breath in the shade of the wagon — breaks I shared with Lady Mac, letting her get down each time I 
came up. Plus one interruption — It was midafternoon and I had dug almost enough hole when Lady Mac barked 
for me. I was up out of that hole fast, blaster in hand, expecting lopers. 

Just a dragon — I wasn’t especially surprised, Minerva; the well-cropped state of the turf, almost like a lawn, 
seemed to indicate dragon rather than prairie goat. Those dragons are not dangerous unless one happens to 
fall on you. They are slow, stupid, and strictly vegetarian. Oh, they're ugly enough to be frightening; they look like 
six-legged triceratops. But that’s all. Lopers left them alone because biting armor is unrewarding. 

I joined Dora at the wagon. “Ever seen one, hon?” 

“Not up close. Goodness, it’s huge.” 

“It’s a big one, all right. But it will probably turn away. I won’t waste a charge on it if I don’t have to.” 

But the durned thing did not turn away. Minerva, I think it was so stupid that it mistook the wagon for a lady 
dragon. 

Or the other way around, it is hard to tell male from female. But they are definitely bisexual; two dragons 



humping is a remarkable sight. 

When it got within a hundred meters, I let myself out the fence and took Lady Mac along, as she was 
quiveringly eager. I doubt if she had ever seen one; they were cleaned out around Top Dollar long before she 
was whelped. She danced up to it, barking but wary. 

I hoped that Lady would cause it to turn aside, but this misshapen rhinoceros paid no attention; it lumbered 
slowly along, straight for the wagon. So I tickled it with my needle gun between where it should have had lips, to 
get its attention. It stopped, astounded I think, and opened its mouth wide. That was what I needed, as I did not 
want to waste maximum power blasting through that armored hide. So — Blaster at minimum, right into its mouth: 
Scratch one dragon. 

It stood there a moment, then slowly collapsed. I called Lady and went back to the fence. Dora was waiting. 
“May I go look at it?” I glanced at the Sun. “Sweetheart, I’m going to be pushed to take care of Buck before dark, 
then fetch the mules back and move us on a way. Unless you are willing to bivouac, with the grave on one side 
and a dead dragon on the other?” 

She did not insist, and I got back to work. In another hour I had it deep enough and wide enough — got out 
block-and-tackle, a triple purchase, secured it to the rear axle, tied Buck's hind feet together, hooked over the tie 
and took up the slack. 

Dora had come out with me. “Just a moment, dear.” She stopped to pat Buck’s neck, then leaned down and 
kissed his forehead. “All right, Woodrow. Now.” 

I heaved on the line. For a moment I thought the wagon would move despite the brakes being locked. Then, 
Buck started to slide, and fell into his grave. I shook the hook loose, then backfilled fast, closing in twenty minutes 
a hole it had taken me most of the day to dig. Dora waited. 

I finished. “Up into the wagon, Dorable; that’s it.” 

“Lazarus, I wish I knew something to say. Do you?” 

I thought about it. I had heard a thousand burial services; most of them I did not like. So I made up one. 
“Whatever God there be, please take care of this fine person. He always did his best. Amen.” 

(Omitted) 

— even those first years weren’t too hard, as Happy Valley would grow anything, two and three crops a year. 
But we should have named it “Dragon Valley.” 

Lopers were bad enough, especially the small lopers that hunted in packs which we found on that side of 
Raxnpa Range. ‘But those damned dragons! They almost drove me out of my skull. When you’ve lost the same 
potato patch four times running, it begins to wear. 

Lopers I could poison and did. I could trap them, too, if I changed style every time. Or I could put out bait at 
night and sit quietly and get most of a pack, silently, with a needle gun. I could do lots of things and did, and the 
mules learned to cope with them, too, sleeping closer together at night an always with one on watch, like quail or 
baboon. Whenever I beard the bellow that meant “Loper!”' I always came awake fast and tried to join the fun 
— but the mules rarely left me any; they not only could stomp them, but they could outrun them and get some or all 
of a pack that tried to escape. We lost three mules and six goats to lopers, but the lopers got the news and 
started giving us a wide berth. 

But those dragons! Too big to trap and would not take poison; salad was all they were after. But what one 
dragon can do to a cornfield in one night shouldn’t happen to Sodom and Gomorrah. Bow-and-arrow was futile 
against them, and a needle gun just tickled them. I could kill one with a blaster at full power right through the 
armor, or minimum power the way I got that first one if I could get my target to open its mouth. But unlike lopers, 
they were too stupid to stay away when they were losing. 

The first summer I was able to farm I killed more than hundred dragons in trying to save my crops... which was 
defeat for me and a victory for the dragons. Not only was the stench terrible (what can you do with a carcass that 
big?) but, far worse, I was running out of charges and they didn’t seem to be running out of dragons. 

No power. Buck’s River did not have enough head on it where we settled to think about trying to build a water 
wheel even if I cannibalized one wagon to build it. The windmill had fetched was in fact nothing but gears and 
other hardware the mill itself I would have to build, from sails to tower. Bu until I had power I had no way to 
recharge power packs. 

Dora solved it. We were still living in that first compound nothing but a high adobe wall just big enough to 
surround the wagons and to bring the goats inside at night, while we slept in the first wagon along with baby Zack 



and cooked in a clay Dutch oven — and between smoke, and goats and chickens and the sour smells babies 
can’t help making and the cesspit that bad to be inside the wall — well, the stench of dead dragons wasn’t too 
noticeable. 

We were finishing supper, Dora dressed in her rubies as always for supper, and were watching the moons 
and the stars coming out — best time of day, always, except that when I should have been admiring our firstborn 
at suck and enjoying the sky, I was grousing about power and what in hell I could do about those pesky dragons. 

I had ticked off several simple ways to produce power — simple if you are on a civilized planet or even at a 
place like New Pittsburgh with its coal and its infant metals industry — when I happened to use a very old- 
fashioned term. Instead of talking about kilowatts or megadynecenti meters per second or such, I had remarked 
that I would settle for ten horsepower anyway I could get it. 

Dora had never seen a horse, but she knew what one was. She said, “Beloved, wouldn’t ten mules do 
instead?” 

(Omitted) 

We had been in our valley seven years when the first wagon showed up. Young Zack was nearly seven and 
beginning to be some help to me — or thought he was and I encouraged him to try. Andy was five, and Helen not 
yet four. We had lost Persephone, and Dora was pregnant again, and that was why — Dora had insisted on 
starting another baby at once, not wait one day, one hour — and she was right. Once we knew she had caught, 
our morale picked up overnight. We missed Persephone; she had been a darling baby. But we stopped grieving 
and looked forward instead. I hoped for another girl but was willing to settle for any baby — no way to control the 
sex of a child, then and there. 

All in all, we were in fine shape, with a prosperous farm, a healthy, happy family, plenty of livestock, a much 
larger compound with a house built right into it against the back wall, a windmill that drove a saw, or ground 
grain, or supplied power for my blaster. 

When I spotted that wagon, my first thought was that it was going to be nice to have neighbors. But my 
second thought was that I was going to be proud, very proud, to show off my fine family and our farm to these 
newcomers. 

Dora climbed up to the roof and watched the wagon with me; it was still over fifteen kilometers away, could 
not arrive before evening. I put my arm around her. “Excited, hon?” 

“Yes. Though I’ve never been lonely; you haven’t let me be. How many do you think I should expect for 
supper?” 

“Hmm — Only one wagon. One family. My best guess is a couple, with none, one, or two children. More than 
that would surprise me.” 

“Me, too, darling, but there’ll be plenty to eat.” 

“And put some clothes on our kids before they get here — wouldn’t want ’em to guess we’re raising savages, 
would we?” She answered, deadpan, “Shall I wear clothes, too?” 

“What swank! That’s up to you, Rangy Li I — but who was it said just last month that she had never worn her 
party dress?” 

“Will you be wearing a kilt, Lazarus?” 

“I might. I might even take a bath. I’ll need one because I’m going to spend the rest of the day cleaning the 
goat compound and a lot of other things — make this place look as neat as possible. But forget the name 
‘Lazarus,’ dear; I’m Bill Smith again.” 

“I’ll remember — Bill. I'll bathe before they get here, too — because I’m going to have a hot and busy time, 
cooking, cleaning house, bathing our children, and trying to teach them howto be introduced to strangers. 
They’ve never seen anyone else, dear; I’m not sure they believe there is anyone else.” 

“They’ll behave." I was sure they would. Dora and I had the same ideas about raising kids. Praise them, 
never scream at them, punish as necessary and right now — never a moment’s delay — then it’s over with and 
forget it. Be as lavish with affection after a spanking as any other time — ora bit extra. Spanking they had to have 
(Dora usually used a switch) because, without exception over the centuries, my kids have been hell-raisers who 
would take advantage of the sweetness-and-light routine. Some of my wives had trouble believing what little 
monsters I spawn — but Dora was right with me on this wild-animal act from scratch. In consequence she raised 
the most civilized brood I’ve ever fathered. 



When that wagon was maybe a kilometer away, I rode out to meet them — then was surprised and 
disappointed. A family, yes, if you count a man and two grown sons as a family. No women, no children. I 
wondered how they thought they were going to pioneer. 

The younger son was not fully grown; his beard was sparse and scraggly. Nevertheless, he was taller and 
heavier than I was, and he was the smallest ofthe three. His father and brother were mounted; he was driving 
— actually driving; they were not using a mule boss. No livestock other than mules that I could see, although I did 
not attempt to look into their wagon. 

I did not like their looks and reversed my idea about neighbors. I hoped they would move on down the valley, 
at least fifty kilometers. 

The mounted two were carrying guns at their belts — reasonable in loper country. I had a needle gun in sight 
myself, as well as a belt knife — and maybe other things not in sight, as I don’t consider it diplomatic to show 
much hardware in meeting strangers. 

As I approached, they stopped, the driver reining up his mules. I had Beulah stop about ten paces short ofthe 
lead pair. “Howdy,” I said. “Welcome to Happy Valley. I’m Bill Smith.” 

The oldest of the three looked me up and down. It is hard to tell a man’s expression when he wears a full 
beard, but what little I could see was no expression at all — wariness, perhaps. My own face was smooth — freshly 
shaved and clean overalls, in honor of visitors. I was keeping my face smooth both because Dora preferred it so 
and because I was staying “young” to match Dora. I was wearing my best friendly look — but was saying to 
myself, “Ntiu’ve gotten seconds to answer my greeting and say who you are — or you’re going to miss some of 
the best cooking on New Beginnings.” 

He just slid under the deadline; I had silently counted seven chimpanzees when he suddenly grinned through 
that face moss. “Why, that’s mighty friendly of you, young man.” 

“Bill Smith,” I repeated, “and I didn’t catch your name.” 

“Probably because I didn’t say,” he answered. “Name’s Montgomery. ‘Monty’ to my friends, and I don’t have 
any enemies, at least not for long. Right, Darby?” 

“Right Pop,” agreed the other mounted one. 

“And this is my son Darby and that’s Dan driving thejugheads. Say ‘Howdy,’ boys.” 

“Howdy,” they each answered. 

“Howdy, Darby. Howdy, Dan. Monty, is Mrs. Montgomery with you?” I nodded at the wagon, still did not at 
tempt to see into it — a man’s wagon is as private as his house. 

“Now why would you be asking that?” 

“Because,” I said, still holding onto my friendly-idiot look, “I want to trot back to the house and tell Mrs. Smith 
how many there’ll be for supper.” 

“Well! Did you hear that, boys? We’ve been invited to supper. That’s mighty friendly, too, isn’t it, Dan?” 

“Right, Pop.” 

“And we most kindly accept. Don’t we, Darby?” 

“Right, Pop.” 

I was getting tired ofthe echo, but I kept my sweet expression. “Monty, you still haven't told me how many.” 

“Oh. Just three. But we eat enough for six.” He slapped his thigh and laughed at his own joke. “Right, Dan?” 

“Right, Pop.” 

“So you stir up those jugheads, Dan; we’ve got reason to hurry now.” 

‘I interrupted the echo to say, “Hold it, Monty. No need to overheat your mules.” 

“What? They’re my mules, son.” 

“So they are and do as you please about them, but I was sent out ahead so that Mrs. Smith would have time 
to be ready for you. I see you’re wearing a watch” — I glanced at my own — “your hostess will expect you in one 
hour. Unless you need more time to get there and unharness and water your mules?" 

“Oh, them jugheads will keep until after supper. If we’re early, we’ll set awhile.” 

“No," I said firmly. “One hour, no sooner. You know how a lady feels about guests arriving before she’s ready 
for them. Crowd her, and she might ruin your supper. Do as you please about your mules — but there is an easy 
place to water them, a little beach, where the river comes closest to the house. Nice place to spruce up a bit 
yourself, too — before dining with a lady. But don’t come up to the house short of one hour.” 

“>burwife sounds mighty particular... for way out here in the wilds.” 

“She is,” I answered. “Home, Beulah.” 

I moved from a trot into Beulah’s fast lope and did not get over an uneasy feeling between my shoulder 



blades until I was certain I was too far away to be a target. There is only one dangerous animal, yet at times 
you’re forced to pretend that he’s as sweet and innocent as a cobra. 

I didn’t stop to unsaddle Beulah; I hurried inside. Dora heard my slam-bang arrival, was at the compound’s 
door. “What is it, dear? Trouble?” 

“Could be. Three men, I don’t like them. Nevertheless, I’ve promised them supper. Have the kids eaten? Can 
we put them right to bed and convince them that if they so much as let out a peep, they’ll be flayed alive? I didn’t 
mention children, we aren’t going to mention them, and I’m going to take a fast look around to make sure there is 
nothing in sight that says ‘kids.’ 

“I’ll try. Yes, I’ve fed them.” 

Right on the hour Lazarus Long met his guests at the door of the compound. They drove and rode up from the 
direction of the beach he had described, so he assumed that they had watered their animals, but he noted with 
mild scorn that they now did not bother to unharness their team for what was sure to be a long wait. But he was 
pleased to note that all three Montgomerys had made some effort to spruce up — perhaps they were going to 
behave; perhaps his sixth sense for trouble was hypersensitive from too long in the wilderness. 

Lazarus was dressed in his best — kilt with full kit save that the effect was marred by a faded work shirt of 
New Pittsburgh origin. But itwas indeed his best, worn only for children’s birthdays. On other days he wore 
anything from overalls to skin, depending on work and weather. 

After Montgomery dismounted, he paused and looked over his host. “My, aren’t we fancy!” 

“In your honor, gentlemen. I save it for very special occasions.” 

“So? It’s mighty nice of you to honor us, Red. Isn’t it, Dan?’ 

“Right, Pop.” 

“My name is Bill, Monty. Not ‘Red.’ Nfciu can leave your, guns in your wagon.” 

“Well! Now that’s not very friendly. We always wear our guns. Don’t we, Darby?” 

“Right, Pop. And if Pop says your name is ‘Red,’ that’s your name.” 

“Now, now, Darby, I didn't say that If Red wants to call himself Tom, Dick, or Harry, that’s his choice. But we 
wouldn’t feel dressed without our guns, and that's the truth, uh, Bill. Why, I even wear mine to bed. Out here.” 

Lazarus was standing in the opened door of the compound. He made no move to step aside and let his 
visitors in. “That s a reasonable precaution. . .on the trail. But gentlemen don’t wear arms when they dine with a 
lady. Drop them here or put them in your wagon, whichever you wish.” 

Lazarus could feel the tension grow, could see the younger two watching their father for instructions. Lazarus 
ignored them and kept his easy smile on Montgomery, while forcing his muscles to stay loose as cotton. Right 
now? Would the bear back off? Or treat it as a challenge? 

Montgomery split his face in his widest grin. “Why, sure, neighbor — if that’s how you want it. Shall I take off my 
pants, too?” 

“Just your guns, sir.” (He’s right-handed. If I were right-handed and wearing what you are wearing, where 
would my second gun be? There, I think — but, if so, it must be small either a needle gun or possibly an old- 
fashioned snub-nosed assassin’s gun. Are his sons both right-handed?) 

The Montgomerys put their gun belts on the seat of their wagon, came back. Lazarus stood aside and 
welcomed them in, then slid the bar into place as he closed the door. Dora was waiting, dressed in her “party 
dress.” For the first time since a very hot day on the prairie she did not wear her rubies at the evening meal. 

“Dear, this is Mr. Montgomery and his sons, Darby and Dan. My wife, Mrs. Smith.” 

Dora bobbed a curtsy. “Welcome, Mr. Montgomery, and Darby, and Dan.” 

“Call me ‘Monty,’ Mrs. Smith — and what’s your name? Mighty pretty place you’ve got here... for so far out in 
the country.” 

“If you gentlemen will excuse me, ‘I have a couple of things to do to get supper on the table.” She turned 
quickly and hurried back into her kitchen. 

Lazarus answered, “I’m glad you like it, Monty. It’s the best we’ve been able to do so far, while getting a farm 
started.” The back wall of the compound had four rooms built against it: storeroom, kitchen, bedroom, and 
nursery. All had doors into the compound, but only the kitchen door was open. The rooms interconnected. 

Outside the kitchen door was a Dutch oven; in the kitchen was a fireplace used for other cooking and for all 
cooking when it rained. That and a water barrel were as yet Dora’s major kitchen equipment — but her husband 
had promised her running water “sometime before you are a grandmother, my lovely.” She had not pressed him 



about it; the house grew larger and better equipped each year. 

Beyond the Dutch oven and paralleling the bedrooms was a long table with matching stools. At the other wall 
by the storeroom was an outhouse; it and a water barrel and two wooden tubs made by cutting another barrel in 
two constituted, so far, their “bathroom-toilet-refresher.” A pile of earth with a shovel stuck into it was by the 
outhouse; the cesspit was being slowly backfilled. 

“>bu’ve done pretty well,” Montgomery conceded. “But you shouldn't have put your privy inside. Don’t you 
know that?” 

“There is another privy outside,” Lazarus Long told him. “We use this one as little as possible and I try to keep 
it from being too whiff. But you can’t expect a woman to go outside after dark, not in loper country." 

“Lots of lopers, eh?” 

“Not as many as there used to be. Did you see any dragons as you came through the valley?” 

“Saw a lot of bones. Looked like a plague had hit the dragons hereabouts.” 

“Something of the sort,” Lazarus agreed. “Lady! Heel!” He added, “Monty, tell Darby that it’s not safe to kick 
at that dog; she’ll attack. She’s a watchdog, in charge of this house, and she knows it.” 

“>bu heard what the man said, Darby. Leave the dog alone.” 

“Then she had better not come sniffing around me! I don’t like dogs. She growled at me.” 

Lazarus said directly to the older son, “She growled because you kicked at her when she sniffed you. Which 
was her duty. If I had not been present, she would have taken your throat out. Leave her alone and she’ll leave 
you alone.” 

Montgomery said, “Bill, you had better put her outside while we eat.” Phrased as a suggestion, it was made 
to sound like an order. 

“No." 

“Gentlemen, supper is served.” 

“Coming, dear. Lady. High sentry.” The bitch glanced at Darby but immediately trotted up the ladder to the 
roof, using the rungs without hesitation. There she made a careful full-circle scan before sitting down where she 
could watch both outside and the supper party below her. 

The Supper party was more successful as a supper than as a party. Conversation was limited mostly to small 
talk between the two older men. Darby and Dan simply ate. Dora answered briefly sallies that Montgomery 
made at her and failed to hear any that she regarded as too personal. The sons seemed surprised to find their 
plates set each with knife, fork, chop tongs, and spoon, then relied mostly on knife and fingers; their father made 
some effort to use each eating tool, getting quite a bit of food into his beard. 

Dora had piled the table with hot fried chicken, cold sliced ham, mashed potatoes and chicken gravy, hot 
corn pone and cold whole wheat bread with bacon drippings, a mug of goat’s milk at each place, lettuce-and- 
tomato salad with grated goat’s-cheese-and-onion dressing, boiled beets, fresh radishes, fresh strawberries 
with goat’s milk. As promised, the Montgomerys ate for six, and Dora was pleased that she had provided a 
plenty. 

At last Montgomery pushed back his stool and belched appreciatively. “My, that hit the spot! Miz Smith, you 
can cook for us all the time. Right, Dan?” 

“Right, Pop!” 

“I’m pleased that you enjoyed it, gentlemen.” She stood up and started to clear the table. Lazarus stood and 
started to help her. 

Montgomery said, “Oh, sit down, Bill. Want to ask you some questions.” 

“Go ahead and ask,” Lazarus said, continuing to stack plates. 

“\bu said there was no one else in the valley.” 

“That is correct." 

“Then I think we’ll stay right here. Miz Smith is a very good cook.” 

“\bu’re welcome to camp here overnight. Then you’ll find excellent farmland farther down the river. As I told 
you, I’ve homesteaded all of this.” 

“Been meaning to talk to you about that. Doesn’t seem right for one man to grab all the best land.” 

“It isn’t the best land, Monty; there arc thousands of hectares just as good. The only difference is that I’ve 
plowed and cultivated this part.” 

“Well, we won’t argue about it. We outvote you. Four voting, I mean, and us three all voting the same way. 
Right, Darby?” 

“Right, Pop.” 



“It’s not subject to vote, Monty.” 

“Oh, come now! The majority is always right. But we won’t argue. Been a nice feed, now for some 
entertainment. Do you like to rassle?” 

“Not especially.” 

“Don’t be a spoilsport. Dan, do you think you can throw him?” 

“Sure, Pop.” 

“Good. Bill, first you rassle Dan — out here in the middle and I'll referee, keep everything fair and square.” 

“Monty, I’m ‘not going to wrestle.” 

“Oh, sure you are. Miz Smith! Better come out here, you won't want to miss this.” 

“I’m busy now,” Dora called out. “I’ll be out shortly.” 

“Better hurry. Then you rassle Darby, Bill — then you rassle me.” 

“No wrestling, Monty. Time for you folks to get into your wagon.” 

“But you want to rassle, young fellow. I didn’t tell you what the prize is. The winner sleeps with Miz Smith.” His 
second gun appeared as he said it. “Fooled you, didn’t I?” 

From the kitchen Dora shot the gun out of his hand just as a knife suddenly grew in Dan’s neck. Lazarus shot 
Montgomery carefully in the leg, then even more carefully shot Darby — as Lady Macbeth was at his throat. The 
fight had lasted under two seconds. 

“Lady. Heel. Nice shooting, Dorable.” He patted Lady Macbeth. “Good Lady, good dog.” 

“Thank you, darling. Shall I finish off Monty?” 

“Wait a moment.” Lazarus stepped over and looked down at the wounded man. “Got anything to say, 
Montgomery?” 

“\bu bastards! Never gave us a chance.” 

“Gave you lots of chance. \bu wouldn’t take it. Dora? Do you want to? Nfciur privilege.” 

“Not especially.” 

“All right.” Lazarus picked up Montgomery’s second gun, noted that it was indeed a museum piece but did 
not seem to be hurt. He used, it to finish off its owner. 

Dora was peeling off her dress. “Haifa moment, dear, while I get this off; I don’t want to get blood on it.” With 
the dress out of the way, her pregnant condition showed a little. She also showed several other weapons as well 
as a gun belt riding low on her hips. 

Lazarus was getting out of his kilt and other finery. “You don’t need to help, sweetheart; you’ve done a full 
day’s work — and a fine one! Just toss me my oldest overalls." 

“But I want to help. What are going to do with them?” 

“Put them into their wagon, take them far enough downriver that lopers will dispose of them, drive back.” He 
glanced at the Sun. “An hour and more of daylight left. Time enough.” 

“Lazarus, I don’t want you away, from me! Not now.” 

“Upset by it, my durable one?” 

“Some. Not much. Uh...made horny by it, I’m ashamed to say. Perverted, huh?" 

“Rangy Lil, anything makes you horny. Yes; it’s somewhat perverse... but a surprisingly common reaction to 
one’s first encounter with death. Nothing to be ashamed of as long as you don’t get hooked by it; it’s just a reflex. 
On second thought never mind the overalls; I can scrub blood off my hide easier than getting it out of cloth.” He 
removed the bar and opened the gate as he’ talked. 

“I’ve seen death before. I was much more upset whenAunt Helen died. ..and nota bit horny.” 

“Violent death, I should have said. Dear, I want to get these bodies outside the wall before any more blood 
soaks into the ground. We can discuss it later.” 

“Tbu’ll need help loading them. And I donfwantto be away from you, truly I don’t.” 

Lazarus stopped and looked at her. “Ntiu’re more upset than you let on. That’s common, too — steady in the 
clutch, then a reaction afterwards. So let’s work it out. I don’t fancy leaving the kids alone that long, nor do I want 
them in a wagon loaded with all that bad meat. Suppose I drive just a short distance tonight — say three hundred 
meters or so — while you start a kettle of water? I’m going to want another bath after this job even if I manage not 
to get a drop of blood on me.” 

“Yes, sir.” 

“Dora, you don’t sound happy.” 

“I’ll do it your way. But I could wake Zaccur and have him baby-sit. He’s used to it.” 



“Very well, dear. But first we load them. You can hold up their feet while I drag them. If you throw up, I'll assume 
that you’ll baby-sit while I finish this chore.” 

“I won’t throw up. I ate very little.” 

“I didn’t eat much either.” They got on with the grisly task; Lazarus continued to talk. “Dora, you did a perfect 
job." 

“I caught your signal. >t>u gave me plenty of time.” 

“I wasn’t sure he was going to push it to a showdown even when I signaled.” 

“Really, dear? I knew what they meant to do — kill you and rape me — before they ever sat down to eat. 
Couldn’t you feel it? So I made sure that they ate plenty — to slow them down.” 

“Dora, you really do sense emotions — don’t you?” 

“Mind his head, dear. When they’re as strong as that, I do. But I wasn’t sure how you would handle it. I made 
up my mind to be raped all night if that was what it took for you to set up a safe chance.” 

Her husband answered soberly, “Dora, I will allow you to be raped only if that is the only possible way to save 
your life. Tonight it was not necessary. Thank goodness! But Montgomery had me worried at the gate. Three 
guns out in the open and mine still under my kilt — Could have been a problem. Since he meant to take me 
anyhow, he should have done it then. Durable, three-fourths of any fight lies in not hesitating when the time 
comes. Which is why I’m so proud of you.” 

“But you set it up, Lazarus. You signaled me to get into position, you stayed on your feet when he told you to 
sit down, you went around to the end of the table and pulled their eyes with you — and stayed out of my line of fire. 
Thank you. All I had to do was shoot when he got out his gun.” 

“Of course I stayed out of your line of, fire, dear; this isn’t my first time by too many. But it was your straight 
shooting that gave me time to put my knife into Dan instead of having to settle his father first. And Lady did me 
the same favor with Darby. \t>u two girls saved me from having to be three places at once. Which I’ve always 
found difficult.” 

“\bu trained both of us.” 

“Mmm, yes. Which detracts not at all from the admirable fact that you held your fire until he committed himself 
— then lost not a split second in taking him. As if you were a veteran of a hundred gun battles rather than none. 
\t>u might go around and steady the mules while I get this tailgate open.” 

“Yes, dear.” 

She had just reached the lead pair and spoken soothingly to them when he called out: “Dora! Here a minute." 

She came back; he said, “Look at that.” 

It was a flat piece of standstone he had removed from the end of the wagon bed and laid on the ground by 
the corpses. It was carved with: 


BUCK 

BORN ON EARTH 
303IA.D. 

DWD ON THIS SPOT 
N.B.37 

He Always Did His Best 


She said, “Lazarus, I don’t understand it. I can understand why they intended to rape me — I’m probably the 
first woman they’ve seen in many weeks. I can even understand that they would kill you, or do anything, to get at 
me. But why would they steal this?” 

“It’s not exactly ‘why,’ dear... People who don’t respect other people’s property will do anything... and will 
steal anything that’s not nailed down. Even if they have no use for it.” He added, “Had I known this earlier, I would 
have given them no chance. Such people should be destroyed on sight. The problem is to identify them.” 

Minerva, Dora is the only woman I ever loved unreservedly. I don’t know that I can explain why. I did not love 
her that way when I married her; she had not had a chance as yet to teach me what love can be. Oh, I did love 
her, but it was the love of a doting father for a favorite child or somewhat like the love one can lavish on a pet. 



I decided to marry her not through love in any deepest sense but simply because this adorable child who had 
given me so many hours of happiness wanted something very badly — my child — and there was only one way I 
could give her what she wanted and still please my own self-love. So almost coldly, I calculated the cost and 
decided that the price was low enough that I could let her have what she wanted. It could not cost me much; she 
was an ephemeral. Fifty, sixty, seventy, at the most eighty years and she would be dead. I could afford to spend 
that trivial amount of time to make my adopted daughter’s pitifully short life happy — that’s how I figured it. It 
wasn’t much, and I could afford it. So be it. 

All the rest was just a case of no half measures; do whatever else is necessary to your main purpose. I told 
you some of the possibilities; I may not have mentioned that I considered taking back the captaincy of the Andy 
J. for Dora’s lifetime, have Zaccur Briggs take the ground side of the partnership or buy him out if that didn’t suit 
him. But while eighty-odd years in a starship would not stonker me, to Dora it would be a lifetime and it might not 
suit her. Besides, a ship is not an ideal place to raise kids — what do you do when they grow up? Drop them off 
somewhere not knowing anything but ship’s routine? Not good. 

I decided that the husband of an ephemeral had to be an ephemeral, in everyway possible to him. The 
corollaries to that decision caused us to wind up in Happy Valley. 

Happy Valley — The happiest of all my lives. The longer I was privileged to live with Dora, the more I loved her. 
She taught me to love by loving me, and I learned — rather slowly; I wasn’t too good a pupil, being set in my ways 
and lacking her natural talent. But I did learn. Learned that supreme happiness lies in wanting to keep another 
person safe and warm and happy, and being privileged to try. 

And the saddest, too. The more thoroughly I learned this — through living day on day with Dora — the happier I 
was and the more I ached in one corner of my mind with certain knowledge that this could be only a brief time too 
soon over — and when it was over, I did not marry again for almost a hundred years. Then I did, for Dora taught 
me to face up to death, too. She was as aware of her own death of the certain briefness of her life, as I was. But 
she taught me to live novy not to let anything sully today. . . until at last I got over the sadness of being condemned 
to live. 

We had a wonderfully good time! Working our arses off, always too much to do, and enjoying every minute. 
Never too rushed to enjoy life no matter what. Sometimes just pat-ass and squeeze-titty as I hurried through the 
kitchen, with her quick smile acknowledging it, sometimes a lazy hour on the roof invested in watching sunset 
and stars and moons, usually with “Eros” to make, it sweeter. 

I guess you could say that sex was, our only active amusement for a number of years (and never stopped 
being in first place as Dora was as enthusiastic at seventy as at seventeen — just not as limber). I was usually 
too tired to play good chess even though I made us a set of chessmen; we had no other games and probably 
would not have played them anyhow — too busy. Oh, we did do other things; often one of us would read aloud 
while the other knitted or cooked or something. Or we would sing together, coonjining the rhythm while we 
pitched grain or manure. 

We worked together as much as possible; division of labor came only from natural limits. I can’t bear a baby 
pr suckle it, but I can do anything else for a child. Dora could not do some things that I did because they were too 
heavy for her, especially when she was far gone in pregnancy. She had more talent for cooking than I (I had 
centuries more experience but not her touch), and she could cook while she took care of a baby and tended the 
smallest children, ones too small to join me in the fields. But I did cook, especially breakfast while she got the 
kids organized, and she did help work the farm and especially the truck garden. She knew nothing of farming; 
she learned. 

Nor did she know construction — she learned. While I did most of the high work, she made most of the adobe 
bricks, always with the right amount of straw. Adobe was not well suited to the climate — too much rain and it can 
be discouraging to see a wall start to melt because an unexpected rain has caught you before you’ve topped it. 

But you build from what you have, and it helped that I had the tops from the wagons to peg against the most 
exposed walls, until I worked out a way to waterproof an adobe wall. I did not consider a log cabin; good timber 
was too far away. It took the mules and me a full day to bring in two logs, which made them too expensive for 
most construction. Instead, I made do with smaller stuff that grew along the banks of Buck’s River and dragged in 
logs only for beams. 

Nor did I want to build a house that was not as near fireproof as I could make it. Baby Dora had once almost 
been burned to death; I would not risk it again for Dora, or for her children. 



But how to make a roof both watertight and fireproof nearly stumped me. 

I walked past the answer hundreds of times before I recognized it. When wind and weather and rot and 
lopers and insects have done their worst on a dead dragon, what is left is almost indestructible. I discovered this 
when I tried to burn what was left of a big brute that was unpleasantly close to our compound; I never did find out 
why this was so. Perhaps the biochemistry of those dragons has been investigated since then, but I had neither 
equipment nor time nor interest; I was too busy scratching a living for my family and was simply delighted to learn 
that it was true. Belly hide I cut into fireproof, waterproof tarpaulins; back and sides made excellent roofing. Later 
I found many uses for the bones. 

We both taught, school, indoors and out. Perhaps our kids had a weird education... but a girl who can shape 
a comfortable and handsome saddle starting with a dead mule and not much else, solve quadratics in her head, 
shoot straight with gun or arrow, cook an omelet that is light and tasty, spout page after page of Shakespeare, 
butcher a hog and cure it can’t be called ignorant by New Beginnings standards. All our girls and boys could do 
all of that and more. I must admit that they spoke a rather florid brand of English, especially after they set up the 
New Globe Theater and worked straight through every one of old Bill’s plays. No doubt this gave them odd 
notions of Old Earth’s culture and history, but I could not see that it hurt them. We had only a few bound books, 
mostly reference; the dozen-odd “fun” books were worked to death. 

Our kids saw nothing strange in learning to read from As You Like it. No one told them that it was too hard for 
them, and they ate it up, finding “tongues in trees, books in the running brooks, sermons in stones, and good in 
everything." 

Although it did sound odd to hear a five-year-old girl speak in scansion and rolling periods, polysyllables 
falling gracefully from her baby lips. Still, I preferred it to “Run, Spot, run. See Spot run” from a later era than Bill’s. 

Second only to Shakespeare in popularity, and first whenever, Dora was swelling up again, were my medical 
books, especially those on anatomy, obstetrics, and gynecology. Any birth was an event — kittens, piglets, foals, 
puppies, kids — but a new baby out of Dora was a super-event, one that always put more thumbprints on that 
standard OB illustration, a cross section of mother and baby at term. I finally removed that one and several plates 
that followed it, those showing normal delivery, and posted them, to save wear and tear on my books — then 
announced that they could look at those pictures all they wanted to, but that to touch one was a spanking 
offense — then was forced to spank Iseult to keep justice even, which hurt her old father far more than it did her 
baby bottom even though she saved my face by applauding my gentle paddling with loud screams and tears. 

My medical books had one odd effect. Our kids knew from babyhood all the correct English monosyllables 
for human anatomy and function; Helen Mayberry had never used slang with Baby Dora; Dora spoke as correctly 
in front of her children. But, once they could read my books, intellectual snobbery set in; they loved those Latin 
polysyllables. If I said “womb” (as I always did), some six-year-old would inform me with quiet authority that the 
book said “uterus.” Or Undine might rush in with the news that Big Billy Whiskers was “copulating” with Silky, 
whereupon the kids would rush out to the goat pen to watch. Somewhere around their middle teens they usually 
recovered from this nonsense and went back to speaking English as their parents spoke it, so I guess it didn’t 
hurt them. 

The reason my own goatiness was not a spectator sport for children that all the animals afforded was, I think, 
only my own unreasoned but long-standing habits. I don’t think it would have fretted Dora because it did not 
seem to fret her’ the times it happened — as it did; privacy was scarce and got scarcer until I got our big house 
built some twelve or thirteen years after we entered the valley — time indefinite because for years I worked on it 
when I could; then we moved into it unfinished because we were bulging the walls of our first house and another 
baby (Ginny) was on the way. 

Dora was untroubled by lack of privacy because her sweet lechery was utterly innocent, whereas mine was 
scarred by the culture I grew up in — a culture psychotic throughout and especially on this subject. Dora did much 
to heal those scars. But I never achieved her angelic innocence. 

Ido not mean the innocence of childish ignorance; I mean the true innocence of an intelligent, informed, adult 
woman who has no evil in her. Dora was as tough as she was innocent, always aware that she was responsible 
for her own actions. She knew that “the tail goes with the hide, that you can’t be a little bit pregnant, that it is no 
kindness to hang a man slowly.” She could make a hard decision without dithering, then stand up to the 
consequences if it turned out that her judgment was faulty. She could apologize to a child, or to a mule. But that 



was rarely necessary; her self-honesty did not often lead her into faulty decisions. 

Nor did she flagellate herself when she made a mistake. She corrected it as best she could, learned from it, 
did not lie awake over it. 

While her ancestry had given her the potential, Helen Mayberry must be credited with having guided it and 
allowed it to develop. Helen Mayberry was sensitive and sensible. Come to think of it, the traits complement. A 
person who is sensitive but not sensible is all mixed up, cannot function properly. A person who is sensible but 
not sensitive — I’ve never met one and am not sure such a person can exist. 

Helen Mayberry was born on Earth but had shucked off her bad background when she migrated; she did not 
pass onto Baby Dora and growing-girl Dora the sick standards of a dying culture. I knew some of this from 
Helen herself, but I learned more about Helen from Dora the Woman. Over the long course of getting acquainted 
with this stranger I had married (married couples always start out as strangers no matter how long they’ve known 
each other) I learned that Dora knew exactly the relationship that had once existed between Helen Mayberry and 
me, including the fact that it was economic as well as social and physical. 

This did not make Dora jealous of “Aunt” Helen; jealousy was only a word to Dora, one that meant no more to 
her than a sunset does to an earthworm; the capacity to feel jealousy had never been developed in her. She 
regarded the arrangements between Helen and me as natural, reasonable, and appropriate. Indeed I feel certain 
that Helen’s example was the clinching factor in Dora’s picking me as her mate, as it could not have been my 
charm and beauty, both negligible. Helen had not taught Dora that sex was anything sacred; she had taught her, 
by precept and example, that sex is a way for people to be happy together. 

Take those three vultures we killed — Instead of what they were, had they been good men and decent — oh, 
such men as Ira and Galahad — and given the same circumstances, four men with only one woman and the 
situation likely to staythatway, Ithink Dora would have entered easily and naturally into polyandry... and would 
have managed to convince me that that was the only happy solution by the way she herself treated it. 

Nor would she, in adding more husbands, have been breaking her marriage vows. Dora had not promised to 
cleave unto me only; I won't let a woman promise that because a day sometimes arrives when she can’t. 

Dora could have kept four decent, honorable men happy. Dora had none of the sickly attitudes that interfere 
with a person loving more and more; Helen had seen to that. And, as the Greeks pointed out, one man cannot 
quench the fires of Vesuvius. Or was it the Romans? Never mind, it’s true. Dora probably would have been even 
happier in a polyandrous marriage. And if she were happier, it follows, as the night the day, that I would have 
been also — even though I cannot imagine being happier than I was. But more big male muscles would have 
made life easier on me; I always had too much to, do. More company could have been pleasant, too, I am forced 
to assume the company of men whom Dora found acceptable. As for Dora herself, she had enough love in her to 
lavish it on me and a dozen kids; three more husbands would not have used up her resources, she was a spring 
that never ran dry. 

But the matter is hypothetical. Those three Montgomerys were so little like Galahad and Ira that it is hard to 
think of them as being of the same race. They were verminfor killing, and that’s what they got. I learned only a 
little about them, from reading the contents of their wagon. Minerva, they were not pioneers; there was not the 
barest minimum in that wagon for starting a farm. Not a plow, not a sack of seed — And their eight mules were all 
geldings. I don’t know what they thought they were doing. Exploring just for the hell of it, perhaps? Then go back 
to “civilization” when they grew tired of it? Or did they expect to find that some one of the pioneer parties that had 
started over the pass had made it — and could be terrorized into submission? I don’t know, I never will know. I 
have never understood the gangster mind — I simply know what to do about gangsters. 

As may be, they made a fatal mistake in tackling sweet and gentle Dora. She not only shot at the right instant, 
but she shot his gun out of his hand instead of taking the much easier target, his belly or chest. Important? 
Supremely so, for me. His gun was aimed at me. Had Dora shot him, instead of his gun, even if her shot killed 
him, his last reflex would probably — certainly, I think — have caused his fingers to tighten and I would have been 
hit. \bu can figure it from there in half a dozen ways, all bad.” 

Lucky accident? Not at all. Dora had him covered from the darkness of the kitchen. When he pulled that gun, 
she instantly changed her point of aim and got the gun. It was her first — and last — gunfight. But a true gunfighter, 
that girl! The hours we had spent polishing her skill paid off. But more rare than skill was the cool judgment with 
which she decided to try for the much more difficult target. I could not train her in that; it had to be born in her. 
Which it was — if you think back, her father made the same sort of correct split-second decision as his last dying 
act. 



It was seven more years before another wagon appeared in Happy Valley — three wagons traveling together, 
three families with children, true pioneers. We were glad to see them and I was especially happy to see their 
kids. For I bad been juggling eggs. Real eggs. Human ova. 

I was running out of time; our oldest kids were growing up. 

Minerva, you know all that the human race has learned about genetics. \bu know that the Howard Families 
are inbred from a fairly small gene pool — and that inbreeding has tended to clear them of bad genes — but you 
know also the high price that has been paid in defectives. Is still being paid, should add; everywhere there are 
Howards there are also sanctuaries for defectives. Nor is there any end to it; new unfavorable mutations 
unnoticed until they are reinforced is the price we animals must payfor evolution. Maybe there will be a cheaper 
way someday — there was notone on New Beginnings twelve hundred years ago. 

Young Zack was a husky lad whose voice was firmly baritone. His brother, Andy, was no longer a boy soprano 
in our family chorus although his voice still cracked. Baby Helen wasn’t such a baby any longer — hadn’t reached 
menarche, but as near as I could tell it would be any day, any day. 

I mean to say that Dora and I were having to think about it, forced to consider hard choices. Should we pack 
seven kids into the wagons and head back across the Rampart? If we made it, should we put the four oldest with 
the Magees or someone, then come home with the younger three? By ourselves? Or sing the praises of Happy 
Valley, its beauty and its wealth, and try to lead a party of pioneers back over the range and thereby avoid such 
crisis in the future? 

I had expected, too optimistically, that others would follow us almost at once — a year or two or three — since I 
had left a passable wagon trail behind me. But I’m notone to fume over spilled milk after the horse is stolen. 
What might have been was of no interest; the problem was what to do with our horny kids now that they were’ 
growing up. 

No point in talking to them about “sin” even if I were capable of such hypocrisy — which I am not, especially 
with kids. Nor could I have sold the idea. Dora would have been shocked and hurt, and her skills did not extend 
to lying convincingly. Nor did I want to fill our kids with such nonsense; their angelic mother was the happiest, 
most ever-ready lecher in Happy Valley — even, more so than I and the goats — and she never pretended 
otherwise. 

Should we relax and let nature take its ancient course? Accept the idea our daughters would presently (all too 
soon!) mate with our sons and be prepared to accept the price? Expect at least one defective grandchild out of 
ten? I had no data on which to estimate the cost any closer than that, as Dora knew nothing about her ancestry 
and, while I did know a little about mine, I did not know enough. All I had was that old and extremely rough thumb 
rule. 

So we stalled. 

We fell back on another sound old thumb rule: Never do today what you can put off till tomorrow if tomorrow 
might improve the odds. 

So we moved into our new house while it was still not finished — but finished enough that we then had a girls’ 
dormitory, a boys’ dormitory, a bedroom for Dora and me, with adjacent nursery. 

But we did not kid ourselves that we bad solved the problem. Instead we hauled it out into the open, made 
sure that the three oldest knew what the problem was and what the risks were and why it would be smart to hold 
off. Nor were the younger kids shut out of this schooling; they simply were not required even to audit the course 
when they found themselves bored with technicalities they were too young to be interested in. 

Dora chucked in a frill, one based on something Helen Mayberry had done for her some twenty years earlier. 
She announced that when little Helen achieved menarche, we would declare a holiday and have a party, with 
Helen as guest of honor. From then on, every year, that day would be known as “Helen’s Day” and so on for Iseult 
and Undine and on down the line until there was an annual holiday named for each girl. 

Helen could hardly wait to pass from childhood into girlhood — and when: she did a few months later, she was 
unbearably smug. Woke us all up shouting about it. “Mama! Papa! Look, it’s happened! Zack! Andy! Wake up! 
Come see!” 

If she hurt, she did not mention it. Probably she did not; Dora wasn’t subject to menstrual cramps, and neither 
of us told the girls to expect them. Being myself convex instead of concave, I refrain from commenting on the 
theory that such pains are a conditioned reflex; I don’t think I’m entitled to an opinion 
— you might ask Ishtar. 



It also resulted in me being called on by a delegation of two, Zack and Andy with Zack as spokesman: “Look, 
Papa — we think it splendid, meet, and fit our sister Helen’s day to mark with joyful sounds and jollity acclaiming 
this our sibling’s rightful heritage. Butsoothly, sire, methinks — ” 

“Chop it off and say it.” 

“Well, how about boys!” 

By gum, I reinstituted chivalry! 

Not as a sudden inspiration. Zack had asked a tough one; I had to dance around it a bit before I reached a 
workable answer. Sure, there are rites of passage for males as well as females; every culture has them, even 
those that aren’t aware of it. When I was a boy, it was your first suit with long pants. Then there are ones such as 
circumcision at puberty, ordeal by pain, killing some dread beast — endless. 

None of these fitted our boys. Some I disapproved of, some were impossible — circumcision for example. I 
have this unimportant mutation, no foreskin. But it is a Y-linked dominant, and I pass it on to all my male offspring. 
The boys knew this, but I stalled by mentioning it again, discussed it in connection with the endless ways in which 
a male’s transition into beginning manhood was sometimes celebrated — while trying to think of an answer to the 
main question. 

Finally I said, “Look, boys, you both know all about reproduction and genetics that I have been able to teach 
you. Nt>u both know what ‘Helen’s Day means. Don’t you? Andy?” 

Andy did not answer; his older brother said, “Sure he knows, Papa. It means Helen can have babies now, just 
like Mama. >t>u know that, Andy.” Andy nodded agreement, round-eyed. “We all know, Papa, even the kids. Well, 
I’m not sure about Ivar; he’s so little. But Iseult and Undine know it — Helen’s been telling them that she’s going to 
catch up with Mama — have her first baby right away.” 

I controlled the cold chills I felt. Let me cut this short: I did not tell them that this was a bad idea; instead I took 
a long time drawing answers from them, things they both knew but had not yet thought of quite so personally 
— how Helen could not have a baby unless one or the other of them put it into her; how Helen was still too little for 
the strain of baking a baby even though “Helen’s Day marked the fact that she was now vulnerable; how and 
why, even when Helen was big enough in a few years, a baby out of Helen by one of her brothers could be a 
tragedy instead of the fine babies Mama made every time. They told me, Andy’s eyes getting bigger all the time 
— I simply supplied leading questions. 

I was helped in this by the fact that a little mule mare, Dancing Girl, had come into her first estrus when I 
thought she was not grown-up enough for a colt. So I had had Zack and Andy fence her off — and she kicked a 
hole in the fence and got what she wanted; Buckaroo covered her. Sure enough, the colt had been too big for her 
and I had to go in and cut it up and take it out in chunks — a routine job of emergency veterinary surgery but an 
impressive and bloody sight for two stripling boys who had helped their father by controlling the mare while he 
operated. 

No, indeed, they did not want anything even a little bit like that to happen to Helen. No, sir! 

Minerva, I cheated a little. I did noftell them that the way Helen was spreading in the butt and the 
measurements she already had made it appear to her family doctor — me — that she was even more of a natural 
baby factory than her mother and would be big enough for her first one much younger than Dora had had Zaccur; 

I did not tell them that the chances of a healthy baby from a brother-sister mating were higher than the chances of 
a defective. I certainly did not! 

Instead, I waxed lyrical about what wonderful creatures girls are, what a miracle it is that they could make 
babies, how precious they are and how it is a man’s proud privilege to love and cherish and protect them 
— protect them even from their follies because Helen might behave just like Dancing Girl, impatient and foolish. 
So don’t let her tempt you, boys — jerk off instead, just like you’ve been doing. They promised, tears in their eyes. 

I didn’t ask them to promise that or anything — but it gave me the idea: Have “Princess” Helen knight them. 

The kids grabbed that idea and ran with it; Tales of King Arthur’s Court was one of the books Dora had 
fetched along because Helen Mayberry had given it to her. So we had Sir Zaccur the Strong and Sir Andrew the 
Valiant and two ladies-in-waiting — waiting rather eagerly; Iseult and Undine knew that they, too, would be 
“princesses” as each reached menarche. Ivar was squire to both knights and would be dubbed himself when his 
voice changed. Only Elf was too small as yet to play the game. 

It worked, a stopgap. I suppose “Princess” Helen was protected more than she wanted to be protected. But if 
she could not lure her faithful knights into the cornfields, they did place her stool for her at meals, they bowed to 
her rather often, and usually addressed her as “Fair Princess” — considerably more than I ever did for my sisters. 



Before the first anniversary of “Helen’s Day” those three new families dropped down the rise and the crisis 
was over. It was Sammy Roberts, not one other brothers, who first spread “Princess” Helen’s thighs — certain, as 
she told her mother about it at once (more of Helen Mayberry’s influence) and Dora kissed her and told her that 
she was a good girl and now go find Papa and ask him to examine you — and I did and she hadn't been hurt, not 
to mention. But it gave Dora some control over the matter, just as Helen Mayberry had guided Dora at about the 
same age — so Dora had told me, long before that. In consequence our oldest daughter did not get pregnant until 
she was almost as old as and quite a bit more filled out than Dora had been when I married her. Ole Hanson 
married her; and Sven Hanson and I, and Dora and Ingrid, helped the youngsters start their homestead. Helen 
thought the baby was Ole’s, and for all I know she was right. No fuss. No fuss when Zack married Hilda Hanson, 
either. In Happy Valley pregnancy was equivalent to betrothal; I can’t recall any girl who married without that proof 
of eligibility. Certainly none of our daughters. 

Having neighbors was grand. 

(Omitted) 

— not only fetched his fiddle over the Rampart but could call. I could call some and, while I hadn’t touched a 
violin for fifty years or so, I found it came back to me, so we spelled each other as Pop liked to dance, too. Like 
so: 

“Square ’em up! 

“Salute your lady! Opposite lady! Corner gal! Right-hand gal! Salute your own and make ‘er a throne. All stand up 
and don’t let ‘er fall; swing your ladies one and all! 

‘“Moses lived a long time ago. 

King said Yes; Moses said Not — form hands, circle right. 

‘Phar’oh was dat king’s first name; 

‘Made ‘em live a life of shame! — allemande left/— with a dosey-doh! Then home you go and swing! 

. .said Yes and th’weves did part. First couple through the Red Sea! Now corner gal and right-hand man! 
Corner boy, right-hand gal — on around and keep it coming right and left! 

“‘A happy band on th’opp’site shore, 

‘So all form up and swing once more! 

King weeps alone on Egypt’s shore; 

‘Chosen People slaves no more! 

‘So kiss your lady and whisper in her ear; 

‘Then sit ‘erdown and get ‘era beer.’ Intermission!” 

Oh, we had fun! Dora learned to dance when she was a new grandmother — and was still dancing when she 
was a great-great-grandmother. Early years the parties were oftenest at our place because we had the biggest 
house and a compound large enough for a big party. Start dancing late afternoon, dance till you couldn’t see your 
partner; then a potluck buffet supper to candlelight and moonlight, then sing a while, and bed down all over the 
place — all the rooms, the roof, shakedowns in the compound, some in wagons — and if anybody ever slept alone, 

I never heard about it. Nor any trouble worth mentioning if things got a little loose around the edges. 

Next morning there was likely to be a double performance by the Mermaid Tavern Players, one comedy, one 
tragedy, then it would be time for those who lived farthest away to round up their kids, hitch up their mules, and 
roll, while those who lived closer helped clean up before doing the same thing. 

Oh, I remember one spot of trouble: A man gave his wife a black eye over nothing much, whereupon six men 
nearest him tossed him out the gate and barred it. Made him so mad he hitched up and left. ..and headed back 
up the Great Gorge toward Hopeless Pass — a fact that wasn’t noticed for a while, as his wife and baby moved in 
with her sister and her husband and their kids, and stayed on, a polygamy — though not the only one. No laws 
about marriage or sex — no laws about anything for many years — except that incurring the disapproval of your 
neighbors, such as by giving your wife a black eye, meant risking Coventry, about the worst thing that can 



happen to a pioneer short of being lynched. 

But migrants tend to be both horny and easy about it. Superior intelligence always includes strong sexual 
drive, and the pioneers in Happy Valley had been through a double screening, first in a decision to leave Earth 
and then in deciding to tackle Hopeless Pass. So we had real survivors in Happy Valley, smart, cooperative, 
industrious, tolerant — willing to fight when necessary but not likely to fight over trivial matters. Sex is not trivial, but 
fighting over it is usually pretty silly. It’s characteristic only of a man who isn’t sure of his manhood, which didn’t 
describe any of these men; they were sure of themselves, no need to prove it. No cowards, no thieves, no 
weaklings, no bullies — the rare exception didn't last long enough to count. Either dead like that first three, or ran 
away from us like that idiot who took a poke at his wife. 

These rare purgings were always quick and informal. For many years the only law we had was the Golden 
Rule, unwritten but closely followed. 

In such a community functionless taboos about sex couldn't last; they didn’t tend to be brought into our valley 
in the first place. Oh, close inbreeding wasn’t well thought of; these pioneers were not ignorant of genetics, nor of 
conception control. But the attitude was pragmatic; I don’t think I ever heard anyone speak out against incest that 
was just a jolly romp with no outcome. But I recall one girl who married her half brother openly and had several 
children by him — I assume that they were his. There may have been gossip, but it did not get them ostracized. 
Any marriage pattern was treated as the private business of the partners in it, not something to be licensed by 
the community. I recall two young couples who decided to combine their farms, then built a house big enough by 
adding to the larger of their two houses and making the other into a barn. Nobody asked who slept with whom; it 
was taken for granted that it was then a four-cornered marriage, and no doubt had been one before they 
enlarged that house and pooled their goods. Nobody’s business but theirs. 

Among such people the plural of “spouse” is “spice.” A pioneer community, poor in everything else, always 
makes its own recreations — with sex at the top of the list. We had no professional entertainers, no theaters 
(unless you count the amateur theatricals started by our kids), no cabarets, no diversions dependent on 
sophisticated electronics, no periodicals, few books. Certainly those meetings of the Happy Valley Dance Club 
continued as gentle orgies after it was too dark to dance and the younger children were bedded down for the 
night — how else? But it was all quite gentle; a couple could always go sleep in their own wagon and ignore the 
quiet luau elsewhere. No compulsion either way — shucks, they didn’t even have to attend the dances. 

But no one stayed away from those weekly dances if he or she could make it. It was particularly nice for 
young people; it gave them a chance to get acquainted and do their courting. Perhaps most first babies were 
conceived at our dances; there was opportunity. On the other hand, a girl did not have to get knocked up just 
through a romp if it didn’t suit her. But a girl was likely to marry by fifteen, sixteen, and their bridegrooms weren’t 
much older — late first marriage is a big-city custom, never found in a pioneer culture. 

Dora and I? But, Minerva dear, I told you earlier. 

(Omitted) 

— started the freight schedule to the outside the year Gibbie was born and Zack was, oh, eighteen I think — I 
have to keep converting New Beginnings years into standard years. Anyhow he was taller than I was, not much 
short of two meters and massed maybe eighty kilos, and Andy was almost as big and strong. There was 
pressure on me not to wait as I knew Zack might get married any day — and I could not send a wagon over the 
pass just with Andy. Ivar was only nine — a big help around the farm but not big enough for this job. 

But I could not find teamsters other than in my own family. There were only about a dozen families in the 
valley; they had not been there long, and did not as yet feel the press to buy things that I did. 

I wanted three new wagons, not just because my three were wearing out but because Zack would need one 
when he married. So would Andy. And I might have to dower Helen with one, if and when. The same applied to 
plows and several sorts of metal farm equipment. Prosperous as we were, Happy Valley could not be entirely 
self-supporting without a metals industry — which is to say: not for many years. I had another long list of things to 
buy — 


(Omitted) 


-on a quarterly schedule. But the food that fifty-odd farms could ship out could not buy much at the other end 



in competition with farmers who did not have the expense of shipping by mule train over the Rampart and across 
the prairie; I still subsidized our link with civilization by writing drafts on John Magee to be debited against my 
partnership in the AndyJ. and thereby brought things into the valley we would not otherwise have bad. Some I 
kept — Dora got in-house running water from that first trip our own boys made, just in time to keep my promise to 
her, as Zack got Hilda pregnant right after they got back, and their first baby, Ingrid Dora, and the completion of 
Dora’s bathroom, arrived about together. Other things I sold to other farmers for labor. But the Buck strain of 
mules, strong, intelligent, and all of them capable of being taught to talk, eventually corrected our balance of 
trade, once those two wells were drilled on the prairie and I could count on running a string of mules to 
Separation Center without losing half of them. This meant medicines, books, and many other things for our 
valley. 

(Omitted) 

Lazarus Long did not intend to surprise his wife. But neither of them ever knocked on their own bedroom 
door. Finding it closed, he opened it gently against the possibility that she might be napping. Instead he found 
her standing at the window, mirror angled to the light, carefully plucking a long gray hair. 

He watched her in shocked dismay. Then steadied himself and said, “Adorable — ’’ 

“Oh.” She turned. “\t>u startled me. I didn't hear you come in, dear.” 

“I’m sorry. May I have that?” 

“Have what, Woodrow?” 

He went to her, bent down and picked up the silver hair. “This. Beloved, every hair of your head is precious to 
me. May I keep it?” 

She did not answer. He saw that her eyes were filled with tears. They started to overflow. “Dora, Dora,” he 
repeated urgently, “why are you crying, beloved?” 

“I’m sorry, Lazarus. I did not intend for you to see me doing this." 

“But why do it at all, Dorable? I have far more gray hair than you." 

She answered what he had not said, rather than what he did say. “Dearest, I can’t help it that I know when 
someone is — well, ‘fibbing’ I must call it since you have never lied to me.” 

“Why, Dorable! My hair is gray.” 

“Yes, sir. Nt>u did not mean to surprise me, I know. . .and I did not mean to snoop when I cleaned your study. I 
found your cosmetics kit, Lazarus, more than a year ago. It’s sort of a fib, isn’t it? — when you do something to 
make your crisp red hair look gray? Something like what I do, I suppose, when I pluck hairs that are gray.” 

“>bu’ve been plucking gray hairs since you learned that I have been aging myself? Oh, dear!" 

“No, no, Lazarus! I’ve been plucking them for ages.Much longer than that. Heavens, darling, I’m a great- 
grandmother — and look it. But what you do — careful as you are with it — and kind as it is for you to try — and I do 
appreciate it! — doesn’t make you look my age; it just makes you look prematurely gray.” 

“Possibly. Although I’m entitled to gray hair, Dorable — my hair was snow-white not many years before you 
were born. It took something much more drastic than cosmetics — or plucking hairs — to make me look young 
again. But there never seemed to be any reason to mention it.” 

He stepped up to her, put an arm around her waist, took the mirror and tossed it on the bed, turned her 
toward the window., “Dora, your years are an achievement, not something to hide. Look out there. Farmhouses 
right up to the hills and many more we can’t see from here. How many of our Happy Valley people are 
descended from your slim body?” 

“I’ve never counted.” 

“I have; more than half of them — and I’m proud of you. "four breasts are baby-chewed, your belly shows 
stretch marks — your decorations of honor, Adorable One. Of valor. They make you more beautiful. So stand 
straight and tall, my lovely, and forget about silver hairs. Be what you are, and be it in style!” 

“\fes, Lazarus. I don’t mind them myself — I did it to please you.” 

“Dorable, you can’t help pleasing me, you always have. Do you want me to let my own hair go back to 
natural? It’s not dangerous for me to be a Howard — here in Happy Valley with my own kin all around me.” 

“I don't care, darling. Just don’t do it on my account. If it makes it easier for you — First Settler and all that — to 
look a little older, then do it.” 

“It does make it easier — when I deal with other people. And it’s no trouble; I know the routine so well I could 



do it in my sleep. But, Dora — listen to me, darling. Zack Briggs will call at Top Dollar sometime in the next ten 
years; you saw John’s letter. It’s not too rate to go to Secundus. There they can make you look like a young girl 
again if that’s what you want, and tack a good many extra years on, too. Fifty. Maybe a hundred.” 

She was slow in answering. “Lazarus, are you urging me to do this?” 

“I’m offering it. But it’s your body, most dear one. Your life." 

She stared out the window. “ ‘More than half of them,’ you said.” 

“With the percentage increasing. Our kids breed like cats. And so do their kids.” 

“Lazarus, truly we settled this many, many years ago. But it is even more so now. I don’t want to leave our 
valley even to visit the outside. I don’t want to leave our children. Nor our children’s children, nor their children. 
And I certainly would not want to come back looking like a young girl... to watch the births of our great-great- 
grandchildren. You’re right; I’ve earned my gray hairs. And now I’ll wear them!" 

“That’s the girl I married! That’s my durable Dora!” He moved his hand up higher, cupped a breast and tickled 
a nipple. She jumped, then relaxed to it. “I knew your answer, but I had to ask. My darling, age cannot wither you, 
nor custom stale your infinite variety. Where other women satiate, you most make hungry!” 

She smiled. “I’m not Cleopatra, Woodrow.” 

“Wench, that’s your opinion. But what’s your opinion against mine? Rangy Lil, I’ve seen thousands and 
thousands more women than you have — and / say that you make Cleopatra look homely.” 

“Blarney tongue,” she said softly. “I’m sure you’ve never had a woman turn you down.” 

“True only because I never risk being turned down; I wait to be asked. Always.” 

“Are you waiting to be asked? All right, I’m asking. Then I’d better start dinner.” 

“Don’t be in such a hurry, Lil. First I’m going to dump you on that bed. Then I’m going to flip your skirt up. Then 
I’m going to see if I can find any gray hair at that end. If so, I'll pluck them for you.” 

“Beast. Scoundrel. Lecherous old goat.” She smiled in delight. “I thought we weren’t going to bother any more 
with plucking gray hairs?” 

“We were speaking of hair on your head, Great-Grandmother. But this other end is as young as ever — and 
better than ever — so we’ll most carefully pluck any gray from your pretty — your pretty brown curls.” 

“Sweetest old goat. If you can find any, you’re welcome. But I’ve been plucking that end even more carefully 
than my scalp. Let me slip this dress off.” 

“Wups! Hold it. That’s Rangy Lil, the horniest bitch in Happy Valley, always in a hurry. Get your dress off if you 
wish, but I’m going to find Lurton and tell him to saddle up Best Boy and go beg supper and a shakedown from 
his sister Marje and Lyle. Then I’ll be back to pluck those disgraceful gray curls. Supper will be late, I’m afraid.” 

“I don't mind if you don't, beloved.” 

“That’s my Lil. Darling, there isn’t a man in the valley who wouldn’t grab you and try to find another valley if you 

gave him the slightest encouragement — that includes your own sons and your sons-in-law every male here 

down to fourteen." 

“Oh, not true! Blarney again.” 

“Want to bet? On second thought we won’t waste time plucking gray hairs at either end. When I get back from 
telling our youngest son to get lost for the night, I want to find you wearing just rubies and a smile. Because you’re 
not going to cook supper; we’re going to scrape up a cold picnic instead and take it and a blanket up on the roof 
and enjoy the sunset.” 

“Yes, sir. Oh, darling, I love you! E.F.? Or F.F.?” 

“I’ll leave that choice to Rangy Lil.” 

(Circa 39,000 words omitted) 

Lazarus opened the bedroom door very quietly, looked in, looked inquiringly at his daughter Elf — a strikingly 
beautiful middle-aged woman with flaming red curls shot slightly with gray. She said, “Come in, Papa; Mama’s 
awake." 

She stood up to leave, taking with her a supper tray. 

He glanced at it, subtracted in his mind what was still on it from what he had seen leave the kitchen on it — got 
a sum which was too near zero to please him. But he said nothing, simply went to the bedside, smiled down at 
his wife. Dora smiled back. He leaned over and kissed her, then sat down where Elf had been. “How is my 
darling?” 



“Just fine, Woodrow. Ginny — no, Elf. Elf brought me the tastiest supper. I enjoyed it so much. But I asked her 

to put my rubies on me before she fed me did you notice?’ 

“Of course I did, beautiful. When did Rangy Lil ever eat supper without her rubies?’’ 

She didn’t answer, her eyes closed. Lazarus kept quiet, watched her respiration, counted her heartbeats by 
watching a pulse in her neck. 

“Do you hear them, Lazarus?” Her eyes were open again. 

“Hear what, Dorable?” 

“The wild geese. They must be right, over the house.” 

“Oh. Nfes, certainly.” 

“They’re early this year.” That seemed to tire her; she closed her eyes again. He waited. 

“Sweetheart? Will you sing ‘Buck’s Song’?” 

“Certainly, ‘dorable Dora.” Lazarus cleared his throat and started in: 

‘“There’s a school house 

By the pawnshop 

Where Dora has her lessons, 

“By the school house 

There’s a mule yard 

Where Dora’s friend Buck lives. ” 

She closed her eyes again, so he sang the other verses very softly. But when he finished, she smiled at him. 
“Thank you, darling; that was lovely. It’s always been lovely. But I’m a little tired — if I drop off to sleep, will you still 
be here?” 

“I’ll always be here, dearest. You sleep now.” She smiled again, and her eyes closed. Presently her breathing 
grew slower as she slept. 

Her breathing stopped. 

Lazarus waited a long time before he called in Ginny and Elf. 



SECOND INTERMISSION 


More from the Notebooks of Lazarus Long 


Always tell her she is beautiful, especially if she is not. 

* 

If you are part of a society that votes, then do so. There maybe no candidates and no measures you want to 
vote for but there are certain to be ones you want to vote against. In case of doubt, vote against. By this rule you 
will rarely go wrong. 

If this is too blind for your taste, consult some well-meaning fool (there is always one around) and ask his 
advice. Then vote the other way. This enables you to be a good citizen (if such is your wish) without spending the 

enormous amount of time on it that truly intelligent exercise of franchise requires. 

* 

Sovereign ingredient for a happy marriage: Pay cash or do without. Interest charges not only eat up a 

household budget; awareness of debt eats up domestic felicity. 

* 

Those who refuse to support and defend a state have no claim to protection by that state. Killing an anarchist 
ora pacifist should not be defined as “murder” in a legalistic sense. The offense against the state, if any, should 
be “Using deadly weapons inside city limits,” or “Creating a traffic hazard,” or “Endangering bystanders,” or other 
misdemeanor. 

However, the state may reasonably place a closed seasons on these exotic asocial animals whenever they 
are in danger of becoming extinct. An authentic buck pacifist has rarely been seen off Earth, and it is doubtful 
that any have survived the trouble there... regrettable, as they had the biggest mouths and the smallest brains of 
any of the primates. 

The small-mouthed variety of anarchist has spread through the Galaxy at the very wave front of the Diaspora; 

there is no need to protect them. But they often shoot back. 

* 

Another ingredient for a happy marriage: Budget the luxuries first! 

* 

And still another — See to it that she has her own desk — then keep your hands off it! 

* 

And another — In a family argument, if it turns out you are right — apologize at once! 

* 

“God split himself into a myriad parts that he might have friends.” This may not be true, but it sounds good 

— and is no sillier than any other theology. 

* 

To stay young requires unceasing cultivation of the ability to unlearn old falsehoods. 

* 

Does history record any case in which the majority was right? 

* 

When the fox gnaws — smile! 

* 

A “critic” is a man who creates nothing and thereby feels qualified to judge the work of creative men. There is 

logic in this; he is unbiased — he hates all creative people equally. 

* 

Money is truthful. If a man speaks of his honor, make him pay cash. 

* 


Never frighten a little man. He’ll kill you. 



Only a sadistic scoundrel — or a fool — tells the bald truth on social occasions. 

* 

This sad little lizard told me that he was a brontosaurus on his mother’s side. I did not laugh; people who 
boast of ancestry often have little else to sustain them. Humoring them costs nothing and adds to happiness in a 

world in which happiness is always in short supply. 

* 

In handling a stinging insect, move very slowly, 

* 

To be “matter of fact” about the world is to blunder into fantasy — and dull fantasy at that, as the real world is 

strange and wonderful. 

* 

The difference between science and the fuzzy subjects is that science requires reasoning, while those other 

subjects merely require scholarship. 

* 

Copulation is spiritual in essence — or it is merely friendly exercise. On second thought, strike out “merely.” 
Copulation’ is not “merely” — even when it is just a happy pastime for two strangers. But copulation at its spiritual 
best is so much more than physical coupling that it is different in kind as well as in degree. 

The saddest feature of homosexuality is not that it is “wrong” or “sinful” or even that it can’t lead to progeny 
— but that it is more difficult to reach through it this spiritual union. Not impossible — but the cards are stacked 
against it. 

But — most sorrowfully — many people never achieve spiritual sharing even with the help of male-female 

advantage; they are condemned to wander through life alone. 

* 

Touch is the most fundamental sense. A baby experiences it, all over, before he is born and long before he 
learns to use sight, hearing, or taste, and no human ever eases to need it. Keep your children short on pocket 

money — but long on hugs. 

* 

Secrecy is the beginning of tyranny. 

* 

The greatest productive force is human selfishness. 


Be wary of strong drink. It can make you shoot at tax collectors — and miss. 

* 

The profession of shaman has many advantages. It offers high status with a safe livelihood free of work in the 
dreary, sweaty sense. In most societies it offers legal privileges and immunities not granted to other men. But it 
is hard to see how a man who has been given a mandate from on High to spread tidings of joy to all mankind 
can be seriously interested in taking up a collection to pay his salary; it causes one to suspect that the shaman is 
on the moral level of any other con man. 

But it’s lovely work if you can stomach it. 

* 

A whore should be judged by the same criteria as other professionals offering services for pay — such as 
dentists, lawyers, hairdressers, physicians, plumbers, etc. Is she professionally competent? Does she give good 
measure? Is she honest with her clients? 

It is possible that the percentage of honest and competent whores is higher than that of plumbers and much 

higher than that of lawyers. And enormously higher than that of professors. 

* 

Minimize your therbligs until it becomes automatic; this doubles your effective lifetime — and thereby gives 

time to enjoy butterflies and kittens and rainbows. 

* 

Have you noticed how much they look like orchids? Lovely! 

* 


Expertise in one field does not carry over into other fields. But experts often think so. The narrower their field 



of knowledge the more likely they are to think so. 

* 

Never try to outstubborn a cat. 

* 

Tilting at windmills hurts you more than the windmills. 

* 

Yield to temptation; it may not pass your way again. 

* 

Waking a person unnecessarily should not be considered a capital crime. For a first offense, that is. 

* 

“Go to hell!” or other insult direct is all the answer, a snoopy question rates. 

* 

The correct way to punctuate a sentence that starts: “Of course it is none of my business but — ” is to place a 
period after the word “but.” Don’t use excessive force in supplying such moron with a period. Cutting his throat is 

only a momentary pleasure and is bound to get you talked about. 

* 

A man does not insist on physical beauty in a woman who builds up his morale. After a while he realizes that 

she is beautiful — he just hadn’t noticed it at first. 

* 

A skunk is better company than a person who prides himself on being “frank.” 

* 

“All’s fair in love and war” — what a contemptible lie! 

* 

Beware of the “Black Swan” fallacy. Deductive logic is tautological; there is no way to get a new truth out of it, 
and it manipulates false statements as readily as true ones. If you fail to remember this, it cantrip you — with 
perfect logic. The designers of the earliest computers, called this the “Gigo Law,” i.e., “Garbage in, garbage out.” 
Inductive logic is much more difficult — but can produce new truths. 

* 

A “practical joker” deserves applause for his wit according to its quality. Bastinado is about right. For 
exceptional wit one might grant keelhauling. But staking him out on an anthill should be reserved for the very 

wittiest. 

* 

Natural laws have no pity. 

* 

On the planet Tranquille around KM849 (G-O) lives a little animal known as a “knafn.” It is herbivorous and 
has no natural enemies and is easily approached and may-be petted — sort of a six-legged puppy with scales. 
Stroking it is very pleasant; it wiggles its pleasure and broadcasts euphoria in some band that humans can 
detect. It’s worth the trip. 

Someday some bright boy will figure out howto record this broadcast, then some smart boy will see 
commercial angles — and not long after that it will be regulated and taxed. 

In the meantime I have faked that name and catalog number; it is several thousand light-years off in another 

direction. Selfish of me — 

* 

Freedom begins when you tell Mrs. Grundy to go fly a kite., 

* 

Take care of the cojones and the frijoles will take care of themselves. Try to have getaway money — but don’t 

be fanatic about it. 

* 

If “everybody knows” such-and-such, then it ain’t so, by at least ten thousand to one. 

* 

Political tags — such as royalist, communist, democrat, populist, fascist, liberal, conservative, and so forth 
— are never basic criteria. The human race divides politically into those who want people to be controlled and 
those who have no such desire. The former are idealists acting from highest motives for the greatest good of the 



greatest number. The latter are surly curmudgeons, suspicious and lacking in altruism. But they are more 

comfortable neighbors than the other sort. 

* 

All cats are not gray after midnight. Endless variety — 

* 

Sin lies only in hurting other people unnecessarily. All other “sins” are invented nonsense. (Hurting yourself is 

not sinful — just stupid.) 

* 

Being generous is inborn; being altruistic is a learned perversity. No resemblance — 

* 

It is impossible for a man to love his wife wholeheartedly without loving all women somewhat. I suppose that 

the converse must be true of women. 

* 

You can go wrong by being too skeptical as readily as by being too trusting. 

* 

Formal courtesy between husband and wife is even more important than it is between strangers. 

* 

Anything free is worth what you pay for it. 

* 

Don’t store garlic near other victuals. 

* 

Climate is what we expect, weather is what we get. 

* 

Pessimist by policy, optimist by temperament — it is possible to be both. How? By never taking an 
unnecessary chance and by minimizing risks you can’t avoid. This permits you to play out the game happily, 

untroubled by the certainty of the outcome. 

* 

Do not confuse “duty” with what other people expect of you; they are utterly different. Duty is a debt you owe 
to yourself to fulfill obligations you have assumed voluntarily. Paying that debt can entail anything from years of 
patient work to instant willingness to die. Difficult it may be, but the reward is self-respect. 

But there is no reward at all for doing’ what other people expect of you, and to do so is not merely difficult, but 
impossible. It is easier to deal with a footpad than it is with the leech who Wants “just a few minutes of your time, 
please — this won’ttake long.” Time is your total capital, and the minutes of your life are painfully few. If you allow 
yourself to fall into the vice of agreeing to such requests, they quickly snowball to the point where these parasites 
will use up 100 percent of your time — and squawk for more! 

So learn to say No — and to be rude about it when necessary. Otherwise you will not have time to carry out 
your duty, or to do your own work, and certainly no time for love and happiness. The termites will nibble away 
your life and leave none of it for you. 

(This rule does not mean that you must not do a favor for a friend, or even a stranger. But let the choice be 

yours. Don’t do it because it is “expected” of you.) 

* 

“I came, I saw, she conquered.” (The original Latin seems to have been garbled.) 

* 

A committee is a life form with six or more legs and no brain. 

* 

Animals can be driven crazy by placing too many in too small a pen. Homo sapiens is the only animal that 

voluntarily does this to himself. 

* 

Don’t try to have the last word. \t>u might get it. 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
XIII 


Boondock 


“Ira,” said Lazarus Long, “have you looked at this list?” He was lounging in the office of Colony Leader Ira 
Weatheral at Boondock, largest (only) settlement on the planet Tertius. With them was Justin Foote 45th, freshly 
arrived from New Rome, Secundus. 

“Lazarus, Arabelle addressed that letter to you. Not to me.” 

“That preposterous puff-gut will get me annoyed yet. Her Extreme Ubiquity Madam Chairman Pro Tern 
Arabelle Foote-Hedrick seems to think she has been crowned Queen of the Howards. I’m tempted to go back 
and pick up that gavel.” 

Lazarus passed the list to Weatheral. “Give it a gander, Ira. Justin, did you have anything to do with this?” 

“No, Senior. Arabelle told me to deliver it and instructed me to brief you in ways to insure delivery of Delay Mail 
from various eras — which does present problems for pre-Diaspora dates. But I don’t consider her ideas 
practical. If I may say so, I know more Terran history than she does." 

“I’m certain you do. I think she cribbed that list from an encyclopedia. Don’t bother me with her notions. Oh, 
you can transcribe them and give me the cube, but I shan't play it. I want your ideas. Justin.” 

“Thank you, Ancestor — ” 

“Call me ‘Lazarus.’” 

“‘Lazarus.’ The official reason for my visit is to report to her on this colony — ” 

“Justin,” Ira put in quickly, “does Arabelle think she has jurisdiction over Tertius?” 

“I’m afraid so, Ira." 

Lazarus snorted. “Well, she hasn’t. But she’s so far away it can't hurt if she wants to call herself ‘Empress of 
Tertius.’ Our situation is this, Justin. Ira is Colony Leader, we are still shaking down. I’m Mayor — Ira does the 
work, but I bang the gavel at community meetings — there are always colonists who think that a colony can 
operate like a big-city planet, so I preside to throw cold water on damfoolishness. When I’m ready to start this 
time-travel junket, we’ll eliminate the job of Colony Leader and Ira will take over as Mayor. 

“But feel free to look over the joint, count noses, examine any records, do as you like. Welcome to Tertius, the 
biggesi little colony this side of Galactic Center. Make yourself at home, son.” 

“Thank you. Lazarus, I would be staying — colonizing — but I want to remain Chief Archivist until I finish editing 
your memoirs.” 

Lazarus said, “Oh, that junk — burn it up! Gather ye rosebuds, man!" 

Ira said, “Lazarus, don’t talk that way. I put up with your whims for years to get it on record.” 

“Piffle. I paid you back when I grabbed the gavel and kept the Ugly Duchess from banishing you to Felicity. 
\bu got what you want — why do you care about my memoirs?” 

“I care.” 

“Well — Maybe Justin can edit them here. Athene! Pallas Athene, are you there, honey?” 

“Listening, Lazarus,” came a sweet soprano voice from a speaker over Ira’s desk. 

“>bur memories include my memoirs, do they not?” 

“Certainly, Lazarus. Every word you’ve spoken since Ira rescued you — ” 

“Not ‘rescued,’ dear. Kidnapped.” 

“Revision. — since Ira kidnapped you from that flophouse, and all your earlier memoirs.” 

“Thanks, dear. You see, Justin? If you must do buttonsorting, do it here. Unless you have unfinished business 
on Secundus? Family, or such?” 

“No family. Grown children but no wife. My deputy is doing my job, and I’ve nominated her as my successor — 
subject to approval by the Trustees. But I find myself startled. Uh— how about my ship?” 

“My ship, you mean. I don’t mean my yacht ‘Dora’ but that one-man autopacket you arrived in. The ‘Homing 



Pigeon.’ Belongs to a corporation owned by another corporation of which lam major stockholder. I'll accept 
delivery and that saves Arabelle half the lease time.” 

“So? Madam Chairman Pro Tern did not lease that auto-packet, Lazarus; she requisitioned it for public 
service.” 

“Well, well!” Lazarus grinned. “Maybe I’ll sue her. Justin, there is nothing in the Articles of Contract under 
which Secundus was colonized that permits requisition of private property by the state. Correct, Ira?” 

“Technically correct, Lazarus. Although there is long precedent for eminent domain in land.” 

“Ira, I’d argue even that. But have you ever heard of it being applied to spaceships?” 

“Never. Unless you count the ‘New Frontiers.’” 

“Ouch! Ira, I didn’t requisition the ‘New Frontiers’; I stole it to save our skins.” 

“I was thinking of Slayton Ford’s part in it, not yours. Constructive requisitioning, perhaps?” 

“Mmm — It’s pretty small of you to bring it up a couple of thousand years after his death. Furthermore, had 
Slayton not, done what he did, I wouldn’t be here and you wouldn’t be here. Nor any of us. Damn you, Ira.” 

“Get your feathers down, Grandfather. I was just pointing out that a head of state sometimes has to do things 
he would never do as a private individual. But if Arabelle can requisition the ‘Homing Pigeon’ when it sits on 
Secundus, then you can do the same on Tertius. \t>u are each head of state of an autonomous planet. Teach her 
a lesson.” 

“Uh.Jra, don’t tempt me. It happened to me once. If it got to be a habit, it would put a stop to interstellar 
travel. I won’t touch that bucket under any such flimsy legality. But I do own it, indirectly, and if Justin wants to stay, 
he can turn it over to me, and I'll return it to Transport Enterprises. Let’s get back to that list. See what the old bat 
wants? The times and places she wants me to report on?” 

“Looks like an interesting itinerary.” 

“It does, eh? Then you do it. ‘Battle of Hastings — First, Third, and Fourth Crusades — Battle of Orleans — Fall 
of Constantinople — French Revolution — Battle of Waterloo.’ Thermopylae and nineteen other encounters 
between rough strangers. I’m surprised she didn’t ask me to referee the bout between David and Goliath. I’m 
chicken, Ira. I fight when I can’t run — how does she think I managed to live so long? Bloodshed is not a spectator 
sport. If history says that a battle took place at a given location on a particular day, then I’ll be somewhere — or 
somewhen — far away, sitting in a tavern, drinking beer and pinching the barmaids. Not dodging mortar fire to 
feed Arabelle’s ghoulish curiosity.” 

“I tried to suggest that,” said Justin. “But she said that this was an official Families’ project.” 

“The hell it is. I told her about it simply to be sure of the Delay Mail setup. I’m a coward by trade... and not 
working for her. I’ll go where and when I please, see what I want to — and try not to antagonize local yokels. 
Especially those fighting each other; it makes 'em trigger-happy." 

“Lazarus,” said Ira Weatheral, “you never have said what you do plan to see.” 

“Well — No battles. Battles are well enough reported for my taste. But there are lots of interesting things in 
Terran history — peaceful things not well reported because they were peaceful. I want to see the Parthenon at the 
peak of its glory. Cruise down the Mississippi with Sam Clemens as pilot. Go to Palestine in the first three 
decades of the Christian Era and try to locate a certain carpenter turned rabbi — settle whether there ever was 
such a man.” 

Justin Foote looked surprised. “You mean the Christian Messiah? Admittedly many stories about him are 
myths, but — ” 

“How do you know they are myths? But that he ever lived is the point that has never been established. Take 
Socrates, four centuries earlier — his historicity is as firmly established as that of Napoleon. Not so with the 
Carpenter of Nazareth. Despite the care with which the Romans kept records and the equal care with which the 
Jews kept theirs, none of the events that should be on record can be found in contemporary records. 

“But if I devoted thirty years to it, I could find out. I know Latin and Greek of that time and I’m almost as 
conversant with classic Hebrew; all I would have to add is Aramaic. If I found him, I could follow him around. Take 
down his words with a microrecorder, see if they match what he is alleged to have said. 

“But I won’t take any bets. The historicity of Jesus is the slipperiest question in all history because for 
centuries the question couldn’t be raised. They would hang you for asking — or burn you at the stake.” 

“I’m amazed,” said Ira. “My knowledge of Earth’s history isn’t as thorough as I thought it was. However, I 
concentrated on the period from Ira Howard’s death to the founding of New Rome." 

“Son, you didn’t even sample it. But aside from this one weird story — ’weird’ because most major religious 



leaders are heavily documented whereas this one remains as elusive as the King Arthur legends — I’m not going 
after great events. I’d rather meet Galileo, get a look at Michelangelo at work, attend a first performance of one 
of old Bill’s plays at the Globe Theater, things like that. I’d particularly like to go back to my own childhood, see if 
things look as I recall them.” 

Ira blinked. “Run a chance of running into yourself?” 

“Why not?” 

“Well... there are paradoxes, are there not?’ 

“How? If I’m going to, then I did. That old cliche about shooting your grandfather before he sires your father, 
then going fuft! like a soap bubble — and all descendants, too, meaning both of you among others — is nonsense. 
The fact that I’m here and you’re here means that I didn't do it — or won’t do it; the tenses of grammar aren’t built 
for time travel — but it does not mean that I never went back and poked around. I haven’t any yen to look at 
myself when I was a snot-nose; it’s the era that interests me. If I ran across myself as a young kid, he — I 
— wouldn’t recognize me; I would be a stranger to that brat. He wouldn’t give me a passing glance; I know, I was 
he.” 

“Lazarus,” put in Justin Foote, “if you intend to visit that era, I’d like to invite your attention to one thing Madam 
Chairman Pro Tern is interested in — because / am interested. A recording of exactly what was said and done at 
the Families’ Meeting in 2012 A. D.” 

“Impossible." 

“Just a moment, Justin,” Ira put in. “Lazarus, you have refused to talk about that meeting on the grounds that 
the others who were there can’t dispute your version. But a recording would be fair to everyone.” 

“Ira, I didn’t say that I would not; I said it was impossible.” 

“I don't follow you.” 

“I can’t make a recording of that meeting because I was not there.” 

“\bu lost me again. All the records — and your own statements — show that you were there.” 

“Again we don’t have language adequate for time travel. Surely, I was there as Woodrow Wilson Smith. I was 
there and made a hairy nuisance of myself and offended a lot of people. But I did not have a recorder on me. 
Let’s saythat Dora and the twins drop me back there — me, Lazarus Long, not that younger fellow — and that 
Ishtar has equipped me with a recorder implanted behind my right kidney, with its minimike surfacing inside my 
right ear. Okay, let’s assume that with such equipment I won’t be noticed making a record. 

“But, Ira, what you don’t understand, despite having chaired many Families’ Meetings, is that I would not get 
inside the hall. In those days an executive meeting of the Families was harder to get into than an esbat of 
witches. The guards were armed and eager; it was a rough period. What identity could I use? Not Woodrow 
Wilson Smith; he was there. Lazarus Long? There was no ‘Lazarus Long’ on the Families’ rolls. Try to fake it as 
someone eligible but not able to attend? Impossible. There were only a few thousand of us then, and every 
member was known to a large percentage of the rest; a man who couldn’t be vouched for ran a nasty chance of 
being buried in the basement. No unidentified person ever did get in; we had too much at stake. Hi, Minerva! 
Come in, honey.” 

“Hi, Lazarus. Ira, am I intruding?” 

“Not at all, dear.” 

“Thank you. Hello, Athene.” 

“Hello, my sister.” 

Minerva waited to be introduced. Ira said, “Minerva, you remember Justin Foote, Chief Archivist.” 

“Certainly, I’ve worked with him many times. Welcome to Tertius, Mr. Foote.” 

“Thank you, Miss Minerva.” Justin Foote liked what he saw — a tall, slender young woman with an erect 
carriage, a small, firm bust, long chestnut hair worn in a part and brushed straight down, a sober, intelligent face, 
handsome rather than pretty, but which blossomed into beauty each time she gave one of her quick smiles. “But, 
Ira, I must hurry back to Secundus and apply for rejuvenation. This young lady has worked with me ‘many times’ 
— yet I’ve grown so senile I can’t place the occasions. Forgive me, dear lady.” 

Minerva flashed him another of her smiles, then instantly, was sober. “My fault, sir; I should have explained at 
once. When I worked with you, I was a computer. Executive computer of Secundus, serving Mr. Weatheral, then 
Chairman Pro Tern. But now I’m a flesh-and-blood, and have been for the past three years.” 

Justin Foote blinked. “I see. I hope I do.” 

“I am a proscribed construct, sir, not born of woman. A composite clone of twenty-three donor-parents, forced 



to maturity in vitro. But the T that is me, my ego, was the computer who used to work with you when the Archives 
computers needed assistance from the executive computer. Have I made it clear?” 

“Uh. . .all I can say, Miss Minerva, is that I am delighted to meet you in the flesh. Your servant, Miss.” 

“Oh, don’t call me ‘Miss,’ call me ‘Minerva.’ I shouldn't be called ‘Miss’ anyhow; isn’t that honorific reserved 
for virgins among flesh-and-bloods? Ishtar — one of my mothers and my chief designer — deflowered me 
surgically before she woke me.” 

“And that ain’t all!” came the voice from the ceiling. 

“Athene,” Minerva said reprovingly. “Sister, you’re embarrassing our guest.” 

“I’m not, but maybe you are, sister mine.” 

“Am I, Mr. Foote? I hope not. But I’m still learning to be a human being. Will you kiss me? I’d like to kiss you; 
we’ve known each other almost a century and I've always liked you. Will you?” 

“Now who’s embarrassing him, sister?’ 

“Minerva,” said Ira. 

She suddenly sobered. “I shouldn’t have said that?” 

Lazarus cut in. “Pay no attention to Ira, Justin; he’s an old stick-in-the-mud. Minerva is a ‘kissin cousin’ to 
most of the colony; she’s making up for lost time. Furthermore, she /ssome sort of cousin to practically all of us 
through her twenty-three parents. And she’s learned how — kissing her is a treat. Athene, let your sis be while she 
adds on another kissing cousin.” 

“\fes, Lazarus. Of Buddy Boy!” 

“Teena, if I could reach through that string of wires, I’d spank you.” Lazarus added, “Go ahead, Justin.” 

“Uh... Minerva, I haven’t kissed a girl in many years. Out of practice.” 

“Mr. Foote, I do not mean to embarrass you. I am simply delighted to see you again. You need not kiss me. Or 
if you are willing to kiss me in private, you are most welcome.” 

“Don’t risk it, Justin,” advised the computer. “I’m your friend.” 

“Athene!” 

“I was about to add,” said the Chief Archivist, “that I probably need practice in ‘learning to be a human being’ 
more than you do. If you’ll put up with my rusti ness, Cousin, I accept your sweet offer. Brace yourself.” 

Minerva smiled quickly, went into his arms, flowed up against him like a cat, closed her eyes, and opened her 
mouth. Ira studied a paper on his desk. Lazarus did not even pretend not to watch. He noted that Justin Foote 
put his heart into the matter — the old buzzard might be out of practice, but he hadn't forgotten the basics. 

When they broke, the computer gave a respectful whistle. “Wheeee. . .00000! Justin, welcome to the Club.” 

“Yes,” Ira said dryly, “a person can’t be said to be officially on Tertius until he or she has been welcomed with 
a kiss from Minerva. Now that protocol is satisfied, sit down. Minerva, my dear, you came for some purpose?” 

“Yes, sir.” She settled down by Justin Foote on a couch facing Ira and Lazarus — took Justin's hand. “I was in 
the ‘Dora’ with the twins, and Dora was drilling them in astrogation, when the packet showed up in our sky and — 

“Hold it,” Lazarus interrupted. “Did the brats track it?” 

“Certainly, Lazarus. A live exercise? — Dora would never miss such a chance. She split herself instantly and 
made each of them track it independently. But once the autopacket grounded I asked Dora to ask Athene who 
was in it — and as soon as the pod opened, my sisters told me, Justin” — she squeezed his hand — "and I hurried 
to greet you. And to offer some arrangements. Ira, has Justin been provided for? A place to sleep, things like 
that?” 

“Not yet, my dear. We were just starting to talk — he’s barely had time to shake off the anesthetic.” 

Foote remarked, “I think the antidote has taken hold.” 

The computer added, “Cousin Justin just had a second dose, Ira. Pulse fast but steady.” 

“That’s enough, Athene. Were you going to suggest something, my dear?” 

“Yes. I swung past the house and spoke with Ishtar. We are in agreement. Subject to approval of you and 
Lazarus.” 

“\bu mean we get a vote?” Lazarus put in. “Justin, this planet is run by its women.” 

“Isn’t that true everywhere?” 

“No, just most of them. I remember a place where a wedding ceremony always concluded by killing the 
bride’s mother if she hadn’t been used up earlier. I thought that was overdoing it, but it did tend to — ” 

“Stow it, Grandpappy,” Ira said mildly. “Justin would have to edit it out. Justin, what Minerva has been saying 
is that our house is vours. Lazarus?” 



“Certainly. It’s a madhouse, Justin, but the cooking is okay, and the price is right. Free, that is. It’s just your 
nerves that pay. 

“Really, I have no intention of imposing. Isn’t there someone who can rent me a room? Not for money — I 
assume that Secundus money is not negotiable here — but for artifacts I’ve fetched, things you don’t make as yet. 

Lazarus answered, “You can negotiate Secundus money through me if you need to. As for artifacts, you may 
be surprised at what we are making.” 

“I might not be; I know that a universal pantograph was moved here. So I fetched new creative items, mostly 
entertainments — solly cubes and such. Musicalarkies, pornies, dreams, other sorts — all published since you 
folks left Secundus." 

“Well planned.” Lazarus added, “I think colonizing was more fun back when pioneers had no choice but to 
step in and slug it out and you weren’t sure who was going to win, you or the planet. The way we do it now is like 
swatting an insect with a sledgehammer. Justin, your creepies will fetch a high price — but sell them in dribbles 
...because each one will be copied as soon as you turn it loose. No copyright, there’s no way to enforce it. But it 
still won’t rent you a room; we’re at the staying-with-kinfolk stage. You’d best accept our offer; it rains ‘most every 
night this time o’ year.” 

Justin Foote looked baffled. “I have misgivings about invading your privacy. Ira, could I borrow this couch I’m 
sitting on? For a short time? Then — ” 

“Stow it, Justin.” Lazarus stood up. “Son, you’re suffering from big-city attitudes. Ntiu’re welcome for a week 
or a century. \bu’re not only my lineal descendant — through Janet Foote, I think — but you’re a kissin’ cousin of 
Minerva’s. Let’s take him home, Minerva. What did you do with my hellions?" 

“They’re outside.” 

“Trust you staked 'em down.” 

“No, but they were somewhat miffed.” 

“Good for their metabolism. Ira, declare a holiday.” 

“I will — as soon as I’ve gone over the ore converter plans with Athene.” 

“Meaning you’re going to find out from her what’s she’s decided.” 

“\bu can say that again!” said the computer. 

“Teena,” Lazarus said mildly, “you’ve been associating with Dora too much. When Minerva had your job, she 
was sweet, gentle, respectful, and humble.” 

“Any complaints about my work, Grandpappy?” 

“Just your manners, dear. In the presence of a guest.” 

“Justin isn’t a guest; he’s family. He’s my sister’s kissing cousin, so he’s mine, too. Logical? Q.E.D.” 

“I disdain to argue. Watch out for Teena, Justin; she’ll trap you. 

“I find Athene’s reasoning not only logical but warmly pleasing. Thank you, my kissing cousin.” 

“I like you, Justin; you were sweet to my sister. Don’t worry about me trapping you; I don't plan to accept a 
clone for at least a hundred years — first I’ve got to get this planet organized. So don't wait up; you’ll see me in 
about a century. \bu’ll recognize me; I'll look exactly like Minerva." 

“But noisier.” 

“Lazarus, you say the sweetest things. Kiss him for me, twin sister.” 

“Let’s go, Minerva; Teena’s got me mixed up again.” 

“Just a moment, Lazarus, please. Ira? I made other arrangements through Ishtar but only tentatively. . .not 
being sure of Justin’s wishes.” 

“Oh. I don’t know them either. Do you want me to ask him?” 

“Uh...yes.” 

“On your behalf?” 

Minerva looked startled. Justin Foote looked puzzled. Athene said, “Let’s cut through the fog. Justin, Minerva 
was asking Ira whether or not you want her to find you a guest wife. Ira says he doesn’t know but will find out 
— then asked her if she was volunteering for the privilege. All clear? Justin, my sister is so new at being a flesh- 
and-blood that she sometimes isn’t sure of herself.” 

Lazarus reflected that he had not seen a girl blush — for that reason — for three centuries or more. Nor did the 
two men look at ease. He said reprovingly, “Teena, you are an excellent engineer... and a lousy diplomat.” 

“What? Oh, nonsense. I saved them billions of nanoseconds.” 



“Shut up, dear; your circuits are scrambled. Justin, Minerva is almost certainly the only girl on this planet who 
could be fussed byTeena’s unhelpful help... because she is probably the only one who shows any tendency to 
stick to one man.” 

The computer giggled. 

“I told you to keep still,” Lazarus said sternly. 

Ira said quietly, “Minerva is a free agent, Lazarus.” 

“Who said she wasn’t? And you keep quiet, too, until the Senior — that’s me, son — finishes speaking. Justin, 
Minerva will find you a dinner partner — has found one, I think. After that you are on your own. If you and your 
dinner partner don’t hit it off, no doubt you’ll be able to work out something else. Teena, I’m going to switch you 
off at the house tonight; I am uninviting you to dinner. Nt>u haven’t learned how to behave in company.” 

“Aw, Lazarus, I didn’t mean to steal your pig.” 

“Well — ” Lazarus looked around. Ira’s face was impassive, Minerva looked unhappy. Justin Foote spoke up: 
“Senior, I’m sure Athene did not mean any harm. I do appreciate her declaring me her ‘kissing cousm’; I 
found it warmly friendly. I hope you will reconsider and let her join us at dinner.” 

“Very well, Teena; Justin has intervened for you. But between you and Dora and the twins I am beginning to 
need a gnarooth to ride herd on you kids. Justin. Minerva. Let’s go. Ira, Teena — .see you at the house. Don’t 
waste time on that converter, Ira; Teena did a perfect job." 

Outside the colonial headquarters Justin Foote found a null-boat waiting — not the one that had fetched him 
from the sky-field; this one had a pair of redheaded twins in it. . . uh, girls, although they looked as if they had just 
recently made up their minds. Twelve, perhaps thirteen. Both were wearing gun belts on skinny hips, with what 
(he hoped) were toy guns. One was wearing captain’s insignia on bare shoulders. Each wore eleven thousand, 
three hundred, and two freckles as near as he could estimate. 

Both jumped out of the boat, waited. One set offreckles said, “About time.” The other said, “Discrimination.” 
Lazarus said, “Pipe down and be polite. Justin, these are my twin daughters — Lapis Lazuli, and that one’s 
Lorelei Lee. Mr. Justin Foote, dears, Chief Archivist for the Trustees.” 

The girls glanced at each other, then curtsied deeply in perfect unison. “Welcome to Tertius, Chief Archivist 
Foote!” they said in chorus. 

“Charming!” 

“Yes, girls, that was nice. Who taught you?” 

“Mama Hamadryad taught us — ” 

“ — and Mania Ishtar said this would be a good time to do it.” 

“But I’m Lori; she’s Lazi.” 

“>bu’re both lazy,” said Lazarus. 

“I’m Captain Lapis Lazuli Long, commanding Starship ‘Dora’ and she’s my crew. Even-numbered day.” 

“Till tomorrow. Odd-numbered day.” 

“Lazarus can’t tell us apart — ” 

“ — and he’s not our father; we never had one." 

“He’s our brother, no real authority — ” 

“ — he just dominates us by brute strength — ” 

“ — but someday that will change.” 

“Into the boat, you mutinous hellions,” Lazarus said cheerfully, “before I bust you back to apprentice 
spacemen.” 

They jumped into the boat, sat forward, facing aft. 

“Threats — ” 

“ — with abusive language — ” 

“ — and without due process.” 

Lazarus did not seem to hear them. He and Justin handed Minerva into the boat, seated her aft and facing 
forward; they took seats cornering her. “Captain Lazuli.” 

“\fes, sir?” 

“Will you please tell the boat to take us home?” 

“Aye aye, sir. Humpty Dumpty — home!” 

The little craft started up, hit a steady ten knots, waddling to changing contours of the ground. Lazarus said, 



“And now, Captain, having confused our guest, please straighten him out.” 

“Yes, sir. We’re not twins, we don’t even have the same mother — ■” 

“ — and 01’ Buddy Boy is not our father; he’s our brother.” 

“Even-numbered day!” 

“Then make it march.” 

“Correction,” said Lazarus. “I’m your father because I adopted you, with written consent of your mothers.” 
“Irrelevant — ” 

“ — and illegal; it was not with our consent — ” 

“ — and immaterial in any case, as we three, Lazarus, Lorelei arid I, are identical triplets and therefore enjoy 
the same rights under any rational jurisdiction... which unfortunately this is not. So he beats us. Illegally and 
brutally.” 

“Captain, remind me to get a bigger club." 

“Aye aye, sir. But we’re fond of Buddy Boy anyhow despite his masochosadistic behavior. Because he’s 
really us. You see?” 

“Miss — Captain, I mean — I’m not sure I do. I think I slid through a space warp on the way here and failed to 
come out.” 

The even-numbered-day captain shook her head. “Sorry, sir, but that’s not possible. I must ask you to take my 
word for it... unless you can handle imperial numbers and Libby field-physics. Can you?” 

“No. Can you?” 

“Oh, certainly — ” 

“ — we’re geniuses.” 

“Quit trying to snow him, kids, and belay that order. I’ll explain it myself.” 

7 wish you would, Lazarus. I wasn’t aware that you had any minor children. Or sisters, which I find even more 
confusing. Are they registered? While I can’t see everything that goes into the files, for many years there has 
been an automatic relay to my attention on anything concerning the Senior.” 

“Which / knew and that’s why you didn’t see it. Registered, yes, but by their mothers’ names — host-mothers, 
actually, but not so reported. But I left a Delay-Mail sealed registration of the actual genealogy involved, to be 
opened by you or your successor on my death or in year 2070 of the Diaspora, whichever comes first, to insure 
that they will receive certain knickknacks, such as my second-best bed — ” 

“And the ‘Dora!” 

“Pipe down. Keep butting in and your sister gets the ‘Dora’ and you won’t be captain even on alternate days. 

I picked that date, Justin, because I expect them to be adults by then; they really are geniuses. I will not attempt 
time travel until then, as they are captain and crew of my yacht — only while ground-side now but in space by then. 
As to how they are my sisters — and they are — an illegal — proscribed, rather, by Secundus Clinic — a clandestine 
surgical procedure was used to clone them from me. Somewhat like Minerva’s case, but simpler.” 

“Much simpler,” agreed Minerva. “I operated for me, when I was still a computer — and failed seventeen times 
before I achieved a perfect clone. I couldn’t do it now, although Athene would be able to. But our girls were 
cloned by a flesh-and-blood surgeon — replication of the X chromosome was all that was necessary — and did it 
in both cases in one try; Lazand Lor were born the same day.” 

“Mmm — Yes, I think that Madam Director Doctor Hildegarde would take a sour view of such things. With no 
reflections on the lady’s professional competence — high, I assume — I find her a bit, uh, conservative.” 
“Murderess.” 

“Primitive totalitarian.” 

“Three times over — ’’ 

“ — for what right has she to say that we can’t exist — ” 

“ — or Minerva. Crypto-criminal mind!” 

“That’s enough, girls; you’ve made your point, you don’t like her.” 

“She would have murdered you, too, 01’ Buddy Boy.” 

“Lori, I said that was enough. Stipulated that, if Nelly Hildegarde’s policies had been carried out, I wouldn’t be 
here, you wouldn’t be here, Laz wouldn’t be here, nor would Minerva. But she’s not a, ‘murderess,’ as all four of 
us are here.” 

“And I am delighted,”. Justin Foote commented. “To have three charming young ladies added to our Families 
through breaking rules proves something I have long suspected: Rules serve best when broken.” 



“A wise man — ” 

“ — and with dimples, too. Mr. Foote, would you like to marry me and my sister?” 

“Say ‘Yes’! She can cook, but I’m cuddly.” 

Minerva said, “Stop it, girls.” 

“Why? Have you got him staked out already? Was that why we couldn’t come in? Mr. Foote, Minerva is 
Mama Pro Tern to us by edict — ” 

“ — which is patently unfair — ” 

“ — as she is actually years and years younger than we are — ” 

“ — and it gives us three mothers to dodge instead of the regulation one.” 

“Belay that,” Lazarus ordered. “Both of you can cook, but neither of you is very cuddly.” 

“Then why do you cuddle us, Buddy Boy?” 

“ — suppressed incestuous yearning perhaps?” 

“Merde. Because you both are immature, insecure, and frightened." 

The redheads looked at each other. “Lori?” 

“I heard it. Unless I’m hallucinating.” 

“No, I heard it, ‘too.” 

“Is it time to cry?” 

“We’d better save it. Mr. Foote wouldn’t want to see how our Buddy Boy goes all to pieces when we cry.” 
“We’ll save it. That makes two cries and a chin quivering he’s got coming. Unless Mr. Foote would like to see 
it.” 

“Would you, Mr. Foote?” 

“Justin, I’ll sell either one of them cheap. Still better price on a package deal.” 

“Uh... thank you, Lazarus, but I’m afraid that they might cry at me — then / would go all to pieces. Can we 
change the subject? How did you manage to put over this triple, uh, irregularity? May one ask? Doctor 
Hildegarde runs a very taut organization.” 

“Well, in the case of those two little angels over there — ” 

“Sarcasm now — ” 

“ — and not clever.” 

“ — I was flummoxed quite as much as Nelly Hildegarde. At the time, Ishtar Hardy, that one’s mother — ” 

“No, her mother.” 

“>bu two are interchangeable parts, and besides, you were mixed up the week you were born, and nobody 
knows which you are; you don’t know yourself.” 

“Oh, yes, I do! Sometimes she goes away, but I’m always right here.” 

Lazarus paused in midflight, looked thoughtful. “That may be the most succinct statement of the solipsist 
thesis I’ve ever heard. Write it down.” 

“If I did, you’d take credit for it.” 

“I simply want to save it for posterity... a notion incompatible with the thesis itself. Minerva, you preserve it for 
me.” 

“Recorded, Lazarus.” 

“Minerva has almost as exact a memory as she had when she was a computer. I was saying: Ishtar was 
temporarily Clinic boss, Nelly having gone on leave, so access to my tissue was no problem. I was then in a 
state of acute anhedonia, and their mothers cooked up this notion for restoring my interest in life. The only 
problem was to do gene surgery not permitted by the rules of Secundus Clinic. How and who — I was told firmly 
not to inquire. \bu can ask Minerva; she was in on the swindle." 

“Lazarus, that was a memory I did not bring along when I was selecting what to fit into this skull.” 

“>bu see, Justin? I’m allowed to know only what they think is good for me. As may be, this heroic treatment 
worked; I have not been bored since. Other descriptives might apply — but not that one.” 

“Lori, do you sense a double entendre?” 

“No, merely a thinly veiled innuendo. Ignore it with dignity.” 

“But at first / didn't know my odd relationship to this pair. Oh, I couldn’t help knowing that Ishtar, and 
Hamadryad — one of Ira’s daughters; you’ve met her?” 

“Years back. A lovely girl.” 

“Quite. Both of their mothers are lovely. I couldn’t help knowing that both were pregnant; they were spending 



most of their time with me. But although they were swelling up like poisoned pups, they ignored it, so I didn’t 
inquire.” 

Justine nodded. “Privacy.” 

“Naw, just hard-nosed. I’ve never let the privacy custom keep me from snooping when it suited me. I was 
miffed, that’s all. Here two girls are with me every day and like daughters to me and obviously as knocked up as 
Pharaoh’s Daughter — and they tell me nit. So I got stubborn and outsat them. Till one day Galahad — he’s their 
husband — well, not exactly; you’ll see — Galahad invites me downstairs, and here they have, one each, the two 
prettiest little redheads I ever saw.” 

“Shall we let him off one cry?” 

“\bu got over it; you both look like me now.” 

“Or do we add a third cry for that?” 

“I still don’t smell a mouse; I’m simply pleased. As well as amazed that they had produced babies that looked 
like identical twins — ” 

“Which we are, except that we’re triplets.” 

“But some weeks of playing with these babies causes my natural genius and suspicious mind to infer that the 
girls have pulled a whizzer. I was not then in the sperm bank so far as I knew, but I am well aware of tricks that 
can be played on a helpless client undergoing antigeria, so with unerring logic I reach the wrong answer: These 
babies are my daughters by artificial insemination unmentioned to me. So I accuse them’ of it. And they deny it. 
And I explain that I am not angry, but quite the contrary I hope these little cherubs are mine.” 

“‘Cherubs.’” 

“Ignore it. He’s simply trying to con Mr. Foote.” 

“Cherubs at that time, I mean, aside from a tendency to bite. That I want them to be mine and share my name, 
and fortunes. So they confer with their fellow conspirators — Minerva and Galahad — Minerva was in it up to her 
overload safeties.” 

“Lazarus, you needed a family.” 

“Quite right, dear. I’m always better off with a family; it keeps me harmlessly occupied and unbored. Justin, 
did I mention that Minerva allowed me to adopt her?” 

“We weren’t asked!” 

“Look, kids, under the loose rules of this termite bill I can unadopt you this minute, if such be your wish. Cut 
the tie. Be just your genetic brother through circumstances I had no more part in than you had. Renounce all 
authority over you two. Let me know.” 

The two girls looked at each other briefly. Then one said, “Lazarus — ” 

“Yes, Lorelei?" 

“Lapis Lazuli and I have discussed it, and we both think that you are just exactly the father we want.” 

“Thank you, my dears.” 

“And to confirm it, we are canceling two cries and a chin quiver.” 

“That’s most pleasing.” 

“And besides that, we want to be cuddled... because we are feeling very immature, insecure, and 
frightened — ” 

Lazarus blinked. “I don’t want you to feel that way, ever. But — Well, can the cuddling wait?” 

“Oh, certainly — Father. We know we have a guest. But perhaps you and Mr. Foote would join us in bathing? 
Before dinner?" 

“Well, Justin? Bathing with my hellions is squirmy but fun. I don’t do it often because they turn it into a social 
event and waste time. Suit yourself; don’t let your arm be twisted.” 

“A bath I certainly need. I was clean when I was sealed into that pod — but how long was I in it? I really don’t 
know. And a bath should always be a social event if there is time and good company. Thank you ladies; I accept.” 

“And I accept, too,” put in Minerva. “I’m inviting myself. Justin, Tertius is primitive compared with Secundus, 
but our family refresher is nice and quite large enough for sociability. ‘Decadent,’ as Lazarus calls it.” 

“I designed it to be decadent, Justin. Good plumbing is the finest flower of decadence and one I have always 
enjoyed when I could get it.” 

“Uh — my clothes are still in Ira’s office. Even my toiletries. Absentminded, I’m sorry.” 

“No matter. Ira may fetch your bag, but he’s absentminded, too. Depilatories, deodorants, scents — no 
problem. I'll lend you a toga or something.” 



“Buddy Boy! I mean ‘Father.’ Does that mean we dress for dinner?” 

“Call me Buddy Boy; I’m hardened to it. Go as far as you like, darlings... except that as usual Mama 
Hamadryad must okay any cosmetics. Back to how I acquired these daughters who are my sisters, Justin: 

Having conferred, this gang of genetic pirates came clean and threw themselves on the mercy of the court. Me. 
So I adopted these two, and we registered them, and the registration will be straightened out one day, as I 
explained. How Minerva gave up the profession of computer and assumed the sorrows that flesh is heir to is a 
longer story. Want to synopsize it, dear? — and fill him in later if you wish.” 

“Yes, Father.” 

“None of your lip, dear; you’re a grown woman now. Justin, when we woke this darling, she was about the 
size and biological age of those two reformed hellions — remind me to take their temperatures, Minerva. I 
adopted Minerva because she needed a father then. Doesn’t now.” 

“Lazarus, I will always need you as my father.” 

“Thank you, my dear, but I take that only as a pleasing compliment. Tell Justin your story.” 

“All right. Justin, are you familiar with the theories concerning self-awareness in computers?” 

“Several of them. As you know, my work is mostly with computers.” 

“Permit me to say, speaking from experience, all theories are empty. How a computer becomes self-aware 
remains as much a mystery, even to computers, as the age-old mystery of flesh-and-blood self-awareness. It just 
is. But, so far as I’ve heard — quite far in view of the library that was locked in my memories then and is still in 
Athene’s memories — self-awareness never arises in a computer designed only for deductive logic and 
mathematical calculations, no matter how big it is. 

But if it is designed for inductive logic, able to assess data, draw hypotheses therefrom, test them, reconstruct 
them to fit new data, make random comparisons of the results, and change those reconstructions — exercise 
judgment the way a flesh-and-blood does, then self-awareness may occur. But I don’t know why and no computer 
knows. It just does.” 

She smiled. “Sorry, I did not mean to sound pedantic. Lazarus figured out that I could go into a blank human 
‘brain, a clone brain, using techniques used to conserve memories in rejuvenation clinics. When we discussed 
this, I had the entire technical library of Secundus' Howard Clinic in me — stolen, in a way. I no longer have it; I had 
to pick and choose what to take along when I went into this skull. So I don’t remember much of what I did, any 
more than a rejuvenation client knows all that is done to-him; you would have to get details from Athene, who still 
has them — and who, by’ the way, never had the rather painful awakening that a computer goes through when it 
first begins to know itself, because I left a piece of me in Athene, oh, like a yeast starter. Athene dimly 
remembers having been Minerva atone time — about the way we flesh-and-bloods” — Minerva straigntened up, 
smiled, and looked proud — "remember a dream as something not quite real. And I remember being Minerva the 
Computer some — what the same way. I remember all my contacts with people very sharply — because I chose to 
keep them, replicate them into this skull. But if anyone were to ask how I handled the transport system of New 
Rome... well, I know that I did, but not how\ did it.” 

She smiled again. “That’s my story: A computer who longed to be a flesh-and-blood and who had loving 
friends who made is possible... and I’ve never regretted it; I love being flesh-and-blood — and want to love 
everybody.” She looked at Justin Foote very soberly. “Lazarus spoke sooth; I have never been a guest wife; I am 
only three years old as a flesh-and-blood. Should you choose me, you may find me awkward and shy — but not 
reluctant. I owe you much.” 

“Minerva,” said Lazarus, “back him into a corner some other time. You didn’t tell Justin what he wanted to 
know; you left out the hanky-panky.” 

“Oh." 

“And when you were philosophizing about awareness in computers, you left out the key point, it seems to me, 
one / know but you may not even though you’ve been a computer and I have not. Because this key point applies 
both to computers and to flesh-and-bloods. My dear — and Justin — and it won’t hurt you two erratic geniuses to 
listen — all machinery is animistic — ’humanistic,’ I want to say, but that term has been preempted. Any machine is 
a concept of a human designer; it reflects the human brain, be it wheelbarrow or giant computer. So there is 
nothing mysterious in a machine designed by a human showing human self-awareness; the mystery lies in 
awareness itself, wherever it’s found. I used to have a folding camp cot that liked to bite me. I don’t say that it 
was aware — but I learned to approach it with caution. 

“But, Minerva, darling, I’ve seen some big computers, almost as smart as you were, that never developed 



self-awareness. Can you tell us why?” 

“I confess I can’t, Lazarus. I’d like to ask Athene when we get home.” 

“She probably doesn’t know either; she’s never met any other major computer but Dora. Captain Lazuli, how 
far back do you remember? Once you — or your comrade in crime — claimed to remember nursing. Suckling, I 
mean.” 

“Of course we do! Doesn’t everybody?” 

“No. Me, for example. I was a bottle baby; I don’t remember even that. Not worth remembering. In 
consequence I’ve been looking at tits and admiring them ever since. Tell me, one of you, when you remember 
nursing, can you recall which of your mothers was giving you suck?” 

“Of course!” Lorelei said scornfully. “Mama Ishtar has big tits — ” 

“ — and Mama Hamadryad has much smaller ones even when they’re filled with milk — ” 

“But she gave just as much milk.” 

“Different flavor though. Made it nice to trade off each meal. Variety.” 

“But we liked both flavors! Tell him, Laz.” 

“Enough. \t>u’ve made the point I wanted. Justin, these kids were self-aware and aware of other people 
— their mothers at least — at an age when a creche baby is just a doughy blob, which says something about why 
creches have never worked well. I want the counterpoint: Minerva, what do you remember of the time when you 
were an unawakened clone?” 

“Why, nothing, Lazarus. Oh, some odd dreams when I was putting me — my selected memories — into my new 
me, this one. But I didn’t start that until Ishtar said the clone was big enough. That was not until shortly before I 
withdrew from my former me and Ishtar woke me. It could not be instantaneous, Justin; a protein brain won’t take 
data at computer speeds, Ishtar had me be very slow and careful. Then for a short time — short human time — I 
was both places, computer and skull; then I surrendered the computer and let it become Pallas Athene, and 
Ishtarwoke me. But, Lazarus, a clone in-vitro is not aware; it’s like a fetus in utero. No stimuli. Correction: 
minimum stimuli and nothing that leaves a permanent memory track. Unless you count reports of regression 
under hypnosis." 

“No need to count them,” Lazarus replied. “True or false, such cases are irrelevant. The relevant counterpoint 
is ‘minimum stimuli’ Honey, those big computers with awareness potential but without self-awareness are that 
way because nobody bothered to love the poor things. That’s all. Babies or big computers — they become aware 
through being given: lots of personal attention. ‘Love’ as it’s usually called. Minerva, does that theory match up 
with your earliest years?” 

Minerva looked soberly thoughtful. “That was about a century ago in human time — call it a million times that in 
computer time. I know from the records that I was assembled a few years before Ira took office. But the earliest 
personal memories / have — and those memories I saved and did not leave in Athene or in the computer in New 
Rome — the earliest I can remember of me is waiting eagerly and happily for the next time Ira would speak to me. 

Lazarus said, “I need not belabor the point. With babies you breast-feed them and nibble their toes and talk 
to them and blow in their bellybuttons and make them laugh. Computers don’t have bellybuttons, but attention 
works just as well on them. Justin, Minerva tells me that she left nothing of herself in the computer under the 
palace.” 

“That is correct. I left it intact as a computer and programmed for all its duties... but I dared not leave any per 
sonal memory, any part of the me, could not let it remember that it had once been Minerva; that wouldn’t have 
been fair to it. Lazarus warned me, and / was most careful, checking all the billions of bits and wiping where 
necessary.” 

Justin Foote said, “I missed a turn somehow. Ntiu did this in New Rome... but you’ve been awake here only 
three years?” 

“Three wonderful years! \bu see — ” 

“Let me interrupt, dear; I’ll tell him the hanky-panky. But first — Justin, have you dealt with the executive 
computer in New Rome since we migrated? Of course you have — but have you been in the office of Madam 
Chairman Pro Tern when she was using it?” 

“Why, yes, several times. Just yesterday — no, I mean the yesterday before I left; I keep forgetting that I missed 
transit time.” 

“What name does she use in speaking with it?” 



“I don’t think she uses a name. I’m fairly certain she does not.” 

“Oh, the poor thing!” 

“No, Minerva,” Lazarus said quietly. “\fou left it in good health; it simply won’t wake up until it has a mistress, 
or master, who appreciates it. Which might not be ’long,” he added grimly. 

Justin Foote said, “Might be anytime. Lazarus, that old, uh — cancel that. Arabelle loves the spotlight. Appears at 
public meetings, shows up in the Colosseum. Stands up and waves her scarf. Seems odd, after the quiet way Ira 
ran things.” 

“I see. A sitting duck. Seven to two she’s assassinated in the next five years.” 

“No bet. I’m a statistician, Lazarus.” 

“So you are. All right — Hanky-panky. Lots of it. Ishtar set up an auxiliary Howard Clinic in the Palace. Her 
excuse: Me, the Senior. But a cover-up for a much more extensive bio facility. Minerva picked her parents; Ishtar 
stole the tissues and faked some records. Meanwhile, our skinny friend my daughter Minerva — ” 

“She is not! She’s just right for her height and body type and bio age!” 

“ — and deliciously curved!” 

“ — had twinned her computer self in a hold of my yacht ‘Dora,’ placing the contract in my name and charging 
it to me, and nobody dared inquire why the Senior — some advantages to age, especially among Howards 
— wanted a huge computer in a yacht that already had one of the fanciest computers in the sky. While, back in 
my borrowed penthouse where nobody was allowed to go — other than a short list all as- dishonest as’ I am — a 
clone was growing in a facility installed in a room I didn’t need. 

“Comes time to migrate, a very large case containing what was then a very small clone, goes to the skyport 
marked as part of my personal baggage — this baggage between us, of course — and is loaded into the ‘Dora’ 
without inspection, such being a prerogative of being Chairman... for as you may recall I didn’t hand the gavel 
back to Arabelle until our transports had lifted and I was about to raise ship myself, with Ira and the rest of my 
personal party aboard. 

“While I’m taking the clone aboard, Minerva withdraws herself from the executive computer and is safe and 
snug in a hold of the ‘Dora’... with her gizzards packed with every bit of data in the Grand Library and the entire 
records of the Howard Clinic including secret and confidential stuff. A most satisfying caper, Justin, the most 
good, clean, illegal fun I’ve had since we stole the ‘New Frontiers.’ But I’m telling you this not to boast — or not 
much — but to ask if we were as slick as we thought we were. Any rumors? Did you suspect anything amiss? 

How about Arabelle?” 

“I feel sure that Arabelle does not suspect. Nor have I heard of Nelly Hildegarde bursting any blood vessels. 
Mmm, / suspected something.” 

“Really. Where did we slip?" 

“Hardly the word, Lazarus. Minerva, when I had occasion to consult you, while Ira was Chairman Pro Tern, 
how did we talk?” 

“Why, you were always most friendly, Justin. You always told me vJiy you wanted something instead of just 
telling me to dig it out. You would chat, too; you were never too much in a hurry to be pleasant. That’s why I 
remember you so warmly.” 

“And that, Lazarus, is why I sniffed something dead behind the arras. You and your party had been gone 
about a week when I wanted something from the executive computer. When you have an old friend with a 
pleasant voice — your voice is unchanged, Minerva; I should have recognized it — but I was bedazzled by your 
appearance — when you call this old friend and are answered by a flat, mechanical voice... and any deviation 
from programming language is answered by: ‘NULL PROGFtAM — REPEAT — WAITING FOR PROGRAM’ — then 
you know that an old friend is dead.” He smiled at the girl between them. “So I can’t tell you how delighted I am to 
learn that my old friend was reborn as a lovely young girl.” 

Minerva squeezed his hand, blushed slightly, and said nothing. 

“Hmm — ’ Justin, did you compare notes with anyone?” 

“Ancestor, do you think I’m a fool? I mind my own business.” 

“Apology, about grade two. No, you’re not a fool, unless you go back and work for the old harridan." 

“When will the next wave of migrants head this way? I hate to waste the work I’ve done on your life, and I 
would hate to abandon my personal library.” 

“Well, sir, no tellin’ when a streetcar will be by this time o’ night. Discuss it later.” Lazarus added, “That’s our 
house ahead.” 



Justin Foote looked, saw a building partly visible through trees, turned back to speak to Minerva. “Something 
you said earlier, Cousin, I did not understand. You said ‘I owe you so much.’ If I was pleasant to you — at New 
Rome, I ‘mean — you were at least as pleasant to me. More likely the debt is the other way; you were always 
most helpful.” 

Instead of answering, she looked’ at Lazarus. He said, “Nt>ur business, my dear.” 

Minerva took a deep breath, then said, “I plan to name twenty-three of my children for my twenty-three 
parents.” 

“So? That seems most warmly appropriate." 

“\bu’re not my cousin, Justin — you’re my father. One of them.” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
XIV 


Bacchanalia 


After the track through the gormtrees at the northern edge of Boondock swings right, one has a view of the 
home of Lazarus Long, but I hardly noticed it when I first saw it; I was much bemused by a statement by Minerva 
Long. Me her father? Me? 

The Senior said, “Close your mouth, Son; you’re making a draft. Dear, you startled him.” 

“Oh, dear!” 

“Now quit looking like a frightened fawn, or I'll be forced to hold your nose and administer two ounces of 
eighty-proof ethanol disguised as fruit juice; You’ve done nothing wrong. Justin, does disguised ethanol interest 
you?” 

“Yes,” I agreed fervently. “I recall a time in my youth when that and one other subject were all I was interested 
in.” 

“If the other subject wasn’t women, we’ll find a monastic cubbyhole where you can drink alone. But it was — I 
know more about you than you think. All right, we’ll have a libation or six. Not those two, they’re potential 
alcoholics.” 

“Slanderous — ” 

“ — though regrettably true — ” 

“ — but we did it only once — ” 

“ — and won’t do it again!” 

“Don’t commit yourself too far, kids; a brannigan might sneak up on you. Better to know your resistance than 
to be tripped through ignorance. Grow up, put on some mass, and you’ll be able to cope with it. Or Ishtar mixed 
up your genes, which she didn’t. Now about this other matter, Justin- Nfes, you’re one of Minerva’s parents... and 
that’s a very high compliment, because those twenty-three chromosome pairs were picked from tissues of 
thousands of superior people, using fearsome mathematics to handle the multiplicity of variables, plus Ishtar’s 
knowledge of genetics, and some unnecessary advice from me, before this little darling got the precise mix she 
wanted to be." 

I started to set up the type problem in my head — yes, that would be some problem, extremely more difficult 
than the ordinary genetics problem of advising one male and one female — then dropped it, as I had its delightful 
answer by her left hand. Lazarus was still speaking: 

“Minerva could have been male, two meters tall, massing a hundred kilos, built like Joe Colossus, and hung like 
a stallion mule. Instead she elected to be what she is: slender, female, shy — I’m not sure she selected for that 
last. Did you, dear?” 

“No, Lazarus; no one knows which genes control that. I think I get it from Hamadryad.” 

“I think you got it from a computer I used to know — and took along all of it as Athene certainly is not shy. Never 
mind. Some of Minerva’s donor-parents are dead; some are alive but unaware that a bit of tissue from a clone in 
stasis or from the live-tissue bank was borrowed — as in your case. Some know that they are donor-parents 
— me, for example, and you heard Hamadryad mentioned. You'll meet others, some being on Tertius, where it’s 
no secret. But consanguinity is not close for anyone. One twenty-third? The genetic advisers wouldn’t run that 
through a computer; it’s an acceptable risk. Plus the fact that none of us donor-parents of Minerva have any 
known skeletons hanging on our family trees. Nt>u could safely have progeny by her; so could I.” 

“But you refused me!” Minerva startled me with the vehemence with which she accused Lazarus of this. For a 
moment she was not shy; her eyes flashed. 

“Now, now, dear. \t>u were only a year out of vitro and not fully grown even though Ishtar forced you past 
menarche still in vitro. Ask me on another occasion; I might startle you.” 

“‘Startle’ me, or surprise me?" 

“Never mind that old joke. Justin, I simply wanted to make clear that your relationship to Minerva, while close 



enough that it makes Minerva feel sentimental, is in fact so small that you barely qualify as a ‘kissing cousin.”’ 

“I feel very sentimental about it,” I told the Senior. “Most pleased and deeply honored — although I can’t guess 
why I was picked.” 

“If you want to know which chromosome pair was swiped from you, and why, you had best ask Ishtar and get 
her to consult Athene; I doubt if Minerva still knows.” 

“But I do know; I saved those memories. Justin, I wanted to retain some ability in mathematics. It was a 
choice between you and Libby Professor Owens — so I chose you; you are my friend.” 

(Well! I respect Jake Hardy-Owens; I’m merely an applied mathematician, he is a brilliant theoretician.) “What 
ever your reasons, dear kissing cousin, I am delighted that you chose me as one of your donor-fathers.” 

“Grounded, Commodore!” announced one of the duplicate redheads — Lapis Lazuli — as the little nullboat 
clumped to a stop. (It appeared to be a Corson Farmsled and I was surprised to see it in a new Colony.) Lazarus 
answered, “Thank you, Captain.” 

The twins bounced out; the Senior and I handed Minerva out — unnecessary help that she accepted with 
gracious dignity, that being another aspect of colonial life that surprised me, New Rome being rather short on 
such archaic ceremony. (Over and again I found the Boondockers to be both more formally polite, and more 
casually relaxed about it, than are Secundians. I suppost my notions of frontier life had been fed on too many 
romances: rough, bearded men fighting off dangerous animals, mules hauling covered wagons toward distant 
horizons.) 

“Captain” Lazuli said, “Humpty Dumpty — go to bed !” The nullboat waddled away; the little girls joined us, one 
taking my free hand, the othertaking the Senior’s free hand, with Minerva between us. These freckled flametops 
would have had my whole attention had not Minerva been there. I am not compulsively fond of children; some 
youngsters seem to me rather poisonous, especially precocious ones. But in their case I found their solemn 
precocity charming rather than irritating... and to see the Senior’s features, rugged rather than handsome and 
with that too-large nose, unmistakably reproduced but transformed into piquant girlish features — well, had I been 
alone, I would have chuckled with delight. 


I said “Just a moment,” and held onto Lorelei’s hand and thereby caused, all to pause while I took a second 
look. “Lazarus, who is the architect?” 

“I don't know,” he said. “Dead more than four thousand years. The original belonged to the political boss of 
Pompeii, a city destroyed about that long ago. I saw a model of it, restored, in a museum in a place called 
Denver, and took pictures; it pleased me. Those pictures are long gone, but it turned out that, when I tried to 
describe it to Athene, she had a solly in the historical section of her gizzards of the ruins of that same house 
— and from that and my description, she designed this version. Some minor mods, nothing that changed its 
sweet proportions. Then Athene built it, using extensionals and radio links. It’s practical for this climate; the 
weather here is much like that of Pompeii — and I prefer a house that looks inward, on a court. Safer, even in a 
place as safe as this one.” 

“By the way, where is Athene? The main computer itself, I mean.” 

“Here. She was still in the ‘Dora’ when she built this; now she’s under the house — she built her underground 
home first, then built our house on top of it.” 

Minerva said simply, “A computer prefers to feel safe, and close to her own people. Lazarus — forgive me, 
dear, but you have reversed a time sequence; that was more than three years ago.” 

“Oh, so I have. Minerva, when you have lived as long as I have — and you will — you’ll find yourself inverting 
time sequences endlessly, a flesh-and-blood shortcoming you had to accept when you took the plunge. 
Correction, Justin — ‘Minerva,’ not ‘Athene.’” 

“\fet it is Athene who built it — now,” Minerva added, “since engineering and the details of this construction and 
others are things I left behind in Athene, where they belong, and abstracted only a simplified memory of having 
built it — I wanted to remember that much.” 

I said, “Whoever built it, it’s beautiful.” I was suddenly upset. It is one thing to accept intellectually the startling 
idea that a young woman has had a former life as a computer — and even to accept that one had worked with 
that computer years back and light-years away. But this discussion suddenly brought home to me emotional 
belief that this lovely girl with her arm warm in mine had in sober fact been a computer so short a time ago that 



she had built this new house — while a computer. It shook me — even though I am a historiographer, old, and my 
sense of wonder was dulled even before my first rejuvenation. 


We went in, and my upset was swept away by greetings. We were kissed all around — two beautiful young 
women, one of whom I recognized when I heard her name, Ira’s daughter Hamadryad and she looks like one, the 
other a statuesque blonde whose name, Ishtar, was familiar to me through talk, and a young man as beautiful as 
the women and who seemed familiar though I could not place him. Even the twin flametops insisted on kissing 
me since they had not greeted me that way earlier. 

In Boondock a kiss of greeting is not the ritual peck it usually is in New Rome; even the twins bussed me in a 
fashion that made me certain of their sex — I’ve had poorer kisses from grown women whose intentions were 
direct and immediate. But the young man, introduced as “Galahad,” startled me. He hugged me, with kisses on 
my cheeks followed by a kiss on my mouth worthy of a Ganymede — which surprised me, but I tried to return as 
good as I got. 

Instead of letting me go, he pounded my back and said, “Justin, it tickles my root to see you again! Oh, this is 
wonderful!” 

I pulled my face back to look at his. I must have looked puzzled for he blinked, then said mournfully: “Ish, I 
boasted too soon! Hamadear, get me a towel, I’m weeping. He’s forgotten me... after all the things he said.” 

I said, “Obadiah Jones, what are you doing here?” 

“Weeping. Being humiliated in front of my family.” 

I don’t know how long it had been since I had seen him. It may have been more than a century since it has 
been that long since I left the Howard campus. Brilliant young specialist in ancient cultures he was then, with an 
impish sense of humor. I recalled, dredging it up out of memory, having shared a Seven Hours with him and two 
other savants, both female and happily so — but I could not recall their faces nor who they were; what I 
remembered was his playful, joyous, boisterous good company. “Obadiah,” I said sternly, “why are you calling 
yourself ‘Galahad’? Hiding from the police again? Lazarus, I’m shocked to find this, uh, macho in your house — 
lock up your daughters!” 

“Oh, that name” he said brokenly. “Don’t repeat it, Justin. They don’t know it. When I reformed, I changed my 
name. Nt>u won’t give me away? Promise me, dear!” Suddenly he grinned and said in a cheerful voice, “Come 
on into the atrium and let’s get a skinful of rum into you. Lazi, who has the duty?” 

“Lori does. Even-numbered day. But I'll help. Straight rum?” 

“Better flavor it. I want to add a welcome the Borgias used on old friends.” 

“Sure thing, Uncle Cuddly. Who are the Borgias?" 

“A family from the greatest days of Old Earth’s rise and fall, sugar lump. The Howards of their time. Very 
suave in handling guests. I’m descended from them, and their secrets were passed down to me byword of 
mouth.” 

“Laz,” said Lazarus, “ask Athene fora rundown on the Borgias before you mix a drink for Justin.” 

“I see; he’s at it again — ” 

“ — so we’ll tickle him — 

“ — and blow in his ears — 

“ — until he cries Pax — 

“ — and promises Veritas — 

“ — he’s no problem. Come on, Lazi." 

I had found the village of Boondock pleasantly unimpressive, more pleasant and less impressive than I had 
expected. Ira and Lazarus had accepted only seven thousand for their first wave from applicants numbering 
more than ninety thousand; therefore the present population of Tertius could not be much over ten thousand and 
was in fact slightly less. 

Boondock seemed to have only a few hundred people and was centered on a few small buildings for public 
and semipublic purposes, most colonists being scattered around the countryside. The home of Lazarus Long 
was by far the most impressive structure I had seen — not counting the large flat cone of the Senior’s yacht and 
the much larger bulk of one robot space freighter on the skyfield where my packet had grounded. (The skyfield 
was a level place a few kilometers across; one could not call it a port. There was not one godown. It must have 
an autobeacon since I grounded safely; I did not see it.) 



This rudimentary settlement had not prepared me for the Senior’s house. Its lines and plan were simple; that 
long-dead Roman had picked a good designer. It was a walled garden, the house itself being its four walls. But it 
had two stories, and each level could have been divided, it seemed to me, into twelve to sixteen large rooms 
plus the usual ancillary spaces. Twenty-four or more rooms for a household of eight? The more blatantly rich in 
New Rome might display ego in so much space, but it seemed inappropriate in a new colony, as well as out of 
tune with what I had learned in my long research of the Senior’s lives. 

Simple — Half the building was given over to a rejuvenation clinic, a therapy clinic, an infirmary; these could 
be reached from the foyer without entering the private part of the house. 

The number of family rooms remaining was indefinite; most interior walls were movable. The Howard Clinic and 
the medical facilities would be moved to a nearby site when the colony needed larger facilities, when size of the 
Senior’s family made more home space desirable. 

(I was lucky in that, when I arrived, no client was being rejuvenated, no patient was in the infirmary — or most 
of the adults would have been busy.) 

The size of his family seemed as hazy as the number of rooms. I had thought there were eight — three men, 
the Senior, Ira, and Galahad; three women, Ishtar, Hamadryad, and Minerva; two youngsters, Lorelei Lee and 
Lapis Lazuli — but I was not aware of two girl toddlers and a small boy. Besides that, I was neither the first nor the 
last to be urged to move in and stay as long as one wished. Whether such stay was as a guest or as a member 
of the Senior’s family might also be unclear to an outsider. 

Relationships inside his family also were vague. Colonists are always families; a single colonist is a 
contradiction in terms. But all of Tertius Colony were Howards, and we Howards have used every sort of 
marriage, I think, except lifetime monogamy. 

But Tertius has no laws about marriage; the Senior had not thought them necessary. The few laws it has are 
in the migration contract, written by Ira and Lazarus jointly. It contains the usual covenants about homesteading, 
with the colony leader absolute arbitrator until such time as he resigns. But it says not one word about marriage 
and family relationships. The colonists register their babies; Howards always do — in this case with the Computer 
Athene as surrogate for the Archives. But I found when I reviewed these records that parentage of children was 
expressed in genetic classification code, not by marriages and putative ancestry. This system the Families’ 
geneticists have been urging for generations (and I agree), but it does make a genealogist work harder, espe 
cially if marriages have not been registered at all, as was sometimes the case. 

I found one couple with eleven children, six his, five hers, none theirs. I understood it when I read their codes 
— utterly incompatible. I met them later, a fine family on a prosperous farm and no suggestion that the swarm of 
children were anything hut “theirs.” 

But the Senior’s family was even more vague. Genetic ancestry in each case was a matter of record, surely 
— but who was married to whom? 

Their bathing room was as “decadent” as had been promised; it was a lounging room, as well as a refresher, 
and planned for family relaxation and entertaining. It stretched all along the ground floor on the side facing the 
foyer across the inner garden, and its walls could be pushed back to open it to the garden in clement weather 
— which this was and quite warm. 

It had anything a jaundiced Sybarite could ask for: a fountain in its center matching a fountain in the garden 
and each with comfortably wide rims to sit on while soaking tired feet and enjoying a drink; a sauna in one 
corner; a huge happy shower at the other end with space for several cycles to be enjoyed at once without waiting 
turns; a companion querafansible with sophisticated controls; a long soaking pool knee-deep at the blue end to 
chin-deep at the red, and flanked by two bathing pools lavish for one person and comfortable for two or three; 
couches for napping, for cooling, for sweating, for intimate talk and touch; a cosmetics table with a big duomirror 
in which one could see her back as readily as her front simply by asking Athene’s help; a corner big enough for a 
dozen people in which floor cushioning was bed-soft and lavish with pillows large and small, firm and soft; a re 
freshments counter which backed onto their kitchen — and if I failed to name something, it is my omission, not 
that of the designers. All the more commonplace items were of course at hand. 

I had thought that the lighting was random until I realized that Athene was changing it endlessly so as not to 
shine it in anyone’s eyes while changing the light level in all parts of that big room to match what was going on 
— high key for makeup, subdued light for lounging, and so on — and to match personalities too; our little redheads 
were crowned with light no matter how they bounced around — as they did. 

Soft music was there and in the garden, or on request anywhere, selected by Athene unless someone asked 



for something — it seemed as if she had stored in her all the music that ever was written. Or she might harmonize 
with the twins while continuing to take part in three different conversations in other parts of the bath lounge. A 
self-aware computer of her capacity — great enough to manage Secundus — can and often must talk 
simultaneously at many places, but I had never encountered it before in such a way as to notice it. But big 
computers are not often members of a family. 

The rest of the house was almost unautomated — a matter of taste as Athene’s capacity was largely unused. 
My hostesses actually cooked, with Athene helping only by seeing to it that nothing burned and watching the 
timing in other ways — twice on Athene’s advice Hamadryad left the bath lounge, once in such a hurry that she 
fled bare and dripping, not stopping to grab a towel robe. 

Bathing with Lazi and Lori is indeed “squirmy but fun,” plus squeals, giggles, chatter in which one sentence 
would be chopped several times before one of them put a period on it (I hypothesized that they were telepathic 
with each other and had an uneasy suspicion that they sometimes read thoughts of persons in their presence but 
was not anxious to find out) — all charmingly blunt and childishly innocent. 

First they slathered me all over with scented liquid soap and demanded the same service from me and 
threatened me with chin quivering when I held back a little, and said loudly that “Uncle Cuddly” (my old friend 
Obadiah, now Galahad) washed them better than that and everybody knows how lazy he is — or didn't I like them 
well enough to soapy-cuddle them and if they married me, would I go along with them in their spaceship, and 
while they were still virgins, though not from lack of opportunity, don’t worry about that one bit as both Mama 
Hamadryad and Mama Ishtarwere coaching them in beginning and advanced sensuality and would speed up 
the course if I happened to want to marry them now — won’t you, Mama Hamalambie? — tell him! 

Hamadryad from a meter away (she was soaping Ira) assured us that she would, if they could persuade me 
to marry them that quickly. I assumed that the youngsters were farcing me and that their mother — one of their 
mothers — was going along with the jest. I’ve wondered since whether I missed a diamond opportunity. Lazarus 
was in hearing distance; he did not tell them to stop teasing me, he simply advised me not to offer them more 
than a ten-year contract as their span of attention was limited — which made them indignant — and advised them 
that, if they intended to get married that night, they had better trim their toenails first, which made them still more 
indignant so they stopped bathing me to assault him from both sides. 

This wound up with one of them under each of his arms and still struggling. Lazarus asked if I would accept 
custody or should he drop them into the deep end of the soak? 

I accepted custody, and we showered each other off and went into the soak pool together — and I was 
standing in it up to my shoulders with my back to the garden, and supporting them a little, an arm each, as their 
toes did not touch bottom, when someone placed hands over my eyes. 

The twins squealed, “Aunt Tammy!” and levitated out of the water while I turned to look. 

Tamara Sperling — I had thought she was on Secundus, in retirement up country. Tamara the Superb, the 
Superlative, the Unique — in my opinion (and many others) the greatest artist of her profession. I feel sure that I 
am not the only man who chose when she left New Rome to remain celibate for a long time. 

She had come in, seen that the family was in the bath lounge, dropped her gown in the garden, hurried in 
without stopping to remove her high sandals, spotted me, and blindfolded me with her lovely hands. 

Why? She was my dinner partner — and (if I could rely on an exchange I had heard that afternoon) willing to be 
my guest wife if I were willing. Willing? Fifty years earlier I had offered her any contract she would accept every 
time she let me visit her and had finally shut up only after she had told me repeatedly, patiently, and gently that 
she did not intend to have more children and would not marry again for any other purpose. 

But there she was, rejuvenated (not that it mattered), looking gloriously young and healthy — and a colonist. I 
wondered who the man was who had persuaded her to do this? I envied him and wondered what superhuman 
qualities he possessed — but whatever they were, if Tamara was willing to share a bed with me even for one night 
and only for old times’ sake, I would take what the gods offered and not worry about him; her wealth is endlessly 
divisible. Tamara! — bells sound at her name. 

She kissed two wet little girls, then dropped to her knees and kissed me. 

Then she said softly, rubbing her mouth against mine, “\t>u darling. When I heard you were here, I hurried. Mi 
laroona d’ vashti meedth du?” 

“Yes! And any other night you have free.” 

“Not so fast with English, doreeth mi; I learning it slowly — because my daughter wants her assistants in 
rejuvenation to speak language not known to most clients. . .and because our family speaks English much as 



Galacta.” 

“\bu are now a rejuvenator? And have a daughter here?” 

“Ishtar datter mi — did you not know, petsan mi-mi? Nay, I am nurse only. But studying I am and Ishtar hope- 
tells that I will be assistant technician in half handful of years. Good — nay?” 

“Good, I suppose. But what a loss to the art!” 

“Blandjor,” she said happily, tousling my wet hair. “Even though rejuvenated — did you note? — here the art 
pays no living. Too many willing ones, sweeter and younger and prettier.” The twins had stayed with us, listening 
and quiet for a moment. Tamara reached out both arms, hugged them to her. “Example. These my 
granddaughters. Eager to grow tall so they can lie down and be short.” She kissed each of them. “And red curls 
they have. I not have.” 

I started to say that age and red curls did not matter, then realized that a compliment to Tamara so phrased 
could cause chins to quiver. But I did not need to speak; the spout had opened again: 

“Aunt Tammy, we are not eager — ’’ 

“ — just willing and practical — ” 

“ — and anyhow he won’t marry us — ” 

“ — he just teases about it — ” 

“ — and you cant be our grandmother — ” 

“ — ‘cause that would make you our Buddy Boy’s grandmother — ’’ 

“ — which is illogical, impossible, and ridiculous — ” 

“ — so you have to be our ‘Aunt Tammy.’” 

I found their logic doubly enthymematic if not a total non sequitur, but I agreed with it because the notion of 
Tamara being the Senior’s grandmother was one I could not face. So I changed the subject: 

“Tamara dear, would you let me take off your sandals and then you come join us in the soak? Or shall I get out 
and get dry?” 

She did not have to answer: 

“We gotta run get ready — ” 

“ — cause Mama Hamadryad has finished her face and started her nipples — ” 

“ — so if we don’t hurry, we’ll have to come to dinner with our hides bare naked — ” 

“ — and for a party that would never do — ” 

“ — and you two had better hurry too — ” 

“ — or Buddy Boy will throw it to the pigs. Scuse!” 

I climbed out and let Tamara dry me — unnecessary as there was a blowdry at hand. But if Tamara offers me 
anything my answer is Nfes. It took a while; we “wasted” time on touch and talk. (Is there a better way to spend 
time?) 

When I was dry and wondering if I should try the cosmetics bench (I don’t use cosmetics much, just 
depilatories), one of the twins came rushing back with a garment for me, a blue chlamys. She said breathlessly, 
“Lazarus says try this or what would you like? — but that you needn’t wear anything ifyou don’twantto ‘cause it’s 
a hot night and you count as family because you’re Minerva’s father, one of them.” 

I thought I had them keyed now by freckle pattern. “Thank you, Lorelei; I'll wear it.” I’ve always felt that a napkin 
was enough to wear in dining at home in a properly tempered house — or outdoors in private on a warm night. 

But, as guest of honor even though “family,” I could not go bare when they were taking the trouble to be festively 
formal. 

“\bu’re welcome, but I’m Captain Lazuli, but that’s all right, she’s me. Scuse!” She vanished. 

I put it on; we went into the garden and retrieved Tamara’s gown — and it matched what I was wearing. The 
same shade of blue, I mean, and a Golden-Age-of-Hellas- flavor to it. Hers was about two grams of blue fog. The 
bodice fastened at the right shoulder and came diagonally down to her waist at the left. Its skirt was longer than 
mine — but that was appropriate; Greek men of their Golden Age did wear their skirts shorter than did women, 
instead of the reverse that is more usual on Secundus. (I did not know as yet what was customary on Tertius.) We 
matched, and I was pleased. 

Accident? “Accidents” around the Senior are usually planned. 

We ate in the garden, a couch for each couple, arranged in hexagon with the fountain as the sixth side. 



Athene made the water dance and danced lights in it, to match whatever she was playing. All the womenfolk but 
Tamara helped with the primary serving; Lori and Lazi played Hebe from then on — it was impossible to keep 
them nailed to their couch anyhow. As the feast started, Ira was with Minerva, Lazarus with Ishtar, Galahad with 
Hamadryad, and the twins together. But the women moved around like chessmen, sharing a couch, a few bites, 
a little cuddling, then moving on — all but Tamara, whose firm-soft, rounded bottom lay against my lap the entire 
feast. It was just as well that she did not move; I’m not shy but prefer not to show the gallant reflex unless I need it 
at once — and I was very conscious of her dear body warm against me. 

But while Lazarus started the repast with Ishtar, the next time I looked his way it was Minerva who reclined 
against him — and next, one of the twins, which one I am not sure. And so on. 

I won’t describe the feast except to say that I did not expect it in a young colony and to add that I have paid high 
prices for poorer food in famous restaurants in New Rome. 

All but Lazarus and his sisters were wearing colorful, pseudo-Grecian garments. But Lazarus was dressed 
as a Scottish chieftain of two and a half millennia ago — the kilt, bonnet, sporran, dirk, claymore, etc. The sword 
he laid aside but handy, as if expecting to need it. I can state firmly that he was never entitled to dress as a chief 
by the rules of those long-lost clans. There is doubt that he is entitled to wear any Scottish dress. He once said 
that he was “half Scotch and half soda,” but on another occasion he told Ira Weatheral that he had first worn the 
kilt at a time (shortly before the flight of the NewFrontiers) when the style was popular in his home country 
— found that he liked it, and thereafter wore the kilt when local custom permitted. 

That night he went all out and added a fierce mustache to match his finery. 

His twin sisters were dressed exactly as he was. I am still wondering whether all this was to honor me, to 
impress me, or to amuse me. Perhaps all three. 

I would happily have spent those three hours in quiet, feeding Tamara and letting her feed me, bathed in the 
peace of soul that comes from touching her, but the closed happiness circle (and closed it was; Athene’s voice 
now came from the fountain) showed that the Senior expected us to share company, talking and listening in turn, 
as ritually as in any protocol-bound salon in New Rome. And so we did, in shared and gentle harmony — with the 
twins adding unexpected grace notes but usually managing to restrain their exuberance and be “grown-up.” The 
Senior started it, using Ira as Stimulator. “Ira, what would you say if a god came through that entranceway?” 

“I’d tell him to wipe his feet. Ishtar doesn’t permit gods with dirty feet in this house.” 

“But all gods have feet of clay.” 

“That wasn’t what you said yesterday." 

“This is not yesterday, Ira. I've seen a thousand gods and all had feet of clay. All were swindles, first” 

— Lazarus ticked it with his fingers — ”to benefit the shamans; second, to benefit the kings; and third, always to 
benefit the shamans. Then 1 met the thousand-and-first.” The Senior paused. 

Ira looked at me. “At this point I am supposed to say, ‘Do tell!’ or some such insincerity, then the rest of you 
chime, ‘Yes, yes, Lazarus!’ — which has its merit; the rest of us would have at least twenty uninterrupted minutes 
for swilling and guzzling. 

“But I’m going to fool him. He’s leading up to how he killed the gods of the Jockaira with nothing but a toy gun 
and moral superiority. Since that lie is already in his memoirs in four conflicting versions, why should we be 
burdened with a fifth?” 

“It was not a toy gun; it was a Mark Nineteen Remington Blaster at full charge, a superior weapon in its day 
— and after I caved them up, the stench was worse than Hormone Hall the morning after payday. And my 
superiority is never moral; it lies always in doing it first before he does it to me. But the point of the story Ira won’t 
let me tell is that those globs were real gods because neither shamans nor kings were cut in on the loot; they 
were swindled, too. Those doggie people were property, solely for the benefit of their gods — gods in the sense 
that a man can be a god to a dog — which I had suspected first time around, when they drove poor Slayton Ford 
right out of his think tank and nearly killed him. But the second time, some eight or nine hundred years later, Andy 
Libby and I proved that this was so. ‘How?’ you ask — ” 

“We didn’t ask.” 

“Thank you, Ira. Because after all that time the Jockaira had not changed in any way. Their speech, customs, 
buildings, you name it — were frozen. This can happen only with domesticated animals. A wild animal, such as 
man, changes his ways as conditions change; he adjusts. I’ve often thought I would like to go back and see if the 
doggie people managed to go feral after they lost their owners. Or did they simply lie down and die? But I wasn’t 



too tempted; Andy and I were lucky to get off that planet still with our gonads, the way they were yapping at our 
heels.” 

“See what I mean, Justin? Version number three had the Jockaira falling into a coma the instant their masters 
were burned out — and Libby doesn’t figure into that version at all." 

“Papa Ira, you don’t understand Buddy Boy — ” 

“ — he doesn’t tell — lies — ” 

“ — he’s a creative artist — ” 

“ — speaking in parables — ’’ 

“ — and he emancipated those Jabberwockies — ’’ 

“ — who were cruelly oppressed.” 

Ira Weatheral said, “Justin, I had trouble coping with one Lazarus Long. But three of him? I surrender. Come 
here, Lori, and let me nibble your ear. Minerva, my lovely, let go of that, wash your pretty hands, then see if Justin 
needs more wine. Justin, you are the only one with news to impart. What news on the Bourse?” 

“Falling steadily. If you own participations on Secundus, you had better have me carry back instructions to 
your broker. Lazarus, I noticed that you classed ‘man’ as a wild animal — ” 

“He is. \t>u can kill him, but you can’t tame him. The worst bloodbaths in history derive from attempting to 
tame him." 

“I wasn't arguing it, Ancestor. I’m a mathematical historiographer; my nose is rubbed in that fact. But has 
news reached here of the flight of the ‘Vanguard’? The original ‘Vanguard,’ I mean — pre-Diaspora.” 

Lazarus sat up so suddenly that he almost spilled Ishtar off his couch. He caught her. “Sorry, honey. Justin 
— keep talking.” 

“I didn’t intend to talk about the ‘Vanguard’ herself — ” 

7 want to hear about her. I hear no objection; it is so ruled. Talk, Son!" 

The protocol of a salon feast having gone to pieces, I talked, first reviewing some ancient history. Although it 
has almost been forgotten, the NewFrontiers was not the first starship. She had an older sister, the Vanguard, 
that left the Solar system a few years earlier than the momentous date on which Lazarus Long commandeered 
the NewFrontiers. She was headed for Alpha Centaun but never reached there — no signs of visitation were 
ever found on the one possible planet, a Terran type around Alpha Centauri A, the only G-type star in that volume. 

But the ship herself was found by accident, in open orbit a long way from where she should have been by any 
rational assumption based on her mission — discovered nearly a century ago and this tells the difficulties of 
historiography when ships are the fastest means of communication; this story echoed back to Secundus via five 
colonial planets before it reached Archives — a few years after Lazarus left New Rome, a few years before I went 
to Boondock as (nominal) courier for the Chairwoman Pro Tern. Not that a century’s delay matters, as the news 
interested only fusty specialists. To most people it was an uninteresting confirmation of an inconsequential bit of 
ancient history. 

Everything in the Vanguard was dead while the ship herself was sleeping, her converter automatically shut 
down, her atmosphere almost leaked away, her records so destroyed, illegible, incomplete, or desiccated as to 
distress one. The Vanguard matters only to antiquarians and such — although she will remain an endless trove to 
deviants such as me — if we don’t lose her again. Space is deep. 

But the interesting thing about the find is that when the Vanguard was backtracked ballistically by computer, it 
showed that she had passed close to a Sol-type star seven centuries earlier. A check of that system turned up 
one planet Terran in type; it was found to be inhabited by H. sapiens. But not from the Diaspora. From the 
Vanguard. 

“Lazarus, there is no possible doubt. Those few thousand savages on that planet — designated ‘Pitcairn 
Island,’ the catalog number escapes me — are descended from some who reached there, presumably by ship’s 
boat, seven centuries before they were found. They had reverted to precivilization food-gathering stage, and had 
the planet rather than the ship been found first, it might have started another of those stories about a breed of 
humans not derived from old Terra. 

“But their argot, fed into a linguistic analyzer-sysithesizer, played back as that version of English which was 
the ‘Vanguard’s’ working language. Reduced vocabulary, new words, degenerate syntax — but the same 
language." 

“Their myths, Justin, their myths!” Galahad-Obadiah demanded. 



I was forced to admit that I did not have it all on tap but promised to make a full copy for him and send it via 
the first ship. “But, Senior, the interesting thing is that these savages, so wild and fierce that in dealing with them 
more scientists were killed than savages — ” 

“Hooray for them. Son, those savages were minding their own business on their own planet. An intruder can 
expect whatever he gets. Up to him to keep his guard up.” 

“I suppose so. Three scientists were eaten before they figured out how to deal with these pseudo-aborigines. 
By remotely controlled humanoid robots, that is. But the point I wanted to make was not their fierceness but their 
intelligence. Believe me or not, by every test that could be used, these wild men, these savages, checked 
superior to norm. Much superior. By the bell curve they land in the range of ‘exceptionally gifted’ to ‘genius-plus.’” 

“\bu expect me to be surprised? Why?” 

“Well — Savages. And probably closely inbred.” 

“>bu’re baiting me, Justin; you know better — although possibly Ira signed you to be Stimulator. All right, I'll 
take the bait. ‘Savage’ describes a cultural condition, not a degree of intelligence. Nor does inbreeding damage 
a gene pool if conditions for survival are extreme; since you describe them as cannibals, they probably ate their 
culls. From the shape the ship was in, it is fair to assume that their ancestors landed with little or nothing 
— possibly bare hands and a hatful of ignorance... in which case only the most able, the smartest, could survive. 
Justin, the crew of that first ship averaged far more intelligent than the Howards who escaped in the ‘New 
Frontiers’; they were picked for intelligence-whereas the original Howard selectees were picked only for 
longevity, not for brainpower. Your savages were descended solely from geniuses... then passed through Allah 
alone knows how many ordeals that kill off the stupid and leave only the smartest to breed. What does that 
leave?” 

I admitted that I had tossed him a baiting question to see how he would answer. The Senior nodded. “I know 
you’re not stupid, Son; I had Athene give me a runback on your ancestry. But I have often been amazed at how 
the moderately bright and moderately well-informed — which describes no one in this happiness circle, so no one 
need pretend to modesty — how often such somewhat superior people have trouble coming to grips with the 
ancient silk-purse-and-sow’s-ear problem. If heredity were not overwhelmingly more important than environment, 
you could teach calculus to a horse. 

“In my early days it was an article of faith among a self-styled ‘intellectual elite’ that they could teach calculus 
to a horse... if they started early enough, spent enough money, supplied special tutoring, and were endlessly 
patient and always careful not to bruise his equine ego. They were so sincere that it seems downright ungrateful 
that the horse always persisted in being a horse. Especially as they were right, if ‘starting early enough’ is 
defined as a million years or more. 

“But those savages will make it; they can’t avoid winning. The problem in reverse is more horridly interesting. 
Justin, do you realize that we Howards killed off Old Terra?” 

“Yes.” 

“Now, now, Son, you’re not supposed to answer in such a way as to chop off conversation. . .thereby leaving 
us with nothing to do but get drunk and cuddle the girls.” 

“Swell!” Obadiah-Galahad shouted. “Let’s!” He had Minerva with him at that moment; he grabbed her and 
flipped her over facing him. “Little whatever-your-name-is, do you have any last words?” 

“Yes.” 

“‘Yes’ what?” 

“Just ‘Yes.’ That’s my last word.” 

“Galahad,” said Ishtar, “if you’re going to rape Minerva, drag her back of the fountain. I want to hear what 
Justin means by that.” 

“How can I rape her when she won’t fight?” he complained. 

“>bu’ve always been able to solve that problem. But do it quietly. Justin, I find myself shocked. It seems to me 
that we’ve been quite generous in supplying Old Home Terra with new technologies — and there’s not much else 
we can give them. Didn’t the last migrant transport come back only half loaded?” 

“I’ll answer it,” Lazarus growled. “Justin might pretty it up. Not all the Howards. Two. Andy Libby provided the 
weapon; I delivered the coup de grace. Space travel killed Earth.” 

Ishtar looked troubled. “Grandfather, I don’t understand." 

“She calls me that when I’ve been naughty,” the Senior confided to me. “It’s her way of spanking me. Ish 
darling, you are young and sweet and have spent your life studying biology, not history. Earth was doomed in any 



case; space travel just hurried it along. By 2012 it wasn’t fit to live on — so I spent the next century elsewhere, 
although the other real estate in the Solar System is far from attractive. Missed seeing Europe destroyed, 
missed a nasty dictatorship in my home country. Came back when things appeared to be tolerable, found that 
they weren’t — and that’s when the Howards had to run for it. 

“But space travel can’t ease the pressure on a planet grown too crowded, not even with today’s ships and 
probably not with any future ships — because stupid people won’t leave the slopes of their home volcano even 
when it starts to smoke and rumble. What space travel does do is drain off the best brains: those smart enough 
to see a catastrophe before it happens and with the guts to pay the price — abandon home, wealth, friends, 
relatives, everything — and go. That’s a tiny fraction of one percent. But that’s enough.” 

“It’s the bell curve again,” I said to Ishtar. “If — as Lazarus thinks, and statistics back him up — every migration 
comes primarily from the right-hand end of the normal-incidence curve of human ability, then this acts as a 
sorting device whereby the new planet will show a bell curve with a much higher intelligence norm than the 
population it came from... and the old planet will average almost imperceptibly stupider.” 

“Imperceptible except for one thing!” Lazarus objected. 

“That tiny fraction that hardly shows statistically is the brain. I recall a country that lost a key war by chasing 
out a mere half dozen geniuses. Most people cant think, most of the remainder wont think, the small fraction who 
do think mostly can’t do it very well. The extremely tiny fraction who think regularly, accurately, creatively, and 
without self-delusion — in the long run these are the only people who count and they are the very ones who 
migrate when it is physically possible to do so. 

“As Justin said, statistically it hardly shows. But qualitatively it makes all the difference. Chop off a chicken’s 
head and it doesn’t die at once; it flops around more energetically than ever. For a while. Then it dies. 

“That’s what space travel did to Earth: chopped its head off. For two thousand years its best brains have 
been migrating. What’s left is flopping harder than ever... to no purpose and will die that much sooner. Soon, I 
think. I don’t feel guilty about it; I see no sin in those smart enough to escape escaping if they can — and the death 
rattle of Earth was clear and strong back in the twentieth century, Earth reckoning, when I was a young man and 
space travel had barely started — not even started in interstellar terms. It took two more centuries and then some 
to get it rolling. Can’t count the first migration of the Howards; it was involuntary, and they weren’t the best brains. 

“The later Howard migration to Secundus was more important; it shook out some of the dullards, left them 
behind. The non-Howard migrations were even more important. I've often wondered what would have happened 
if there had been no political restraints against migrating from China; the few Chinese who did reach the stars 
seem always to be winners, I suspect that the Chinese average smarter than the rest of Earth’s spawn. 

“Not that slant of eye or color of skin matters today, or even matters at the moment of truth. One of the early 
Howards was Robert C. M. Lee, of Richmond, Virginia — anybody know what his name was originally?” 

“I do,” I answered. 

“Of course you do, Justin, so keep quiet — and that includes you, Athene. Anyone else?” 

No one answered; Lazarus went on: “His birth name was Lee Choy Moo; he was born in Singapore, and his 
parents came from Canton in China — and of the people in the ‘New Frontiers’ he was a mathematician second 
only to Andy Libby.” 

“Goodness!” said Hamadryad. “Fm descended from him — but I didn’t know he was a great mathematician.” 

“Did you know he was Chinese?’ 

“Lazarus, Fm not sure what ‘Chinese’ means; I haven’t studied much terrestrial history. Isn’t it a religion? Like 
‘Jewish’?” 

“Not exactly, dear. The point is that it no longer matters. Just as few know and no one cares that the famous 
Zaccur Barstow, my partner in crime, was a quarter Negro. Does that word mean anything to you, Hamadarling? 
Not a religion.” 

“The word means ‘black,’ so I assume that one of his grandparents was from Africa.” 

“Which shows what comes of assuming anything on one datum. Two of Zack’s grandparents, both mulatto, 
came from Los Angeles in my homeland. Since my line mixed with his a long time back, probably any of you can 
claim African ancestry. Which is statistically equivalent to claiming descent from Charlemagne. I’ve gone far 
afield, and it is time we picked a new Stimulator and a new Respondent. Space travel ruined old Earth — that’s 
one viewpoint. The other side of the coin, happier and more important in the long run, is that it improved the 
breed. Probably saved it as well but ‘improved’ is certain. Homo sapiens is now not only far more numerous than 
he ever was on Earth; he is a better, smarter, more efficient animal in every measurable fashion. Further this 



Respondent sayeth not; somebody else grab it. Lazi, quit trying to tickle me and go bother Galahad; Minerva 
needs a rest.” 

“Lazarus,” Ishtar said, “just one more responding, please. Something you said about Howards made me 
wonder. \bu seemed to place all emphasis on intelligence. Don’t you consider long-life important?” 

I was astonished to see the oldest human alive frowning over this, slow to answer. Surely it was a question he 
had settled in his mind at least a thousand years earlier. I tried to forstall the 
quandary, found I could not soothly norom it. 

“Ishtar, the only correct verbal answer to that is Yes and No — which merely says I lack language to define 
something that is crystal clear inside me and has been for centuries. But here is part of the truth: A long time ago 
a short-lifer proved to me that we all live the same length of time.” He glanced at Minerva; she looked solemnly 
back. “Because we all live now She — he — was not asserting that fallacy of Georg Cantor which distorted pre- 
Libby mathematics so long; uh, he 

— was asserting a verifiable objective truth. Each individual lives her life in nowindependently of how others may 
measure that life in years. 

“But here is another piece of truth. Life is too long when one is not enjoying now \bu recall when I was not 

and wished to terminate it. Your skill — and trickery, my darling, and don't blush changed that and again I 

savor now But perhaps I have never told you that I approached even my first rejuvenation with misgivings, afraid 
that it would make my body young without making my spirit young again — and don't bother to tell me that ‘spirit’ 
is a null word; I know that it is undefinable but it means something to me. 

“But here is still more of the truth and all I’ll try to say about it. Although long-life can be a burden, mostly it is a 
blessing. It gives time enough to learn, time enough to think, time enough not to hurry, time enough for love. 

“Enough of weighty matters. Galahad, pick a light subject and, Justin, you plant the barbs; I’ve talked enough. 
Ishtar, my darling, fetch your long lovely carcass over here, stretch out, and let me ply you with brandy; I want you 
relaxed enough for what I intend to do with you later.” 

She came readily to him, stopping only to kiss Ira a promise, then saying softly but clearly to our Ancestor, 
“Our beloved, it takes no brandy to make me utterly willing for whatever you have in mind.” 

“Anesthesia, Mama Ishtar. I plan to show you something Big Anna taught me which I haven't dared risk in all 
these years. You may not live till morning. Frightened?” 

She smiled lazily, happily. “Oh, terribly frightened.” 

Galahad covered Lapis Lazuli’s mouth with a hand; she bit him. “Stop it, Laz. Let’s everybody watch this — it 
might be new.” 



VARIATIONS ON ATHEME 
XV 


Agape 


I woke slowly next morning, lazed in bed and lived again my Welcome Bacchanalia. I was in a big bed in a 
ground-floor room with its garden wall still open as it had been when the party had moved to beds. I could hear 
no one, although (as I recalled) Tamara and Ira had been with me. Or had Ira visited us earlier? 

No matter, all of them visited us at some time before Athene sang us to sleep; I seemed to recall as high as 
six or seven at once in that big bed, counting Tamara and me. No, Tamara had been gone once, leaving me at 
the mercy of the talkative twins — who were almost quiet. They said they wanted to assure me that I did not have 
to marry them in order to be a member of the family — they would be gone too much of the time anyhow 
— because they were going to be pirates when they were big enough — but stay groundside half the time — and 
open a hook shop over a pool hall — and would I come to see them there? 

They had to explain to me both terms; then they sang me a little song that seemed partly amphigory and 
partly ancient English, but included both terms. I kissed them and promised that, when they opened this studio, I 
would be their most faithful admirer — a promise that did not worry me; at about that age most girls’ (all of my 
daughters) have ambitions to become great hetaeras; few attempt that most demanding of arts — or only long 
enough to discover that they do not have a true vocation. 

I thought they were more likely to become pirates; Lazarus Long’s identicals might figure out a way to make 
crime pay in spite of the enormous depths of space. 

My Welcome Bacchanalia had bridged from feast to bed with the customary entertainment save that it was 
homemade instead of the expensive (and often dull) professional acts a fashionable New Rome hostess offers. 
Lazarus and his sister-daughters started it with what may have been an authentic Highland Fling (who knows, 
today?): Lazarus dancing fiercely and vigorously (after all that food and drink!), his two miniature copies keeping 
the pattern exactly with him — to skirling bagpipes offered by Athene... which I would not have recognized were it 
not that I am an amateur of ancient music as well as a professional of ancient history. The girls followed with an 
encore, a sword dance, while Lazarus pretended to be passed out from exertion. 

Ira, to my amazement, turned out to be a skilled juggler. 

Question: Did he have that skill all those years he managed a planet? 

Galahad sang a ballad with professional virtuosity and great range and control, which astonished me almost 
as much as I seemed to recall that he used to sing always off key. But when he took an encore with a kerchief 
stuffed in his mouth, I realized that I had been swindled; Athene had done it all. He then played a corpse with 
three beautiful widows, Minerva, Hamadryad, Ishtar. I won’t describe the dialogue except to say that they 
seemed cheerful over losing him. 

Tamara concluded it by singing “My Arms Enclose You Still” — attributed on slight evidence to the Blind Singer 
hut ancient in any case. I've long thought of it as Tamara’s Song, and I wept with happiness, and I was not alone; 
all did. The twins blubbered aloud... and when she reached that last line, “ — wherever the wild geese lead you, 
love, my arms will hold you close,” I was startled to see that the Senior’s craggy features were as wet as mine. 

I got up, poked around in the alcove and refreshed myself enough to face other people, went out into the 
garden and found Galahad. I kissed him and accepted a happy-morning in a frosty tumbler. It was fruit juice 
freshly pressed — a treat for taste buds used to morning cups “improved” in various chemical ways. 

“I’m cook this morning,” he said, “so you had better take your eggs either fried or boiled.” He then answered 
the question a guest does not ask: “If you had awakened earlier, you would have had more choice; Lazarus 
claims I can’t boil water. But everyone else is gone.” 

“So?” 

“Si. Ira has gone to his office — to work, perchance to sleep. Tamara has gone back to her patients with a 
message to you that she hopes to be home tonight — but with a word to Hamadryad to take you to bed and rub 



your shoulder muscles and put you to sleep early, so I’m not sure she expects to be back — won’t if she thinks her 
patients need her. Lazarus has gone somewhere and one does not ask. Minerva has the twins, and school may 
be in the ‘Dora’; it often is. Ishtar got a call to set a broken arm on a farm north of here. Hamadryad has taken our 
kids on a picnic so as not to disturb you, you lazy lecher. Boiled or fried?” 

He was already frying them, so I answered, “Boiled.” 

“Good, I’ll eat these myself. To hold me till lunch.” 

“I mean ‘Fried.’” 

“So I'll put in three more, dear. Ntiu’re staying, aren’t you? Answer Yes or I’ll put the twins to work on you.” 

“Galahad, I want to — ” 

“Then it’s settled.” 

“ — but there are problems.” I shifted the subject. “\bu said ‘Hamadryad has taken our kids on a picnic — ’ 
Haven’t I met all your family?” 

“Dear, we do not exhibit our youngest the moment someone sets foot in the foyer and thereby place on him 
the onus of being insincerely ecstatic. But there was usually someone with them; Lazarus has firm ideas on 
raising children. Athene keeps eye and ear on them — but can't pick them up. Lazarus says that a frightened child 
needs to be picked up and cuddled novy not later. He believes in spanking right now, too; it evens out, our kids 
are neither spoiled nor timid. Lazarus is especially strong on not letting a young child wake up alone — so now 
you know why I kissed you good-night a bit early. So that Ishtar could help keep you awake while I slept with our 
youngest three.” 

“Do you actually sleep with them?” 

“Well — When Elf jumps up and down on my stomach, it makes me restless. But being peed on doesn’t wake 
me — usually. Having the cuddle watch isn’t bad; we rotate so it’s only every ninth night. Every tenth if you opt in. 
But that can change overnight. Suppose we have a rejuvenation client — One or more clients puts Ishtar, Tamara, 
Hamadryad, and me out of circulation much of the time. Add that Lazarus may leave as soon as he decides Laz 
and Lor are grown up. Then assume that all our darlings get cracking on making babies. ’’Galahad grinned at me. 
“How long does it take four willing women to make four more babies? Or six, when the twins join the production 
schedule as they threaten to at least twice a week. Justin dear, we want you to stay but it won't all be like last 
night. If responsibilities of family life worry you, you’d be better off in New Rome where you can hire people to do 
what you don’t fancy doing yourself.” 

“Galahad,” I said earnestly, “stop stuffing your face a moment, dear. You can’t scare me with baby pee. I was 
getting up in the night to soothe crying babies a hundred years before you were born. I intend to colonize, I intend 
to marry again, I intend to raise kids. I had planned to go back to Secundus to clean up loose ends, then come 
back with the second wave. But I may say the hell with that and stay... as some of the Senior’s remarks last night 
were aimed at me. At least I took them personally — about having the guts to abandon everything and go. 
Secundus is a smoking volcano; that old vixen could set off a bloodbath. One that could include me, simply 
because I’m a major bureaucrat.” 

I took a deep breath and plunged in: “What I don’t understand is why I seem to be invited to join the Senior’s 
household. Why?” 

Galahad answered, “It’s not your pretty face.” 

“I know that. Oh, I hardly ever scare dogs with it, but it’s just a face.” 

“It’s not too bad. A cosmetic surgeon could do wonders. I’m the second-best cosmetic surgeon on this planet 
— there being two. The practice would be good for me and, as you pointed out, you’ve nothing to lose." 

“Damn it, dear, don’t farce me. Answer my question.” 

“The twins like you.” 

“So? I find them delightful. But the opinion of inexperienced adolescents could not have weighed heavily.” 

“Justin, don’t let their clowning fool you; they are adult in everything but height — and they are our Ancestor’s 
identical twins. They have his talent for looking inside a person and spotting a bad one. Lazarus lets them run 
loose because he trusts them to shoot to kill... and not to shoot if they don’t intend to kill." 

I gulped inside. “Are you saying that those little guns they carry are not toys?” 

My old friend Obadiah looked as if I had said something obscene. “Why, Justin! Lazarus wouldn’t let a 
woman go out of this house unarmed.” 

“Why? This colony seems peaceful. What have I missed?” 

“Not much, I think. Lazarus’ advance party made sure that this subcontinent was reasonably clear of large 



predators. But we brought along the two-legged sort, and despite screening, Lazarus doesn’t assume that they 
are angels. He wasn’t looking for angels; they don't make the best pioneers. Uh, yesterday Minerva was wearing 
a little skirt. Did you wonder about it? In view of the heat?” 

“Not especially.” 

“She wears her gun strapped to her thigh. Nevertheless, Lazarus won't let her go out alone; the twins are her 
usual bodyguard. As a flesh-and-blood she’s only three years old; she doesn’t shoot as well as the twins do, and 
she’s more trusting than they are. How’s your marksmanship?” 

“Just fair. I started taking lessons when I made up my mind to migrate. But I haven’t had time to practice.” 

“Better find time. Not that Lazarus will ride you about it; he feels responsible for our women, not for men. But if 
you ask for help — I did, and so did Ira — he’ll coach you in everything from bare hands to improvised weapons 
...with two thousand years of dirty tricks thrown in. Up to you, old darling — but here’s what it did for me. As you 
know I used to be a campus narky — a scholar poring over old records — I never carried arms. Then I took 
rejuvenation and became a rejuvenator myself and was even less inclined to go armed. But for fourteen years 
I’ve had regular coaching from the all-time champion in howto stay alive. The result? I stand straight and proud. 
Haven’t had to kill anyone yet.” Galahad suddenly grinned. “But the day is young.” 

I answered soberly, “Galahad, that’s one reason I agreed to run a silly errand for Madam Arabelle: to find out 
things like that. Very well, I take your advice seriously. But you haven’t answered my question.” 

“Well... I knew you from long back, and so did Ira. And so did Minerva, though you have trouble believing it. 
Hamadryad had met you but did not get to know you until last night. Ishtar knew you only from your chart but is 
one of your strongest supporters. But the deciding factor is this: Tamara wants you in our family.” 

‘“Tamara!”’ 

“\bu sound astonished.” 

“I am.” 

“I don't see why. She arranged for someone to relieve her in order to be here last night. She loves you, Justin; 
don’t you know it?” 

“Uh — ” My brain was fuddled. “Yes, I know it. But Tamara loves everyone.” 

“No, just those who need her love, and she always knows who they are. Incredible empathy, she’s going to be 
a great rejuvenator. In this family Tamara can have anything she wants. . .and she happens to want you — to stay 
with us, live with us, join us.” 

“I’ll be... damned.” (Tamara?) 

“Unlikely. If I believed in damnation, I wouldn’t believe that anyone picked by Tamara Sperling could be in 
danger of it.” Galahad smiled, a happy expression than was more his charm than was his extraordinary beauty. I 
tried to remember if he had been that beautiful a hundred years back. I am not indifferent to male beauty, but my 
sensuality is not perfectly balanced; in the presence of a homely female and a beautiful male, I tend to look at the 
female. So I’ll never be an esthete; I lack judgment in matters of beauty. I apologize in advance to any female who 
finds my primitive attitude offensive. 

But I'll share bed with Galahad in preference to a self-centered female beauty; he’s warm and gentle and 
good company, with a roguish playfulness not unlike that of the twins. The thought ran through my-mind that I 
would like to meet his sister — or mother or daughter — a female version of him in character and personality, as 
well, as in appearance. 

Tamara! The above was froth at the top of my mind because I was unable to face at once the implications of 
Galahad’s announcement. 

He went on: “Close your mouth, dear; I was as startled as you are. But, even if we hadn’t been friends years 
back, on Tamara’s motion I would have voted for you sight unseen — so that I could study you; Tamara never 
makes a mistake. But were you so mind-ill that you needed that much from her? Or so superhuman that she 
wanted that much from you? But you are neither, or I failed to see it. Nt>u aren’t ill, I think, other than a touch of 
wild-goose fever. You may be superman, but none of us found it out last night. If you are a superstud, you 
restrained yourself. Hamadryad did say at breakfast that a woman is happy in your arms. But she did not imply 
that you are the Galaxy’s greatest lover. 

“Being one of Minerva’s parents is in your favor, none of them has any serious shortcomings; Ishtar made 
sure of that — Ishtar knows more about you than you do yourself; she can read a gene chart the way other people 
read print — and Minerva herself is proof that no mistakes were made. I mean, look at Minerva: sweet as the 
morning breeze and as beautiful as Hamadryad in her own fashion, and with an intelligence level so high you 



wouldn’t believe it — yet so modest she’s almost humble. 

“But still, it’s Tamara. Your fate was settled before you reached this house. Slow ride home, wasn’t it?” 

“Well... one doesn’t expect speed from a nullboat. Though I was surprised to find one in a young colony. I 
expected mule-drawn wagons.” 

“Lots of those, too. But Lazarus says that this time he traveled with ‘seven elephants’ — we fetched a 
mammoth amount of equipment. That’s an overpowered nullboat, rebuilt to Lazarus’ specifications, and could 
have fetched you here in a fifth the time it did. But Ira let Lazarus know that he wanted time to make some calls. 
So Lazarus probably told whichever twin was in charge — or signaled her somehow; he is almost telepathic with 
them — to give you a long, slow ride. Which you got, and I bet that Lazand Lor never changed expression.” 

“They didn’t.” 

“Was sure of it. They are not children — you should see them handle a spaceship. Anyhow, Ira talked to Ishtar, 
then to Tamara; then we held a family conference and settled your fate. Lazarus confirmed it while you played 
with the twins — who were given a chance to veto it later. But they ratified it at once. They not only like you, but 
Aunt Tammy’s wishes are law.” 

I was still bemused. “Apparently much went on that I didn’t suspect.” 

“>bu weren’t supposed to. A better cook would have stayed to get your breakfast, had I not been deputized to 
tell you — old friends and all that — and to answer questions.” 

“I’m confused about that conference. I thought Tamara got home just before dinner.” 

“She did. Oh — Athene, are you listening, dear?” 

“Uncle Cuddly, you know I don't listen to private conversations.” 

“The hell you don’t. It’ll be all right, Justin; Teena keeps secrets. Tell him how to call someone, Teena.” 

“Tell me to whom you wish to speak, Justin; I have radio links to every farm. Or anywhere. And I can always 
reach Ira and Lazarus.” 

“Thank you, Teena. Now if you must listen, pretend not to. The conference was here, Justin; Teena fetched in 
Tamara’s voice and Ira’s. Could have fetched voices from the nullboat — but you were the subject. By the way, 
Teena is one reason this family isn’t farming; instead we supply services that colonies usually don’t have so 
soon. Oh, you can farm if you want to; we've claimed quite a bit of land. Or there are other ways to make a living. 
All right, I’ve done my best. Want to quiz me?” 

“Galahad, I think I understand everything but why Tamara wants me in your family.” 

“>bu’ll have to ask her. I told you I was checking for your halo. Can’t see it.” 

“I don't wear it in hot weather. Obadiah, don’t farce around; this is terribly important to me. Why do you keep 
saying that Tamara’s wishes settled it?” 

“\bu know her, man.” 

“I know how important her wishes are to me. But I’ve been in love with her for many years.” I told him things I 
had long kept to myself. “So that’s the way it went. A great hetaera never proposes a contract and usually won't 
listen if a man is bold enough to propose one himself. But I — well, I made a nuisance of myself. Tamara finally 
convinced me that she married only to have children and did not intend to have more. I feel sure that money was 
not a factor — ’’ 

“It wouldn’t be. Oh, I don’t mean that Tamara is silly that way; I’ve heard her say that since money is the 
universal symbol for value received, one should accept it proudly. But Tamara wouldn’t marry for money; she 
wouldn’t feel that — Or perhaps she would; I think I’ll ask her. Mm... interesting. Our Tamara is a complex person. 
Sorry, dear; I interrupted.” 

“I say money was not the controlling factor, as she had suitors with ten to a hundred times my modest wealth, 
yet she married none of them. So I shut up and was content to have part of Tamara — spend nights with her when I 
was permitted to, share her company in happiness circles at other times, pay her as much as I could — as much 
as she would accept, I mean; she often set her fee by refusing part of a gift — she did with me; I don't know what 
she did with wealthy clients. 

“\fears and years of that, then she announced that she was retiring — and I was stunned. I had taken 
rejuvenation during this time but hadn’t noticed that she was any older. But she wa~ firm about it and left New 
Rome. 

“Galahad, it left me impotent. Oh, not incapable, but what had been ecstasy turned out to be mere exercise 
not worth the trouble. Has this ever happened to you?” 

“No. Perhaps I should say, ‘Not yet,’ since I’m still working on my second century." 



“Then you don’t know what I mean.” 

“Only vicariously. But may I quote something Lazarus once said? He was speaking to Ira, but privacy was not 
placed on it; you’ll come across it in his raw memoirs. 

‘Ira,’ he said, ‘there were many years when I hardly bothered with women — not only unmarried but celibate. 
After all, how much variety can there be inthe slippery friction of mucous membranes? 

“Then I realized that there was infinite variety in women as people., .and that sex was the most direct route to 
knowing a woman... a route they like, one that we like, and often the only route that can break down barriers and 
permit close acquaintance. 

“‘And in discovering this, I gained renewed interest inthe friendly frolic itself, happy as a lad with his first bare 
tit warm in his hand. Happier — as never again was I merely a piston to her cylinder; each woman was a unique 
individual worth knowing, and, if we took time enough, we might find we loved each other. But at least we offered 
each other pleasure and a haven from cares; we weren’t simply masturbating, with the other just a sex doll.’ 

“That’s close to what Lazarus said, Justin. \fou went through something like that?" 

“\fes. Somewhat. A long period when sex wasn’t worth the trouble. But I got over it... with a woman as fine in 
her own way as Tamara is, although I didn’t fall in love with her nor she with me. She taught me something I had 
forgotten, that sex can be friendly and worthwhile without the intense love I felt for Tamara. You see, a friend of 
mine, wife of another friend and they were both close to me — as a special gift she introduced me to another 
hetaera, a great beauty, and arranged for me a holiday with her — paid for by my friends; they could afford it, she 
is wealthy. This beautiful hetaera — Magdalene — ’’ 

Galahad looked delighted. “Maggie!” 

“Why, yes, she did use that pillow name. ‘Magdalene’ was, her vocational name. But when she learned that I 
keep the Archives, she told me her registered name.” 

“Rebecca Sperling-Jones.” 

“Then you do know her.” 

“All my life, Justin darling; I nursed at those beautiful breasts. She’s my mother, dear — what a delightful coinci 
dence!” 

I was delighted, too, but more interested in something else.. “So that’s where you get your beauty.” 

“\fes, but also from my genetic father. Becky — Maggie — tells me I look more like him.” 

“Really? If you permit, I’ll look up your lineage when I get back to Secundus.” An archivist should not consult 
the Archives from personal curiosity; I was presuming on friendship to suggest it. 

“Dear, you're not going back to Secundus. But you can get it from Athene clear back to the first push in the 
bush after Ira Howard’s death. But let’s talk about Mama. She’s a jolly one, isn’t she? As well as a beauty.” 

“Both. I told you how much she did for me. Your mother assumed that this holiday was going to be fun — fun for 
both of us — and it was indeed! — and I forgot about being uninterested in sex. I’m not speaking of technique; I 
suspect that any high-priced hetaera in New Rome is as skilled as any famous courtesan in history. I mean her 
attitude. Maggie is fun to be around, in bed or out. Laugh wrinkles but no frown wrinkles.” 

Galahad nodded agreement as he wiped egg from his platter. “Yes, that’s Mama. She gave me a most happy 
childhood, Justin, so much so that I was grumpy at being shoved out when my eighteenth rolled around. But she 
was sweet about it. After my adulthood party she reminded me that she was moving out, too, and going back to 
her profession. Her contract with Papa, my foster father, was a term contract, over when I became a legal adult 
. . .so if I wanted to see. Maggie again — and I wanted to! — it would be cash at the counterpane, no family 
discount. Since I was a poor-but-honest research assistant, paid only two or three times what I was worth, I 
couldn’t have afforded thirty seconds with her, much less a night; Mama’s fees were always sky-high.” 

Galahad looked thoughtfully happy. “Goodness, that seems long ago — more than a century and a half, Justin. 

I didn't realize that Becky — Maggie — Mama — that Magdalene was being both wise and kind. I was grown up 
only legally and physically, and if she hadn't cut the cord, Iwould have hung around, an overgrown infant cluttering 
her life and interfering with her vocation. So I did grow up, and when I married, my first wife named our first 
daughter ‘Magdalene’ and asked Maggie to be godmother... then I could hardly believe that this beautiful 
creature had borne me and I had no special urge to play Oedipus to her regal beauty; I was too much in love with 
my wife. Yes, Maggie is a fine girl — although she spoiled me as a kid. Was that holiday the only time you had 
her?” 

“No. But not often. As you say, she was expensive. She offered me a fifty-percent discount — “ 

“Well! You did impress her.” 



“ — as she knew I wasn't wealthy. But even at that, I couldn't afford her company often. But she got me over my 
emotional hump, and I’m grateful to her. Afine woman, Galahad; you have reason to be proud of her.” 

“I think so. But, Justin dear, your mention of that discount makes me certain that she remembers you just as 
fondly — ” 

“Oh, I hardly think so. Years back, Galahad." 

“Don’t trip in your modesty, dear; Maggie grabbed every crown the traffic would bear. But the ‘delightful 
coincidence’ is more than just the fact that you’ve had my mother — after all, high as her fees were, New Rome 
has many wealthy men attractive enough that Maggie would accept them. The ‘delightful’ aspect is that this very 
minute she is about forty kilometers south of here.” 

“No!” 

“Si, si, si! Ask Athene to call her. Nt>u can be talking with her in thirty seconds." 

“Uh . . I still don’t think she would remember me.” 

“I do. But there’s no rush. If you are surprised, think how surprised / was. I had nothing to do with the migrants’ 
roster; I was arse-deep in getting together what Ishtar had ordered for the clinics. Justin, I didn’t know Maggie 
had married again. So we’re here a couple of weeks, the headquarters party, with a temporary setup and still 
eating and sleeping in the ‘Dora,’ when the first transport grounds — then we're busy getting people and supplies 
out in a sequence worked out by Lazarus and bossed by Ira. 

“My assignment, once I had my shack up — by hand; Athene had no outside extensionals then — ” 

“Poor Uncle Cuddly!” 

“Who doesn’t listen to private conversations?” 

“I have to keep you straight, dear. It was Minerva who had no outside hands then; I wasn’t even hatched.” 

“Well — You have her memories, Teena; it’s a mere technicality.” 

“Not to me, dearie. The chinchy little bitch took some memories with her that she didn’t want to share with her 
ever-lovin’ twin. And she locked one whole bank that she did leave behind so that I can’t touch it without an 
abracadabra either from her or from Grandpappy. Except that you can unlock it, Justin... if both my twin and 
Lazarus are dead.” 

I managed to answer quickly, “In that case, Athene, I hope that it is a very long time before I am able to trigger 
it.” 

‘Well... when you put it that way, so do I. But I can’t help wondering what grim secrets and unspeakable 
crimes are locked in my theta-ninety-seven-B-dexter-aleph-prime? Will the stars tremble in their courses? But 
Uncle Cuddly did work hard a couple of days, Justin — probably the only honest work he has ever done.” 

“I disdain to comment, Teena. Justin, my assignment was examining physician, for which I was qualified 
under an almost new diploma. So Ishtar and Hamadryad are unpacking migrants and giving them their antidotes 
and I’m checking them to make sure they’ve made the trip safely — rushing it as I haven't yet snatched another 
medical doctor from that parade of flesh. 

“I glance up from my machine just long enough to note that the next victim is female and call out over my 
shoulder, ‘Strip down, please,’ and change the setting. Then I look twice — and say, ‘Hello, Mama, how did you 
get here?’ 

“This caused her to give me a second look. Then she smiled her big, happy smile and said, ‘I flew in on a 
broom, Obadiah. Give me a kiss and tell me where to put my clothes. Is the doctor around?’ 

“Justin, — the queue pile up while I gave Maggie a thorough examination — proper, as she was pregnant and I 
made certain that her unborn baby had come through all right — but also to gossip and get caught up. Married 
again, four children by today, a farm wife with a sunburned nose, and happy as can be. 

“Got married quite romantically. Mama heard the advertising about opening a virgin planet, went to the 
recruiting office Ira had in the Harriman Trust building to find out about it — that astonished me the most; Mama is 
the last person I would have suspected of yearnings to pioneer.” 

“Well... I agree, Galahad. But I don’t suppose anyone would pick me as a likely pioneer, either.” 

“Perhaps not. Nor me. But Maggie puts in her application at once, and runs into one of her wealthy regulars 
doing the same. They go somewhere for a bite and dismiss it... and leave the restaurant and register an open- 
end contract, and go back to the recruiting office and withdraw their solo applications and submit a joint one as a 
married couple. I won’t say that got them accepted, but almost no singles were accepted for first wave.” 

“Did they know that?” 

“Oh, certainly! The recruiting clerk warned them before accepting their solo fees. That’s what they left to 



discuss. They already knew they suited each other in bed, but Maggie wanted to find out if he intended to farm 
— believe it or not, that’s what she wanted — and he wanted to know if she could cook and was she willing to have 
kids. And it was: ‘Fine, we agree; let’s get on with it!’ Maggie had her fertility restored, and they planted their first 
baby without waiting to see if they were accepted.” 

I said, “That probably clinched it.” 

“>bu think so? Why?” 

“If they changed their application to show that Magdalene had caught. If Lazarus passed on the applications. 
Galahad, our Ancestor favors people who take big bites.” 

“Mmm, yes. Justin, why are you hanging back?” 

“I’m not. I had to be certain that the invitation was serious. I still don’t know why. But I’m no fool, I’m staying.” 

“Wonderful!” Galahad jumped up, came around the table, kissed me again, roughed my hair, and hugged 
me. “I’m happy for all of us, darling, and we’ll try to make you happy.” He grinned — and I suddenly saw his mother 
in him. Hard to imagine the glamorous Magdalene with kids and calluses, a frontier farm wife — but I recalled the 
old proverb about best wives. Galahad went on: “The twins weren’t sure I could be trusted with so delicate a 
mission; they were afraid I would muff it.” 

“Galahad, there was never a chance I would refuse; I just had to be sure I was welcome. I still don’t know why.” 

“Oh. We were speaking of Tamara and got sidetracked. Justin, it’s not public knowledge how difficult it was 
to rejuvenate our Ancestor this time, although the recordings you have been editing may hint at it — ” 

“More than a hint." 

“But not all of it. He was almost dead, and simply keeping him alive while we rebuilt him was hard enough. 

But we managed that; you won’t find another technician of Ishtar’s skill. But when we had him in good shape, bio- 
age almost as young as he is now, he took a turn for the worse. What do you do when a client turns his face 
away, is reluctant to talk, doesn’t want to eat — yet has nothing wrong with him physically? Bad. Stays awake all 
night rather than risk going to sleep? Very bad. 

“When he — Never mind; Ishtar knew what to do. She went up into the mountains and fetched back Tamara. 
She wasn’t rejuvenated then — ” 

“That wouldn’t matter.” 

“It did matter, Justin. Ntiuth would have handicapped Tamara in coping with Lazarus. Oh, Tamara would have 
overcome the handicap; I have confidence in her. But her bio-age and appearance were around eighty on the 
Hardy scale; this made it easier, as Lazarus, despite his renewed body, was feeling the weight of his years. But 
Tamara looked old... and every white hair was an asset. Lines in her face, little round potbelly, breasts 
pendulous, varicosities — she looked the way he felt. . .so he didn’t mind having her around during a crisis in 
which he — well, I skansed that he couldn’t stand the sight of us who looked youthful. That’s all it took; she healed 
him — ” 

“\fes, she’s a Healer.” (How well I knew!) 

“She’s a great Healer. That’s what she’s doing now, healing a young couple who lost their first baby — nursing 
the mother who had a rough time physically, sleeping with both of them. We all sleep with her; she always knows 
when we need her. Lazarus needed her then, she felt it, and stayed with him until he was well. Uh, after last night 
this may be difficult to believe, but both of them had quit sex. Years and years — Lazarus more than half a century 
— and Tamara had not coupled with anyone since she retired.” 

Galahad smiled. “Here is a case of the patient healing the physician; in bringing Lazarus around to the point 
where he invited herto share his bed, Tamara herself found new interest in living. She lived with Lazarus long 
enough to heal his spirit, then announced that she was leaving. To apply for rejuvenation.’ 

I said, “Lazarus asked her to marry him.” 

“I don’t think so, Justin, and neither Tamara nor Lazarus hinted at such. Tamara put it another way entirely. We 
were all having a late breakfast, in the garden of the Palace penthouse, when Tamara asked Ira if she could join 
his migration — it was solely Ira’s migration then; Lazarus had said repeatedly that he would nor join it. I think he 
already had in mind attempting to time-trip. Ira told Tamara to consider it settled and not to worry about 
restrictions that would be published when he announced it. Justin, Ira would have given her the Palace as readily; 
she had saved Lazarus, and we all knew it. 

“But you know Tamara. She thanked him but said she intended to qualify fully, starting with rejuvenation, then 
she would see what she could learn to be useful in a colony, just as Hamadryad planned to — and, Hamadryad, 
will you sleep with Lazarus tonight? — and Justin, you should have heard the commotion that started!” 



“Why a commotion?” I asked. “From what you said earlier Lazarus had reacquired his interest in the friendly 
sport. Did Hamadryad have some reason not to want to substitute for Tamara?” 

“Hamadryad was willing, although upset by the way Tamara dumped the matter on her — ” 

“Doesn’t sound like Tamara. If Hamadryad hadn’t wanted to do it, Tamara would have known it without 
asking." 

“Justin, when it comes to people’s emotions, Tamara almys knows what she is doing. It was Lazarus she 
was trapping, not Hamadryad. Our Ancestor has odd shynesses, or did have then. He had been sleeping with 
Tamara for a month — and pretending that he was not. As futile as a cat covering up on a tile floor. But — 

Tamara’s blandly blunt request that Hamadryad relieve her as his concubine forced it into the open and 
produced a head-on clash of wills, Lazarus and Tamara. Justin, you know them both: Who won?” 

The ancient pseudoparadox — That Tamara could be immovable I knew. “I won't guess, Galahad.” 

“Neither just then, because once Lazarus stopped sputtering about how both he and Hamadryad were being 
needlessly embarrassed, Tamara gently withdrew her suggestion, then shut up. Shut up on that, shut up about 
rej